Key takeaways
- Sort the call first: a visitor hurt here, a local hit by an out-of-state driver, or a local hurt while traveling. Each raises different venue and insurance questions.
- Record where the crash happened down to the county and the police agency, plus every party's home state and insurer. Twelve states and Puerto Rico run no-fault systems[2].
- A rental company is generally not liable just for owning the car[3], so intake collects the rental agreement and the renter's own coverage rather than stopping at the company's name.
- Visitors go home. Flag the departure date, collect a home address and phone, and book the consultation before the flight.
- Whether the firm can take a case venued in another state is the attorney's decision; intake gathers the facts that decision needs.
Three different calls under one label
“Out-of-state accident” covers three calls that need different handling, and intake should know which one it has inside the first minute. A family on vacation was rear-ended near the theme parks and flies home on Sunday. A local commuter was hit by a driver with plates from two states away, in a rental car. A local caller was hurt on a business trip and is back home, holding a police report from an agency the firm has never dealt with.
| Scenario | Where the crash happened | First questions | What the attorney weighs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Visitor hurt in your state | Here | Home state or country, departure date, rental details, home insurer | Timing, treatment back home, how to meet and sign before they leave |
| Local hit by an out-of-state driver | Here | The other driver's license state, plate state, insurer and policy state | Serving a defendant who went home, whose policy applies |
| Local hurt in another state | Elsewhere | State, county, road and police agency where it happened | Which state's rules apply, licensing, co-counsel or referral |
The rest of the car accident intake checklist still applies. What follows is the layer on top: the questions that only matter because two states, or two countries, are involved.
Visitors drive rental cars
Tourism puts a steady stream of unfamiliar drivers on local roads. The National Travel and Tourism Office estimates that 9.4 million overseas visitors rented a car in the US in 2025[1]. Their trips concentrate in a few states: 40.1% of those renters visited Florida, 26.6% California and 12.7% New York[1]. Those counts leave out Canadians and Mexicans who drive across the border and the far larger number of Americans driving in from the next state over, so the real volume of out-of-state drivers is much higher.
For a firm in one of those states, the practical problem is time. A visitor with a fractured wrist and a flight on Saturday has days, not weeks, to meet the firm, sign anything the attorney wants signed and hand over the documents that are still in the rental car. Evidence that a local client could bring in next Tuesday has to be photographed tonight. Plan for phone or video consultations as the default for these callers, not the exception.
Pin down where it happened
Location drives almost every legal question in these cases, and callers who don't know the area describe it badly: “on the highway near the outlet mall.” Ask for the state, the county or nearest city, the road and direction of travel, the nearest exit or cross street, and which agency came: city police, county sheriff or state highway patrol. If the caller has the police report number or an exchange-of-information form, photograph it now.
The crash state's rules matter because they differ so much. Twelve states and Puerto Rico have no-fault auto insurance laws, under which the injured person's own personal injury protection pays first and lawsuits are limited by a threshold; Florida, Michigan, New Jersey, New York and Pennsylvania use verbal thresholds, and Hawaii, Kansas, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Minnesota, North Dakota and Utah use monetary ones[2]. A visitor from a tort state who crashes in a no-fault state is in a system they have never heard of. Intake does not explain it; it records the crash state and each party's home state so the attorney can.
Filing deadlines differ too. New York gives three years for an action to recover damages for a personal injury[4]; Florida lists an action founded on negligence among those to be brought within two years[5]. Which deadline governs a crash that involves two or three states is a question for the attorney. Intake captures the crash date, the crash state and the caller's home state, and never tells a caller how long they have. Screening for limitation deadlines covers the wording.
Rental car questions
Callers often assume the rental company will pay. Federal law limits that: under the Graves Amendment, a company in the business of renting or leasing vehicles is not liable under state law merely because it owns the vehicle, as long as there was no negligence or criminal wrongdoing on its part[3]. The same section leaves state financial responsibility and insurance requirements in place[3]. So intake does not stop at “it was a rental.” It collects the paperwork that shows who rented the car, who was driving and what coverage was bought.
- Rental company, pickup location and rental agreement number; ask the caller to photograph every page of the agreement, including the coverage section.
- Who signed the agreement and who was driving at the time of the crash, and whether the driver was listed on it.
- Any coverage the renter accepted or declined at the counter, as shown on the agreement rather than from memory.
- The renter's own auto insurer at home, with the policy number and the state where the policy was issued.
- The card used to pay for the rental, which the attorney may want to check for benefits.
- Whether the rental company or its claims administrator has already contacted the caller, and whether they gave any statement.
Rideshare vehicles look like rentals to some callers and follow different rules; those calls go through rideshare accident intake instead.
Insurance written in another state
The other driver's policy was written under their home state's law, with that state's minimum limits and options. Forty-nine states and the District of Columbia require drivers to buy liability insurance; New Hampshire, the only state without a compulsory insurance law, requires drivers to show proof of financial responsibility instead[6]. Intake records the insurer, policy number and the state where the policy was issued for every vehicle, alongside the driver's license state and the plate state, which do not always match.
Then turn to the caller's own coverage, which often matters more than callers expect when the other driver is far from home. Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage, medical payments and personal injury protection on the caller's policy, and policies on other cars in the household, all go in the file. The full list is in insurance details to collect in accident cases, and calls where the other driver has no coverage at all follow uninsured driver accident intake.
Venue, service and who can handle the case
Parties from different states open a door to federal court. District courts have jurisdiction over civil actions between citizens of different states where more than $75,000 is in controversy[7], and such cases are common: 78,893 diversity filings were made in the year ending March 31, 2025, even after a 51% drop from the year before[8]. Whether a crash case belongs in state or federal court, and in which state, is strategy the attorney decides. Intake's contribution is getting each party's home state right.
States also have ways to reach a driver who has gone home. New York, for example, treats a nonresident's use of a vehicle on its roads as appointing the New York secretary of state as that driver's agent to receive a summons[9]. That only works if the firm has the driver's name and address exactly as they appear on the license or exchange form, so ask the caller to photograph the form rather than read it out.
When the crash happened in a state where the firm's lawyers are not admitted, the attorney decides whether to take the case, bring in local counsel or refer it out. Have the referral partners lined up before the call, using the firm's attorney referral network, and know the rules in referral fees and fee splitting between lawyers. The broader questions for callers whose matter sits in another state are in out-of-state caller jurisdiction screening.
The first call with a visitor
- Caller
- SI Employee
- System
- Your team
01Caller
Visitor calls from hotel
Hurt in a crash two days ago, flying home on Sunday, unsure who pays.
02SI Employee
Conflict names and states
Both drivers, the owner and the rental company, with each party's home state.
03SI Employee
Location and agency
State, county, road, and which police agency took the report.
04SI Employee
Insurance and rental papers
Insurers and states of issue, rental agreement photos, the caller's own policy.
05System
Departure date flagged
A caller leaving within 72 hours goes down the firm's escalation tree.
06Your team
Attorney decides
Take it, bring in local counsel or refer; consultation set before the flight.
The firm writes the questions, the 72-hour rule and the escalation order; nothing about venue or value is said on the call.
The conflict check comes before the story, as on any injury call. ABA Formal Opinion 506 notes that trained non-lawyers can collect the names of all relevant parties and the incident dates, but the lawyer makes the final call when a related name turns up[10]. In out-of-state cases the list is longer than usual: the rental company, the renter, the driver, the vehicle owner, any employer of the driver and any tour or travel company involved. The order for those names is in running a conflict check at intake.
Plan the follow-up before they leave
Once a visitor is home, every step gets slower. Collect a home address, a mobile number with country code for international visitors, an email address and the local number where they are staying until departure. Ask where they will continue treatment at home and the name of that doctor or clinic, because records will come from two states. Note the time zone they will be in, so callbacks land at a reasonable hour.
Then make sure the callback gets answered. Only 19% of US adults say they generally answer calls from unknown numbers[11], and a traveler's phone fills up with calls from insurers, the rental company and repair shops. Tell the caller the number the firm will call from and when, and ask them to save it before they hang up.
International visitors add a language question. Decide in advance how the firm handles a caller who is more comfortable in another language, whether that is a bilingual staff member, an interpreter line or a scheduled call; the approach in intake for callers with limited English proficiency works here too.
Covering the calls that come at night
Visitors call from hotel rooms in the evening, after the emergency room and the rental counter. If the firm forwards its line after hours, an SI Employee can work through the same questions in the same order, read back the departure date and the rental agreement number, and send a caller who is leaving within the firm's threshold down the escalation tree, up to three destinations with a tested fallback. It never tells a caller where to sue, how long they have or what the case is worth. The attorney gets a summary, recording and transcript in the AssistCall account. You can call one yourself to hear how the questions sound. The solo personal injury lawyer example models the evening and weekend pattern for a small injury firm.
Example: the Ohio family near Orlando
Example. A man from Columbus, Ohio, calls a Florida firm at 8:15 on a Wednesday evening. Two days ago a local pickup rear-ended the family's rental SUV at a light near Orlando. His wife was driving; he was in the passenger seat and was treated at an emergency room for a neck and shoulder injury. The family flies home Saturday morning.
Intake takes the names first: the caller, his wife, the pickup driver and its owner from the exchange form, and the rental company. It records the road and county, that the county sheriff took the report, and the report number from a photo he sends during the call. He is unsure what coverage was bought at the counter, so he photographs every page of the rental agreement. He gives his Ohio auto insurer and policy number and his health plan. The pickup driver's insurer has already left him two voicemails.
Because the family leaves in under 72 hours, the call goes to the on-call attorney that night. The attorney calls back Thursday morning and holds a video consultation that afternoon. Florida's no-fault rules, the Ohio policy and where treatment will continue are the attorney's to sort out, with the facts already in the file. The intake note's first line reads: “Departs Saturday 9:40 am. Rental agreement photographed. Other driver's insurer calling.”
Checklist for the intake note
- Scenario: visitor hurt here, local hit by an out-of-state driver, or local hurt elsewhere.
- Crash state, county, road, police agency and report number.
- Every party's home state or country, license state and plate state.
- Every insurer, policy number and state of issue, including the caller's own.
- Rental company, agreement number, renter, driver and coverage shown on the agreement.
- Departure date and time, home address, phone with country code, and treating provider at home.
- Any statements given to insurers or the rental company, with dates.
- Documents received tonight and documents still owed.
Frequently asked questions
Can our firm take a case if the crash happened in another state?
That is the attorney's decision. It depends on where the case would be filed, where the firm's lawyers are admitted and whether local counsel is brought in. Intake records the crash state, county and each party's home state so the attorney can decide quickly, and has the referral list ready if the answer is no.
The rental company's claims department already called the caller. What should intake record?
The company or administrator's name, the adjuster's name and number, any claim number, the date of each call and whether the caller gave a recorded statement or signed anything. The approach in handling insurance adjuster calls applies.
Which state's filing deadline applies to a crash involving two states?
The attorney decides. Deadlines differ: New York allows three years for a personal injury action[4], while Florida lists negligence actions among those with a two-year limit[5]. Intake records the crash date, crash state and each party's home state, and never gives the caller a deadline.
The caller goes home tomorrow. Should intake try to get a fee agreement signed tonight?
Only if the attorney has set that process up and approved it. Intake's job is to flag the departure date, book the earliest consultation the attorney will take and collect documents before the caller leaves. Signing injury clients fast covers the attorney's side.
What if the other driver lives in another country?
Record the driver's full name and address exactly as on the license or exchange form, the license country, the insurer if any, and the rental company if the car was rented. Photographs beat dictation. The attorney decides what that means for the case.
References
National Travel and Tourism Office, International Trade Administration (2025). Market Profile: Car Rental (Overseas Visitors to the U.S.) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Insurance Information Institute (2026). Background on: No-fault auto insurance (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 49 U.S. Code § 30106 - Rented or leased motor vehicle safety and responsibility (opens in a new tab) ↑
The New York State Senate (2026). New York Civil Practice Law and Rules § 214 (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Florida Senate (2025). Florida Statutes 2025, § 95.11 Limitations other than for the recovery of real property (opens in a new tab) ↑
Insurance Research Council (2025). One in Three U.S. Drivers Are Either Uninsured or Underinsured (news release on Uninsured and Underinsured Motorists: 2017–2023) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 28 U.S. Code § 1332 - Diversity of citizenship; amount in controversy; costs (opens in a new tab) ↑
Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts (2025). Federal Judicial Caseload Statistics 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
The New York State Senate (2026). New York Vehicle and Traffic Law § 253: Service of summons on non-residents (opens in a new tab) ↑
American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2023). Formal Opinion 506: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistants (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑