Practice Area Playbooks

Car Accident Case Intake Checklist

A complete car accident intake checklist: crash facts, police report, every insurance policy that might pay, treatment and the evidence to collect today.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. How to use this checklist
  2. Screen before the story
  3. Crash facts
  4. Liability questions without leading the caller
  5. Police report and other records
  6. Insurance: every policy that might pay
  7. Injuries and treatment
  8. Evidence the caller can send today
  9. Plan for the summer surge
  10. Reaching the caller again
  11. Example: completing the checklist in one call
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References
Practice Area Playbooks: Car Accident Case Intake ChecklistArticle coverPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSCar Accident CaseIntake ChecklistAva for LawyersInsightsPractice Area Playbooks: Car Accident Case Intake ChecklistArticle coverPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSCar Accident CaseIntake ChecklistAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Screen for representation, date and state before taking the full story.
  • List every policy that might pay, including the caller's own coverage, not just the at-fault driver's insurer.
  • Ask callers to send photos while still on the phone; 91% of US adults own a smartphone[1].
  • Staff up for summer: US traffic deaths in July to September 2024 ran about 23% above January to March[2].

How to use this checklist

Car accident calls are the most common personal injury inquiry for many firms, which makes them easy to rush. This checklist is designed for the first call. It collects the facts an attorney needs to decide whether to take the matter and what must be preserved right away, without giving legal advice. Staff should explain early that they are not lawyers and that an attorney will review the information.

Work through the sections in order, but follow the caller. If they mention a letter from an insurer with a deadline, capture it immediately. Mark every item known, unknown or not applicable, so the attorney can see what was asked as well as what was answered. A blank field is ambiguous; unknown is information.

Screen before the story

  1. Do you have a lawyer for this accident, or have you signed anything with a law firm? If yes, stop the fact interview and note the call.
  2. When did the accident happen, and in which state and county? Record the exact date.
  3. Was anyone hurt, and is anyone still in the hospital?
  4. Is this about your own injuries, or are you calling for someone else? If someone else, who, and can they speak with us?

Crash facts

  • Date, time of day and exact location: street names, highway and direction, or nearest landmark.
  • Vehicles involved, who was driving each, and where the caller was sitting.
  • How it happened, in the caller's own words, then specifics: rear-end, intersection, lane change, head-on, parking lot.
  • Traffic controls: signals, stop signs, and who had the right of way in the caller's view.
  • Weather, light and road conditions.
  • Whether any driver was cited or arrested at the scene.
  • Whether the other vehicle was a commercial truck, a company car, a rideshare, a delivery vehicle or a government vehicle. Each changes the insurance picture and sometimes the deadlines.
  • Hit-and-run or uninsured driver: was the other driver identified at all?

Liability questions without leading the caller

Fault decides most car accident claims, and callers often blame themselves or the other driver in ways the evidence later contradicts. Staff should collect the account neutrally and leave the analysis to the attorney. Open questions produce better records than yes-or-no ones.

  • Ask: walk me through the few seconds before the impact. Not: did they run the light?
  • Ask: what did the other driver say at the scene? Statements such as I didn't see you are worth recording word for word.
  • Ask: what did you say to the other driver or the officer? An apology at the scene is common and the attorney needs to know about it.
  • Ask: were you using your phone, or was anything distracting you? Ask it the same way on every call so nobody feels singled out.
  • Ask: had anyone in your car been drinking, or taken any medication that day? Again, the same wording every time.

If the caller seems partly at fault, keep going. Many states allow recovery even when the injured person shares some fault, and the rules differ by state. That is a question for the attorney, not a reason to end the call.

Police report and other records

  • Did police come to the scene? Which agency: city police, county sheriff or state highway patrol?
  • Report or incident number, if the caller has it, or the officer's name.
  • Did the caller receive an exchange-of-information form at the scene?
  • Was an ambulance called, and which hospital did it go to?
  • Did the caller file a report with the state motor vehicle agency or their own insurer?

Insurance: every policy that might pay

Callers usually think only about the other driver's insurance. The attorney needs the full list. Ask for company names and claim numbers, and whether the caller has given a recorded statement to anyone.

Insurance questions for a car accident intake
PolicyWhat to askWhy it matters
Other driver's liability insurerCompany, claim number, adjuster name, any statement givenUsual source of recovery for injuries caused by the other driver
Caller's own auto policyCompany, policy number, whether they have medical payments, personal injury protection, or uninsured and underinsured motorist coverageMay pay medical bills regardless of fault, or cover a driver with too little insurance
Employer or commercial policyWas the other driver working? Company name on the vehicleBusiness policies often carry higher limits
Rideshare or delivery appWas the driver logged into an app, and was a passenger on board?Coverage can depend on the driver's app status at the time
Health insurance, Medicare or MedicaidWhich plan paid for treatmentThese payers may claim repayment from any recovery
Workers' compensationWas the caller driving for work?Opens a separate benefit and changes the claim structure

Injuries and treatment

  • Injuries, in the caller's words and by body part.
  • Where and when they were first seen: emergency room, urgent care, primary doctor, chiropractor.
  • Current treatment: who, how often, and what is planned next, such as imaging, therapy or surgery.
  • Time off work, and the employer's name.
  • Prior injuries or treatment for the same body parts.
  • Any gap between the crash and the first visit, and the reason for it.

Cost is often why callers delay treatment. In 2025, only 63% of US adults said they would cover a $400 emergency expense completely with cash or its equivalent[3]. Record the reason for any gap without judgment. Do not tell the caller to see a doctor or which provider to use; if they describe worsening symptoms, tell them to seek medical care or call 911, and let the attorney discuss treatment and billing options.

Evidence the caller can send today

Most evidence in a car crash is fragile: vehicles are repaired or scrapped, scenes change, and private video is overwritten. Nearly every caller can help. Pew finds 91% of US adults own a smartphone[1], so ask callers to send what they have while you are still on the line, using a secure upload link rather than personal email or texts to a staff phone.

  • Photos of all vehicles, the scene, road markings, traffic signals and visible injuries.
  • The exchange-of-information form and the police report number.
  • Insurance cards and any letters or emails from insurers.
  • Names and phone numbers of witnesses.
  • Dashcam footage, and the names of nearby businesses that may have cameras.
  • Medical discharge papers and appointment cards.
  • Repair estimates or total-loss letters, and where the vehicle is now.

Plan for the summer surge

Call volume follows crash patterns. NHTSA's early estimate shows 39,345 traffic deaths in 2024, and the third quarter had 10,565 deaths against 8,595 in January to March, about 23% more[2]. In every year from 2013 to 2024, July to September had more traffic deaths than January to March[2]. Injury crashes follow a similar seasonal shape in many areas, so plan intake coverage, vacation schedules and consultation capacity for summer before it arrives.

US traffic deaths by quarter, 2024
US traffic deaths by quarter, 2024Comparison. January to March: 8,595; July to September: 10,565.8,595January to MarchJanuary to March: 8,59510,565July to SeptemberJuly to September: 10,565US traffic deaths by quarter, 2024Comparison. January to March: 8,595; July to September: 10,565.8,595January to MarchJanuary to March: 8,59510,565July to SeptemberJuly to September: 10,565

Source: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2024[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
January to March8,595
July to September10,565

Reaching the caller again

Car accident callers are often contacting several firms at once. The firm that books the consultation first often gets the case, and follow-up calls fail more often than firms expect: only 19% of US adults say they generally answer calls from unknown numbers[4]. Before ending the call, confirm the best number and time, tell the caller which number you will call from, and book the consultation on the call if the attorney's calendar allows.

When someone calls for a spouse, parent or friend, take their details and the basic facts, but arrange to speak with the injured person directly as soon as they can talk. The injured person is the potential client, and their own account, consent and contact preferences matter. If the injured person is a minor, confirm who the parent or legal guardian is and record both names.

Example: completing the checklist in one call

Example: a caller was hit at an intersection by a delivery van four days ago. She has no lawyer. She went to the emergency room that night and has a follow-up with her doctor next week. While on the call, she uploads photos of both vehicles, the exchange form and her insurance card. The van had a company name on the side, and she has not spoken to any insurer.

Intake marks the commercial vehicle and the possible employer policy, notes a nearby gas station that may have video, and books a consultation for the next morning. The attorney's first task is a preservation letter to the delivery company, which the intake summary flagged at the top.

For the general first-call framework, see personal injury intake questions and red flags. Crashes involving large commercial vehicles have their own urgency; see truck accident intake. The full path from this call to a signed agreement is in the client intake checklist.

Frequently asked questions

What should I ask in a car accident intake call?

Representation status, date and place, how it happened, police involvement, every insurance policy that might apply, injuries and treatment, work impact, and what evidence exists and who holds it.

Why ask about the caller's own insurance?

The caller's policy may include medical payments, personal injury protection or uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage, which can matter as much as the other driver's policy.

Should intake staff ask for photos during the first call?

Yes, through a secure upload link. Photos, the exchange form and insurer letters help the attorney evaluate the matter and show what needs to be preserved.

What if the other vehicle was a government vehicle?

Flag it as urgent. Claims against public entities often require formal notice within a short period, so the attorney needs to see it the same day.

References

  1. Pew Research Center (2026). Americans' Use of Mobile Devices in 2026 (Mobile Fact Sheet) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (2024). Early Estimate of Motor Vehicle Traffic Fatalities in 2024 (DOT HS 813 710) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2025). Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households: Unexpected expenses (data table) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo