Key takeaways
- Nonlawyers conducting intake should identify their nonlawyer status, ask factual questions only, give no legal advice and refer legal questions to a lawyer[1].
- Intake records trigger dates; attorneys write the review thresholds; only an attorney tells a caller anything about a deadline.
- People seek legal help for only a minority of serious problems, and often late, so deadline flags matter on every call[2].
- Decline letters should say that time limits may apply and that the person should consult another lawyer promptly, without stating any deadline.
The line intake staff must not cross
Almost every intake specialist has been asked some version of the same question: am I too late? It is the most natural question a caller can ask and one of the most dangerous for a nonlawyer to answer. Limitation periods depend on the claim, the state, the defendant, when the injury was discovered, tolling rules and exceptions. Getting it wrong in either direction harms the caller: telling them they have time when they don't, or telling them it's too late when an exception applies.
Florida Ethics Opinion 88-6, which the Florida Bar's 2024 opinion on generative AI calls especially useful for intake chatbots, sets out the boundaries plainly: nonlawyers conducting an initial intake interview must identify their nonlawyer status, limit questions to factual information, give no legal advice and refer legal questions to the lawyer[1]. Those four rules work as a policy statement for any firm.
The supervising attorneys carry responsibility for making that policy real. Model Rule 5.3 requires partners and managers to make reasonable efforts to ensure the firm has measures giving reasonable assurance that nonlawyers' conduct is compatible with the lawyer's professional obligations, and requires direct supervisors to make reasonable efforts as well[3]. A written deadline-screening procedure is one of those measures.
Why screening still matters on every call
Not giving advice does not mean ignoring deadlines. Many callers reach a firm late. The Legal Services Corporation found that people with higher incomes seek legal help for 32% of the problems that substantially affect them, against 25% for low-income Americans[2]. Many problems never reach a lawyer at all, and those that do often arrive after months of trying other routes.
Source: Legal Services Corporation, 2022[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Higher-income Americans | 32% |
| Low-income Americans | 25% |
There is also a duty that survives even if the firm declines. Under Model Rule 1.18, a person who consults a lawyer about possibly forming a client-lawyer relationship is a prospective client, and even when no relationship follows, the lawyer must not use or reveal what was learned except as the rules permit[4]. The firm's handling of a prospective client's deadline, including how it declines, is part of doing that consultation responsibly.
Facts to collect, words to avoid
| Ask for this fact | Never say this | Say this instead |
|---|---|---|
| When did the incident or event happen? | You're still within the deadline. | I've recorded that date for the attorney. |
| When did you first realize there was a problem or injury? | That date doesn't matter. | The attorney may ask more about that date. |
| Have you received court papers or letters? What dates are on them? | You can ignore that letter. | Please send me a photo of every page of that letter. |
| Is a hearing or response date coming up? | You've got plenty of time. | I'm marking this for prompt review because of that date. |
| Has anything been filed already, by you or anyone else? | It's probably too late now. | The attorney will review the timing with you. |
Train staff to repeat dates back to the caller and to mark each date as exact, approximate or unknown. An honestly approximate date is useful; a guess recorded as a fact is not.
Trigger dates to record by matter type
- Injury and accident: date of the incident, date of first treatment, date the caller learned of the injury if later, and whether a government vehicle or property was involved.
- Medical treatment: date of the procedure or treatment at issue, date the caller learned something went wrong, and the provider's name.
- Employment: date of termination or the adverse action, dates of any agency charge already filed, and the date of any right-to-sue or decision letter.
- Contracts and debts: date of the contract, date of the breach or last payment, and the date of any demand letter.
- Lawsuits against the caller: the date the caller was served and the date on the summons.
- Government decisions: the date on the decision letter and the date it was received.
- Death-related matters: date of death and whether anyone has been appointed for the estate.
Each item is a date or a yes-or-no fact. None requires staff to know what the deadline is. The form simply ensures the attorney has what they need to calculate it.
Flag levels set by attorneys, applied by staff
Staff need a way to sort urgency without applying law. The answer is a short table of review triggers written by the attorneys for each practice area. The attorneys choose the thresholds; staff only compare recorded dates against them.
Red: same-day attorney review
Court papers have been served, a hearing or response date is on a document, a government entity is involved, or the incident date is older than the attorney-set red threshold for that practice area.
Amber: next-business-day review
The incident date is older than the amber threshold, the discovery date differs from the incident date, or the caller is unsure of key dates.
Green: standard review
Recent events with no documents carrying dates and no government involvement.
Record the flag and the reason
Write which trigger applied, so the attorney can check the sorting as well as the case.
A red flag tells the attorney to look today. It never tells the caller anything about their deadline. The caller hears only that the file is being reviewed promptly.
Review the thresholds at least once a year, and whenever the firm adds a practice area or a state. Keep the table in the intake manual and in whatever system staff use on calls, so the same version is applied by the day team, the evening team and anyone covering a holiday.
A script for the too-late question
When a caller asks directly whether they have missed a deadline, staff should acknowledge the question, explain why they can't answer it, and show what happens next.
- That's an important question, and I'm not able to answer it because I'm not an attorney.
- Deadlines depend on details the attorney needs to review, so I want to make sure they have the right dates.
- Can I confirm the dates you've given me? [Repeat them back.]
- Because timing may matter, I'm marking your file for prompt review. You'll hear from us by [specific time].
- If you have any letters or court papers, please send photos of every page now.
Automated and after-hours intake follow the same rules
The boundary applies whoever, or whatever, answers the phone. The Florida Bar warns that website intake chatbots risk creating a prospective-client or even lawyer-client relationship without the lawyer's knowledge[1]. California's State Bar names autonomously facilitating client intake as an example of agentic AI and says lawyer supervision must correspond to the system's level of access and autonomy[5].
If your firm uses an SI Employee such as Ava for after-hours calls, configure it exactly like a staff member: collect the trigger dates, apply the attorney-set flags, route red-flag calls by your escalation rules, and never state whether a deadline has passed. Review a sample of transcripts against this standard each month.
Example: a dog bite from last year
Example (fictional): A caller says a neighbor's dog bit her daughter last summer, and the wound has since needed a second surgery. She asks whether it's too late to do anything. The specialist uses the script, records the bite date (approximate, early July), the first emergency treatment date (exact, from the hospital bill), the second surgery date, and the neighbor's name for the conflict check. Because the firm's attorney-set threshold for injury matters is passed, she marks the file red and promises a call by the end of the day. She does not say anything about time limits for minors. The attorney calls back that afternoon.
Declining without creating a deadline problem
- Decline in writing, by email or letter, and keep a copy in the prospective-client record.
- State that the firm is not representing the person and has not evaluated the merits.
- Say that time limits may apply to their matter and that they should consult another lawyer promptly. Do not state any specific deadline.
- Offer the state bar's lawyer referral service or a legal aid contact if appropriate.
- Do not return original documents by ordinary mail without a record; offer pickup or tracked delivery.
Review a sample of declined and flagged files each month to check that staff applied the triggers consistently and that no caller was told anything about a deadline. Related reading: qualifying leads without giving legal advice, the medical records step for injury matters and the deadline questions in family law intake for military families.
Frequently asked questions
Can intake staff tell a caller the statute of limitations for their type of case?
No. Even a general statement can be wrong for that caller because of the state, the defendant, discovery rules or exceptions. Staff record the dates and route the file; the attorney discusses timing.
Who sets the review thresholds for red and amber flags?
The attorneys, in writing, for each practice area. Staff compare dates against those thresholds without interpreting the law.
What should a decline letter say about deadlines?
That time limits may apply and the person should consult another lawyer promptly. It should not state a specific deadline or an opinion on the merits.
Does this apply to automated intake?
Yes. Ethics guidance treats intake systems as something lawyers must supervise. Configure automated intake to collect facts and flag files, never to advise.
References
The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) โ
American Bar Association (2026). Rule 5.3: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistance, ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ
American Bar Association (2025). Rule 1.18: Duties to Prospective Client, ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ
The State Bar of California (2026). Practical Guidance for the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence in the Practice of Law (opens in a new tab) โ