Key takeaways
- Sort every adjuster by type (liability, the client's own carrier, property damage, workers' compensation) because the type decides the route.
- Write one log line per call: carrier, claim number, insured, direct line, request, any date given and what the caller was told.
- Never agree to or refuse a recorded statement at the front desk. Log it and route it the same day.
- Capture any settlement figure word for word and get it to the attorney within minutes: the lawyer must promptly convey offers[2] and the client decides whether to settle[3].
Why adjuster calls need a fixed routine
Adjusters call injury firms all day, and they are good at it. Their job is to gather facts, close files and pay what the policy and the evidence require, and the first person they reach at a law firm is rarely the lawyer. A receptionist who wants to be helpful can, in one friendly sentence, confirm a gap in treatment, guess at a return-to-work date or agree to “just a quick recorded statement next week.” None of that can be taken back.
The money behind those calls keeps growing. The average paid auto bodily injury liability claim reached $28,278 in 2024, up from $17,014 in 2015, in industry data that include the insurer's own claim-handling costs[1]. Paid bodily injury claims ran at 0.80 per 100 insured car years in 2024[1]. Every one of those claims involves an adjuster, and in a represented claim many of the adjuster's calls land on a law firm's front desk.
Source: Insurance Information Institute, 2025[1]
Show the data
| Year | Average paid claim |
|---|---|
| 2015 | $17,014 |
| 2016 | $16,082 |
| 2017 | $16,234 |
| 2018 | $18,213 |
| 2019 | $19,151 |
| 2020 | $20,769 |
| 2021 | $23,592 |
| 2022 | $24,681 |
| 2023 | $26,178 |
| 2024 | $28,278 |
Adjusters also work to deadlines. California's fair claims rules, for example, require an insurer to give a complete response within 15 calendar days to a claimant's communication that reasonably expects one, and to acknowledge a notice of claim and begin investigating within 15 calendar days[4]. Other states have their own versions. A firm that loses track of what an adjuster asked, or what the firm sent and when, gives up a timeline it could have held the carrier to.
Sort the adjuster before you say anything
“Adjuster” covers several kinds of caller with different relationships to your client. Ask three things first: which company, which claim number, and whose policy. The answers decide where the call goes.
| Adjuster type | Usually calling about | Front desk response | Routes to |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liability adjuster for the at-fault party | Status, medical records, a recorded statement, settlement discussions | Take details; nothing about the client or the injuries | Attorney or case manager on the file |
| Client's own auto carrier (PIP, MedPay, collision) | Benefit forms, a statement under the policy, bills, the vehicle | Take details; the attorney decides what the client provides under the policy | Case manager, same day |
| Property damage adjuster | Vehicle location, photos, rental, total-loss value | Logistics only if the attorney has approved a property damage contact | Paralegal handling property damage |
| Workers' compensation adjuster | Benefits, return to work, scheduling an independent medical exam | Take details; never confirm work status | Attorney on the file |
| Health plan recovery unit | Repayment of accident-related bills | Where to send the notice in writing | Lien desk |
First-party and third-party callers are not interchangeable. The client's own insurer may have rights under the policy, and the client may owe it cooperation; how the client meets those duties is advice only the attorney gives. A liability adjuster for the other driver has no such relationship with the client. Staff do not need to know the difference in depth, only that they must write down which one is calling. The coverage layers the firm records at intake are listed in insurance details to collect in accident cases, and they make this sort quicker.
One log line for every adjuster call
Every adjuster call produces the same record, whether the adjuster asks for something specific or just “checks in.” Use the same fields every time so the attorney can scan a week of calls on one matter in a minute.
Example log line: 10:42 am Tue | MATTER: Ruiz v. Doe (PI-2291) | CALLER: Dana Whitfield, bodily injury adjuster, [carrier] | CLAIM NO.: 44-81-0973 | INSURED: Doe | DIRECT LINE: [number], ext. 4471 | REQUEST: recorded statement from client | DATE GIVEN: “by Friday” | TOLD CALLER: the attorney's office will respond in writing | ROUTED TO: case manager, 10:44 am
Two fields carry more weight than they look. Date given records any deadline the adjuster mentions, because it sets the attorney's priorities and later shows who said what. Told caller records the firm's promise, which stops the next person from contradicting it. Courts and opposing counsel get a similar record in handling calls from opposing counsel and courts; for adjusters, put the claim number and the insured's name at the top.
- Caller
- Your team
01Caller
Adjuster calls
A bodily injury adjuster asks for a recorded statement from the client by Friday.
02Your team
Carrier and claim taken
Company, claim number, insured and direct line, checked against the file.
03Your team
Request logged word for word
The request and the Friday date are written down; nothing is said about the client.
04Your team
Routed as urgent
The case manager and attorney have the message within minutes.
05Your team
Adjuster told the next step
“The attorney's office will answer you in writing.” No promise beyond that.
Example sequence. The same five steps apply to any adjuster request; only the routing changes.
Recorded statement requests
Recorded statement requests are the call staff most often get wrong, in both directions. Saying yes commits the client to an interview the attorney has not prepared for. Saying “we never do those” may be wrong under the client's own policy, and it is an answer only the attorney can give. The right response is neither.
Example script: “I'm not able to schedule or agree to anything on the client's behalf. I'm passing your request to the attorney now, with your claim number and the date you mentioned. You'll hear back from the attorney's office.”
Then route it that day. The solo personal injury example treats an adjuster wanting a recorded statement before the attorney can call back as one of three urgent triggers, which is a sensible default for any injury practice. If the adjuster mentions having already spoken to the client directly, write that down too; the attorney will want to know before the client's next call.
Settlement figures said to the front desk
Adjusters sometimes float numbers to whoever answers: “Tell her we could do fifteen if it closes this month.” Staff should neither react to the figure nor discuss it, but they must capture it exactly. A lawyer who receives a settlement offer in a civil matter must promptly tell the client its substance unless the client has already said how to respond[2], and the decision whether to settle belongs to the client[3]. An offer that dies on a sticky note is a problem for the client, the lawyer and the firm.
- The exact figure and any conditions, in the adjuster's own words.
- Any deadline or expiry the adjuster attached to it.
- Whether it was put as an offer, a range or “authority.”
- The time of the call and the name of the person who took it.
Read it back to the adjuster, send it to the attorney as an urgent message within minutes, and confirm to the adjuster that it has been passed on. That is the whole of the front desk's role: no counteroffer, no “I think she was hoping for more,” no view on whether the number is fair.
What staff can share, and what they must not
The default is nothing about the client. ABA Model Rule 1.6 bars a lawyer from revealing information relating to the representation without the client's informed consent, implied authorization to carry out the representation, or one of the rule's listed exceptions[5]. Adjusters do receive information from the firm, through demand packages and the attorney's own calls, because that disclosure carries out the representation. It is still a decision the attorney makes about what to share, when and in what form.
| Improvised answer | Routine answer | |
|---|---|---|
| Recorded statement request | “Sure, Tuesday works.” | Logged, routed today; the answer comes from the attorney |
| Settlement figure mentioned | “That seems low.” | Exact words read back; urgent message to the attorney |
| Question about treatment | “She's still in therapy twice a week.” | “I can't discuss the client. I'll pass on your question.” |
| Request for records | “I'll fax what we have.” | Request logged; documents go out only on the attorney's word |
| “Is she back at work?” | “I think she started last week.” | Not answered; question logged for the attorney |
| Callback request | “Someone will call you today.” | A callback window the attorney's calendar can keep |
Example answers. The routine column is what the attorney approves in writing.
Verification matters as much as discretion. Call adjusters back on the carrier's main number or the number on the claim correspondence, not only a number left in a voicemail. A caller who says they are an adjuster but cannot give a claim number or a carrier phone number is unverified, and gets nothing beyond an offer to take a message.
When the client calls about the adjuster
Half of adjuster traffic arrives secondhand. A client rings to say the other driver's insurer left a voicemail, or texted a link to upload photos, or asked her to sign a medical release. Most injury attorneys give clients a standing instruction about insurer contact when the retainer is signed. The front desk's job is to repeat that instruction exactly as the attorney wrote it, not to improvise a softer or stronger version, and to log the contact as if the adjuster had called the firm.
Ask the client for the adjuster's name, company, claim number and phone number from the voicemail or letter, what was asked for, and whether the client said or signed anything. Then send it to the case manager the same day. A release or authorization the client is unsure about goes to the attorney before it goes back to the insurer.
Example: on a Thursday afternoon the front desk takes three adjuster-related calls in forty minutes. A property damage adjuster wants the car's location, which the attorney has approved sharing, so the desk gives the tow yard address and logs it. A liability adjuster asks whether the client has finished therapy; the desk takes the question and routes it. Then the client calls: the same liability adjuster has phoned her directly. All three entries sit on the matter's log by 4 pm, and the attorney sees the pattern in one glance.
Train it, then check it
ABA Model Rule 5.3 puts the duty on partners and supervising lawyers to make reasonable efforts so that nonlawyer staff act in line with the lawyer's own professional obligations[6]. For adjuster calls, that means a written routine, a short practice session and a regular check that the routine is being followed.
Write a one-page routine
The caller sort, the log line, the recorded-statement script, the settlement-figure capture and the questions never answered. The attorney signs it.
Role-play five calls
A liability adjuster asking about treatment, the client's own carrier asking for a statement, a property damage call, an adjuster with a number, and a caller who will not give a claim number.
Spot-check the log weekly
Pick five adjuster entries. Is the claim number there? Did settlement figures reach the attorney the same day? Did anyone answer a question that should have been routed?
Fix the script, not only the person
If the same mistake appears twice, the routine is unclear. Rewrite the line, retrain, and check again the following week.
When the attorney is in and wants the call, transfer it once the log line is written; the habits in warm transfers: passing calls to attorneys smoothly apply. When the attorney is out, the format in message-taking standards for law offices plus the claim number and insured's name is enough.
Overflow and late-afternoon adjuster calls
Adjusters keep business hours, but they call when the desk is busy and leave voicemails at 4:55 pm on a Friday. An SI Employee can take those calls with the same routine: it asks for the company, claim number, insured, direct line and request, never discusses the client, and sends the summary with the recording and transcript to the case manager. Recorded-statement requests and anything that sounds like an offer can be marked urgent and sent down the firm's escalation tree, and it never promises that the attorney is available. More on how it answers a firm's calls.
Medical providers and lienholders calling about bills need a different routine, with an authorization check and an update calendar; that is set out in handling medical provider and lien calls.
Frequently asked questions
Should the receptionist tell an adjuster that the client has a lawyer?
If the adjuster is calling the firm about the claim, they already know. If someone calls to ask whether a person is a client, staff confirm nothing and take a message; the attorney handles the letter of representation.
Can staff send an adjuster the client's medical records?
Only when the attorney directs it. Records usually go out as part of a demand package the attorney prepares, and disclosure without the client's consent or implied authorization is barred[5].
What if an adjuster tells the receptionist a settlement figure?
Write it down word for word, read it back, and send it to the attorney as an urgent message. The lawyer must promptly convey the substance of offers to the client[2], and the client decides whether to settle[3].
Do adjusters have their own deadlines?
Yes, under state fair claims rules. In California an insurer must give a complete response within 15 calendar days to a claimant's communication that reasonably expects one[4]. Logging dates lets the attorney hold carriers to them.
Should we record adjuster calls?
Many firms record every call. Check the consent rules where your callers are, say so in your greeting, and see call recording consent laws by state before you switch it on.
References
Insurance Information Institute (2025). Facts + Statistics: Auto insurance (opens in a new tab) ↑
American Bar Association (2025). Comment on Rule 1.4, ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) ↑
American Bar Association (2025). Rule 1.2: Scope of Representation and Allocation of Authority Between Client and Lawyer, ABA Model Rules (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 10, § 2695.5 - Duties upon Receipt of Communications (opens in a new tab) ↑
American Bar Association (2025). Rule 1.6: Confidentiality of Information, ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) ↑
American Bar Association (2026). Rule 5.3: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistance, ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) ↑