Scenario profile
- Business
- Example: Fernhollow Injury Law (solo attorney, one paralegal)
- Industry
- Personal injury law: car crashes, falls on someone else's property and dog bites, on contingency
- Size
- One attorney who owns the firm and one full-time paralegal; no receptionist
- Setting
- Small office in a suburban county; new cases come from search ads, social ads and a local TV spot
- Call volume
- About 45 calls a week, roughly 18 of them on weekday evenings or at weekends
Key takeaways
- In this example about two in five calls arrive after 6 pm or at the weekend, when the ads are working and the office is closed.
- The modelled setup takes the conflict-check names and asks whether the caller already has a lawyer before it asks what happened.
- Intake covers the incident date, injuries, treatment and insurance, then books a consultation or takes a request the paralegal confirms by 9 am.
- The attorney keeps every legal judgment: whether there is a case, what it may be worth, the fee and any conflict.
- Every figure here is modelled from the sources listed, not measured at a real firm.
The firm in this example
Fernhollow Injury Law is a fictional firm. One attorney owns it and handles consultations, negotiations and court work. One paralegal runs everything else: medical records, demand packages, client calls and, until now, every new inquiry. There is no receptionist.
The firm buys its cases with advertising: search ads, social ads and a fifteen-second spot during the local evening news. That spend sets the phone pattern. People call about a crash when they are home from work and have time to think, and most of them work weekdays: 81% of employed people worked on an average weekday in 2025, against 30% on an average weekend day[1].
In this example the firm takes about 45 calls a week. Roughly 18 come after 6 pm or on Saturday and Sunday, and about half of those are new injury inquiries. The rest are existing clients, billing offices at medical providers, the odd adjuster and the usual sales calls.
Evenings and weekends before the change
Before the change, the main line goes to voicemail at 6 pm with a greeting that promises a call back the next business day. The attorney checks messages from home most nights and returns the ones that sound serious, from a personal mobile. Everything else waits for the paralegal.
Monday is the worst of it. In this example the paralegal starts the week with eight to twelve weekend messages. Several callers have told the whole story into the machine, names and injuries and what the other driver said, before anyone has checked for a conflict.
In a two-car crash both drivers can end up calling the same firm. ABA Model Rule 1.18 can bar a lawyer who learned information that could significantly harm a prospective client from acting against that person in the same or a substantially related matter; one way out requires reasonable measures to avoid hearing more than was needed to decide whether to take the case[2]. A voicemail box takes no measures at all.
Then come the callbacks. The paralegal rings back from a direct line the caller has never seen, and eight in ten Americans say they do not generally answer when an unknown number calls[3]. In this example, someone who called three firms from the couch on Saturday night may already have booked with whichever one picked up. The paralegal finds that out on the third attempt, or never.
How the SI Employee is set up
In the modelled setup an SI Employee answers the firm's main number from 6 pm to 8:30 am on weekdays and all weekend, plus any daytime call the paralegal cannot pick up within four rings. The attorney signs off every part of it first: the greeting, the question order, the matters the firm turns away and who gets an urgent call.
The greeting tells the caller they are speaking with the firm's automated intake assistant, not a person and not a lawyer, that it cannot give legal advice and that the call is recorded. Florida Bar Opinion 24-1 says a firm's AI chatbot must tell people it is an AI program, not a lawyer or a firm employee, and suggests screening questions for people who already have a lawyer[4]. The attorney words the greeting for their own state bar.
The questions come in a fixed order, and the order is the point:
- Names first: the caller, anyone else hurt, and the other driver, property owner or business involved, for the paralegal's conflict check.
- Representation: has the caller already hired or signed with a lawyer about this incident? If so, the call ends politely with a note for the attorney.
- The incident: date, city and type, such as a rear-end crash, a store fall or a dog bite.
- Injuries and treatment: what hurts, whether they went to the ER, urgent care or their own doctor, and whether treatment is continuing.
- Insurance: the caller's auto carrier, the other side's carrier if known, any claim number, and whether an adjuster has asked for a recorded statement.
It does not ask for the story in the caller's own words, and steers back to the list when a caller starts telling it. ABA Formal Opinion 506 lets lawyers train and supervise non-lawyer staff to take this kind of intake, from the parties' names to a first conflict check, but if a prospect asks what legal help they need, wants to negotiate the fee or asks what the agreement means, the lawyer must answer[5]. The setup keeps that split: such questions go into the attorney's summary, unanswered on the call.
- Caller
- SI Employee
- System
- Your team
01Caller
Call at 8:40 pm
Rear-ended at a light on Sunday; neck pain, seen at urgent care on Monday.
02SI Employee
Disclosure, then names
Says it is automated, not a lawyer, and the call is recorded; takes both drivers' names.
03SI Employee
Already represented?
The caller has not hired another lawyer, so intake continues.
04SI Employee
Injuries and insurance
Treatment so far, both carriers, a claim number, no recorded statement given yet.
05SI Employee
Consultation booked
Wednesday 9:30 am on the firm's consultation calendar; the caller accepts.
06System
Summary to the firm
Summary, recording and transcript in the account; attorney and paralegal emailed.
07Your team
Conflict check at 8:30
Paralegal runs both names before the consult and calls to confirm the time.
Example: fictional firm and caller, after the calendar is connected. A real setup follows the script the attorney approves.
Three yes-or-no answers count as urgent in this example: someone in the incident died, the caller or a family member is still in hospital, or an adjuster wants a recorded statement before the attorney could call back in the morning. Those calls go to the attorney's mobile, then the paralegal's, then a tested fallback: an urgent message for the attorney and an honest word to the caller that nobody picked up. No caller is promised the attorney.
Everyone else who fits the firm's criteria is offered a consultation, booked straight onto the firm's consultation calendar once that calendar is connected and tested. Until then, for the first few days of live calls in this example, the SI Employee takes a request with two preferred times and the paralegal confirms each by 9 am. Every call lands in the firm's account with a summary, recording and transcript, and the attorney and paralegal both get an email.
Before and after, call by call
| After-hours moment | Before (voicemail, next-day callbacks) | After (modelled setup) |
|---|---|---|
| Tuesday 8:40 pm, rear-end crash, from a search ad | Voicemail; the paralegal calls back at 10 am Wednesday from a direct line the caller does not recognize | Answered; names, intake and a Wednesday 9:30 am consultation booked on the call |
| Saturday 2 pm, caller just home from the ER | Message waits until Monday; two callbacks go unanswered | Treatment and insurance taken; Monday consultation booked; summary emailed |
| Caller starts with the whole story | Four minutes of facts on the voicemail before any conflict check | Steered to names and the representation question first; facts kept to the intake list |
| Caller has already signed with another firm | Found out on the callback, after a full conversation | Asked early; the call ends politely and the summary records it |
| Adjuster wants a recorded statement tomorrow | Heard on Monday, possibly after the statement was given | Urgent rule met; routed to the attorney's mobile, then the paralegal's |
| Sunday call from a client about a medical bill | Mixed in with new leads in the voicemail box | Message for the paralegal, kept apart from new inquiries |
| Monday 8:30 am | Paralegal works through the weekend's voicemails | Paralegal runs conflict names and confirms booked consultations |
The morning after
In this example the paralegal blocks the first 45 minutes of every day for the overnight calls, before the phones get busy.
8:30 Run the names
Search every name from the overnight summaries in the conflict system before anyone discusses the facts. Any close match goes to the attorney, who decides whether there is a conflict[5].
8:40 Read the urgent flags
See what the attorney handled last night and what still needs a call.
8:50 Confirm consultations
Call each booked or requested consultation from the firm's main line, the number the caller dialed.
9:05 Open prospect records
Copy each summary into the case management system by hand; there is no direct connection yet.
9:15 Close the loop
Send the attorney's approved decline letter to callers who had a lawyer or fell outside the practice.
The main line matters: the caller dialed it the night before and heard the firm's name, so a call from it stands a better chance of being picked up than one from a number they have never seen.
What the numbers would look like
The model counts the signed cases at risk when evening and weekend inquiries never become a conversation. The average paid private passenger auto bodily injury liability claim was $28,278 in 2024, including the insurer's own claim-handling costs[6]. Florida's bar rules presume a fee above a third of a recovery up to $1 million excessive when an auto case settles before the defendant answers, unless a court approves more[7]. A third of the average claim is about $9,400; the model rounds down to $9,000 because the insurer's costs never reach the client.
| Input | Example |
|---|---|
| Evening and weekend calls per week | 18 |
| Share lost before a callback connects | 35% |
| Share that are new injury inquiries | 50% |
| Share of those inquiries that would sign | 12% |
| Fee on one signed case | $9,000 |
| Unanswered calls a month | 27 |
| From new customers | 14 |
| Bookings that would have followed | 1.6 |
| Monthly value at risk | $14,731 |
How it is worked out: Calls a week × 4.33 weeks × unanswered share × new-customer share × booking rate × average value.
Assumptions
- A fee of $9,000, rounded down from a third of the $28,278 average paid auto bodily injury liability claim in 2024.[6]
- A third is the most Florida's bar rules allow, without court approval, on an auto case settled before an answer is filed.[7]
- Callbacks from an unfamiliar number often go unanswered: eight in ten Americans say they do not generally answer when an unknown number calls.[3]
- Eighteen calls a week, a 35% lost share, half of them new inquiries and a 12% signing rate are invented for this example.
Example only: modelled, not measured. A contingency fee is paid only if the case resolves, usually months after the first call.
In this example that is about 27 lost calls a month, 14 of them new injury inquiries and 1.6 signed cases: roughly $14,700 in modelled fees that would go to whichever firm answered first. Use your own numbers: lower the fee if your cases settle well below the insurance average, and the lost share if you already return every call within the hour.
The first 30 days in this example
Day 1
Attorney approves the greeting, disclosures, question order and the matters the firm turns away.
Day 3
Test calls with fictional cases: a rear-end crash, a store fall, a caller with a lawyer, one asking what the case is worth.
Day 7
Evening, weekend and missed daytime calls forward to the new setup; the paralegal keeps the daytime line.
Day 10
Consultation calendar connected after test bookings land correctly; requests become bookings.
Day 14
Attorney and paralegal listen to every after-hours recording and tighten the questions that confused callers.
Day 30
Attorney compares consultations booked and kept from after-hours calls with the month before.
Example timeline; a real rollout follows the firm's own schedule.
In this example the paralegal keeps two short lists through the first month: callers who said too much before the names were taken, and urgent calls that were not routed. If either list grows, the question order or an escalation rule needs work, and the fix goes into the approved script.
Lessons from the scenario
- Take the conflict names and the representation question before the story. It protects the firm and shortens the call.
- Write the urgent rules as yes-or-no answers. “Sounds serious” is not a rule.
- Keep case value, fees and the meaning of the agreement with the attorney, and have the script say so out loud.
- Call back early, from the number the caller dialed, with the summary open.
- Judge the month on consultations booked and kept from after-hours calls, not on how many calls were answered.
In this example the firm keeps its ads, its number, its attorney and its paralegal. What changes is that the 8:40 pm caller is answered that night, gives the names before the story, and has a consultation time before the next firm on the list calls back.
More detail: personal injury intake questions and red flags, running a conflict check at intake, insurance details to collect in accident cases, qualifying leads without giving legal advice and speed to lead for law firms. For what an SI Employee handles on a live call today, see what it does.
Frequently asked questions
Is Fernhollow Injury Law a real firm?
No. It is a fictional firm used to show the method. The call volumes, rates and timeline are invented for the example or modelled from the sources listed.
Does the SI Employee tell callers whether they have a case?
No. In this example it takes conflict names, gathers the intake facts and books or requests a consultation. Whether there is a case, what it may be worth and what the fee would be are questions for the attorney, and the script tells the caller so.
Who runs the conflict check?
The paralegal, in the firm's own system, before the consultation. Any close match goes to the attorney, who decides whether there is a conflict. The phone setup only collects the names in the order the attorney approved; it makes no conflict decision. See running a conflict check at intake.
What happens if the caller already has a lawyer?
In this example the call ends politely once the caller says they have signed with another firm about the same incident, and the summary notes it for the attorney. Nobody tries to win the case away on that call.
Can it text the caller a confirmation?
Not in this setup. Texting callers is scoped separately and only with the consent and wording the law requires. Here the paralegal confirms each consultation by phone from the firm's main line.
References
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). American Time Use Survey - 2025 Results (opens in a new tab) ↑
American Bar Association (2020). Rule 1.18: Duties to Prospective Client, ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) ↑
American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2023). Formal Opinion 506: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistants (opens in a new tab) ↑
Insurance Information Institute (2024). Facts + Statistics: Auto insurance (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Florida Bar (2018). Consumer Pamphlet: Attorneys' Fees (opens in a new tab) ↑