Ethics and Compliance

Running a Conflict Check at Intake: What to Collect First

The data points to collect before any substantive facts, how to search them, and a script that keeps intake calls below the disqualification threshold.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. Why the order of questions matters
  2. What to collect before any facts
  3. A script that keeps the call clean
  4. How to run the search
  5. Why returning callers need extra care
  6. Common gaps in conflict systems
  7. When the check finds something
  8. Checks are not only for new callers
  9. Example: a business dispute
  10. Related guides
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Ethics and Compliance: Running a Conflict Check at Intake: What to Collect FirstArticle coverETHICS AND COMPLIANCERunning a ConflictCheck at Intake: Whatto Collect FirstAva for LawyersInsightsEthics and Compliance: Running a Conflict Check at Intake: What to Collect FirstArticle coverETHICS AND COMPLIANCERunning a ConflictCheck at Intake: Whatto Collect FirstAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Collect names and relationships before the story: a lawyer who hears significantly harmful facts from a prospective client can be disqualified from the other side[1].
  • Search every party, not just the caller: a concurrent conflict exists when one client's matter is directly adverse to another client or materially limited by duties to others[2].
  • Ask early whether the caller already has a lawyer for this matter[3].
  • People with one legal problem often have several: 39% of low-income households had five or more civil legal problems in a year[4], so log every name, every time.

Why the order of questions matters

The conflict check is the one intake step that protects existing clients as well as the caller. If staff collect the full story first and check conflicts afterwards, the firm may already have received information that could be significantly harmful to the caller, which under the ABA Model Rule can disqualify the lawyer, and through them the firm, from representing the other side in the same or a substantially related matter[1]. If the other side is an existing client, the firm has created a problem it did not need.

The fix is a fixed order. Identity and parties first, a short description of the matter second, the conflict search third and the facts only after the check clears. The rest of this guide sets out exactly what to collect at each step.

What to collect before any facts

Minimum conflict data to collect before taking any narrative
Data pointWhy it mattersExample question
Caller's full legal name and former namesMatches past clients and adverse parties recorded under a different nameWhat is your full name, and have you used any other names?
Company names, if a business is involvedBusinesses appear under trade names and parent companiesWhat is the business's legal name, and does it trade under another name?
Other parties and their relationshipsThe core of the adverse party searchWho is on the other side? Anyone else involved?
Lawyers already involvedIdentifies represented persons and opposing counselDo you already have a lawyer for this? Does the other side?
Matter type in one lineLets the attorney judge substantial relationshipIn a sentence, what is this about?
Key datesFlags urgency without needing the storyIs there a court date or deadline coming up?

Florida's ethics guidance on AI intake tools makes the same point about represented persons: a lawyer should consider screening questions that limit an intake chatbot's communications if the person already has a lawyer[3]. The question belongs in human intake too.

A script that keeps the call clean

Script: β€œBefore you tell me what happened, I need to check that we're able to help, because we may already represent someone involved. Can I take your full name, the names of the other people or companies involved, and whether anyone already has a lawyer? It takes a minute, and then I can hear the details.”

Callers accept this when it is framed as protecting them. If they start telling the story anyway, interrupt politely: β€œI'd like to hear that, and I will. Let me just get the names first so we don't put your information at risk.” Note in the record that the caller began to share details and what was said, so the attorney can judge any exposure.

If an SI Employee such as Ava answers your intake line, give it the same order: it should ask the questions your firm approves, including the names needed for your conflict check, before hearing the story, and hand a clean summary to the person who runs the search.

  1. Search every name, not just the caller

    Search the caller, every adverse party, related businesses and opposing counsel. Under the ABA rule, a concurrent conflict exists where one client's matter would be directly adverse to another client, or where duties to another client, a former client or a third person create a significant risk of materially limiting the representation[2].

  2. Use variations

    Search maiden and married names, both surnames for people who use two, nicknames, initials and common misspellings. Search businesses by legal name, trade name and parent company.

  3. Include declined prospects

    Search the prospective client list as well as clients. A person the firm declined last year may still be owed confidentiality, and what they told the firm may affect whether it can act against them now[1].

  4. Record the result

    Note who ran the search, when, which names were searched and what was found, even when nothing was found.

  5. Escalate any hit

    Any match goes to an attorney before the firm takes facts or books a consultation. Staff should not decide whether a hit is a real conflict.

Why returning callers need extra care

Legal problems cluster. The Legal Services Corporation found that 74% of low-income households experienced at least one civil legal problem in a year, 39% experienced five or more and 20% experienced ten or more[4]. A caller who rings about a debt collection lawsuit this year may call about an eviction or a family matter next year. Every one of those contacts adds names to your database, and every one of those names may matter later.

Low-income US households with civil legal problems in the past year
Low-income US households with civil legal problems in the past yearBar chart. At least one problem: 74%; Five or more problems: 39%; Ten or more problems: 20%.At least one problemAt least one problem: 74%74%Five or more problemsFive or more problems: 39%39%Ten or more problemsTen or more problems: 20%20%Low-income US households with civil legal problems in the past yearBar chart. At least one problem: 74%; Five or more problems: 39%; Ten or more problems: 20%.At least one problemAt least one problem: 74%74%Five or more problemsFive or more problems: 39%39%Ten or more problemsTen or more problems: 20%20%

Source: Legal Services Corporation, 2022[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
At least one problem74%
Five or more problems39%
Ten or more problems20%

That is why a good conflict database records prospective clients, adverse parties and related people for declined matters as well as accepted ones. A database that only holds clients will miss the cases where the risk is highest.

Common gaps in conflict systems

  • Only clients are entered, not prospective clients or adverse parties.
  • Names live in email and voicemail but never reach the database.
  • Attorneys who joined from another firm have not entered their former clients, where your state's rules require that to be checked.
  • Business relationships, such as a corporate client's subsidiaries, are missing.
  • Searches are exact-match only, so spelling variations slip through.
  • Nobody owns the database, so duplicates and gaps build up.

When the check finds something

A hit is not automatically a conflict. The attorney needs to judge whether the matters are the same or substantially related, whether interests are actually adverse and whether consent is possible. While that happens, intake should pause without revealing why. Never tell a caller that the firm represents the other side; that disclosure itself can breach confidentiality.

Script when a hit needs review: β€œThank you. I need an attorney to review something before we go further. I'm not able to say more than that right now. Can I call you back by the end of today?”

If the attorney concludes the firm cannot act, decline promptly in writing, without detail, and suggest the caller consult another lawyer soon if time limits may apply.

Checks are not only for new callers

Intake is the obvious moment for a conflict check, but it is not the only one. Existing clients bring new matters, and each new matter can involve new adverse parties. Parties are added to litigation, a business client acquires a company, a divorce client's new partner becomes relevant to custody. Each of these events should trigger a fresh search, run the same way and recorded the same way as a new intake.

  1. New matter for an existing client: run a full search on the new parties before opening the file.
  2. New party added to an open matter: search them the day they appear in pleadings or correspondence.
  3. Change in a corporate client's structure: update parent, subsidiary and affiliate names.
  4. New lawyer or staff member joining: follow your state's rules on checking their prior work.
  5. Matter reopened after a long gap: search again, because the database has changed since.

Give one person responsibility for noticing these triggers. In a small firm that is often the paralegal who opens files, with a standing instruction that no new matter number is issued until the search is recorded.

Example: a business dispute

Example (fictional): a caller says his landscaping company is owed money by a property management firm. Intake takes his name, his company's legal and trade names, the property manager's name and the fact that the property manager has a lawyer. The search shows the property manager's parent company is a current client of the firm's real estate group. The intake specialist pauses the call, promising a callback.

The attorney reviews the hit and concludes the matter would be directly adverse to a current client. The firm declines by letter the same day. Because intake never took the story, the firm received nothing beyond names and a one-line description, and its existing client relationship is untouched.

For the rule behind this process, read ABA Model Rule 1.18: duties to prospective clients. For what to do when a lawyer has already heard too much, see avoiding disqualification after a prospective client consult. The full intake sequence is in our client intake checklist from first call to signed retainer. This article is general information, not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

What information is needed for a conflict check?

The caller's full name and former names, business names, the names of other parties and their relationships, any lawyers already involved, a one-line description of the matter and key dates.

Should intake take the facts before running conflicts?

No. Collect names first and run the check before taking the story, so the firm does not receive significantly harmful information from someone it cannot represent.

Do declined prospective clients belong in the conflict database?

Yes. The firm still owes them confidentiality, and what they shared may limit whether the firm can act against them later.

What should staff say if the conflict check finds a match?

Pause without explaining, say an attorney needs to review something and promise a callback. Never reveal that the firm represents the other side.

References

  1. American Bar Association (2025). Rule 1.18: Duties to Prospective Client, ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. American Bar Association (2026). Rule 1.7: Conflict of Interest: Current Clients, ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo