Practice Area Playbooks

Insurance Details to Collect in Accident Cases

The insurance data list for first contact in accident cases: every policy that may apply, claim and adjuster details, health plan liens and the documents.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why insurance belongs on the first call
  2. The layers of coverage to ask about
  3. The question order that works on the phone
  4. Documents to request
  5. Policy limits: what intake records and what it doesn't
  6. Example: a passenger in a rideshare crash
  7. Health plans and liens: note them early
  8. Mistakes that cost weeks
  9. Keeping insurance data usable
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Practice Area Playbooks: Insurance Details to Collect in Accident CasesArticle coverPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSInsurance Details toCollect in AccidentCasesAva for LawyersInsightsPractice Area Playbooks: Insurance Details to Collect in Accident CasesArticle coverPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSInsurance Details toCollect in AccidentCasesAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • More than one in seven US drivers (15.4%) were uninsured in 2023, and one in three (33.4%) were uninsured or underinsured, so the caller's own policy often matters as much as the other driver's[1].
  • Collect insurance in layers: the other party, the caller's own auto policy, household policies, any employer or rideshare policy, and health coverage.
  • Ask callers to photograph cards, declarations pages and adjuster letters; 91% of US adults own a smartphone[2].
  • Record whether the caller has given a recorded statement or signed anything, and flag it for the attorney.

Why insurance belongs on the first call

In most accident cases, the money that pays a settlement comes from an insurance policy. Which policies exist, and how much coverage they hold, shapes whether a case is viable and how it will be valued. Callers rarely know this, and they rarely volunteer what they do know. A structured insurance section in the intake form, asked the same way every time, saves days of chasing later.

The need is not shrinking. NHTSA estimates 39,345 people died in US motor vehicle crashes in 2024[3], and the injured far outnumber the dead. Meanwhile coverage gaps are widening: the Insurance Research Council estimates that 15.4% of drivers were uninsured in 2023 and that 33.4% were either uninsured or underinsured, a combined rate up 10 percentage points since 2017[1].

US drivers without adequate auto insurance, 2023Insurance Research Council estimates based on insurance claims data
US drivers without adequate auto insurance, 2023Comparison. Uninsured: 15.4%; Uninsured or underinsured: 33.4%.15.4%UninsuredUninsured: 15.4%33.4%Uninsured or underinsuredUninsured or underinsured: 33.4%US drivers without adequate auto insurance, 2023Comparison. Uninsured: 15.4%; Uninsured or underinsured: 33.4%.15.4%UninsuredUninsured: 15.4%33.4%Uninsured or underinsuredUninsured or underinsured: 33.4%

Source: Insurance Research Council, 2025[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Uninsured15.4%
Uninsured or underinsured33.4%

That second figure is the reason intake must ask about the caller's own policy, not just the other driver's. When the at-fault driver has no coverage or too little, uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage on the caller's policy may be where the claim goes. Whether it applies is a question for the attorney; intake's job is to capture the policy details so the question can be answered.

The layers of coverage to ask about

Insurance layers to capture at first contact in an accident case
LayerWhose policyDetails to collect
At-fault party's liabilityThe other driver, owner or businessCarrier name, policy number if known, claim number, adjuster's name and phone
Caller's own auto policyThe callerCarrier, policy number, named insureds, any uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage, medical payments or personal injury protection
Household policiesRelatives living in the same homeCarrier and policy holder for each vehicle in the household
Commercial or employer policyThe employer, if either driver was workingEmployer name, whether the vehicle was a company vehicle, the employer's carrier if known
Rideshare or delivery platformThe platform, if a driver was logged inPlatform name, whether a trip was in progress, the trip receipt or screenshot
Premises or homeowner'sProperty owner, for falls or dog bitesOwner or business name, address, any incident report number
Health coverageThe callerHealth plan, Medicare or Medicaid, employer plan; which plan paid for treatment so far
Workers' compensationThe employer, if injured on the jobWhether a claim was reported, the claim number, the employer's carrier

Not every layer applies to every call. The point of listing them is that staff ask, rather than assume. A caller who says the other driver had insurance may not mention that the other driver was on a delivery shift, which can change the picture entirely.

The working question deserves particular care. Private employers reported 2.5 million nonfatal workplace injuries and illnesses in 2024[4], and a share of those happen in vehicles: delivery drivers, sales staff on the road, contractors driving between job sites. When the caller was working, there may be a workers' compensation claim alongside a claim against the other driver, and the two interact. Record the employer's name, the caller's job and what they were doing at the time of the crash, then let the attorney sort out which claims apply.

The question order that works on the phone

  1. Start with what happened

    Get the date, place and a one-sentence account before any insurance questions, so the caller doesn't feel processed.

  2. Ask about the other party

    Did you get the other driver's name and insurance? Has their insurance company contacted you? Do you have a claim number?

  3. Ask whether anyone was working

    Was either driver working at the time, driving a company vehicle, or logged in to a rideshare or delivery app?

  4. Ask about the caller's own policy

    Who is your auto insurer? Have you reported the crash to them? Do you have your declarations page or an insurance card?

  5. Ask about the household

    Does anyone else in your home have their own vehicle and insurance?

  6. Ask about health coverage

    How has your medical treatment been paid for so far? Which health plan do you have?

  7. Ask about statements and signatures

    Has any insurance company asked you for a recorded statement, or asked you to sign anything? Did you?

If the caller has already given a recorded statement or signed a release or medical authorization for an insurer, mark the file for prompt attorney review and ask the caller to send copies of anything they signed.

Documents to request

  • Photos of both sides of every insurance card exchanged at the scene.
  • The caller's auto declarations page, which lists coverages and limits. Most insurers make it available in their app or online account.
  • Every letter, email or text from an insurer or adjuster, including claim acknowledgment letters.
  • The police report number or exchange-of-information form from the scene.
  • For rideshare cases, a screenshot of the trip in the app.
  • Health insurance cards, front and back, and any explanation-of-benefits statements received since the accident.

Ask callers to photograph documents rather than read them out. In 2026, 91% of US adults owned a smartphone[2], so most callers can send clear images within minutes. Give them a secure upload link or the firm's preferred method, and confirm receipt.

Policy limits: what intake records and what it doesn't

Callers often ask how much the other driver's insurance will pay. Staff should not guess, and should not suggest a value. Intake records whatever the caller knows from their own documents, such as the limits on their own declarations page, and leaves requests for the other party's limits to the attorney. Some states have specific procedures for requesting limits, and the timing of that request can be strategic.

Useful wording when the caller asks: The attorney looks at all the insurance that might apply, including your own policy, before talking about value. Getting your declarations page to us is the most helpful thing you can do right now.

Example: a passenger in a rideshare crash

Example (fictional): A man calls about a crash three days ago. He was a rideshare passenger when another car ran a red light. He has the other driver's insurance card photo, but the other carrier has already called him for a recorded statement, which he declined. He has his own auto policy, though he wasn't driving. He went to urgent care, and his employer health plan paid.

The specialist records the other driver's carrier and claim number, the rideshare platform and a screenshot of the trip, the caller's own auto carrier and policy number, his health plan, and the fact that he declined the statement. She asks for his declarations page and the trip receipt that evening, and flags the file because a rideshare platform policy, the other driver's policy and possibly his own coverage may all be relevant. The attorney sees the full insurance picture before the consultation instead of assembling it afterward.

Health plans and liens: note them early

Whoever paid for treatment may claim repayment from a settlement. Medicare, Medicaid, employer health plans and some private insurers have repayment rights, and the rules differ by plan type. Intake only needs to record which plan paid and whether the caller has received any letters about repayment or subrogation. The attorney or the firm's lien team handles the rest. Missing this at intake can delay settlement disbursement months later.

Mistakes that cost weeks

  • Writing the other driver's insurer down from memory without a claim number. Ask the caller to check their phone for a call or text from the adjuster; the claim number is usually in it.
  • Recording only one vehicle's insurance in a multi-car crash. Ask how many vehicles were involved and capture each one.
  • Assuming the vehicle owner and the driver are the same person. Ask who owns the car and who was driving.
  • Missing the working question, so an employer's or platform's policy is discovered months later.
  • Not asking about health coverage, so a lien surfaces at settlement and delays the client's payment.

Each of these is fixed by asking the same questions in the same order on every call. Build the insurance section into the intake form as required fields, train new staff on why each one matters, and spot-check a few files every week for missing claim numbers and adjuster details.

Keeping insurance data usable

  • Use separate fields for carrier, policy number, claim number and adjuster, not one notes box.
  • Record the source of each item: caller's memory, a photo of a card, or a letter.
  • Update the record when new letters arrive; adjusters change often.
  • Link the insurance record to the provider list from the medical records intake, so billing and coverage can be matched later.

Before any of this, run the conflict check on the other driver, the owner and any business involved. For the dates that sit alongside the insurance data, see screening for limitation deadlines without giving advice.

Frequently asked questions

Should intake ask the caller about their own insurance if the other driver was at fault?

Yes. The caller's policy may include uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage, medical payments or personal injury protection that the attorney needs to know about.

What if the caller already gave the other insurer a recorded statement?

Record when it happened and what the caller remembers about it, ask for any related letters, and flag the file for prompt attorney review. Staff should not comment on its effect.

Can staff tell a caller how much a policy will pay?

No. Value depends on liability, damages, every applicable policy and state law. The attorney discusses value after reviewing the facts.

Why ask about household vehicles?

Some policies extend coverage to relatives living in the same household. Recording the household's policies lets the attorney check that quickly.

References

  1. Insurance Research Council (2025). One in Three U.S. Drivers Are Either Uninsured or Underinsured (news release on Uninsured and Underinsured Motorists: 2017โ€“2023) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Pew Research Center (2026). Americans' Use of Mobile Devices in 2026 (Mobile Fact Sheet) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (2024). Early Estimate of Motor Vehicle Traffic Fatalities in 2024 (DOT HS 813 710) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2024). Employer-Reported Workplace Injuries and Illnesses, 2024 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo