Practice Area Playbooks

Uninsured Driver Accident Intake: UM and UIM Questions

When the other driver has no insurance or too little, the caller's own policy may pay. UM and UIM questions, documents and deadlines for the first call.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing10 min read

On this page
  1. The call that ends too early
  2. Four situations, four sets of questions
  3. Find every policy in the household
  4. Hit-and-run: the clock starts at the scene
  5. Underinsured: the settlement offer is the danger
  6. One call, start to finish
  7. Example: the limits letter
  8. Documents to request before the consultation
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
Practice Area Playbooks: Uninsured Driver Accident Intake: UM and UIM Questions33.4%: of US drivers were uninsured or underinsured in 2023, up 10 percentage points since 2017PRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSUninsured Driver AccidentIntake: UM and UIM Questions33.4%of US drivers were uninsured or underinsured in2023, up 10 percentage points since 2017Ava for LawyersInsightsPractice Area Playbooks: Uninsured Driver Accident Intake: UM and UIM Questions33.4%: of US drivers were uninsured or underinsured in 2023, up 10 percentage points since 2017PRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSUninsured DriverAccident Intake: UMand UIM Questions33.4%of US drivers were uninsured orunderinsured in 2023, up 10 percentagepoints since 2017Ava for Lawyers
Figure source: Insurance Research Council, 2025[1]

Key takeaways

  • “The other driver had no insurance” is the start of the intake, not the end. Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage on the caller's own policy may apply[1].
  • Ask for every policy in the household, the declarations pages and any signed form rejecting or lowering UM coverage[2].
  • Hit-and-run calls carry short reporting clocks. In New York, an MVAIC claim against an unidentified driver needs a police report within 24 hours[3].
  • A settlement offer from the at-fault insurer is an urgent flag. Florida, for one, requires written notice to the underinsured motorist insurer before such a settlement[2].
  • Intake never values the coverage or the case; it collects the documents the attorney needs to do that.

The call that ends too early

Callers often open with the sentence that makes them think they have no case: “The other guy didn't have insurance.” Some say it and hang up before anyone asks a second question. Others mention it near the end, as an apology. Either way, the firm loses the call if intake treats it as a dead end, because the money in these cases frequently comes from the caller's own policy, or from one held by someone in the caller's household.

The situation is common. The Insurance Research Council estimates that 15.4% of US drivers were uninsured in 2023, and that one in three, 33.4%, were either uninsured or underinsured, a rise of 10 percentage points since 2017[1]. Uninsured motorist (UM) coverage compensates people hurt by a driver with no liability insurance or by a hit-and-run driver; underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage pays for costs beyond what the at-fault driver's policy covers[1].

Estimated share of US motorists who were uninsured, 2017–2023Insurance Research Council estimate, measured as the ratio of uninsured motorist claims to bodily injury claims.
Estimated share of US motorists who were uninsured, 2017–2023Line chart. 2017: 12.4%; 2018: 12.1%; 2019: 11.6%; 2020: 14.3%; 2021: 14.6%; 2022: 15.2%; 2023: 15.4%.10%12%14%16%20172018201920202021202220232017: 12.4%2018: 12.1%2019: 11.6%2020: 14.3%2021: 14.6%2022: 15.2%2023: 15.4%15.4%12.4%Estimated share of US motorists who were uninsured, 2017–2023Line chart. 2017: 12.4%; 2018: 12.1%; 2019: 11.6%; 2020: 14.3%; 2021: 14.6%; 2022: 15.2%; 2023: 15.4%.10%12%14%16%20172019202120232017: 12.4%2018: 12.1%2019: 11.6%2020: 14.3%2021: 14.6%2022: 15.2%2023: 15.4%15.4%12.4%

Source: Insurance Information Institute, 2025[4]

Show the data
YearUninsured motorists
201712.4%
201812.1%
201911.6%
202014.3%
202114.6%
202215.2%
202315.4%

Where the firm practices changes how often this call comes in. The estimated uninsured rate in 2023 ranged from 28.2% in Mississippi, 24.1% in New Mexico and 23.1% in the District of Columbia down to 5.7% in Maine, 6.2% in Utah and 6.4% in Idaho[1]. A firm in a high-rate state should expect uninsured-driver calls every week and should build the questions below into its standard car accident intake checklist, not save them for a special form.

Four situations, four sets of questions

“Uninsured” is how callers describe several different problems. Sort the call before going deeper, because each one sends intake after different documents and different deadlines.

Sorting uninsured and underinsured driver calls. The attorney reads the policies and decides what applies.
SituationWhat the caller saysAskWatch for
No insurance at all“He told me he wasn't insured.”Driver's name, plate, owner of the vehicle, what the police report says about insuranceThe owner may have a policy even if the driver does not
Too little insurance“Their insurance offered the policy limits.”The offer letter, the amount, any release or check enclosed, the caller's own UIM limitsA deadline to accept, or a release already signed
Hit-and-run“They never stopped.”Time and place of the police report, witnesses, plate fragments, nearby camerasShort reporting and notice deadlines for unidentified drivers
Coverage denied“Their insurer says he wasn't covered.”The denial letter, who owns the car, whether the driver had permissionA denial the attorney may challenge; do not treat it as final

Find every policy in the household

Most callers know their own car insurer and nothing else about the policy. Few can say whether they carry UM coverage, at what limits, or whether a spouse's or parent's policy might also apply. Twenty states and the District of Columbia have mandatory requirements for uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage[4]; elsewhere it is optional and may have been declined years ago. Florida shows why the paperwork matters: UM coverage must be included in a policy with bodily injury liability coverage unless a named insured rejects it in writing on a state-approved form, and a signed form is conclusively presumed to be an informed rejection for everyone on the policy[2].

  1. The caller's own auto policy

    Carrier, policy number, the named insured and the declarations page, which lists UM and UIM limits if the coverage exists.

  2. Other vehicles at home

    Each car in the household and its insurer, including vehicles insured under a different policy.

  3. Relatives who live with the caller

    Names and insurers of spouses, parents or adult children at the same address; the attorney reads whether their policies extend to the caller.

  4. The vehicle the caller was in

    If the caller was a passenger or driving someone else's car, that owner's insurer and policy number.

  5. Work and commercial coverage

    Whether the caller was working, driving a company vehicle or making deliveries at the time.

  6. Medical coverage

    Personal injury protection or medical payments on the auto policy, and the health plan that is paying for treatment.

  7. Signed forms

    Any form the caller or a household member signed rejecting UM coverage or choosing lower limits, if they can find it.

Ask for documents, not recollections. The declarations page from the insurer's app or website takes most callers a few minutes to find, and a photograph of it answers questions the caller cannot. The general list of layers to cover is in insurance details to collect in accident cases.

Hit-and-run: the clock starts at the scene

Hit-and-run is a large share of the uninsured-driver calls injury firms hear, especially from people on foot. Nearly one in four pedestrians killed in US traffic crashes in 2023, 24%, were struck by hit-and-run drivers[5]. Callers in these cases rarely know the other driver's name, and some never called the police because they were taken away in an ambulance or thought it pointless.

Claims against an unidentified driver often depend on prompt reporting. New York's rule for claims to its Motor Vehicle Accident Indemnification Corporation (MVAIC), which handles certain claims involving uninsured and unidentified drivers, is a clear example: the accident must be reported to a police, peace or judicial officer within 24 hours, and an affidavit filed with the corporation within 90 days; where the at-fault vehicle is identified but uninsured, the affidavit is due within 180 days[3]. Policies that provide UM coverage have their own notice conditions. Intake does not decide which apply. It records the timeline precisely and flags it.

  • When and to whom the crash was reported: police agency, officer's name, report number, and the date and time of the report.
  • If no report was made, why not, and whether the caller was hospitalized or incapacitated at the time.
  • Any part of the plate, the make, model or color of the vehicle, and the direction it went.
  • Witnesses, including first responders and anyone who stopped to help.
  • Cameras nearby: businesses, buses, doorbells, traffic cameras. Video gets overwritten, so note this at the top of the file.
  • Whether the caller has notified their own insurer, when, and whether they gave a statement.

Example script: “Even when the driver who hit you is never found, there may still be coverage that applies, sometimes through your own policy or one in your household. The attorney looks at all of it. To help, I need the exact time and place you or anyone else reported the crash, and the report number if you have one.”

Pedestrian and cyclist cases carry their own evidence list, covered in pedestrian and bicycle accident intake.

Underinsured: the settlement offer is the danger

In underinsured cases, the at-fault driver's insurer may offer its full policy limit quickly, sometimes with a release enclosed. To an injured caller with bills piling up, that check looks like the end of the story. It can be the moment a UIM claim is put at risk. Florida's statute shows the kind of rule involved: if an injured person agrees to settle with the liability insurer for less than the full claim, written notice of the proposed settlement must go by certified or registered mail to every underinsured motorist insurer, which then has 30 days to authorize the settlement or keep its subrogation rights[2]. Other states and individual policies set their own conditions, and the attorney reads them.

The gap between minimum coverage and real injuries is wide. The average paid bodily injury liability claim reached $28,278 in 2024, up from $17,014 in 2015[6]. Example: a driver carrying $25,000 per person in liability coverage hits a caller who needs shoulder surgery and misses two months of work. The at-fault insurer may offer the $25,000 within weeks. Whether more is available through the caller's own UIM coverage, and how to accept the offer without losing it, is the attorney's work. Intake's job is to make sure the attorney sees the offer before the caller signs.

  • Any letter offering policy limits, with its date and any deadline to accept.
  • Any release, settlement statement or check received, and whether it has been signed or cashed.
  • Contacts from the caller's own insurer about a UM or UIM claim, including requests for recorded statements.
  • The at-fault driver's insurer, claim number and adjuster, and the limits if the caller has been told them in writing.

In a UM or UIM claim the caller's own insurer may be on the other side of the negotiation, which surprises most people. Intake doesn't explain the strategy. It records every contact the caller has had with their own carrier and follows the firm's approach to insurance adjuster calls.

One call, start to finish

Example: the first call about an uninsured driver
  • Caller
  • SI Employee
  • System
  • Your team
  1. 01Caller

    Says driver was uninsured

    Or underinsured, or drove off; the caller assumes nothing can be done.

  2. 02SI Employee

    Conflict names and vehicles

    Every driver, owner and passenger named; plates if known.

  3. 03SI Employee

    Household policies

    The caller's carrier, other cars at home, relatives living at the same address.

  4. 04SI Employee

    Clocks and offers

    Police report time, notices sent, any settlement offer, release or check.

  5. 05System

    Urgent rule applied

    An offer with a deadline, or a release in hand, goes to the escalation tree.

  6. 06Your team

    Attorney reviews coverage

    Reads the declarations pages and decides next steps with the caller.

The firm approves the questions and what counts as urgent before any real call is forwarded.

The conflict check runs on more names than usual: the at-fault driver, the vehicle owner, every household member whose policy may be involved and the insurers if the firm tracks them. ABA Formal Opinion 506 confirms that trained non-lawyers can gather the names of all relevant parties and run conflict checks, with the lawyer making the final determination when a related name comes up[7].

Calls like this come in evenings and weekends, after the tow yard and the first adjuster call. If the firm forwards its line after hours, an SI Employee can ask these questions in the approved order, read back policy and claim numbers, and send a caller holding a settlement offer with a deadline down the escalation tree, up to three destinations with a tested fallback. It never estimates coverage or case value. The attorney gets a summary, recording and transcript in the AssistCall account (see what it does). The solo injury lawyer example models how a one-attorney firm would cover those hours.

Example: the limits letter

Example. A retired teacher in Florida calls on a Saturday morning. Three weeks ago a driver ran a stop sign and struck the passenger side of her car. She had surgery on her wrist last week. Yesterday a letter arrived from the other driver's insurer offering its $10,000 per-person limit, with a release enclosed and a request to return it signed within 14 days. She has not signed it. She thinks she has uninsured motorist coverage but is not sure.

Intake takes the names, photographs the letter and the release, and records the 14-day request. It collects her insurer and policy number and asks her to download the declarations page from her insurer's app, which she does during the call; it lists UM coverage. Her son lives with her and insures his own truck separately, so his insurer goes in the file. Her health plan paid for the surgery. Because a settlement document with a deadline is in hand, the call goes to the on-call attorney under the firm's rule.

The attorney calls back on Monday morning and takes it from there, including the notice the underinsured motorist insurer must receive before any settlement[2]. Nobody at intake told her what her coverage was worth or whether to accept the offer.

Documents to request before the consultation

  • Declarations pages for every auto policy in the household.
  • Any signed form rejecting UM coverage or selecting lower limits.
  • The police report number, or the exchange-of-information form from the scene.
  • Photos of the other driver's license, plate and insurance card, if exchanged.
  • Every letter from any insurer: denials, offers, releases, requests for statements.
  • Medical bills, health plan explanation-of-benefits statements and any lien letters.
  • Photos of the vehicles and the scene, and any video the caller already has.

Send the list in writing after the call, and track what comes back. Medical records follow their own process, described in medical records authorizations at injury intake. The point of all of this is the same: when the attorney opens the file, the coverage picture is already on the page, and nothing has been signed that should not have been.

Frequently asked questions

The caller says they don't have uninsured motorist coverage. Should intake stop there?

No. Many callers don't know what their policy includes. Ask for the declarations page and for the policies of anyone they live with. In Florida, for example, UM coverage is included unless a named insured rejected it in writing on a state-approved form[2], so the paperwork, not the caller's memory, answers the question.

What if the at-fault driver was driving someone else's car?

Record the vehicle owner's name and insurer as well as the driver's. The owner's policy may matter even when the driver had no coverage of their own. The attorney decides what applies.

Is a hit-and-run with no police report still worth a consultation?

Record when the crash happened, whether anyone reported it, and why not if nobody did. Some programs require prompt reporting; New York's MVAIC rule for unidentified drivers requires a report within 24 hours[3]. Whether the facts fit an exception is for the attorney.

Should intake tell callers not to talk to their own insurance company?

Intake follows the script the attorney approves. Many firms ask callers to hold off on recorded statements until the attorney has spoken with them, but that wording is the attorney's to choose. Intake always records every contact the caller has already had.

Can the SI Employee tell callers how much their UM coverage will pay?

No. It asks the firm's approved questions, collects policy and claim details, flags settlement offers and deadlines under the firm's rules, and hands the attorney a summary. Coverage and value are legal judgments.

References

  1. Insurance Research Council (2025). One in Three U.S. Drivers Are Either Uninsured or Underinsured (news release on Uninsured and Underinsured Motorists: 2017–2023) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. The Florida Senate (2025). Florida Statutes 2025, § 627.727 Motor vehicle insurance; uninsured and underinsured vehicle coverage (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. The New York State Senate (2026). New York Insurance Law § 5208: Notice of claim (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Insurance Information Institute (2025). Facts + Statistics: Uninsured motorists (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (2025). Pedestrians: 2023 Data (Traffic Safety Facts, DOT HS 813 727) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Insurance Information Institute (2024). Facts + Statistics: Auto insurance (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2023). Formal Opinion 506: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistants (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo