Practice Area Playbooks

Product Liability Intake: Preserve the Product

A product liability intake form that protects the evidence: preservation wording, product identity, purchase records and recall checks on the first call.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing10 min read

On this page
  1. The product is evidence from the first call
  2. Say the preservation words before anything else
  3. Questions that separate a defect from an accident
  4. Pin down which product, and who sold it
  5. Run recall and complaint checks before the consultation
  6. A first call, step by step
  7. Flags that cannot wait until Monday
  8. Example: the heater and the refund offer
  9. Dates and the hand-off note
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Practice Area Playbooks: Product Liability Intake: Preserve the Product38.8M: people sought medical care for an injury related to a consumer product in 2024 (CPSC estimate)PRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSProduct Liability Intake:Preserve the Product38.8Mpeople sought medical care for an injury related toa consumer product in 2024 (CPSC estimate)Ava for LawyersInsightsPractice Area Playbooks: Product Liability Intake: Preserve the Product38.8M: people sought medical care for an injury related to a consumer product in 2024 (CPSC estimate)PRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSProduct LiabilityIntake: Preserve theProduct38.8Mpeople sought medical care for aninjury related to a consumer productin 2024 (CPSC estimate)Ava for Lawyers
Figure source: U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, 2026[1]

Key takeaways

  • Give the preservation wording early in the call: keep the product, don't repair, return or hand it over, and photograph it tonight.
  • CPSC estimates 38.8 million medically attended product-related injuries in 2024 but stresses that related is not caused[1], so intake asks what failed.
  • Product identity comes from purchase records, labels and serial or lot numbers. Collect photos of the product before receipts.
  • Log recall and complaint searches for the attorney without telling the caller what they mean.
  • Return windows, adjuster pickups and scene cleanup are same-day flags.

The product is evidence from the first call

Most injury intake is built around an event: a crash, a fall, a dog bite. Product cases add a physical object, and the caller usually still has it. That is the problem. The space heater that scorched the rug goes out with the trash on Tuesday. The e-bike battery goes back to the store for a refund. The pressure cooker is swapped under the maker's replacement program and the original leaves in a prepaid box. Once the item is gone, nobody can examine the failure, and the attorney is left arguing about an object no expert has seen.

The volume behind these calls is large. CPSC staff estimate that 38,826,000 people sought medical attention for an injury related to a consumer product in 2024, up 7.6% on 2023[1]. The agency is careful about one word, though: these injuries are related to products, not necessarily caused by them[1]. That gap between a product being involved and a product being defective is what intake has to start closing, without pretending to close it.

Medically attended injuries related to consumer products, largest product groups, 2024CPSC estimates of injuries related to, not necessarily caused by, each product group.
Medically attended injuries related to consumer products, largest product groups, 2024Bar chart. Stairs, ramps, landings, floors: 7,751,000; Beds, mattresses, pillows: 2,776,000; Chairs, sofas and sofa beds: 1,937,000; Exercise and equipment: 1,869,000; Bathtub and shower structures: 1,690,000; Clothing: 1,316,000; Bicycles and accessories: 1,135,000; Basketball: 1,055,000.Stairs, ramps, landings, floorsStairs, ramps, landings, floors: 7,751,0007.8MBeds, mattresses, pillowsBeds, mattresses, pillows: 2,776,0002.8MChairs, sofas and sofa bedsChairs, sofas and sofa beds: 1,937,0001.9MExercise and equipmentExercise and equipment: 1,869,0001.9MBathtub and shower structuresBathtub and shower structures: 1,690,0001.7MClothingClothing: 1,316,0001.3MBicycles and accessoriesBicycles and accessories: 1,135,0001.1MBasketballBasketball: 1,055,0001.1MMedically attended injuries related to consumer products, largest product groups, 2024Bar chart. Stairs, ramps, landings, floors: 7,751,000; Beds, mattresses, pillows: 2,776,000; Chairs, sofas and sofa beds: 1,937,000; Exercise and equipment: 1,869,000; Bathtub and shower structures: 1,690,000; Clothing: 1,316,000; Bicycles and accessories: 1,135,000; Basketball: 1,055,000.Stairs, ramps, landings, floorsStairs, ramps, landings, floors: 7,751,0007.8MBeds, mattresses, pillowsBeds, mattresses, pillows: 2,776,0002.8MChairs, sofas and sofa bedsChairs, sofas and sofa beds: 1,937,0001.9MExercise and equipmentExercise and equipment: 1,869,0001.9MBathtub and shower structuresBathtub and shower structures: 1,690,0001.7MClothingClothing: 1,316,0001.3MBicycles and accessoriesBicycles and accessories: 1,135,0001.1MBasketballBasketball: 1,055,0001.1M

Source: U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, 2026[1]

Show the data
Product groupInjuries
Stairs, ramps, landings, floors7,751,000
Beds, mattresses, pillows2,776,000
Chairs, sofas and sofa beds1,937,000
Exercise and equipment1,869,000
Bathtub and shower structures1,690,000
Clothing1,316,000
Bicycles and accessories1,135,000
Basketball1,055,000

Look at what tops the list. Stairs, floors, beds and chairs are where people fall, and most of those injuries will never be defect claims. A firm that advertises for defective products still hears plenty of them. The intake form needs questions that find out what failed, quickly and politely, and a script that protects the product in the calls that might be real. The general personal injury intake questions still apply; what follows are the additions for product cases.

Say the preservation words before anything else

Put preservation near the top of the call, right after the names for the conflict check and before the long story. Callers in pain wander, lines drop, a child needs attention. If the call ends early, the one thing you want them to have heard is: keep it, don't fix it, don't give it away. The wording below is a starting point for the attorney to approve. Staff read it as written and do not improvise.

Example script: “Before we go further, one important thing. Please keep the heater and everything that came with it exactly as it is now. Don't repair it, clean it, take it apart or throw anything away, and don't return it to the store or send it to the manufacturer, even if they offer a refund or a replacement. If anyone asks to collect it, an insurance adjuster or someone from the company, please tell them you need to speak with our attorney first. Could you take some photos of it tonight?”

  • The product itself, in its current condition, stored somewhere dry where nobody will move it or use it.
  • Every part and accessory: batteries, chargers, cords, lids, attachments and any broken pieces swept up afterwards.
  • Packaging, the manual, warning labels and inserts, if the caller still has them.
  • Photos and video already on the caller's phone, plus new photos of every side, the label or rating plate and any serial or lot number.
  • Electronic records: the order confirmation, app history for connected devices and any messages with the seller or maker.

Most callers can do the photo step the same night: 91% of US adults own a smartphone[2]. Ask them to photograph the product before moving it if they can, and to note who else has handled it since the incident.

Electronic material matters as much as the object. In federal court, when electronically stored information that should have been preserved for litigation is lost because a party did not take reasonable steps, Rule 37(e) lets the judge order measures to cure the harm and, where the loss was meant to deprive the other side, presume the information was unfavorable[3]. Phone video of the fire, a connected device's app log and the online order history are all electronically stored information, so they belong on the preservation list.

Questions that separate a defect from an accident

Product liability intake questions. Staff record the answers in the caller's words; the attorney draws the conclusions.
AskWhat the answer tells the attorney
What is the product: brand, model, and any serial or lot number?Who made and sold it, and whether other units share the problem
Where and when was it bought, new or used, and from whom?The chain of sellers, warranty status and possible defendants
What was it being used for when it failed, and how?Whether the use was ordinary or foreseeable, which the attorney weighs
What exactly happened: sparked, overheated, shattered, tipped, gave way?The failure an expert would examine
Had it been repaired, modified, dropped or serviced before?Alternative explanations the other side will raise
Who has it now, and what condition is it in?Custody, and whether the evidence is at risk
What injuries, and where was treatment?Damages, and which medical records to request
Has the seller, maker or an insurer contacted you, or offered a refund or replacement?Pressure to hand the product over, and any release on the table

Some answers sound as if they end the case: the heater was bought second-hand, the ladder was missing a foot, the caller skipped part of the manual. Staff should not react. Those facts are for the attorney to weigh, and a caller who hears “oh, that's a problem” starts editing the story on the next call. Ask the next question in the same tone.

The questions also have to stay factual. A supervised non-lawyer can gather intake facts, but questions about what legal services the caller needs, or about fees, go to the lawyer[4]. Florida's ethics guidance is blunter for non-lawyer intake interviews: identify as a non-lawyer, ask for facts, give no legal advice and send legal questions to the lawyer[5].

Pin down which product, and who sold it

The name on the box is not always the company that made the product. Store brands, private labels, imports sold through online marketplaces and goods assembled from someone else's components all make identity harder. Purchase records do much of the work, and callers often have them without realizing it.

  • Order confirmation emails and the order history on the retailer or marketplace account, including any third-party seller's name.
  • A card or bank statement line showing the merchant and the date.
  • Warranty registration emails or the registration card.
  • A photo of the label, rating plate or stamped code, which may carry the model, a date code or a lot number.
  • For vehicles, tires and car seats, the VIN or the product's own label; for medical devices, the hospital or surgeon's records naming the device.
  • For a gift, the name of the person who bought it, so the purchase can be traced.

Ask the caller to forward what they can find after the call. The document request list for consultations works for product cases with one change: ask for photos of the product before the receipt. A receipt can be reprinted. The product cannot. Vehicle defects that never hurt anyone usually belong in lemon law and warranty intake instead.

Run recall and complaint checks before the consultation

Once the product is identified, staff can check the public record before the attorney calls back. CPSC publishes consumer product recalls, and its SaferProducts.gov database is where the public can file and read complaints about thousands of types of consumer products[6]. Vehicle, tire and car seat recalls are searched through NHTSA, and drugs and medical devices through FDA's recall listings. Record what was searched, when, and what came back, including nothing.

Then leave it there. A recall does not prove this caller's unit was defective, and a missing recall does not prove it was fine. Staff should never tell a caller that a recall means they have a case. The search result goes in the file for the attorney, together with any recall notice or replacement offer the caller received directly, because some remedy programs ask for the product back.

A first call, step by step

Example: the first call on a product injury
  • Caller
  • SI Employee
  • Your team
  1. 01Caller

    Describes what failed

    Product, what it did, when, and the injury, in the caller's own words.

  2. 02SI Employee

    Preservation wording

    Firm-approved script: keep it, don't repair, return or hand it over.

  3. 03SI Employee

    Product identity

    Brand, model, serial or lot number, and where and when it was bought.

  4. 04SI Employee

    Urgency check

    An adjuster pickup, a return deadline or scene cleanup goes to the on-call path.

  5. 05Your team

    Photos and records

    Document list sent after the call; recall searches logged in the file.

  6. 06Your team

    Attorney review

    Viability, deadlines, experts and fees are decided by the lawyer.

Example sequence. Wording, urgency rules and routing come from the firm's own intake playbook.

Product injuries cluster in evenings and weekends, when people cook, use power tools and charge things overnight. If the firm forwards its line after hours, an SI Employee can ask the approved product questions in order, read the preservation wording word for word, and send an urgent call, such as an adjuster arriving tomorrow to collect the heater, down the firm's escalation tree. It never tells a caller whether they have a case. The attorney gets a summary with the recording and transcript (see what it does). The solo injury lawyer example models the same after-hours pattern for crash and fall calls.

Flags that cannot wait until Monday

  • Someone is coming to collect the product: an insurance adjuster, a landlord, the maker's courier or a recall program's prepaid box.
  • A store return or refund window closes in the next few days and the caller plans to use it.
  • The scene is being cleaned, repaired or demolished after a fire, flood or collapse.
  • A vehicle sits at a tow or salvage yard where storage fees or a scheduled auction could dispose of it.
  • The product is still in use at home and someone else could be hurt.
  • The caller has signed, or been asked to sign, a release or claim form.
  • Someone died.

Not every product call belongs to a mass tort campaign, and that matters for routing. Federal personal injury and product liability filings fell 73% in the year to March 31, 2025, and the courts put the wider drop in civil filings largely down to fewer multidistrict litigation cases[7]. The calls that remain are often single incidents with one object at the center. Campaign screening, covered in mass tort intake, suits drugs and devices sold by the million. A burned hand from one heater needs the preservation script and a person on the file the next morning.

Example: the heater and the refund offer

Example. A caller rings the firm at 8:40 on a Wednesday evening. Her mother's space heater caught fire in the living room on Sunday; her mother burned her hand putting it out and was treated in the emergency department. The store has offered a full refund if the heater comes back within 30 days of purchase, and the caller was planning to drop it off on Saturday.

Intake gives the preservation wording first, then asks for the brand and model from the label, which the caller photographs while still on the phone. The order confirmation is in her mother's email. The heater is in the garage in a box, and she agrees to leave it there, soot and all, and not take it back. The Saturday return is an urgent flag under the firm's rules, so the attorney has the call summary that night and calls back on Thursday morning. On Thursday a paralegal searches the CPSC recall list and SaferProducts.gov for the model and logs the result. Nobody tells the family what that result means for a claim. The attorney does that.

Dates and the hand-off note

Product cases can run into a statute of limitations and, in some states, a statute of repose that counts from when the product was first sold rather than from the injury. Intake does not work out which applies. It captures every date the attorney will need: purchase, first use, the incident, when symptoms started in exposure cases, and when the caller first linked the harm to the product. The method in screening for limitation deadlines applies unchanged.

  1. Product and custody

    Brand, model, serial or lot number; who has the product now, where it is stored and what condition it is in.

  2. Incident and injury

    What failed and how, in the caller's words; injuries, treatment, and who else was hurt or what else was damaged.

  3. Dates

    Purchase, first use, incident, start of symptoms, and when the caller connected the harm to the product.

  4. Records

    Photos received, purchase proof, warranty, messages with the seller or maker, and the medical providers named.

  5. Checks and flags

    Recall and complaint searches with results and dates; any urgent flag and the reason it was raised.

Insurance belongs in the same note when there is any: homeowner's or renter's coverage, the health plan that paid for treatment, and any claim the caller has already opened. The insurance checklist for accident cases covers what to ask.

Frequently asked questions

Should the firm ask callers to bring the product to the office?

Only if the attorney has set up a way to receive, label and store it. Moving the product adds another person to the list of who handled it, so many firms prefer the caller keeps it untouched until the attorney decides how it will be stored and examined. Intake follows whatever the attorney has written down.

The manufacturer offered a replacement if the caller sends the old one back. What should intake say?

Read the approved preservation wording, note the offer and its deadline, and flag the call as urgent. Whether to accept any remedy is a question for the attorney.

Can intake staff tell callers whether a product has been recalled?

Staff can search the public databases and record what they find[6], but they should not tell the caller what a recall means for a claim. That is legal advice, and it belongs to the lawyer[4].

What if the product was bought used or from a marketplace seller?

Collect everything: the listing, the seller's name, messages and the payment record. A used or third-party purchase can change who is responsible; it does not mean there is no case, and staff should not suggest that it does.

Does an SI Employee decide which product calls the firm takes?

No. It asks the firm's approved questions, gives the preservation wording, marks urgent calls under the firm's rules and sends the attorney a summary. The attorney decides.

References

  1. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (2026). Consumer Product-Related Injuries and Deaths in the United States: Estimated Injuries Occurring in 2024 and Estimated Deaths Occurring in 2023 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Pew Research Center (2026). Americans' Use of Mobile Devices in 2026 (Mobile Fact Sheet) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). Rule 37. Failure to Make Disclosures or to Cooperate in Discovery; Sanctions (Federal Rules of Civil Procedure) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2023). ABA Formal Opinion 506: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistants (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (2026). SaferProducts.gov (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts) (2025). Federal Judicial Caseload Statistics 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo