Practice Area Playbooks

Personal Injury Intake: Questions and Red Flags

The first-call questions that decide personal injury case viability, the red flags that need an attorney's eye, and how to decline callers safely.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. The first call decides more than case value
  2. The questions that decide viability
  3. Questions and comments to avoid
  4. Red flags and what to do about each
  5. Know where your callers' injuries come from
  6. Callers who already have a lawyer
  7. Declining without harming the caller
  8. Example: two calls on the same morning
  9. What the attorney hand-off should contain
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Practice Area Playbooks: Personal Injury Intake: Questions and Red FlagsArticle coverPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSPersonal Injury Intake:Questions and Red FlagsAva for LawyersInsightsPractice Area Playbooks: Personal Injury Intake: Questions and Red FlagsArticle coverPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSPersonal InjuryIntake: Questions andRed FlagsAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Viability rests on five things: liability, injury and treatment, insurance, timing, and whether the caller already has a lawyer.
  • Ask early whether the injury happened at work; US employers reported 2.5 million nonfatal workplace injuries and illnesses in 2024[1].
  • Screen for existing representation before collecting the story, as Florida Bar Opinion 24-1 suggests for intake tools[2].
  • Red flags are prompts for attorney review, not automatic declines; document every decline in writing.

The first call decides more than case value

A personal injury intake call has two jobs. It must gather enough facts for an attorney to judge whether the firm can help, and it must treat a hurt, often frightened person well whether or not the firm takes the case. Firms that rush the first job lose good cases to slow follow-up. Firms that skip the second lose referrals and reviews from the people they decline.

Intake staff also work within professional limits. Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1, drawing on earlier guidance it calls especially useful for intake, says nonlawyers conducting an initial intake interview must identify their nonlawyer status, limit questions to factual information, give no legal advice and refer legal questions to the lawyer[2]. Other states' rules point the same way. The questions below are factual by design; judgments about value and liability belong to the attorney.

Five things decide whether an injury matter is viable at the first call: someone else was at fault, the injury is real and treated, there is insurance or another source of recovery, the claim is still within its deadlines, and the caller is free to hire you. Every question in a good script feeds one of those five.

The questions that decide viability

  1. Do you currently have a lawyer for this, or have you signed anything with another firm? Ask first, before the story.
  2. What happened, in your own words? Let the caller talk for a minute before narrowing down.
  3. When did it happen, and in which state and county? Date and place drive deadlines and venue.
  4. Were you injured, and where on your body? Record the caller's words, not a diagnosis.
  5. Have you seen a doctor or gone to the hospital? When was the first visit, and are you still treating?
  6. Were you working at the time? This splits workers' compensation from third-party claims.
  7. Who else was involved: another driver, a property owner, a business, an employer, a government agency?
  8. Was a report made: police, store incident report, workplace report? Do you have a copy or number?
  9. Have you talked to any insurance company, given a recorded statement or signed anything?
  10. Are there photos, video, witnesses or damaged property, and who has them now?
  11. Have you had injuries to the same body part before?
  12. Is there anything coming up soon: a deadline on a letter, a court date, a settlement offer?

Keep the order flexible. If the caller mentions a letter with a deadline, capture it immediately rather than waiting for question twelve. If the caller is distressed, slow down; the facts will still be there in two minutes.

Questions and comments to avoid

Some questions feel efficient but damage the call or the case. Train staff to recognize them, and review recorded calls for them during coaching.

  • What is your case worth? Staff should never estimate value, and the caller's own estimate is not useful at this stage.
  • Was it your fault? Ask what happened instead. A leading question invites a defensive or inaccurate answer.
  • You should go to the doctor. That is medical advice. Ask whether they have seen a doctor, and if they describe an emergency, tell them to call 911.
  • Don't talk to the insurance company. That is legal advice. Note the insurer contact and let the attorney give the advice.
  • That sounds like a great case. Enthusiasm creates expectations the attorney may have to undo, and can mislead a caller the firm later declines.

Staff can still be warm. Phrases such as that sounds really hard, thank you for explaining, and I want to make sure the attorney has the full picture keep the caller talking without promising anything.

Red flags and what to do about each

A red flag is a reason to get an attorney's eyes on the matter quickly, not a reason for staff to decline on the spot. Several of these are fixable, and some make a case more urgent rather than weaker.

Common personal injury red flags and the intake response
Red flagWhy it mattersWhat intake does next
Already representedThe firm should not interfere with another lawyer's clientStop the fact interview; suggest they speak to their lawyer; note the call
Incident date long agoLimitation periods vary by state and claim type and may have runCapture exact dates; flag to an attorney the same day
Government vehicle, property or employeeClaims against public entities often need a formal notice within a short windowFlag as urgent; capture the agency name and date
Long gap before first treatmentInsurers argue a gap means the injury was minor or unrelatedAsk why: cost, no insurance, hoping it would improve; record the reason
Recorded statement already givenThe statement may be used against the claimRecord the date, the insurer and what the caller remembers saying
Prior injury to the same body partCausation becomes contestedCapture dates and treatment of the prior injury
Caller was the driver who was citedLiability may be shared or disputedCapture the citation and the caller's account; attorney decides
Injured at workWorkers' compensation may be the main remedy, with third-party claims possibleAsk whether anyone other than the employer was involved

Know where your callers' injuries come from

The mix of calls shapes the script. NHTSA estimates 39,345 people died in US motor vehicle crashes in 2024[3], and far more were injured. Private-industry employers reported 2.5 million nonfatal workplace injuries and illnesses in 2024, a rate of 2.3 cases per 100 full-time-equivalent workers[1]. More than 14 million older adults, about 1 in 4, report a fall every year[4], and a share of those falls happen on someone else's property.

Workplace injuries deserve special care in intake because they fork. If the employer is the only party involved, the matter is usually a workers' compensation claim, which your firm may or may not handle. If a contractor, equipment maker, property owner or driver was involved, there may also be a third-party injury claim. Fatal cases raise the stakes: there were 5,070 fatal work injuries in 2024, down from 5,283 in 2023[5].

Fatal work injuries in the United States
Fatal work injuries in the United StatesColumn chart. 2023: 5,283; 2024: 5,070.02,0004,0006,0002023: 5,2835,28320232024: 5,0705,0702024Fatal work injuries in the United StatesColumn chart. 2023: 5,283; 2024: 5,070.02,0004,0006,0002023: 5,2835,28320232024: 5,0705,0702024

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2024[5]

Show the data
ItemValue
20235,283
20245,070

Callers who already have a lawyer

Some callers are unhappy with their current lawyer and want a second opinion or a change. Florida Bar Opinion 24-1 says firms should consider screening questions that limit an intake chatbot's communications when the person is already represented[2], and the same logic applies to human intake. Ask the representation question first, before the caller tells the whole story.

Script: Before we go further, do you have a lawyer helping you with this right now, or have you signed an agreement with a firm? If yes: Thank you for telling me. I can't discuss your case while you have a lawyer, but if you decide to change lawyers, one of our attorneys can talk with you about how that works. Would you like me to note your details for an attorney to call you about that question only?

Declining without harming the caller

  1. Get the attorney's decision

    Staff gather facts; an attorney decides. Never tell a caller they have no case.

  2. Say no clearly and kindly

    Our firm isn't able to take your matter. That isn't a judgment about whether you have a claim, only about whether we're the right firm for it.

  3. Warn about deadlines without giving a date

    Legal claims have time limits, and they can be short. Please speak with another lawyer soon if you want to pursue this.

  4. Offer a referral

    Give the bar association referral service or a vetted firm from your referral list.

  5. Send a non-engagement letter

    Confirm in writing that the firm is not representing the caller and repeat the deadline warning. Save it to the declined-inquiry file.

Example: two calls on the same morning

Example: the first caller slipped in a grocery store last week, went to urgent care the same day, and has a copy of the store's incident report and photos of a spilled liquid. She has not spoken to any insurer. Intake captures the facts, flags no red flags, and books a consultation for that afternoon.

The second caller was rear-ended by a city bus two months ago, waited three weeks to see a doctor because he had no insurance, and already gave a recorded statement to someone from the city. Three red flags: a public entity, a treatment gap and a recorded statement. Intake does not decline. It records the reason for the gap, the date of the statement and the agency name, and pages the attorney, because the notice window for a claim against a public entity may be close.

What the attorney hand-off should contain

  • A two-line summary: who, what, when, where, injury.
  • The five viability factors, each marked known, unknown or concern.
  • Every date mentioned, with its source.
  • Red flags, with the caller's own explanation.
  • Insurance contacts and anything signed or said to an insurer.
  • What the caller was promised: a callback time, a consultation slot, documents to send.

Practice-specific checklists build on this core: see car accident intake, truck accident intake, slip and fall screening and medical malpractice screening.

Frequently asked questions

What questions should a personal injury intake call ask first?

Whether the caller already has a lawyer, then what happened, when and where, the injury and treatment, whether they were working, who else was involved, reports, insurance contacts and any upcoming deadlines.

Can intake staff tell a caller they don't have a case?

No. Staff collect facts and an attorney decides. A decline should come with a clear deadline warning, a referral and a written non-engagement letter.

Is a gap in medical treatment a reason to decline?

Not by itself. Record why the caller waited, such as cost or lack of insurance, and let the attorney weigh it.

Why ask about representation before hearing the story?

So the firm does not collect confidential facts from someone another lawyer represents. If the caller wants to change lawyers, an attorney can discuss that question separately.

References

  1. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2024). Employer-Reported Workplace Injuries and Illnesses, 2024 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (2024). Early Estimate of Motor Vehicle Traffic Fatalities in 2024 (DOT HS 813 710) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2026). Older Adult Falls Data (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2024). Census of Fatal Occupational Injuries Summary, 2024 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo