Practice Area Playbooks

Construction Accident Intake: Third-Party Claims

Construction injury intake beyond workers' comp: owner, general contractor, subcontractor and equipment questions that surface third-party claims early.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing9 min read

On this page
  1. The question comp-only intake skips
  2. What injures and kills construction workers
  3. Map the site: who was there
  4. Scripts that get names, not shrugs
  5. Fall questions
  6. Equipment, vehicles and struck-by injuries
  7. OSHA, incident reports and witnesses
  8. Construction intake mistakes to design out
  9. Language and timing
  10. Example: one fall, five companies
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Practice Area Playbooks: Construction Accident Intake: Third-Party Claims389: of 1,034 US construction industry deaths in 2024 were falls, slips or tripsPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSConstruction AccidentIntake: Third-Party Claims389of 1,034 US construction industry deaths in 2024 were falls,slips or tripsAva for LawyersInsightsPractice Area Playbooks: Construction Accident Intake: Third-Party Claims389: of 1,034 US construction industry deaths in 2024 were falls, slips or tripsPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSConstruction AccidentIntake: Third-PartyClaims389of 1,034 US construction industrydeaths in 2024 were falls, slips ortripsAva for Lawyers
Figure source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2025[1]

Key takeaways

  • Workers' comp is usually the only claim against the employer, but owners, general contractors, other subcontractors and equipment companies are different parties[2][3].
  • Falls caused 389 of 1,034 construction deaths in 2024[1]: ask how high, what the worker stood on and who supplied it.
  • In New York, Labor Law 240(1) puts the duty for scaffolds and ladders on contractors and owners[4], so who ran the site matters on the first call.
  • Employers must report hospitalizations and amputations to OSHA within 24 hours[5]; ask whether an inspector came.

The question comp-only intake skips

A construction worker who calls after a fall usually asks about workers' comp, and a comp-only intake answers that question and stops. The answer they need is wider. Comp covers the employer. A construction site is full of other companies, and any of them may be the reason the worker got hurt.

New York's statute is a clear example of how the pieces fit. The employer's liability under workers' compensation is exclusive, and the employer cannot be pulled into a third party's claim for contribution or indemnity unless the worker suffered a grave injury, such as death or the permanent and total loss of use of an arm or leg, or the employer had agreed in a written contract before the accident to indemnify that party[2]. A worker hurt by the negligence of someone not in the same employ does not have to choose: they can take compensation and pursue that other party, and the comp carrier has a lien on the recovery[3]. The first call's job is to find every company on that site.

The comp side of the call is covered in workers' compensation intake questions. This checklist adds the questions that find the third parties, and they belong in the same call, because the worker who calls once about comp may not call back.

What injures and kills construction workers

The event type points toward the likely defendants, so it is worth knowing which events dominate. In 2024 the construction industry recorded 1,034 fatal work injuries: 389 from falls, slips or trips, 244 from transportation incidents, 187 from exposure to harmful substances or environments and 161 from contact with objects and equipment[1].

Fatal work injuries in the US construction industry by event, 2024Private construction industry; total 1,034 deaths.
Fatal work injuries in the US construction industry by event, 2024Bar chart. Falls, slips, trips: 389; Transportation incidents: 244; Exposure to harmful substances or environments: 187; Contact with objects and equipment: 161; Violent acts: 46; Explosions and fires: 5.Falls, slips, tripsFalls, slips, trips: 389389Transportation incidentsTransportation incidents: 244244Exposure to harmful substances or environmentsExposure to harmful substances or environments: 187187Contact with objects and equipmentContact with objects and equipment: 161161Violent actsViolent acts: 4646Explosions and firesExplosions and fires: 55Fatal work injuries in the US construction industry by event, 2024Bar chart. Falls, slips, trips: 389; Transportation incidents: 244; Exposure to harmful substances or environments: 187; Contact with objects and equipment: 161; Violent acts: 46; Explosions and fires: 5.Falls, slips, tripsFalls, slips, trips: 389389Transportation incidentsTransportation incidents: 244244Exposure to harmful substances orenvironmentsExposure to harmful substances or environments: 187187Contact with objects and equipmentContact with objects and equipment: 161161Violent actsViolent acts: 4646Explosions and firesExplosions and fires: 55

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2025[1]

Show the data
Event or exposureDeaths
Falls, slips, trips389
Transportation incidents244
Exposure to harmful substances or environments187
Contact with objects and equipment161
Violent acts46
Explosions and fires5

Falls are concentrated in the trades. Specialty trade contractors recorded 606 deaths, 253 of them falls, and roofing contractors alone recorded 120, 96 of them falls[1]. The citation data points the same way: OSHA's preliminary list for fiscal year 2026 ranks fall protection general requirements as its most cited standard, with construction scaffolding fourth, ladders fifth and fall protection training eighth[6].

  • Falls: the property owner, the general contractor, whoever erected the scaffold or supplied the ladder or lift.
  • Struck by a vehicle: the driver, the trucking or delivery company, the company directing traffic on site.
  • Contact with objects and equipment: the maker of the machine, the rental company, the crane or rigging contractor.
  • Electrical and other exposures: the electrical subcontractor, the utility, whoever controlled lockout on that circuit.

Map the site: who was there

Workers rarely know the legal structure of the job, but they know names. They know whose logo was on the trailer, who ran the morning meeting, whose foreman told them where to work and whose truck delivered the material. Ask for those, and treat "I don't know" as an answer to record, not a dead end.

Ask about every row. Company names from hard hats, trucks, trailers, gate signs and the permit board count; so does a foreman's first name.
PartyWhy it mattersQuestions to ask
EmployerComp claim; usually protected from suitWho pays you? Name on the paycheck or pay app?
Staffing agencyMay be the employer on paper while another company directs the workDid an agency place you? Who told you what to do each day?
General contractor or construction managerOften controls site safety and the scheduleWhose name was on the site trailer and the safety meetings?
Property ownerMay carry duties under state lawWhat was being built, and for whom? House, apartment block, store?
Other subcontractorsTheir crew or setup may have caused the injuryWhich other trades were working near you, and for which companies?
Equipment owner or rental companySupplied the scaffold, lift, ladder or machineWhose name or tag was on the equipment? Was it rented?
ManufacturerA defect or missing guard can be a product claimMake and model, if visible on a label or plate.
Outside driver or vehicleA negligent driver is a separate claimWhose vehicle, which company, did police come?

Every company and person on that list goes into the conflict check before the attorney calls back. Construction firms are repeat players, and a firm that represents a contractor in one matter may not be able to take a claim against it in another.

Scripts that get names, not shrugs

Ask a worker "who was the general contractor?" and many will say they don't know. Ask what they saw and the names come out. These lines work because they ask about things a worker noticed every day.

Instead of "Who was the general contractor?": "Whose name was on the trailer or the big sign at the gate? Who ran the safety talk in the morning?"

Instead of "Was the equipment defective?": "Tell me what the scaffold (or lift, or saw) did right before you got hurt. Was there a company name or a tag on it anywhere?"

Instead of "Was anyone else at fault?": "Who else was working near you that day, and what company were they with? Had anyone moved or changed anything where you were working?"

Record every name exactly as the caller says it, even a nickname or half a logo. The attorney can find a company from "the blue trucks with the crane on the door"; nobody can find one from a blank field.

Fall questions

  • How high: the floor, the roof edge, the height of the scaffold platform or ladder rung, in the worker's own estimate.
  • What they were standing on or working from: ladder, scaffold, roof, aerial lift, floor opening, stairwell, beam.
  • Who supplied it and who set it up: the employer, the general contractor, another trade or a rental company.
  • Protection in place: guardrails, covers over openings, harness and lanyard, an anchor point to tie off to.
  • Whether protection was provided at all, whether it was used, and whether anyone had been told to work without it.
  • Training: whether anyone trained them on fall protection for this job, and in which language.
  • Conditions: wet or icy surfaces, wind, lighting, debris on the deck.

Some states add duties that make these answers decisive. New York's Labor Law § 240(1) requires all contractors and owners and their agents to furnish properly constructed and operated scaffolding, ladders and similar devices, except owners of one and two-family dwellings who contract for the work but do not direct or control it[4]. That exception is why intake asks what kind of building it was and whether the owner was on site giving directions. Other states have different rules; intake collects the facts either way.

Equipment, vehicles and struck-by injuries

  • The equipment: type, make and model if visible, and any owner or rental company tag.
  • What went wrong: it moved, collapsed, failed, started unexpectedly, had a guard missing or removed.
  • Where it is now: still on site, taken back by the rental company, repaired, or removed.
  • Vehicles on site: whose truck, loader or delivery van, who was driving, and whether a spotter or flagger was assigned.
  • Photos: ask whether the worker or a coworker took any, and who still works on that site.

Do not ask the worker to go back onto the site, take anything away or confront anyone. Record who might have photos or still has access, and let the attorney decide on preservation letters. Product questions in more depth are in product liability intake: preserve the product, and crashes with commercial trucks on public roads follow the truck accident intake checklist.

OSHA, incident reports and witnesses

Employers must report a work-related fatality to OSHA within 8 hours, and an in-patient hospitalization, amputation or loss of an eye within 24 hours[5]. If the caller was admitted to hospital, an OSHA report may exist, and an inspector may have visited. Ask what the caller knows, and record it without suggesting what it means.

  1. Reports

    Did anyone fill out an incident report? Who, when, and did the caller sign anything or give a statement?

  2. Inspectors and police

    Did OSHA, a building inspector or police come to the site? Names, dates and any card left behind.

  3. Witnesses

    Coworkers and other trades who saw it, with phone numbers now. Crews move to new jobs as phases finish.

  4. Supervisors

    The foreman, the site superintendent and the safety officer, with the company each works for.

  5. Pressure

    Has anyone asked the caller to say it happened elsewhere, to sign a statement, or to come back to work early? Mark any yes as urgent.

When the worker died, the caller is a spouse, parent or adult child, and the pace changes. The approach in wrongful death intake applies, with the site map above taken more gently and over more than one call if needed.

Construction intake mistakes to design out

  • Stopping at the employer's name, so the owner, general contractor and equipment supplier never reach the attorney.
  • Recording "fell off a ladder" without the height, who owned the ladder and what it was standing on.
  • Skipping the conflict check on the companies, then discovering weeks later that the firm acts for one of them.
  • Missing the staffing agency, so the file names the wrong employer for the comp claim.
  • Letting coworker contacts go uncollected until the crew has moved to another job.

Each of these is a form-design problem, not a staff problem. Make the site map a required section with "unknown" as an allowed answer, and review a handful of construction intakes every month against it.

Language and timing

In 2025, 35.4% of the 12.1 million people employed in US construction were Hispanic or Latino[7]. Not every one of those workers prefers Spanish on the phone, but an intake process that only works in English will lose some of the callers it exists to serve. Have a Spanish-speaking intake path ready, with the site-map questions translated and tested, and see call handling for Spanish-speaking callers for the details.

Construction workers start early and finish late, and many call about an injury after a shift or at the weekend, when the office is shut. An SI Employee can answer the forwarded line after hours, ask your approved comp and site-map questions, take every company name for the conflict check, and send calls your firm marks urgent, such as pressure to sign a statement, down your escalation tree. The summary, recording and transcript are waiting for intake in the morning (see what it does). The solo injury lawyer example models how much of a small injury practice's volume lands in those hours.

Example: a fall call routed for third-party review
  • Caller
  • SI Employee
  • System
  • Your team
  1. 01Caller

    Worker calls after shift

    Injured last week; calls the firm's number at 7 pm.

  2. 02SI Employee

    Comp basics

    Injury date, notice to employer, treatment, work status.

  3. 03SI Employee

    Site map

    Employer, GC, owner, other trades, equipment owner; names for the conflict check.

  4. 04System

    Summary and recording

    In the account for intake by morning; urgent items flagged.

  5. 05Your team

    Attorney flags third parties

    Owner, GC or equipment claims reviewed alongside the comp claim.

  6. 06Your team

    Preservation letters

    For equipment, site video and incident reports, if the attorney decides.

Example sequence. The comp questions and the site map happen on the same first call.

Example: one fall, five companies

Example (fictional): a drywall finisher calls on a Saturday morning. Nine days ago she fell about eight feet from a rolling scaffold on the fourth floor of an office renovation and broke her ankle. Her employer is a drywall subcontractor. The site trailer and safety meetings belonged to a general contractor. The scaffold came from a rental company whose tag was on the frame, and she says one of the wheel locks did not hold. An electrician's crew had moved the scaffold the evening before. The building's owner is a property company whose name was on the permit board.

A comp-only intake would have recorded the employer, the injury date and her treatment. The site-map questions add the general contractor, the rental company, the electrical subcontractor and the owner, the scaffold's tag number, two coworkers' phone numbers, the fact that an incident report was written by the GC's superintendent, and her worry that she was asked to sign it. The attorney now has four possible third parties to evaluate on Monday, plus one urgent conversation about that statement. The general first-call framework behind all of this is in personal injury intake questions and red flags.

Frequently asked questions

Can an injured construction worker get workers' comp and also sue someone else?

Often, yes. In New York, a worker hurt by the negligence of someone not in the same employ can take compensation and pursue that other party, and the comp carrier has a lien on the recovery[3]. Other states have similar rules; the attorney decides what applies.

What if the employer was also the general contractor?

Record it. There may still be an owner, another trade, an equipment supplier or a manufacturer involved, so the rest of the site map still matters.

Does it matter whether OSHA came to the site?

It is useful information. Employers must report hospitalizations, amputations and eye losses within 24 hours and deaths within 8 hours[5], so an inspection record may exist. Intake records what the caller knows; the attorney decides what to request.

Should the worker go back and photograph the site?

No. Do not ask a caller to enter a site, remove anything or confront anyone. Record who may already have photos or still works there, and leave preservation to the attorney.

The caller was placed by a staffing agency. Who is the employer?

Possibly the agency on paper, with another company directing the work. Record both, along with who gave daily instructions, and let the attorney sort out the relationships.

References

  1. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Table A-1. Fatal occupational injuries by industry and event or exposure, all United States, 2024 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. The New York State Senate (2026). New York Workers' Compensation Law § 11: Alternative remedy (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. The New York State Senate (2026). New York Workers' Compensation Law § 29: Remedies of employees injured by third parties (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. The New York State Senate (2026). New York Labor Law § 240: Scaffolding and other devices for use of employees (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Occupational Safety and Health Administration (2026). Report a Fatality or Severe Injury (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Occupational Safety and Health Administration (2026). Top 10 Most Frequently Cited Standards (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employed people by detailed industry, sex, race, and Hispanic or Latino ethnicity (CPS Table 18, 2025 annual averages) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo