Practice Area Playbooks

Consumer Protection and Lemon Law Intake

Consumer protection intake: lemon law and warranty screening, debt collection and robocall questions, fee-shifting rules, deadlines and documents.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why consumer intake needs a sorting step
  2. Lemon law and warranty screening
  3. Debt collection and robocall screening
  4. Credit reporting and dealer fraud questions
  5. Why fee-shifting matters at intake
  6. Documents by claim type
  7. Urgent flags in consumer matters
  8. Example: the transmission and the texts
  9. Writing the note and following up
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Practice Area Playbooks: Consumer Protection and Lemon Law IntakeArticle coverPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSConsumer Protection andLemon Law IntakeAva for LawyersInsightsPractice Area Playbooks: Consumer Protection and Lemon Law IntakeArticle coverPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSConsumer Protectionand Lemon Law IntakeAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Sort consumer calls by claim type first: vehicle and warranty, debt collection, robocalls and texts, credit reporting, or dealer and seller fraud.
  • For lemon law and warranty calls, the repair history is the case: dates, mileage, defects and days out of service from every repair order.
  • Federal warranty law lets a prevailing consumer recover costs and attorneys' fees based on time spent[1], which is why many firms take these matters.
  • Debt collection claims under the FDCPA must be brought within one year of the violation[2]; ask for the date of each call and letter.
  • Robocall and text claims under the TCPA carry $500 per violation, up to three times that if willful[3], so call logs and screenshots matter.

Why consumer intake needs a sorting step

Consumer protection callers describe their problem as unfair: the car keeps breaking, a collector will not stop calling, a dealer added charges, a company keeps texting. Each of those can fall under a different law with different screening criteria, documents and deadlines. Intake should sort the call in the first minute, then follow the matching question set.

Consumer claim types and opening questions
Claim typeWhat callers sayFirst questions
Lemon law and warrantyMy new car has been in the shop five timesVehicle, purchase or lease date, mileage, defect, repair visits
Debt collectionA collector keeps calling my workWho is calling, what debt, how often, what they said, dates
Robocalls and textsI keep getting automated calls I never agreed toNumber calling, how many calls, any consent, Do Not Call registration
Credit reportingMy credit report shows a debt that isn't mineWhich bureau, which account, disputes sent and responses
Dealer or seller fraudThey lied about the car's historyWhat was said or shown, documents signed, financing terms
Deceptive practicesThe company charged me for something I cancelledCompany, dates, amounts, communications

Lemon law and warranty screening

State lemon laws set their own thresholds, typically involving the number of repair attempts for the same problem, the number of days a vehicle has been out of service, and a time or mileage window after delivery. They differ by state, and some cover used vehicles, motorcycles or leased cars while others do not. Federal warranty law sits alongside them: a consumer damaged by a warrantor's failure to comply with a written or implied warranty may sue for damages and other relief[1].

  1. The vehicle

    Year, make, model, VIN, new or used, purchased or leased, the dealer's name, the delivery date and mileage at delivery.

  2. The defect

    What goes wrong, in the caller's words, and how it affects use, value or safety. Ask whether a warning light, recall or service bulletin was mentioned.

  3. Repair history

    Every visit: date in, date out, mileage, what the dealer did. Ask whether the caller kept every repair order and whether any visit was refused or not written up.

  4. Days out of service

    Total days the vehicle was at the dealer, including waiting for parts. Repair orders usually show the dates.

  5. Contact with the manufacturer

    Any call or letter to the manufacturer, any arbitration program used, and any buyback or trade offer.

  6. Current status

    Still driving it? Safe to drive? Still under warranty? Any accident related to the defect?

Script: The most useful thing you can send us is every repair order from the dealer, including the ones where they said they could not find the problem. Please photograph each page, front and back.

Debt collection and robocall screening

Debt collection claims under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act must be brought within one year from the date of the violation[2], so the date of each call, letter or message matters more than the overall story. An individual can recover actual damages plus additional damages the court allows up to $1,000, and a successful plaintiff recovers costs and a reasonable attorney's fee[2].

  • Who is collecting, and are they a collection agency, a law firm or the original lender?
  • What debt do they say is owed, and does the caller agree it is theirs?
  • Dates and times of calls, letters, texts and emails, with screenshots and call logs.
  • What was said: threats, calls to family or employers, calls after a written request to stop.
  • Any lawsuit filed on the debt, and whether the caller was served.

Robocall and text claims run under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act. A person may recover actual losses or $500 per violation, whichever is greater, and a court may triple the award for willful or knowing violations[3]. The National Do Not Call Registry held 259 million active registrations as of September 30, 2025[4], so ask whether the caller's number is registered and when.

TCPA statutory damages per violation47 U.S.C. 227(b)(3); the court decides whether to increase the award.
TCPA statutory damages per violationComparison. Per violation (or actual loss if greater): $500; Maximum if willful or knowing: $1,500.$500Per violation (or actual loss if greater)Per violation (or actual loss if greater): $500$1,500Maximum if willful or knowingMaximum if willful or knowing: $1,500TCPA statutory damages per violationComparison. Per violation (or actual loss if greater): $500; Maximum if willful or knowing: $1,500.$500Per violation (or actual loss ifgreater)Per violation (or actual loss if greater): $500$1,500Maximum if willful or knowingMaximum if willful or knowing: $1,500

Source: Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School, 2025[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Per violation (or actual loss if greater)$500
Maximum if willful or knowing$1,500
  • Which numbers called or texted, how many times and over what period.
  • Was the voice recorded or artificial? Were texts automated?
  • Did the caller ever give consent, for example on a form, and did they ask the company to stop?
  • Screenshots of call logs and messages, with dates visible.

Credit reporting and dealer fraud questions

Credit reporting callers usually have one wrong account, a mixed file with someone else's information, or an identity theft problem. Ask which credit bureaus show the error, the account name and number, when the caller first noticed it, whether they disputed it in writing, and what response they received. Ask whether the error has cost them anything concrete, such as a denied loan, a higher interest rate, a lost apartment or a job offer withdrawn, and when that happened.

Dealer and seller fraud calls need the sales story in order: the advertisement or listing, what the salesperson said, what was shown (such as a vehicle history report), what was signed and when, and what the caller learned later. Ask for the full deal jacket if the caller has it: buyer's order, retail installment contract, add-on product forms and any arbitration agreement. Many disputes turn on add-ons the caller did not knowingly agree to, so ask about service contracts, insurance products and fees listed on the contract.

Why fee-shifting matters at intake

Many consumer claims involve modest amounts. Fee-shifting statutes make them viable: under federal warranty law, a consumer who finally prevails may recover costs and expenses including attorneys' fees based on actual time expended[1], and the FDCPA awards a reasonable attorney's fee to a successful plaintiff[2]. Cost is a real barrier for many callers; only 63% of US adults would cover a $400 emergency expense entirely with cash[5]. Staff can say, if the attorney approves the wording, that some consumer laws require the other side to pay legal fees when the consumer wins, and that the attorney will explain how the firm handles fees.

Documents by claim type

Documents to request for each consumer claim type
Claim typeDocuments to request
Lemon law and warrantyPurchase or lease contract, warranty booklet, every repair order, manufacturer letters, photos or videos of the defect
Debt collectionCollection letters, call logs, voicemails, screenshots, any court papers, written requests to stop
Robocalls and textsCall logs and message screenshots, Do Not Call registration confirmation, any stop requests
Credit reportingCredit reports, dispute letters and responses, proof the debt is not the caller's
Dealer or seller fraudAds and listings, purchase contract, financing documents, vehicle history reports, messages

Ask callers not to return, trade in or sell a vehicle, settle with a collector or sign any release until they have spoken with the attorney.

Urgent flags in consumer matters

  • A lawsuit or arbitration demand already filed against the caller, especially by a debt buyer or a lender.
  • A repossession scheduled or completed.
  • A vehicle defect that makes it unsafe to drive, such as brakes, steering or sudden loss of power.
  • A wage garnishment or bank levy notice.
  • A deadline in a manufacturer's buyback or settlement offer.
  • Collection calls that include threats of arrest or contact with the caller's employer after a request to stop.
  • Violations dating back close to a year, given the FDCPA's one-year period.

Any of these should go to the attorney the same day. For an unsafe vehicle, staff can also tell the caller that the firm cannot advise on safety and that they should contact the dealer or manufacturer about whether to drive it.

Example: the transmission and the texts

Example (fictional). A caller bought a new SUV eight months ago. The transmission has slipped since the first month; the dealer has had it four times for a total of 31 days, and replaced a part once. She has three repair orders but says the dealer did not write up one visit. Meanwhile, the dealer's finance company is texting her daily about a payment she says she made.

Intake opens two question sets: lemon law and warranty for the vehicle, and robocalls and texts for the finance company messages. It records the VIN, delivery date and mileage, each repair visit, the missing write-up and the days out of service, then the number texting, the frequency, and her payment confirmation. The attorney reviews both issues at one consultation.

Writing the note and following up

Consumer matters often involve many small events, so the note should be a dated list rather than a narrative. Lead with the claim type and the earliest possible deadline, then list each repair visit, call, letter or text with its date. Attach the documents the caller has sent and list the ones still missing. When the attorney accepts the matter, send the caller a written list of what to keep collecting, such as new repair orders or new collection calls, because many consumer cases grow while they are being prepared.

Frequently asked questions

Can intake tell a caller whether their car qualifies as a lemon?

No. Lemon law criteria vary by state and depend on the repair history and the vehicle. Intake collects the repair orders and dates for the attorney.

What if the dealer refused to write up a repair visit?

Record the date, who the caller spoke to and any texts or emails about the visit. The attorney will consider how to prove it.

Does the caller need to have paid the debt for an FDCPA claim?

Not necessarily. The conduct of the collector is the focus. Record the communications and dates, and let the attorney assess.

How should callers preserve robocall evidence?

Screenshot call logs and messages with dates visible, save voicemails, and do not delete anything. Note any request to stop and its date.

References

  1. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 15 U.S. Code 2310 - Remedies in consumer disputes (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 15 U.S. Code 1692k - Civil liability (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2025). 47 U.S. Code ยง 227 - Restrictions on use of telephone equipment (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Federal Trade Commission (2025). National Do Not Call Registry Data Book, Fiscal Year 2025 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2025). Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households: Unexpected expenses (data table) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo