Key takeaways
- Federal law sets a one-party consent floor for recording calls you are part of, unless the purpose is criminal or tortious[1].
- About 11 states primarily require all parties' consent, four more require it for either phone calls or in-person conversations, and two require it in particularly private places[2].
- Courts disagree on which state's law governs an interstate call[2], so a firm that takes calls from anywhere should default to all-party notice.
- Recording is not the only issue: Illinois treats a voiceprint as a biometric identifier that needs written notice and a written release[3].
The federal baseline
Law firms record calls for good reasons: accurate intake notes, quality review, training and a record of what a caller was told. The starting point is federal wiretap law, which says it is not unlawful for a person not acting under color of law to intercept a wire, oral or electronic communication where that person is a party to it or one of the parties has given prior consent, unless the purpose is to commit a criminal or tortious act[1]. That is a one-party consent rule.
States can add stricter requirements, and many do. For a firm that takes calls from prospective clients across state lines, the stricter rules are the ones that set the policy.
How the states divide
The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, which maintains a state-by-state recording guide, groups the states as follows[2]. About 11 states primarily require the consent of all parties: California, Delaware, Florida, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan (at least for recordings by a third party not in the conversation), Montana, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania and Washington. Four states require all-party consent for one type of conversation: Missouri and Oregon for in-person conversations, Connecticut and Nevada for phone calls. Hawaii and Maine require all-party consent for recordings in particularly private places. Vermont has no recording statute, so federal law applies there.
| Group | States | What it means for an intake line |
|---|---|---|
| All-party consent, most conversations | CA, DE, FL, IL, MD, MA, MI (third-party recordings), MT, NH, PA, WA | Announce recording and get consent from every caller |
| All-party for phone calls only | CT, NV | Phone intake needs all-party consent |
| All-party for in-person only | MO, OR | Phone may be one-party; office meetings need consent |
| All-party in particularly private places | HI, ME | Mostly one-party for calls; check for private-place recordings |
| One-party or no state statute | The remaining states and DC | Firm's own party consent is enough under state law, but interstate calls change that |
State law changes and courts interpret these statutes in detail, including what counts as a confidential conversation. Treat this grouping as a map, not legal advice, and check the statute and recent case law in the states where your callers are.
Interstate calls: why all-party is the safe default
A firm in a one-party state still receives calls from all-party states, and the reverse. The Reporters Committee notes that some courts apply the law of the state where the recording device is located and others the law of the state where the person being recorded is located, so an aggrieved party may sue in whichever jurisdiction is more favorable[2]. For an intake line that accepts calls from anywhere, the only policy that works everywhere is to treat every call as all-party.
The strict states also carry real penalties. California's eavesdropping statute applies to a person who intentionally, without the consent of all parties to a confidential communication, records it, with fines of up to $2,500 per violation for a first offense[4]. Florida makes it lawful to intercept a communication when all parties have given prior consent, and treats unlawful interception as a third-degree felony in most cases[5].
What a good recording notice looks like
The goal is a notice every caller hears before anything substantive is said, that is short enough not to irritate and clear enough that continuing the call is meaningful consent. Put it at the start of the greeting for inbound calls and say it yourself on outbound calls.
Inbound greeting: “Thank you for calling the Law Office of Kim and Diaz. This call is recorded so we can make sure we have your information right. If you'd prefer not to be recorded, please tell us and we'll stop.” Outbound: “Before we start, I should let you know I'm recording this call for our notes. Is that all right?”
- Give the notice before any facts are discussed.
- Offer a way to continue without recording, and make sure staff can actually turn it off.
- For outbound calls, ask and wait for a yes rather than relying on silence.
- Repeat the notice if a new person joins the call, such as a relative picked up on speaker.
- Keep the notice in every language you take calls in.
If an SI Employee such as Ava answers your line, put the recording notice, and the fact that the caller is speaking with an AI assistant, in its approved greeting so every caller hears both first.
Beyond consent: voiceprints and transcripts
Modern call systems transcribe and may identify speakers by voice. Illinois' Biometric Information Privacy Act lists a voiceprint as a biometric identifier and bars private entities from collecting one without first informing the person in writing and obtaining a written release; liquidated damages run to $1,000 per negligent violation and $5,000 per intentional or reckless one[3]. Ask every telephony and transcription vendor whether it creates voice profiles, and turn that feature off unless you have a compliant process.
When a caller says no
Some callers will decline. A person calling about domestic violence, a whistleblower or someone who has been recorded against their will before may not want any recording, and they should not have to hang up to avoid it. Staff need a way to stop the recording on the spot and to note the call manually instead.
- Stop the recording and confirm to the caller that it has stopped.
- Delete any partial recording if your system allows, or flag it for deletion.
- Take careful written notes instead, and note in the record that the caller declined recording.
- Do not ask the caller to justify the choice or treat them differently afterwards.
Recordings are client information
Once a call is recorded lawfully, the recording itself becomes information relating to a prospective or current client. It needs the same protection as the file: access limited to people who need it, storage in systems the firm controls, and a deletion schedule. A recording of a declined prospect's intake call is particularly easy to forget about and particularly sensitive if the firm later acts for the other side. Include recordings in your conflict and confidentiality procedures, not only in your phone settings.
Building a firm-wide recording policy
List every place calls are recorded
Main line, intake line, attorneys' mobile apps, video meetings, answering services and any AI tools.
Apply all-party notice everywhere
Use the same notice wording across inbound, outbound and video calls.
Decide retention and access
Set who can listen to recordings, where they are stored and when they are deleted.
Check vendor features
Confirm whether vendors transcribe, analyze or create voice profiles, and where that data goes.
Train and test
Make test calls monthly to confirm the notice plays and that staff can stop a recording on request.
Document consent
Keep the greeting text and version dates so you can show what callers heard at any point.
Example: a multistate personal injury firm
Example (fictional): a personal injury firm based in a one-party state advertises nationally and receives calls from Pennsylvania, Florida and California. Its phone system records every call, but the greeting says nothing about recording because the firm assumed its home-state law applied. A review flags the interstate risk. The firm adds a short recording notice to the start of every inbound greeting, trains intake staff to say it on outbound callbacks and disables a speaker-identification feature in its transcription tool.
The change cost a few seconds per call. It also gave the firm a consistent answer when a caller asked whether the call was being recorded, which some callers do before they share anything.
State-specific guides
For more detail on two of the strictest states, see California call recording rules for law firm intake and Florida call recording consent for law offices. Recorded consultations raise privilege questions too; see recording video consultations: consent and privilege. This article is general information, not legal advice.
Frequently asked questions
Which states require all-party consent to record a call?
The Reporters Committee lists about 11 states as primarily all-party: California, Delaware, Florida, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan (at least for third-party recordings), Montana, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania and Washington, with Connecticut and Nevada requiring it for phone calls.
Which law applies when a caller is in another state?
Courts disagree. Some apply the law where the recording device is, others where the recorded person is. A firm that takes interstate calls should give all-party notice on every call.
Is a recorded greeting enough for consent?
A clear notice at the start of the call, followed by the caller choosing to continue, is the common approach. Offer a way to continue without recording and ask explicitly on outbound calls.
Do transcription features raise separate issues?
Yes. If a system creates voiceprints, Illinois' biometric privacy law requires written notice and a written release first.
References
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2025). 18 U.S. Code § 2511 - Interception and disclosure of wire, oral, or electronic communications prohibited (opens in a new tab) ↑
Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press (2021). Introduction to the Reporter's Recording Guide (opens in a new tab) ↑
Illinois General Assembly (2025). Biometric Information Privacy Act (740 ILCS 14) (opens in a new tab) ↑
California Legislative Information (2026). California Penal Code § 632 (archived copy of the official code page) (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Florida Legislature (2026). Florida Statutes § 934.03: Interception and disclosure of wire, oral, or electronic communications prohibited (opens in a new tab) ↑