Key takeaways
- Give professional callers their own path: identify them in the first exchange, route to the matter team and log every call against the matter.
- Court and clerk calls are time-sensitive by default; capture the case number, the caller's direct line and any date, and act the same day.
- Staff never discuss the substance of a matter with opposing counsel or an unrepresented opposing party; they take a precise message.
- Court activity can change fast: immigration courts completed 973,669 cases in FY2026, up from 798,975 a year earlier[1].
Why professional calls need their own rules
Most phone guidance at law firms is written for new clients. Yet a large share of calls on any working day come from professionals: court clerks, judges' chambers, opposing counsel and their staff, mediators, court reporters, adjusters, experts and referral sources. These callers rarely need intake. They need the right person, a reliable message and a callback by a specific time. Handled like a new client, they waste time; handled carelessly, they can cost the firm a hearing date or create an ethics problem.
The risk is highest in small offices, where 86.8% of US law offices have fewer than ten employees[2] and the person answering may not know every matter. Clear rules let anyone who picks up the phone handle these calls correctly.
Professional callers at a glance
| Caller | What they usually need | Route to | Target response |
|---|---|---|---|
| Court clerk or chambers | Scheduling, filings, a missing document | Matter attorney's assistant; attorney if a date is at risk | Same day, often within hours |
| Opposing counsel or their staff | Dates, discovery, settlement, procedure | Matter attorney's assistant | Per any deadline mentioned; otherwise one business day |
| Unrepresented opposing party | Varies; often wants to talk about the case | Message to matter attorney only | Attorney decides |
| Mediator or arbitrator's office | Scheduling and submissions | Matter assistant | One business day |
| Court reporter, process server, expert | Logistics, invoices, availability | Matter paralegal | One business day |
| Insurance adjuster | Claim information, statements | Matter attorney's assistant | Per matter instructions |
| Referring attorney | Status of a referral, a new referral | Partner or intake lead | Same day |
Identify professional callers quickly
βThank you for calling [Firm name]. May I ask who's calling and which case this is about?β
Most professional callers answer both parts in one breath. If they give a case name, look it up before transferring, so the call reaches the matter team rather than intake. If they ask for an attorney by name, confirm the matter first; a clerk asking for the attorney on Smith may need the associate who is actually handling it.
Calls from courts and clerks
Treat every court call as time-sensitive until someone on the matter team says otherwise. Clerks and chambers often call about scheduling conflicts, missing documents or hearing changes, and they may not call twice.
- Court name and department or courtroom.
- Case name and case number, read back.
- Caller's name, title and direct line, not just the court's main number.
- Any date or deadline mentioned, written as a date.
- What the court needs, in the caller's words.
- Whether the caller asked for a response by a certain time.
Send the message to the matter team and the responsible attorney at once, and follow up by phone if a date is at risk. If a caller claiming to be from a court asks for payment, personal details or anything unusual, verify by calling the court's published number before acting; see when scammers impersonate your law firm by phone.
Calls from opposing counsel
Opposing counsel and their staff usually want something specific: available dates, a response to a letter, a discovery issue or a settlement conversation. Staff take a precise message and route it to the matter attorney's assistant. They do not discuss the substance of the matter, confirm facts, agree to dates or comment on settlement, even if the caller is friendly and insistent.
βI'm not able to discuss the case, but I'll make sure [attorney name]'s assistant has your message right away. Can you tell me exactly what you need and by when?β
Record any deadline the caller states and whether they asked for a callback, an email or a letter. If they mention a deadline earlier than the matter team expects, flag it.
Calls from unrepresented opposing parties
Calls from the other side of a matter, when that person has no lawyer, are the most delicate. Staff should be polite and brief: take the caller's name, number and the reason for the call, and pass it to the matter attorney, who decides whether and how to respond. Staff give no advice and no information about the case. The general rule for nonlawyer staff applies with extra force here: identify as a nonlawyer, keep to facts and leave legal questions to a lawyer[3].
βI'm not a lawyer and I can't discuss the case. I'll pass your name, number and message to the attorney, who will decide how to respond.β
Adjusters, experts and other professionals
Insurance adjusters often call injury and property firms asking for claim details, medical records or a recorded statement from the client. Staff should take the adjuster's name, company, claim number, direct line and request, and route it to the matter attorney's assistant. They should not provide documents, confirm treatment details or agree to a statement; those decisions belong to the attorney.
Experts, court reporters, process servers and investigators mostly call about logistics: availability, invoices, addresses and deadlines. These calls go to the matter paralegal, but they still need the matter name and any date in the message. A missed message from a process server about a failed service attempt can matter as much as one from the court.
Referring attorneys deserve a prompt, personal response. A same-day callback from a partner or the intake lead protects a referral relationship that may be worth more than any single matter.
Protecting client confidentiality
Some callers who sound professional are not. Others are legitimate but not entitled to the information they ask for. Staff should not confirm whether a person is a client, share contact details or discuss case status with callers they cannot verify. When in doubt, take a message and let the matter team respond through a channel they know is genuine, such as the court's published number or counsel's number from the docket.
Log every professional call against the matter
Log entry: [date, time] | MATTER: [name, number] | CALLER: [name, title, organization] | DIRECT LINE: [number] | REQUEST: [one line] | DATE OR DEADLINE: [date] | ROUTED TO: [person] | TOLD CALLER: [promise] | DONE: [who, when]
A matter log of professional calls shows who called, what they asked and what the firm promised. It protects the firm if there is later a dispute about whether a message was received or a date was agreed, and it helps anyone covering for a colleague who is away. Use the same fields as your general message-taking standard, with the matter fields added.
Court activity changes call volume
Source: U.S. Department of Justice, Executive Office for Immigration Review, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| FY2017 | 163,074 |
| FY2025 | 798,975 |
| FY2026 | 973,669 |
Court workloads shift quickly, and professional calls shift with them. US immigration courts completed 973,669 cases in FY2026, compared with 798,975 in FY2025 and 163,074 in FY2017[1]. In federal district courts, filings for criminal defendants grew 12% in the year ending March 31, 2025, and bankruptcy courts received 13% more petitions[4]. Firms in fast-moving dockets should expect more scheduling calls and plan coverage for them, especially on days attorneys are in court.
Set it up
List your professional callers
Courts you appear in, frequent opposing firms, mediators, adjusters and referral sources.
Write the routing rules
One line per caller type: route, backup and target response, as in the table above.
Add the scripts
Identification, the opposing counsel line and the unrepresented party line, in the front-desk guide.
Create the log
A matter-level log with the fields above in your practice management or phone system.
Brief your answering service
Give outside answerers the same rules, so after-hours and overflow calls are handled the same way.
Review monthly
Check a sample of professional call logs for missing case numbers, direct lines and dates.
Example: a missed clerk call, and the fix
Example (fictional): a family law clerk called a small firm to move a hearing and left a message with the receptionist, who wrote clerk called, please call back and put it in the general queue. The attorney saw it two days later, after the court had moved the hearing to a date she could not attend. The firm added court calls to its urgent list, required the case number and direct line on every court message, and set a rule that any court call is passed to the matter attorney the same morning. The next clerk call was returned within the hour.
Related calls
Professional calls sit alongside other calls that are not new clients but still need careful handling. See our guides on calls from family members and third parties, screening sales calls and robocalls and recording intake calls for the rules that apply to each.
Frequently asked questions
Can staff talk to opposing counsel about a case?
Staff should take a precise message and route it to the matter attorney's assistant. They should not discuss the substance of the matter, agree to dates or comment on settlement.
How should we handle a call from a court clerk?
Treat it as time-sensitive. Capture the court, case name and number, the clerk's direct line, any date and what the court needs, and pass it to the matter team and attorney the same day.
What if the other party in a case calls and has no lawyer?
Take their name, number and reason for calling, give no advice or case information, and pass the message to the matter attorney, who decides whether and how to respond.
Should professional calls be logged?
Yes, against the matter, with the caller, request, any deadline, who it was routed to and what was promised. The log helps anyone covering and protects the firm in later disputes.
References
U.S. Department of Justice, Executive Office for Immigration Review (2026). Adjudication Statistics: Pending Cases, New Cases, and Total Completions (opens in a new tab) β
U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023: U.S. detail file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) β
The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) β
United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts) (2025). Federal Judicial Caseload Statistics 2025 (opens in a new tab) β