Key takeaways
- Most people who call a malpractice firm will be declined, and most claims that are filed never pay[1], so the way the phone is answered is a large part of what the firm offers.
- Let the caller tell the story first, then collect provider, specialty, facility and every date that could matter to a time limit[2]. The service records dates and never says whether a caller is in time.
- Records questions, merits questions and declines belong to the firm. The service takes them down and gives an honest next step.
- Approve a short urgent list with the attorney, such as a death in the last few days, and route those calls down a tested escalation tree.
A practice that says no to most callers
A medical malpractice firm turns away most of the people who call it, and the way it turns them away is part of what it sells. Lawsuits against doctors are common over a career: in 2022, 31.2% of US physicians said they had been sued at some point[3]. Payment is not. In one large insurer's data covering 1991 to 2005, 7.4% of physicians faced a claim each year but only 1.6% had a claim that led to a payment, so 78% of claims ended with nothing paid to the claimant[1]. Those are filed claims. The inquiries that reach a firm's phone line are screened far harder before anyone files anything.
That arithmetic shapes the phone work. The firm needs every caller heard properly, because the rare strong case often sounds like the ten weak ones in its first minute. And the many callers who will be declined still deserve a careful, unhurried conversation, because they are usually sick, grieving or frightened, and because a careless call is how firms end up with complaints, bad reviews or a caller who believes the firm took the case. Medical malpractice intake screening covers what the attorney's team does once a call is passed on; this piece is about the front line that gets it there.
Claim frequency varies a great deal by specialty, from 19.1% of neurosurgeons a year to 2.6% of psychiatrists in the same study[1]. Your intake should record the provider's specialty and the facility for exactly that reason: the attorney reviewing tomorrow's summaries reads them first.
Why these calls defeat a message-taking service
A standard answering service is built for a name, a number and a one-line reason. A malpractice call does not fit that box, for four reasons.
- The story is long and the caller needs to tell it. Cut them off at the one-line reason and they will tell it again to the attorney, angrier, or not call back at all.
- Records come up early. Callers ask whether they should request their chart, whether the hospital can refuse, and whether the firm will get the records for them. None of that is for the front line to answer.
- Dates decide everything and callers rarely have them straight. Treatment dates, the last visit with that provider and the day they first suspected something was wrong all matter, and they are often guessed.
- Many callers are still patients. Some are mid-treatment with the very provider they are calling about, which makes tone and confidentiality more delicate than in most injury calls.
Time limits show why dates matter more than the story. In New York, a medical malpractice action must be started within two years and six months of the act or omission, or of the last treatment where treatment was continuous for the same condition. A foreign object left in the body gets one year from discovery, and a failure to diagnose cancer runs from discovery but no later than seven years after the act[2]. Other states use different rules. The front line does not need to know them; it needs to capture every date the caller can give, mark which are estimates, and leave the conclusion to a lawyer. Screening for limitation deadlines without giving advice covers the wording.
A screening order that stays kind and consistent
Consistency is the point. If two callers with the same facts get different treatment depending on who picked up, the firm cannot trust its own intake numbers and cannot defend its declines. Write the order down and have every call follow it.
Let them tell it
Open with one question, what happened, and listen for a couple of minutes without steering. Note the words the caller uses for the injury and the provider.
Who, where and which specialty
The provider's name, specialty and the facility, spelled and read back. These double as names for the conflict check.
Every date, marked exact or estimated
When the treatment happened, the last visit with that provider, when the caller first suspected a problem, and any date of death.
What happened next
Further treatment, current condition and who is caring for the patient now. If the caller is not the patient, their relationship to the patient.
Other lawyers and paperwork
Whether they already have a lawyer or have been turned down elsewhere, and which records, letters or bills they hold. No advice on getting more.
An honest next step
Every inquiry is reviewed by the legal team, and here is when you will hear from us. No hint that the firm has taken the case.
Some firms put the conflict names before the story. The solo personal injury example takes conflict-check names and asks whether the caller already has a lawyer before asking what happened, which suits fast-moving accident calls. A malpractice line can reasonably reverse it: the provider's name usually arrives inside the story anyway, and a caller describing a death in the family should not be met with a form. The guide to running a conflict check at intake explains which names are essential either way.
Deaths and birth injuries need their own opening lines and a slower pace; wrongful death intake with grieving families and birth injury case intake have scripts the attorney can approve for those callers.
Declines belong to the firm
The front line should never tell a caller they have no case. ABA guidance lets trained nonlawyers gather the first facts, run an initial conflict check and determine whether a matter is in an area the firm handles[4]. That last item is the line. A billing dispute with a hospital or a complaint about a rude nurse can be redirected under a script the attorney approves. A claim that a diagnosis was missed is a legal judgment, and only the firm makes it, in writing, with whatever time-limit language the attorney requires.
The risk runs both ways. Florida's ethics opinion on generative AI warns that intake chatbots can create a prospective-client or even a lawyer-client relationship without the lawyer knowing[5]. A service that sounds too confident, or says something like that sounds like a strong case, creates expectations the firm then has to unwind. The approved closing line should be dull and true. Turning away bad-fit callers kindly and safely has decline wording for the firm's own letters and calls.
Example closing line: Thank you for telling me all of this. I have written it down in your words and it goes to our legal team, who review every inquiry. Someone will contact you by Thursday. I cannot tell you whether there is a case; only the attorneys can do that.
Records and medical details on the phone
Callers will offer diagnoses, medications and test results unprompted. Take down what the caller volunteers that the attorney needs, ask only the approved questions, and do not invite a full medical history on the first call. Records requests, authorization forms and what to do with a stack of discharge papers are for the firm's staff after the attorney has reviewed the inquiry. Medical records authorizations at injury intake covers that step.
Ask any provider who can hear these calls later. Recordings and transcripts of malpractice calls are sensitive, so you want control over who receives each summary and how long recordings and transcripts are kept, and you want that set before the first call is forwarded rather than after.
What faster screening is worth
Malpractice economics are lumpy: a firm may sign a handful of cases a year from hundreds of inquiries, and one of them can carry the year. The cost of a missed call is the chance that the rare strong case went to voicemail and then to the next firm on the caller's list. Few people answer callbacks from unknown numbers; 80% of Americans say they generally do not pick up[6].
| Input | Example |
|---|---|
| Calls per week | 35 |
| Calls that go unanswered (%) | 25% |
| Unanswered calls from new customers (%) | 70% |
| New inquiries that become signed cases (%) | 2% |
| Average fee per signed case | $35,000 |
| Unanswered calls a month | 38 |
| From new customers | 27 |
| Bookings that would have followed | 0.5 |
| Monthly value at risk | $18,565 |
How it is worked out: Calls a week × 4.33 weeks × unanswered share × new-customer share × booking rate × average value.
Assumptions
- Fee per signed case of $35,000. The median malpractice payment in the study data was $111,749[1]; a one-third contingency on that median is about $37,000, before costs and in older dollars, so treat this as a placeholder for your own average.[1]
- A 2% sign-up rate on new inquiries reflects how few claims succeed: 78% of filed claims in the same study ended without payment[1].[1]
- Thirty-five calls a week, a quarter unanswered and 70% of them new inquiries are made up for this illustration. Replace them with a week from your phone log.
Example only. With rare, large cases the monthly figure is an average; in practice it arrives as one signed case or none.
The model says about $18,600 a month is at risk in this example, which really means roughly one signed case every two months that a firm in this position could be losing to unanswered calls. The other side of the ledger is staff time: a careful intake call runs long, and every one taken by a paralegal or associate is time off a file.
How the call should run
- Caller
- SI Employee
- System
- Your team
01Caller
Daughter calls at 7:40 pm
Office closed; the forwarded line answers with the approved greeting and recording notice.
02SI Employee
Story first, unhurried
One open question, then listening. Names and words recorded as the caller says them.
03SI Employee
Names and dates
Surgeon, specialty, hospital; surgery date, date of death, each marked exact or estimated.
04System
Urgent list checked
A death in the last few days is on the attorney's urgent list, so the tree starts.
05Your team
On-call attorney
Transfer with a short briefing to the attorney; if nobody answers, an urgent message.
06System
Summary by morning
Summary, recording and transcript to the intake lead, marked urgent.
Example flow. Whether a recent death is urgent, and who is called in what order, is the attorney's decision.
Most calls never touch the urgent path. They end with an honest next step and a summary the intake lead reads in the morning, with the specialty, facility and dates at the top. That is where the time is saved: the attorney can sort a dozen overnight inquiries in minutes and spend the call-backs on the two that deserve them.
What to ask before you sign
- Can a caller talk for several minutes without being cut off or pushed to the next field? Test it with a long, wandering fictional story.
- Does it capture dates as said, mark estimates, and refuse to comment on timing?
- Who receives each summary, and can you set how long recordings and transcripts are kept?
- Can urgent calls follow a tree of named attorneys with a tested fallback, and what does the caller hear if nobody answers?
- Will it ever say an attorney is available, or that a case sounds strong? The only right answer is never.
An SI Employee from AssistCall is built around those answers (see what it does). You forward your number for the hours you choose and approve the greeting, disclosures, questions and closing line. Urgent calls follow an escalation tree of up to three destinations with a tested fallback, and a transfer to an attorney comes with a short spoken briefing. Every call lands with a summary, recording and transcript, and the right person is notified. It does not connect to case management software today, so the summary goes to people, not into your system.
- New inquiry3 events
- Intake captured5 events
- Urgent routing2 events
- Consultation2 events
- Firm review2 events
Activity
- Call
After-hours call answered
Example caller · greeting includes AI and recording notice
- Call
Practice area: estate planning
In scope for the firm · approved will and trust script
- Call
Contact and callback captured
Name, mobile, email · prefers afternoons
- Call
Names for conflict review
Spouse and adult children listed for the firm's own check
- Call
Consultation booked
Tue 2:30 pm · video · tested calendar
- Call
Summary sent to intake team
Summary, recording and transcript in the AssistCall account
- Call
Lunchtime overflow call
Family law · custody modification question
- Call
Outside the pilot practice area
Approved referral wording · noted for firm review
- Call
Caller has a hearing tomorrow
Matches the firm's urgent rule: court date within 48 hours
- Call
Trying on-call attorney
Destination 1 of 3 · no answer after 25 seconds
- Call
Connected to backup attorney
Destination 2 of 3 · transfer completed
- Call
Message for existing client's attorney
Document question · no case details discussed
- Call
Office hours and parking question
Answered from the approved profile · no message needed
- Call
Consultation request taken
Probate · team to confirm a time with the caller
- 47Inquiries answered this weekExample
- 19Answered after hoursExample
- 5Urgent calls routedExample
- 16Consultations booked or requestedExample
- Under 1 minMedian time to staff alertExample
Example only. Fictional business, people and numbers; not a recording or a live account.
Firms that also take nursing home cases can reuse most of this setup; nursing home abuse case intake lists the questions that change.
Frequently asked questions
Should the answering service tell callers whether they have a case?
No. Trained nonlawyers can gather facts and check whether a matter is in an area the firm handles[4], but whether a case exists is a legal judgment. The service closes with an honest next step and a date the team will keep.
Can the service request medical records for a caller?
No. It notes which records, letters and bills the caller already holds. Authorizations and records requests come from the firm's staff after an attorney has reviewed the inquiry.
What if a caller's time limit may be close?
The service captures every date the caller can give, marks estimates, and follows the attorney's flag rule. Time limits vary by state and by the facts; in New York the base period is two years and six months with exceptions[2]. The firm, not the service, decides.
Which calls should be urgent at a malpractice firm?
Only the ones on a short list the attorney writes, such as a death in the last few days or a caller who says a deadline letter has arrived. Everything else becomes a detailed summary for the morning.
What about calls from doctors, hospitals or insurers?
Take a message with the caller's name, organization and the matter they mean, and route it to the responsible person. The service discusses nothing about a client or a case.
References
New England Journal of Medicine (via PubMed Central) (2011). Malpractice Risk According to Physician Specialty (N Engl J Med 2011) (opens in a new tab) ↑
The New York State Senate (2026). New York Civil Practice Law and Rules 214-A: medical, dental or podiatric malpractice actions (opens in a new tab) ↑
American Medical Association (2023). AMA: One in three physicians previously sued in their career (opens in a new tab) ↑
American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2023). ABA Formal Opinion 506: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistants (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑