Client Intake

Turning Away Bad-Fit Callers Kindly and Safely

Decline scripts for bad-fit legal callers, plus the referral, non-engagement letter and record-keeping steps that limit risk to the firm.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Saying no is part of intake
  2. How much unmet need sits behind your declines
  3. The six-step decline
  4. Scripts for the main decline reasons
  5. The written decline
  6. Declining after a consultation
  7. Handle the emotional calls carefully
  8. Example: a decline done well
  9. Why trust is fragile
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Client Intake: Turning Away Bad-Fit Callers Kindly and SafelyArticle coverCLIENT INTAKETurning Away Bad-FitCallers Kindly andSafelyAva for LawyersInsightsClient Intake: Turning Away Bad-Fit Callers Kindly and SafelyArticle coverCLIENT INTAKETurning Away Bad-FitCallers Kindly andSafelyAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Decline for reasons about the firm (practice area, location, capacity, conflict), never with a view on the merits.
  • Always mention time limits and give a referral; the unmet need is large, with 92% of low-income Americans' serious civil problems getting little or no help[1].
  • Send a short non-engagement letter whenever the conversation reached the specifics of a matter.
  • Treat every declined caller as a future reviewer and referrer: how you say no is part of your reputation[2].

Saying no is part of intake

Every firm turns away more inquiries than it accepts. Some matters are outside the firm's practice areas, some are in the wrong state, some fail the acceptance criteria, and some cannot be taken because of a conflict. How the firm says no matters for three reasons.

The person still has a problem. The Legal Services Corporation found that low-income Americans get no legal help, or not enough, for 92% of the substantial civil legal problems they face[1]. A thoughtful decline with a referral may be the most useful thing that happens to that caller all week.

The firm has risk. A caller who was turned away vaguely may believe the firm is looking into their matter. If a deadline passes, that misunderstanding becomes the firm's problem.

And the firm has a reputation. People who were declined still talk, post reviews and recommend firms to friends. Pew found that 53% of adults aged 18 to 29 and 47% of those aged 30 to 49 always or almost always read online reviews before buying something for the first time[2].

How much unmet need sits behind your declines

The LSC's 2022 Justice Gap research shows how common civil legal problems are. Among low-income households, 74% had at least one civil legal problem in the past year, 39% had five or more, and 20% had ten or more[1].

Low-income US households with civil legal problems in the past year, 2022
Low-income US households with civil legal problems in the past year, 2022Bar chart. At least one problem: 74%; Five or more problems: 39%; Ten or more problems: 20%.At least one problemAt least one problem: 74%74%Five or more problemsFive or more problems: 39%39%Ten or more problemsTen or more problems: 20%20%Low-income US households with civil legal problems in the past year, 2022Bar chart. At least one problem: 74%; Five or more problems: 39%; Ten or more problems: 20%.At least one problemAt least one problem: 74%74%Five or more problemsFive or more problems: 39%39%Ten or more problemsTen or more problems: 20%20%

Source: Legal Services Corporation, 2022[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
At least one problem74%
Five or more problems39%
Ten or more problems20%

Many of the callers you decline will have other legal problems too, and some will come back for a matter you do handle, or send someone who has one. That is a practical reason, not just a kind one, to decline well.

The six-step decline

  1. Thank them

    "Thank you for explaining all of that. I know it isn't easy to call about."

  2. Give the reason, about the firm

    "Our firm doesn't handle [type of matter]" or "Our attorneys only practice in [state]" or "We're not able to take this on." Never "you don't have a case" or "that won't go anywhere".

  3. Mention time limits

    "Legal matters can have deadlines, so please speak to another lawyer soon."

  4. Give a referral

    A named firm, the state or local bar referral service, a legal aid organization or a clinic, with a phone number.

  5. Confirm in writing

    Tell them you will send a short email or letter confirming that the firm is not representing them, then send it.

  6. Record it

    Note the reason, the referral given and when the written decline was sent.

The reason in step 2 should always be true, but it does not need to be detailed. For conflicts in particular, staff should not explain who the firm represents. "We're not able to take this matter on" is enough.

Scripts for the main decline reasons

Decline scripts by reason. All declines include a time-limit caution and a referral where one exists.
ReasonWhat to sayWhat not to sayRecord
Practice area not handledOur firm doesn't handle this kind of matter, but here is a firm or service that doesThat's an easy one, any lawyer can do itReason, referral given
Outside the firm's statesOur attorneys aren't licensed where this is happening. Here is the bar referral service thereIt's probably the same law everywhereState, referral given
Fails acceptance criteriaWe're not able to take this on, but we don't want you to lose timeIt's not worth pursuingRule that applied
Conflict of interestWe're not able to help with this matter. Here are other firms you could contactWe already represent the other sideConflict record reference, no detail in notes
CapacityWe aren't able to take new matters of this type right nowCall back in a few months and we'll seeCapacity rule, referral given
Already representedYour current lawyer is the best person to speak toYour lawyer should have done this differentlyRepresented, no intake taken

The written decline

A phone decline is easily forgotten or misremembered. Many firms send a short written decline, often called a non-engagement letter, whenever the conversation reached the specifics of a matter, and always after an attorney consultation that ended without representation. Ask your malpractice carrier what it expects; many carriers recommend it.

A non-engagement letter should be short and plain:

  • That the firm is not representing the person in the matter and will take no action on it.
  • That the decision is not a view on the merits of the matter.
  • That legal matters may be subject to time limits, and they should consult another lawyer promptly if they wish to pursue it.
  • Any referral details given on the call.
  • That any documents they sent are being returned or, where appropriate, how they will be handled.

Avoid stating a specific deadline or limitation period. If you name one and get it wrong, the letter can be relied on. "Time limits may apply" is the safer and more honest wording from a firm that has not taken the matter.

Declining after a consultation

A decline after a full consultation carries more weight than a decline on the first call, because the attorney has now heard the facts and may have discussed options. The prospective client is more likely to believe the firm is involved, and the firm now holds confidential information it must protect even though it will not act.

The Florida Bar's 2024 guidance warns that intake conversations, including those run by website chatbots, can create a prospective-client or even a lawyer-client relationship without the lawyer realizing it[3]. That is the strongest argument for putting every post-consultation decline in writing, the same day if possible.

The attorney, not staff, should deliver a post-consultation decline, ideally by phone first and then by letter. The conversation can be brief: thank the person for their time, say the firm is not able to take the matter, repeat that time limits may apply, and give a referral. If the attorney gave any general information during the consultation, the letter should not restate it as advice. Keep a copy of the letter on the inquiry record, and make sure any documents the person provided are returned or handled according to the firm's written policy.

Handle the emotional calls carefully

Some declined callers are upset. They have called several firms already and been turned away each time, or their matter involves loss, illness or fear. Staff should expect this and have a few lines ready:

  • "I'm sorry we can't be the firm for this. I don't want you to leave this call without somewhere to go next."
  • "I know it's frustrating to hear that again. The [bar referral service] matches people with lawyers who handle exactly this, and the number is [number]."
  • "Would it help if I emailed you the referral details so you have them in writing?"

If the caller describes a safety risk, such as domestic violence, or a crisis, give emergency and hotline numbers your firm has prepared in advance, and follow your escalation rule. That is not legal advice; it is basic care, and it should be in your intake procedures.

Example: a decline done well

Example (fictional): a caller asks a small business law firm to help with his brother's DUI charge in another state. The coordinator thanks him, explains that the firm handles business matters in Ohio only and does not take criminal cases, and says that a DUI charge can involve court dates and deadlines, so his brother should contact a criminal defense lawyer in that state soon.

She gives him the number for that state's bar lawyer referral service and offers to email it. He accepts. The email, sent within the hour, says the firm is not representing his brother, repeats the referral and the time-limit caution, and asks his brother to contact a lawyer directly. The intake record shows the reason (practice area and state), the referral and the time the email was sent.

Three months later, the same caller contacts the firm about a contract dispute with a supplier. He mentions that the firm was the only one that sent him anywhere useful.

Why trust is fragile

Declines are a test of character that callers notice. Gallup's average positive rating for the honesty and ethics of 11 tracked professions fell to 29% in 2025, the lowest on record[4]. Lawyers do not get the benefit of the doubt. A decline that is quick, respectful and useful is one of the few moments where a firm can show what it is like without being paid to.

  • Train every person who answers the phone on the six steps.
  • Keep the referral list current, so the referral is real.
  • Review a sample of declines each month for tone and for the written follow-up.
  • Track how many declined callers come back or refer others. The numbers are usually small but not zero.

Frequently asked questions

How do I turn down a potential client politely?

Thank them, give a reason about the firm rather than their case, mention that time limits may apply, give a referral, and confirm the decline in writing.

Do I need to send a non-engagement letter?

It is good practice whenever the conversation reached the specifics of a matter, and especially after a consultation. Many malpractice carriers recommend it.

Should we tell a caller we have a conflict?

Say only that the firm cannot take the matter. Do not explain who the firm represents or share details of the conflict.

Should we give a referral every time we decline?

Wherever possible. Many people go without legal help for serious problems[1], and a named referral is often the most useful thing the firm can offer.

References

  1. Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews and ratings (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Gallup (2025). Nurses Continue to Lead in Honesty and Ethics Ratings (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo