Practice Area Playbooks

Medical Malpractice Intake Screening

A careful medical malpractice intake: the screening sequence, deadlines to capture, records to request and how to decline the many callers you cannot help.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why most malpractice calls end in a decline
  2. What the claim data says about who gets sued
  3. The screening sequence
  4. Follow-up questions by claim type
  5. Dates and deadlines intake must capture
  6. Records: what to ask for and how to handle them
  7. Screening factors at a glance
  8. Declining with care
  9. Example: a delayed diagnosis call
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Practice Area Playbooks: Medical Malpractice Intake ScreeningArticle coverPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSMedical MalpracticeIntake ScreeningAva for LawyersInsightsPractice Area Playbooks: Medical Malpractice Intake ScreeningArticle coverPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSMedical MalpracticeIntake ScreeningAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Expect to decline most callers, and design the process so every decline is kind, prompt and documented.
  • Even filed claims rarely end in a finding of fault: two-thirds are dropped, dismissed or withdrawn[1].
  • Capture dates precisely, including when the caller learned of the harm, and never estimate a deadline for them.
  • Treat records and summaries as confidential; keep them out of tools that risk client confidentiality[2].

Why most malpractice calls end in a decline

Medical malpractice callers are often people who suffered a real loss and believe, sometimes correctly, that something went wrong. Most of them will still be declined. The reasons are rarely about sympathy. A viable claim usually needs a departure from the standard of care, a clear causal link between that departure and a significant injury, damages large enough to justify expert-heavy litigation, and a claim that is still within its deadlines. Many states add procedural hurdles such as a certificate or affidavit of merit from a qualified expert before or soon after filing.

Outcomes in the system reflect that difficulty. The American Medical Association reports that two-thirds of civil liability claims against physicians are dropped, dismissed or withdrawn without a finding of fault[1]. For intake, the lesson is not to screen harder for its own sake. It is to collect the right facts quickly, get them to an attorney, and decline with care when the answer is no.

What the claim data says about who gets sued

Nearly one-third of US physicians, 31.2%, reported in 2022 that they had been sued at some point in their careers, and exposure rises with time in practice: 46.8% of physicians over 54 had been sued, against 9.5% of those under 40[1]. Specialty matters most. About 62% of ob-gyns and 59.3% of general surgeons had been sued, compared with 7% of allergists and immunologists[1].

US physicians who have been sued at some point in their careers, 2022
US physicians who have been sued at some point in their careers, 2022Bar chart. Ob-gyns: 62%; General surgeons: 59.3%; All physicians: 31.2%; Allergists and immunologists: 7%.Ob-gynsOb-gyns: 62%62%General surgeonsGeneral surgeons: 59.3%59.3%All physiciansAll physicians: 31.2%31.2%Allergists and immunologistsAllergists and immunologists: 7%7%US physicians who have been sued at some point in their careers, 2022Bar chart. Ob-gyns: 62%; General surgeons: 59.3%; All physicians: 31.2%; Allergists and immunologists: 7%.Ob-gynsOb-gyns: 62%62%General surgeonsGeneral surgeons: 59.3%59.3%All physiciansAll physicians: 31.2%31.2%Allergists and immunologistsAllergists and immunologists: 7%7%

Source: American Medical Association, 2023[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Ob-gyns62%
General surgeons59.3%
All physicians31.2%
Allergists and immunologists7%

Those patterns show up in intake calls. Birth injuries, surgical complications, missed or delayed diagnoses and medication errors make up much of what firms hear. Build short follow-up question sets for each of those categories, so staff know which dates, providers and records to ask about without improvising.

The screening sequence

  1. Representation and prior reviews

    Ask whether the caller has a lawyer, and whether any other firm has already reviewed and declined the matter. A prior decline is not disqualifying, but the attorney needs to know.

  2. Who, where and when

    The patient's name and age, every provider and facility involved, and the dates of the treatment in question. If the patient died or cannot speak for themselves, capture who is calling and their relationship.

  3. What happened, in the caller's words

    Let them tell it fully once. Then ask what the caller believes went wrong and why they believe it, including anything a provider said afterwards.

  4. The harm

    What injury or change in condition followed, the current condition, further treatment needed, and the effect on work and daily life. Severity drives viability more than any other single factor.

  5. Discovery

    When did the caller first learn or suspect that the treatment caused the harm, and how? Many deadlines turn on this date as well as the treatment date.

  6. Records and goals

    Which records the caller already has, and what they want from the firm: answers, accountability, compensation or all three.

Follow-up questions by claim type

After the core sequence, a short set of category questions gives the attorney what they need for a first look. Keep each set to a handful of factual questions, and let the attorney decide what else to ask at the consultation.

  • Birth injury: where the baby was delivered, the length of labor if known, whether there was an emergency cesarean, the baby's condition and any diagnosis since, and early intervention or therapy received.
  • Surgical complication: the procedure, the surgeon and facility, what the patient was told about risks beforehand, what happened afterwards, and any corrective surgery.
  • Missed or delayed diagnosis: each visit where symptoms were reported, what the provider concluded, when the correct diagnosis was made, and how treatment changed as a result.
  • Medication error: the drug, who prescribed and who dispensed it, the dose given against the dose intended, and the reaction that followed.
  • Care facility: the facility name, how long the patient has lived there, the injury or condition that developed, and whether the family raised concerns with staff before.

Dates and deadlines intake must capture

Malpractice deadlines are complex and vary widely by state. Many states have a limitation period running from the injury or its discovery, an outer limit that applies regardless of discovery, special rules for minors, and shorter windows or extra steps for public hospitals and government providers. Staff should never estimate a deadline. They should capture every date that might matter and flag the matter for attorney review the same day when any date is old.

  • Date of each treatment, procedure or visit in question.
  • Date the caller first noticed the harm, and the date they first suspected it was caused by the care.
  • Whether treatment with the same provider is continuing.
  • The patient's date of birth, since rules for minors often differ.
  • Whether any provider is a public hospital, a government clinic, a military or veterans' facility or a federally funded health center, which can mean a separate claim process with its own deadlines.
  • Any letters already received from a provider, insurer or risk manager.

Records: what to ask for and how to handle them

Records decide malpractice matters, and most firms review them before accepting a case. Ask the caller what they already have, such as discharge summaries, operative reports, imaging reports and patient-portal printouts, and have them upload copies through a secure link. If the attorney approves a records review, the firm sends a signed authorization to each provider.

Treat everything the caller sends as confidential, even before engagement. The State Bar of California's guidance says a lawyer must not input confidential client information into a generative AI tool that may present material risks to confidentiality or security[2]. Apply the same caution to any summarizing tool used on medical records: use only systems the firm has vetted, with appropriate data protections in place.

Screening factors at a glance

Signals that help an attorney prioritize medical malpractice inquiries
FactorStronger signalWeaker signal
HarmPermanent injury, major additional surgery, deathTemporary harm that has fully resolved
CausationClear sequence from the care to the harmUnderlying illness could explain the outcome
Departure from careA provider acknowledged an error, or a known safety step was skippedCaller is unhappy with the result but cannot point to a specific act
TimingRecent treatment or recent discoveryTreatment years ago with no explanation of late discovery
RecordsCaller has key records or can authorize themNo records and no clear provider list
Prior reviewsNo prior reviewSeveral firms have declined after records review

Declining with care

Callers to malpractice firms are often grieving or living with a serious injury. A decline should never feel like a judgment that nothing went wrong. Make the decline call personally where possible, follow it with a letter, and keep the facts confidential. Information from a prospective client can create duties for the firm even when it declines, which is one reason Florida Bar Opinion 24-1 warns that intake tools can create a prospective-client relationship without the lawyer's knowledge[3].

Script: Thank you for trusting us with something so difficult. After reviewing what you shared, our firm is not able to take this matter. That is a decision about our firm and these particular facts, not a judgment about what you went through. Malpractice claims have strict time limits, so if you want another opinion, please contact another lawyer soon. We will send you a letter confirming this today.

Call back promptly and from the firm's main number. Eight in ten Americans say they do not generally answer calls from unknown numbers[4], and a decline that never connects leaves the caller waiting while time runs.

Example: a delayed diagnosis call

Example: a caller says her husband's chest pain was diagnosed as indigestion at an urgent care clinic, and he had a heart attack the next day. He survived with lasting heart damage. Intake records both dates, the clinic name, the hospital that treated the heart attack, the discharge summary she uploads and her note that the hospital cardiologist asked why he had not been sent to the emergency room.

The summary flags a specific act, a short and clear sequence, permanent harm and recent dates. An attorney approves a records review the same week. Whatever the review concludes, the family hears back on the date they were promised.

For the wider injury framework, see personal injury intake questions and red flags. When the patient has died, use the wrongful death intake, and review malpractice risks that start at intake for the firm's own exposure.

Frequently asked questions

Why do law firms decline so many medical malpractice cases?

Viable claims need a departure from the standard of care, clear causation, significant harm and timely filing, and they require costly expert review. Many genuine losses do not meet all of those tests.

What is a certificate of merit?

In many states, a malpractice claim must be supported by a statement from a qualified expert, filed with or soon after the complaint, saying the claim has merit. Requirements vary by state.

Can intake staff tell callers how long they have to file?

No. Malpractice deadlines depend on state law, discovery rules, the patient's age and the type of provider. Staff capture the dates and an attorney gives any deadline advice.

Should we request medical records before accepting a case?

Most malpractice firms review records before accepting. Ask what the caller already has, and send signed authorizations to providers once an attorney approves a review.

References

  1. American Medical Association (2023). AMA: One in three physicians previously sued in their career (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. The State Bar of California, Standing Committee on Professional Responsibility and Conduct (2026). Practical Guidance for the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence in the Practice of Law (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo