ExampleExample scenario. Not a real customer. Figures are modelled from the sources listed.

Case studyCriminal defense: state misdemeanors and felonies, DUI and some juvenile matters

Example: a 3-attorney defense firm sorts its night calls

A modelled scenario: how a fictional 3-attorney defense firm would route arrest calls to the on-call attorney and turn the rest into messages.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing9 min read

On this page
  1. Scenario profile
  2. The firm in this example
  3. What the nights looked like before
  4. How the SI Employee is set up
  5. Before and after, call by call
  6. What the numbers would look like
  7. The first 30 days in this example
  8. Lessons from the scenario
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References

Scenario profile

Business
Example: Ninebark Defense Law (3 attorneys)
Industry
Criminal defense: state misdemeanors and felonies, DUI and some juvenile matters
Size
Two partners and an associate on a weekly on-call rotation, one intake paralegal and an office manager who runs billing
Setting
Office two blocks from the courthouse in a mid-size county seat; most clients pass through the county jail
Call volume
About 140 calls a week, roughly 28 of them after 5:30 pm or at weekends

Key takeaways

  • In this example about six in ten night and weekend calls could wait for the morning, yet every one of them rang the on-call attorney's mobile.
  • The modelled setup puts a call through only when one of three written custody-and-police rules is met, down a three-step attorney tree with a tested fallback.
  • Court dates, payment questions and case status would become messages for the right person; new matters with nobody in custody would get a held consultation slot.
  • Every figure here is modelled from the sources listed, not measured at a real firm.

The firm in this example

Ninebark Defense Law is a fictional firm. Two partners and an associate handle state misdemeanors and felonies, a steady run of DUIs and some juvenile matters in a mid-size county seat. The office, two blocks from the courthouse, is staffed 8:30 am to 5:30 pm on weekdays by an intake paralegal and an office manager who also runs billing.

In this example the firm takes about 140 calls a week. Roughly 28 of them arrive after 5:30 pm or at the weekend, four a day on average and more on Fridays and Saturdays. After hours the main number forwards to whichever attorney holds the on-call phone that week.

Arrests do not keep office hours. Local jails reported 7.9 million admissions in the twelve months to June 2024, more than 21,000 a day[1], and 68% of the people held at midyear 2024 were unconvicted, awaiting court action or held for other reasons[1]. For a defense firm, the frightened relative calling at midnight is often the first chance to be hired.

What the nights looked like before

In this example the managing partner pulls a month of the on-call log and sorts it into two piles. About four in ten calls were the reason the firm keeps a night phone: a son booked into the county jail, a husband asked by a detective to come in and talk, a client picked up on a bench warrant. The other six in ten could have waited: a client checking Thursday's court time, a mother asking whether her card payment went through, a girlfriend wanting a case update, a speeding ticket, sales calls, a wrong number.

Every one of them rang the same mobile. The attorney holding it answered payment questions without the ledger and court-date questions without the file, and once nearly discussed a client's case with a girlfriend the client had never authorized. At the county jail in this example, phones go in a locker during attorney visits, so the hour the on-call attorney spent with a client was when the next arrest call went to voicemail.

In this example, voicemail is where those callers would be lost: a relative who has just heard about an arrest keeps calling firms until a person answers. A callback from the attorney's personal mobile shows up as an unknown number, and in a 2020 Pew survey eight in ten Americans said they don't generally answer those[2].

The weekend is not a pause in the case either. Under County of Riverside v. McLaughlin, a judicial probable cause determination within 48 hours of a warrantless arrest is, as a general matter, prompt enough, and intervening weekends do not excuse a longer wait[3]. Decisions about a Friday night arrest can be made before the office opens on Monday, and in this example a family that reaches nobody on Saturday would hire whichever firm picks up.

How the SI Employee is set up

In the modelled setup an SI Employee answers the main number from 5:30 pm on weekdays and all weekend, in the firm's name. The partners approve the greeting word for word: it says the call is recorded and that the caller is talking to an automated assistant, not a person and not a lawyer. Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1, for one, says a chatbot that talks with clients or third parties must disclose that it is an AI program and not a lawyer or employee of the firm[4].

The partners then write the rules for a live transfer: three questions, asked in order, and a yes to any one puts the call through to the on-call attorney:

  1. Is someone in custody right now: arrested, being booked, or held at a jail or police station?
  2. Do police want to question someone, or are officers serving an arrest or search warrant, before the office reopens?
  3. Has an existing client been told to surrender, or been accused of breaking a release condition, since the office closed?

Anyone who says a person is hurt or in danger is told to call 911 first. Nothing else gets a transfer, however upset the caller sounds.

Example: a 12:40 am call about an arrest
  • Caller
  • SI Employee
  • Your team
  1. 01Caller

    Call at 12:40 am Saturday

    A mother says her son was arrested two hours ago and is at the county jail.

  2. 02SI Employee

    Greeting and disclosures

    Firm name, a recording notice, and that this is an automated assistant, not a lawyer.

  3. 03SI Employee

    Rule one is met

    He is in custody now, so the call qualifies. No questions about what happened.

  4. 04SI Employee

    Takes the logistics

    His name, birth date, jail, booking number, charges as told, names for conflicts.

  5. 05Your team

    On-call attorney takes it

    Transferred live; if no answer, to the backup attorney, then the third.

  6. 06Your team

    Intake reads it Monday

    Summary, recording and transcript are waiting in the firm's account at 8:30 am.

Example: fictional firm and rules. A real setup follows the rules the partners approve.

Example family script, approved word for word by the partners: โ€œI can try the attorney on call for you now. To move quickly I only need a few facts: his full name, his date of birth, where he is being held, the booking number if you have it, and the charges as they were told to you. Please don't tell me what happened, and please don't talk about it with him on the jail phone, because those calls can be recorded. The attorney would represent him, not you, and will explain what that means.โ€

The script exists because the caller is usually not the client. ABA Formal Opinion 506 says a lawyer may train and supervise nonlawyers to handle prospective-client intake, provided the prospective client is always offered the chance to talk with the lawyer, and that a question about which legal services to get goes to the lawyer[5]. So the phone agent collects logistics and the names the firm needs for its own conflict check, and gives no view on whether anyone should talk to the police. The guide to calls from family members and third parties has more wording.

If the on-call attorney does not pick up, the call moves to the backup, then the third attorney. If nobody answers, the caller is told plainly that no attorney has picked up yet, with no promised callback time, and all three are notified with the summary. The firm's on-call rotation decides who holds each step in a given week.

Calls that meet no rule take one of two quieter paths. Court-date questions, payment questions and case-status requests become messages, each with a summary, recording and transcript in the firm's AssistCall account, and the right person is notified: the office manager for money, the attorney on the case for everything else. The phone agent never confirms to anyone whether a person is a client. New matters where nobody is in custody, such as a DUI with a court date three weeks out, get a consultation booked into one of two held slots each weekday morning on the firm's consultation calendar.

Before and after, call by call

Before and after: how night and weekend calls would be handled in this example
Night or weekend callBefore (forwarded to the on-call mobile)After (modelled setup)
Mother at 12:40 am, son booked into the county jailRings the on-call attorney; voicemail if the phone is in a jail locker or on silentCustody rule met, logistics taken, transferred down the three-step attorney tree
A detective wants the caller's husband to come in tomorrowReaches an attorney only if the on-call phone is picked upPolice rule met; transferred live to the on-call attorney before anyone agrees to a time
Client asks at 9 pm what time court is on ThursdayAnswered from memory, without the fileMessage for the attorney on the case, with the hearing date noted
Payment question on a Sunday afternoonOn-call attorney guesses or promises a callbackMessage for the office manager, read on Monday at 8:30
A client's girlfriend asks how the case is goingRisk of discussing the case with someone the client never authorizedNothing confirmed or discussed; message passed to the attorney on the case
DUI summons, court in three weeks, nobody in custodyVoicemail and a callback some time on MondayConsultation booked into a held weekday slot and read back to the caller
Intake paralegal arrives on MondayRebuilds the weekend from voicemails and the attorney's textsReads each call's summary; consultations already on the calendar

In this example the calls and the arrests stay the same; what would change is that six in ten night calls would stop reaching the on-call mobile. The ones that still ring it would have met one of the three rules, with the jail and booking number in the summary once the call ends.

A case management connection is planned, not live, so at 8:30 the intake paralegal copies what matters from each summary into the firm's system by hand, as in handling after-hours messages from existing clients.

What the numbers would look like

The worked example prices the on-call attorney's time on night calls that could have waited, at the 2025 median pay for lawyers of $76.76 an hour[6]. The other inputs are invented for this scenario.

ExampleModelled attorney time spent on night calls that could wait
Example: worked figures
InputExample
Night and weekend calls per day4
Attorney minutes per call12
Share that could wait for the morning60%
Hourly pay of the on-call attorney$76.76
Calls a month87
Staff hours on these calls17
Hours handed off10
Monthly value of that staff time$800

How it is worked out: Calls a day ร— 21.7 working days ร— minutes per call รท 60 ร— share handled = hours; hours ร— hourly cost.

Assumptions

  • Hourly cost of $76.76, the 2025 median pay for lawyers; benefits and night premiums are left out.[6]
  • Most lawyers work full time and some work more than 40 hours a week, so these hours come on top of a full week.[6]
  • Four night and weekend calls a day (28 a week), twelve attorney minutes per call including the text to the office afterwards, and a 60% can-wait share are invented for this example.

Example only, modelled from the inputs above. The calculator counts 21.7 working days a month, so it undercounts nights and weekends.

In this example that is about 10.4 hours a month, roughly $800 at that rate. Counted over all 30.4 days of a month, the same inputs give about 14.6 hours, nearer $1,120. The partners care more about when those hours fall: on whoever holds the phone, sometimes the night before a trial.

The larger number is the one the calculator leaves out. Each arrest call that reaches voicemail is a family deciding, at one in the morning, which firm to trust. From July 2023 to June 2024, people admitted to jail spent an average of 31 days inside before release[1]. The setup would not create arrest calls; it would send each one down a tree of three attorneys instead of to one phone that might be in a jail locker.

The first 30 days in this example

Example: a modelled first month
  1. Day 1

    Partners write the three transfer rules, the family script and the greeting with its disclosures.

  2. Day 3

    Attorney tree set with a fallback; consultation calendar connected with two held morning slots.

  3. Day 5

    Test calls with fictional cases: a booked son, a warrant at the door, a payment question, a caller wanting advice.

  4. Day 7

    Night and weekend calls forward to the new setup; the weekly rotation stays as it was.

  5. Day 14

    Partners review every transfer, and every message that perhaps should have been one.

  6. Day 30

    Partners compare transfers per on-call week, missed transfers and booked consultations with the month before.

Example timeline; a real rollout follows the firm's own schedule.

In this example the managing partner keeps two lists through the first month: transfers an attorney says could have waited, and messages that should have been transfers. The second list matters more. A rule that is too loose costs a night's sleep; one that is too tight costs a client. The emergency escalation rules guide has a monthly review routine for this.

Lessons from the scenario

  • Write the transfer rules as yes-or-no questions about custody and police contact, not about how upset the caller sounds.
  • Approve the family script word for word, including who the client is and what not to discuss on a jail phone.
  • Send money questions to the person who keeps the ledger and case questions to the attorney on the case, not to whoever is on call.
  • Hold real consultation slots for overnight bookings, or the promise of a morning appointment falls apart by Wednesday.
  • Test the three-step attorney tree and its fallback before going live, and again whenever the rotation changes.

The firm keeps its number, its rotation and its attorneys. What it loses is the 11 pm call about whether a payment cleared.

For the intake questions behind the logistics, see criminal defense intake: charges, custody and court dates. For what the product handles on a live call today, see what it does.

Frequently asked questions

Is Ninebark Defense Law a real firm?

No. It is a fictional firm used to show the method, and every figure is modelled from the sources listed or invented for the example.

Does the phone agent give the family legal advice?

No. In this example it takes logistics only, follows the script the partners approved and sends any legal question, such as whether someone should talk to the police, to the attorney. Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1, citing Opinion 88-6, says nonlawyers who run an initial interview must limit questions to facts, give no legal advice and refer legal questions back to the lawyer[4].

What happens if no attorney answers the transfer?

The call moves down the tree: the on-call attorney, the backup, then the third attorney. If nobody picks up, the caller is told plainly that no attorney has answered yet, no callback time is promised, and all three are notified with the summary. See emergency escalation rules for after-hours calls.

Can a relative pay for the defense?

That is a conversation for the attorney. In this example the phone agent notes who expects to pay and passes it on; who pays does not change who the client is. See handling calls from family members and third parties.

Do the night calls go straight into case management?

No. A case management connection is planned, not live. Summaries, recordings and transcripts sit in the firm's AssistCall account and consultations in its consultation calendar; the intake paralegal copies what is needed into case management each morning.

References

  1. U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics (2026). Jail Inmates in 2024 โ€“ Statistical Tables (NCJ 311504) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (1991). County of Riverside v. McLaughlin, 500 U.S. 44 (1991) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2023). Formal Opinion 506: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistants (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  6. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Lawyers (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo