Key takeaways
- Texting is the most widely used smartphone feature, so clients will message lawyers whether or not the firm has a policy.
- CISA notes that ordinary SMS messages are not encrypted and recommends end-to-end encrypted apps for sensitive communication.
- End-to-end encryption protects content in transit, but the firm still needs the record: decide how messages reach the matter file.
- Disappearing messages can conflict with retention duties; CISA itself says to check records retention policies before turning them on for work devices.
- Approve a short list of channels, say what may go in each, and verify identities before acting on messages.
Clients message, so the firm needs a plan
Texting is how many people prefer to communicate. Pew found that 97% of smartphone owners used text messaging during its study period, the most widely used smartphone feature, and that 93% of owners aged 18โ29 also used voice or video calls[1][2]. With 91% of US adults now owning a smartphone[3], clients will send messages to whatever number or app they have for you, about scheduling, documents, and sometimes the facts of their case.
Source: Pew Research Center, 2015[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Used text messaging (all smartphone owners) | 97% |
| Used voice or video calls (owners aged 18โ29) | 93% |
ABA Formal Opinion 477R says different communications require different levels of protection, and that at the start of the relationship the lawyer and client should discuss what level of security each kind of electronic communication about the matter needs[4]. Messaging is where that conversation most often gets skipped.
The practical risks are familiar to anyone who has handled a client's phone in discovery: messages sent to the wrong person by autocomplete, previews visible on a locked screen in a shared home, threads that live only on a lawyer's personal phone, and impostors who message from a new number claiming to be the client. A messaging policy is mostly about preventing these ordinary failures, not exotic interception.
The channels compared
| Channel | Encryption | Firm control and record | Good for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carrier SMS and MMS | Not encrypted, according to CISA | Lives on individual phones; hard to archive | Reminders and 'call me' messages only |
| Consumer end-to-end encrypted app | End-to-end encrypted | Messages on users' devices; limited admin control; export varies | Sensitive conversations where the client already uses it, with a plan for the record |
| Client portal messaging | Set by the vendor; confirm in its security documentation | Stored with the matter; firm controls access and retention | Substantive client communication and documents |
| Business texting service | Varies by vendor | Central record and admin control | High-volume scheduling and status updates |
| Internal team chat | Varies by vendor | Admin control and retention settings | Staff-to-staff coordination; not for clients |
CISA's mobile communications guidance is direct about the first row: SMS messages are not encrypted, and a threat actor with access to a telecommunications provider's network can read intercepted messages[5]. It recommends adopting a messaging application that guarantees end-to-end encryption, such as Signal or similar apps, ideally one that works across iPhone and Android[5].
What to look for in an app
- End-to-end encryption by default for messages, calls and attachments, not only as an option.
- Limited metadata. CISA advises evaluating how an app and its services collect and store metadata that could be used to trace or identify users[5].
- Cross-platform support, so clients on any phone can use it.
- Admin control for firm accounts: who can join, removal of departing staff, device management.
- A way to preserve the record, whether by export, archiving or a workflow that copies substance into the matter file.
- Clear terms: no use of message content for advertising or model training.
No single tool scores well on everything. Consumer encrypted apps are strong on confidentiality and weak on firm control; portals are the reverse for convenience. Many firms use both: the portal for substance, an encrypted app only when a client insists, with a rule for getting the content into the file.
Test the shortlisted app the way clients will use it: install it on an older phone, invite a colleague who has never used it, send a document and try to export the conversation. The friction you hit is the friction clients will hit, and it tells you whether the app will actually be used.
Setting up an encrypted app for firm use
If the firm approves a consumer encrypted app for some client conversations, set it up deliberately rather than letting each lawyer use a personal account:
- Register the account to a firm-controlled phone number, not the lawyer's personal number, so the firm keeps the account if the lawyer leaves.
- Turn on the app's registration lock or PIN, so the number cannot be re-registered on another device without it.
- Review linked devices regularly and remove any you do not recognize; linked desktop sessions are a common way accounts are taken over.
- Hide message previews on the lock screen.
- Keep the app updated, along with the phone's operating system.
Record which matters use the app and who holds the account. That list is what lets the firm find, preserve and produce messages later if it needs to.
Disappearing messages and retention
Encrypted apps often offer disappearing messages, and CISA suggests enabling message expiration to automatically delete sensitive messages[5]. But it adds an important qualifier: for employer-issued devices, verify that applicable records retention policies allow the setting to be enabled[5]. For a law firm, that check matters a great deal. Client communications may be part of the file the client is entitled to, may be needed to show what advice was given, and may be subject to a litigation hold.
Decide what counts as a record
Substantive advice, instructions from the client and anything about deadlines or money belong in the matter file.
Capture before it disappears
If a client sends substance through an app with expiring messages, the lawyer copies it into the file the same day, with date and sender.
Suspend expiry under a hold
When a litigation hold or preservation duty applies, turn expiring messages off for the affected conversations and document that you did.
Keep the policy consistent
Apply the same expiry settings across staff and matters, so the firm cannot be accused of selectively deleting messages.
Agreeing channels with each client
The easiest time to set expectations is the engagement meeting, as Opinion 477R suggests. A short script keeps it consistent:
- We will send appointment reminders by text. Please do not reply with details about your case, because ordinary texts are not encrypted.
- For anything about the facts, documents or decisions, please use the secure portal. I will send you the invitation today.
- If you strongly prefer a messaging app, tell me which one, and we can agree how we will use it.
- If you ever get a message that seems to come from us asking for money or new account details, call our main number before doing anything.
Note the client's choices in the file. If they later send sensitive information by text anyway, reply briefly asking them to use the portal, and copy what they sent into the file.
Rules staff can follow
- Use only the firm's approved channels for client communication; no personal social media messaging.
- Ordinary texts are for scheduling, reminders and 'please call me'. Never send settlement figures, medical details, account numbers or legal advice by SMS.
- Send documents through the portal, not as message attachments.
- Copy any substantive message into the matter file the same day.
- Verify identity before acting. CISA warns about attackers who claim an account is compromised to trick people into handing over control, and advises against scanning group-invitation links or QR codes from unknown sources[5].
- Never act on new payment instructions received by message; call a known number.
- Leave client group chats when the matter closes, and remove departing staff from firm accounts on their last day.
Example: a client who only texts
Example (fictional): a criminal defense client will not use email and texts his lawyer's mobile number at all hours, including details about the charges. At the next meeting, the lawyer explains the risks of ordinary texting and suggests an end-to-end encrypted app. The client agrees. The lawyer sets up a firm-managed account on her work phone, turns off message expiry for this conversation because the matter is in active litigation, and copies the substance of each conversation into the case notes at the end of the day. Scheduling reminders still go by text from the firm's business texting system.
Internal chat is a channel too
Staff-to-staff chat tools hold surprising amounts of client information: quick questions about a matter, screenshots, pasted emails. Apply the same discipline. Use the business edition with admin control, enforce multi-factor sign-in, set retention to match the firm's records policy, and restrict channels so people see only the matters they work on. Guest access for clients or co-counsel should be the exception and should be removed when the matter ends.
Related guides
Device rules for the phones these apps run on are in mobile device policies. Vet messaging vendors with the questionnaire in vendor security reviews. Voice calls raise their own issues, covered in protecting privileged information on phone calls, and how long to keep messages is part of data retention and destruction policies.
Frequently asked questions
Is texting clients a confidentiality problem?
Ordinary SMS is not encrypted, according to CISA, so it suits scheduling and reminders, not substance. Use a portal or an end-to-end encrypted app for sensitive content, and keep a record in the matter file.
Is Signal acceptable for lawyers?
CISA names Signal as an example of an end-to-end encrypted messaging app. Encryption addresses interception; the firm still needs a way to keep the record and must manage disappearing-message settings against its retention duties.
Should law firms use disappearing messages?
Only with care. CISA itself says to check records retention policies first for work devices. Client communications may belong in the file or be subject to a litigation hold.
Can staff use WhatsApp or similar apps with clients?
Only if the firm approves the app, staff use a firm-controlled account, and substantive messages are copied into the matter file. Check the app's terms and metadata practices first.
References
Pew Research Center (2015). U.S. Smartphone Use in 2015 (opens in a new tab) โ
Pew Research Center (2015). U.S. Smartphone Use in 2015 (opens in a new tab) โ
Pew Research Center (2026). Americans' Use of Mobile Devices in 2026 (Mobile Fact Sheet) (opens in a new tab) โ
American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2017). Formal Opinion 477R: Securing Communication of Protected Client Information (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ
Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (2025). Mobile Communications Best Practice Guidance (opens in a new tab) โ