Privacy and Security

Vendor Security Reviews for Law Firm Software

How to review the security of law firm software vendors: risk tiers, the evidence to request, a questionnaire, contract terms and how often to re-check.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why vendor reviews are an ethics duty
  2. Clients are reviewing you the same way
  3. Tier vendors by what they can touch
  4. Evidence worth asking for
  5. A questionnaire for high-tier vendors
  6. Red flags that should stop a review
  7. Put the answers in the contract
  8. Example: reviewing an intake vendor
  9. Keep the reviews current
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Privacy and Security: Vendor Security Reviews for Law Firm SoftwareArticle coverPRIVACY AND SECURITYVendor Security Reviewsfor Law Firm SoftwareAva for LawyersInsightsPrivacy and Security: Vendor Security Reviews for Law Firm SoftwareArticle coverPRIVACY AND SECURITYVendor SecurityReviews for Law FirmSoftwareAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • ABA guidance applies the duty to supervise nonlawyer assistance to technology vendors, so vendor due diligence is an ethics duty, not only good IT practice.
  • Tier vendors by what they can touch; a document system or intake service needs a deeper review than a scheduling widget.
  • Ask for independent evidence such as a SOC 2 Type II report, and read the exceptions, not just the cover letter.
  • Clients are asking firms the same questions: 41% of firms of 10โ€“49 lawyers had been asked for security requirements in the 2023 ABA survey.
  • Put the answers into the contract and re-check each vendor at least once a year.

Why vendor reviews are an ethics duty

ABA Formal Opinion 477R lists due diligence on vendors that provide communication technology as one of its considerations for protecting client information, grounding it in Model Rule 5.3's duty to make reasonable efforts to ensure that nonlawyers' conduct is compatible with the lawyer's obligations[1]. Formal Opinion 512, on generative AI, repeats the factors earlier opinions identified for outsourcing: reference checks and vendor credentials, understanding the vendor's security policies and protocols, familiarity with its hiring practices, confidentiality agreements, understanding its conflicts-checking system, and the availability of a legal forum for relief if the vendor breaches its agreement[2]. It adds that these concepts apply to AI providers as well[2].

That list is a useful reminder that vendor review is not only about encryption settings. It is about whether you can trust this company with your clients' information, and what you can do if it lets you down.

Most US law offices are small enough that one person owns this work, often alongside many other jobs. That is fine, as long as the process is written down, the tiers are clear and the review memos are kept. A consistent, documented process done by one careful person is worth more than an elaborate framework nobody follows.

Clients are reviewing you the same way

Corporate and institutional clients increasingly put their law firms through the same process. In the ABA's 2023 Legal Technology Survey, 27% of respondents said clients had asked for the firm's security requirements or guidelines, and 22% had been asked to complete a security questionnaire[3]. Requests rose sharply with firm size: 9% of solo respondents had been asked for security requirements, compared with 41% at firms of 10โ€“49 lawyers and 59% at firms of 50โ€“99[3].

Firms asked by clients for their security requirements, by firm size (2023)Share of ABA Legal Technology Survey respondents whose clients requested a security requirements document
Firms asked by clients for their security requirements, by firm size (2023)Column chart. Solo: 9%; 2โ€“9: 15%; 10โ€“49: 41%; 50โ€“99: 59%; 100+: 50%.0%20%40%60%Solo: 9%9%Solo2โ€“9: 15%15%2โ€“910โ€“49: 41%41%10โ€“4950โ€“99: 59%59%50โ€“99100+: 50%50%100+Firms asked by clients for their security requirements, by firm size (2023)Column chart. Solo: 9%; 2โ€“9: 15%; 10โ€“49: 41%; 50โ€“99: 59%; 100+: 50%.0%20%40%60%Solo: 9%9%Solo2โ€“9: 15%15%2โ€“910โ€“49: 41%41%10โ€“4950โ€“99: 59%59%50โ€“99100+: 50%50%100+

Source: American Bar Association, Law Practice Division, 2023[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Solo9%
2โ€“915%
10โ€“4941%
50โ€“9959%
100+50%

A firm that reviews its own vendors well can answer client questionnaires faster, because many of the questions are about those same vendors: where data is stored, who can access it and how breaches are reported.

Tier vendors by what they can touch

Not every tool deserves the same effort. Most small firms use dozens of services, from email to e-signature to a scheduling widget. Sort them into tiers so the deep reviews go where the risk is.

Vendor risk tiers for a law firm, by the kind of client data each vendor can reach.
TierExamplesReview depth
HighEmail, document storage, practice management, intake and answering services, e-discovery, backupFull questionnaire, independent evidence, contract review, annual re-check
MediumE-signature, billing and payments, client portal add-ons, transcriptionShort questionnaire, security page and terms review, re-check every two years or on change
LowScheduling widgets, website analytics without personal data, research tools without client dataTerms review and confirmation that no client data goes in

The tier depends on use, not product category. A transcription tool used for internal meeting notes may be low risk; the same tool used for client interviews is high. Review the use, and re-tier when it changes.

Evidence worth asking for

Marketing pages promise 'bank-grade security'. Independent evidence tells you more. For high-tier vendors, ask for:

  • A SOC 2 Type II report, prepared by an independent auditor, which describes the vendor's controls and whether they operated over a period. Read the scope, the dates and any exceptions the auditor noted.
  • An ISO 27001 certificate or similar, if the vendor has one, with its scope.
  • A summary of recent independent penetration testing and how findings were resolved.
  • The vendor's incident history and how it notified customers.
  • Its list of subprocessors, the other companies that handle your data on its behalf.

Small vendors may not have a SOC 2 report. That is not automatically disqualifying, but it shifts more weight onto the questionnaire, the contract and your own testing of settings such as multi-factor sign-in.

A questionnaire for high-tier vendors

  1. What client data will you hold, and where is it stored and backed up?
  2. Is data encrypted in transit and at rest, and who manages the keys?
  3. Which of your staff can access our data, under what circumstances, and is that access logged and reviewable by us?
  4. Can we enforce multi-factor sign-in and single sign-on for our users?
  5. How quickly will you notify us of a security incident affecting our data, and what will the notice include?
  6. Which subprocessors handle our data, and will you tell us before adding new ones?
  7. Do you use customer content to train or improve AI models, and can that be turned off contractually?
  8. How long do you keep our data after deletion or termination, and how do we export everything?
  9. What independent assessments have you completed in the last year?
  10. Do you carry cyber insurance, and what are the limits?
  11. How do you screen and train staff who can access customer data?
  12. Where can we bring a claim if you breach the agreement?

Apply the same questionnaire to every high-tier vendor, including any AI intake or answering service the firm uses, such as Ava. Consistency is what lets you compare answers and show a client or regulator how you decided.

Red flags that should stop a review

Most reviews end with a list of small gaps and fixes. A few answers should stop the process until they are resolved, because they go to whether the vendor can be trusted with confidential information at all:

  • The terms give the vendor broad rights to use, license or sell customer content, and it will not change them for a business customer.
  • The vendor cannot say where data is stored or which other companies process it.
  • There is no way to enforce multi-factor sign-in for the firm's users.
  • The vendor will not commit to telling you about a breach, or only 'as required by law'.
  • You cannot get your data back in a usable form if you leave.
  • The sales team's answers contradict the written terms, and nobody will put the sales answers in writing.

When a vendor is otherwise valuable, look for a different plan or edition. Business and enterprise tiers often carry stronger data terms and admin controls than the version a single lawyer signed up for years ago.

Put the answers in the contract

  1. Confidentiality and use limits

    The vendor may use firm data only to provide the service, may not sell or share it, and must keep it confidential.

  2. Security commitments

    Reference the controls the vendor described, or attach its security documentation, so the promises are enforceable.

  3. Breach notice

    A specific notice period and the content of the notice, so the firm can meet its own duties to clients.

  4. Subprocessor changes

    Advance notice of new subprocessors and a right to object or terminate.

  5. Return and deletion

    Full export in usable formats and certified deletion at the end of the relationship.

  6. Cooperation

    Help with investigations, client audits and legal holds.

Example: reviewing an intake vendor

Example (fictional): a ten-lawyer employment firm plans to move intake calls and web inquiries to an outside service. The office manager tiers it as high. The vendor provides a SOC 2 Type II report; she notices an exception about delayed removal of former employees' access and asks how it was fixed. The vendor confirms that recordings and transcripts are kept for a period the firm sets, that customer content is not used to train models, and that it will notify the firm of incidents within a defined period. Those answers go into the contract. The review memo, two pages long, sits in the vendor file with a re-check date a year out.

Keep the reviews current

Vendors change owners, add features and revise terms. Generative AI adoption is moving quickly: Thomson Reuters Institute data show organization-level adoption of 28% among law firms in 2025[4], and AI features are appearing inside tools firms already use. Re-check high-tier vendors annually and whenever they announce new terms, new AI features or an acquisition.

Related guides: how remote staff use these tools in remote work security, device rules in mobile device policies, messaging tools in secure messaging apps for lawyers, and phone-call confidentiality in protecting privileged information on phone calls.

Frequently asked questions

Do lawyers have an ethical duty to vet software vendors?

ABA guidance applies Model Rule 5.3's supervision duty to outside vendors that handle client information, and lists vendor due diligence among the reasonable efforts lawyers should make to protect confidentiality.

Is a SOC 2 report enough to approve a vendor?

It is strong evidence, but read its scope, dates and exceptions, and still review the contract, data use terms and settings such as multi-factor sign-in.

How often should a law firm review its vendors?

High-risk vendors at least annually and whenever terms, ownership or features change; lower-risk vendors every two years or on change.

What if a small vendor cannot answer a security questionnaire?

Consider whether client data needs to go into the tool at all. If it does, weigh the vendor's contract commitments and your own controls more heavily, or choose a different vendor.

References

  1. American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2017). Formal Opinion 477R: Securing Communication of Protected Client Information (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2024). Formal Opinion 512: Generative Artificial Intelligence Tools (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. American Bar Association, Law Practice Division (2023). 2023 Cybersecurity TechReport (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Thomson Reuters Institute (2025). 2025 GenAI report: Executive summary for legal professionals (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo