Key takeaways
- Privilege can be put at risk by who else hears a call, so confirm who is present on both ends before discussing substance.
- ABA Opinion 498 says client conversations should not be overheard by others in the household and that listening devices should be off.
- Federal law allows one-party consent recording, but states can be stricter; settle the firm's recording rules before anyone presses record.
- Voice-analysis features can trigger biometric laws such as Illinois BIPA, which requires written notice and a release.
- Short scripts at the start of calls make the right habit automatic.
Where phone calls go wrong
Most threats to confidentiality on phone calls are mundane. A client takes the call on speaker in a car with a friend. A paralegal discusses a settlement on a train. A lawyer working from home leaves a smart speaker running. A detailed voicemail lands on a phone the client shares with the person they are divorcing. Each of these can expose information the firm must protect, and some can raise arguments that privilege was waived because a third party was present.
The ethics guidance is clear that the duty travels with the lawyer. ABA Formal Opinion 498 says client-related meetings and information should not be overheard or seen by others in the household, office or other remote location who are not assisting with the representation, both to avoid jeopardizing the attorney-client privilege and to avoid violating the duty of confidentiality[1].
The fix is rarely technology. It is a small set of habits, repeated on every call until they feel routine, and a few decisions the firm makes once: which lines are recorded, what voicemails may say, and where people take sensitive calls.
The home office multiplies the risk
Calls now happen in kitchens and spare bedrooms. In 2025, 35% of employed Americans did some or all of their work at home on days they worked[2]. Home offices are shared spaces, and many contain devices that listen.
- Worked at home on days worked 35%
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2025[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Worked at home on days worked | 35% |
Opinion 498 addresses those devices directly: unless the technology is assisting the lawyer's practice, the lawyer should disable the listening capability of smart speakers, virtual assistants and other listening-enabled devices while communicating about client matters, or risk exposing client information to unnecessary and unauthorized third parties[1]. The simplest firm rule is that no smart speaker sits in the room where client calls are taken.
Situations and habits
| Situation | Risk | Habit |
|---|---|---|
| Client on speaker or in a car | Third parties may hear privileged details | Ask who else can hear; offer to call back when they are alone |
| Family member joins the call | Presence of a third party can affect privilege | Pause and discuss whether they need to be there; note it in the file |
| Interpreter or support person | Usually acceptable when necessary for the advice, but needs care | Confirm their role and confidentiality at the start |
| Lawyer in a public place | Strangers overhear names and facts | Do not discuss substance; step away or call back |
| Home office | Household members and listening devices | Closed door, headset, smart speakers off or out of the room |
| Voicemail | Shared phones and transcribed messages | Leave name, firm and call-back request only |
| Conference lines and video links | Unknown participants join | Use unique links or PINs; ask unidentified participants to announce themselves |
A script for the first minute
Habits stick when they are built into the opening of every call. Adapt this for lawyers and intake staff:
- Before we start, are you somewhere you can talk privately? Is anyone else with you or able to hear the call?
- Is this a good number for us to call and leave messages? Does anyone else have access to this phone or its voicemail?
- If someone else needs to join, let us know first so we can discuss whether that is a good idea for your case.
- If you need to stop or move somewhere private at any point, just say so.
Record the answers in the matter file the first time, and update them if anything changes. For family, employment and criminal matters, treat a 'no' to the second question as a reason to agree a different contact method.
Outbound calls need a mirror-image check. Before discussing anything, confirm you are speaking to the client and not a family member who picked up, an assistant at the client's workplace or someone who has taken over the phone. Use a simple verification question agreed at intake, such as a date of birth or the matter's reference, rather than the details of the case.
Inside the office
Open-plan offices and shared reception areas create the same exposure as a train carriage. Visitors in the waiting room can hear the receptionist confirm appointments, and colleagues from other practice groups can hear details of matters they should be screened from. A few physical changes help more than any policy:
- Seat reception so that calls are not taken within earshot of waiting clients, or add a sound-masking device.
- Give lawyers and paralegals a small room or booth for sensitive calls if offices are shared.
- Do not use speakerphone with the door open, even for internal calls about a matter.
- Where the firm has an ethical screen in place, make sure screened staff are not seated where they will overhear the matter's calls.
- Clear names and phone numbers from visible whiteboards and call sheets at the end of each day.
Walk around the office during a busy hour and listen. What a visitor could overhear in five minutes tells you where to start.
Recording calls: settle the rules first
Many firms record intake lines for quality and accuracy. Federal wiretap law, 18 U.S.C. 2511(2)(d), allows a private party to record a call they are part of, or where one party has consented, unless it is done for a criminal or tortious purpose, but state laws can be stricter[3]. Some states require every party's consent, and callers may be in a different state from the firm.
Decide which lines are recorded
Intake and main lines are common; direct lines to lawyers usually are not.
Announce it
Use a greeting that tells callers the call may be recorded, so consent-based rules are addressed whatever state they are in.
Limit access
Store recordings in a system with access controls, and give access only to the people who need it.
Set retention
Decide how long recordings are kept for inquiries that do not become matters, and delete on schedule.
Treat recordings as confidential
A recording of an intake call can hold as much sensitive detail as a file memo; protect it the same way.
Be more careful with tools that analyze voices. Illinois' Biometric Information Privacy Act defines a voiceprint as a biometric identifier and bars collecting one without first informing the person in writing and getting a written release[4]. Ordinary recording and transcription are different from voice identification, but ask vendors in writing whether their features create voiceprints.
Intake calls and AI answering
Intake calls carry a particular risk: callers often describe their whole situation before anyone has checked for conflicts. Train intake staff, and configure any automated answering, to collect names for the conflict check and a short description, and to tell callers that a lawyer will follow up before they share more. If the firm uses an AI intake service such as Ava, the greeting the firm approves can tell callers they are speaking with the firm's AI assistant and that the call is recorded, so the disclosure is the same on every call.
Whatever handles the call, the same principles from Opinion 477R apply: understand where the information goes and how it is stored, and match the protection to the sensitivity of the information[5].
Review a sample of intake recordings each month. Listen for the moments where callers began to overshare and whether staff steered them back, and use those moments as training material.
Example: a call from the car
Example (fictional): a client in a wrongful termination case calls her lawyer while driving, on the car's speaker system. The lawyer opens with the privacy question and learns the client's brother, a coworker at the same employer, is in the passenger seat. The lawyer explains that discussing the case with him present could cause problems and offers to call back that evening. The client agrees. The lawyer notes the call and the reason for rescheduling in the file. Later, the brother is listed as a witness for the employer, and the lawyer is glad the conversation never happened in front of him.
Building it into practice
- Add the first-minute script to the intake manual and to new-hire training.
- Issue headsets to anyone who takes client calls from home or shared offices.
- Write a voicemail rule and include sample wording.
- Review recording settings, access and retention each year.
Related guides: tools for written messages in secure messaging apps for lawyers, how to vet phone and intake vendors in vendor security reviews, how long recordings should be kept in data retention and destruction policies, and handling health information that comes up on injury intake calls in HIPAA and medical records in injury firms. Defense firms taking calls from detention facilities should also read phone calls from jails.
Frequently asked questions
Does a third party on the call waive attorney-client privilege?
It can, depending on the jurisdiction, who the person is and whether their presence was necessary for the legal advice. The safer practice is to confirm who is present and, where needed, reschedule.
Can a law firm record intake calls?
Federal law allows one-party consent recording, but some states require every party's consent. Announcing the recording in the greeting and setting clear access and retention rules addresses most of the risk.
Should lawyers leave detailed voicemails for clients?
No. Leave your name, firm and a request to call back. Voicemails can be heard or transcribed on shared devices.
Are smart speakers a problem for lawyers working from home?
ABA Opinion 498 says to disable listening-enabled devices during client conversations unless they are assisting the practice. Keeping them out of the work room is simplest.
References
American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2021). Formal Opinion 498: Virtual Practice (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). American Time Use Survey - 2025 Results (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2025). 18 U.S. Code ยง 2511 - Interception and disclosure of wire, oral, or electronic communications prohibited (opens in a new tab) โ
Illinois General Assembly (2025). Biometric Information Privacy Act (740 ILCS 14) (opens in a new tab) โ
American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2017). Formal Opinion 477R: Securing Communication of Protected Client Information (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ