Privacy and Security

Data Retention and Destruction Policies

A law firm retention and destruction policy: client files, trust records, prospective-client data, recordings and backups, and how to destroy media.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why keeping everything is a risk
  2. What the rules require
  3. A retention schedule template
  4. Non-client records are the usual gap
  5. Email and shared drives
  6. Litigation holds come first
  7. Destroying records properly
  8. Putting the policy in place
  9. Example: a first purge
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Privacy and Security: Data Retention and Destruction PoliciesArticle coverPRIVACY AND SECURITYData Retention andDestruction PoliciesAva for LawyersInsightsPrivacy and Security: Data Retention and Destruction PoliciesArticle coverPRIVACY AND SECURITYData Retention andDestruction PoliciesAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Keeping everything forever is not safe: every old file is something to protect, search and possibly report after a breach.
  • ABA Model Rule 1.15 calls for complete trust account records to be kept for five years after the representation ends; states set their own periods.
  • ABA Opinion 483 notes that Rule 1.16(d) has been read to permit data destruction policies, and encourages agreeing file handling with clients.
  • Your schedule must cover non-client records too: inquiries, declined matters, call recordings and chat transcripts.
  • NIST's media sanitization guidance distinguishes clear, purge and destroy; paper can only be destroyed.

Why keeping everything is a risk

Many firms keep every file, email and recording indefinitely because deciding what to destroy feels riskier than keeping it. The opposite is often true. Old files still contain names, Social Security numbers, medical records and financial details, and they are exactly what is exposed in a breach. ABA Formal Opinion 483 points out that because of record retention requirements, information compromised in a breach may belong to former clients as well as current ones[1].

A retention policy is the tool that lets a firm keep what it must, for as long as it must, and then dispose of the rest on a schedule rather than on impulse. For most firms it does not need to be complicated. US law offices are overwhelmingly small: 71.8% had fewer than five employees in 2023[2], and 86.8% had fewer than ten[3]. A one-page schedule that everyone follows beats a binder nobody opens.

US law offices by number of employees (2023, cumulative)Share of law office establishments, Census County Business Patterns
US law offices by number of employees (2023, cumulative)Column chart. Fewer than 5: 71.8%; Fewer than 10: 86.8%; Fewer than 20: 94.2%.0%25%50%75%100%Fewer than 5: 71.8%71.8%Fewer than 5Fewer than 10: 86.8%86.8%Fewer than 10Fewer than 20: 94.2%94.2%Fewer than 20US law offices by number of employees (2023, cumulative)Column chart. Fewer than 5: 71.8%; Fewer than 10: 86.8%; Fewer than 20: 94.2%.0%25%50%75%100%Fewer than 5: 71.8%71.8%Fewer than5Fewer than 10: 86.8%86.8%Fewer than10Fewer than 20: 94.2%94.2%Fewer than20

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2023[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Fewer than 571.8%
Fewer than 1086.8%
Fewer than 2094.2%

What the rules require

Two Model Rules frame the policy. Rule 1.15(a) requires complete records of client trust account funds and other property to be kept and preserved for a period of five years after termination of the representation; the period appears in brackets because each state sets its own[4]. Rule 1.16(d) requires lawyers to surrender papers and property the client is entitled to at the end of a representation.

Opinion 483 adds that Rule 1.16(d) has commonly been understood to include the client's file in whatever form it is held, and has been interpreted as permitting lawyers to establish appropriate data destruction policies to avoid retaining client files and property indefinitely[1]. As a best practice, it encourages lawyers to reach agreement with clients, before or at the end of a representation, about how the file will be handled[1]. Check your state's rules and ethics opinions for minimum periods for client files, special categories such as files involving minors or estate documents, and notice requirements before destruction.

Malpractice carriers often have their own views on how long to keep closed files, because files are the firm's evidence if a former client later sues. Ask your carrier for its guidance and record it alongside the state rule. Where the two differ, the longer period usually wins for files, while personal data that serves neither purpose can go sooner.

A retention schedule template

The periods below are examples to show the structure, not recommendations for any state. Replace each one with the period your jurisdiction, malpractice carrier and practice area require.

Retention schedule structure for a law firm. All periods are fictional examples; set your own.
RecordTriggerRetention (Example)Disposal
Trust account recordsEnd of representationExample: at least the period your state's version of Rule 1.15 setsSecure deletion; shred paper
Closed client filesFile closing letter sentExample: 7 years, longer for minors and estate planningNotice to client; then secure deletion or shredding
Original wills and signed originalsVariesExample: hold until claimed or as state law directsDo not destroy without following state rules
Conflict-check data for inquiriesInquiry receivedExample: indefinitely, in the conflicts system onlyNot destroyed while the firm practices
Full text of declined or abandoned inquiriesDecision not to proceedExample: 12 monthsDeleted from forms, inbox and vendors
Intake call recordings and transcriptsCall dateExample: 90 days unless the caller becomes a clientDeleted in the phone or intake system
Chat transcripts on the websiteChat dateExample: 90 daysVendor retention setting
Marketing listsLast engagementExample: 24 months of inactivityDeleted or anonymized
BackupsBackup dateExample: rolling 90 daysExpire automatically; destroyed media certified

Non-client records are the usual gap

Firms often have a closed-file policy and nothing else. Yet the fastest-growing stores of personal information sit outside client files: web form submissions, intake call recordings, chat transcripts and text threads. Many sit with vendors under default settings that keep data indefinitely.

  • Keep what the conflicts system needs from every inquiry: names of the prospective client and other parties, dates and the matter type.
  • Delete the narrative of declined inquiries on a schedule, from every place it lives.
  • Set retention inside each vendor's admin console, not only in the firm's policy.
  • Include personal phones and messaging apps used for client contact; substance should be copied into the file and the rest allowed to expire under the policy.

Write these rules into the intake procedure as well as the retention policy, so the person handling inquiries knows what to keep and the person running the schedule knows what to delete.

Email and shared drives

Email is where retention policies usually fail. Lawyers keep everything in their mailboxes, including attachments that duplicate the file, personal notes and forwarded threads with former clients. A workable approach has three parts:

  1. File what matters. Substantive emails and attachments are saved to the matter in the practice management or document system, which then becomes the record that the schedule governs.
  2. Expire the rest. Mailbox items older than a set period are deleted automatically unless they have been filed or placed on hold, with a warning period so people can file anything they missed.
  3. Clean shared drives. Folders created outside the document system, often named after clients or staff, are reviewed each year and either moved into the matter or deleted.

Introduce automatic expiry gradually, starting with a long period and shortening it once people trust that filed items are safe. Announce each change in advance and explain why: less old email means less to search, less to protect and less to disclose.

Litigation holds come first

Any destruction schedule must stop when a preservation duty applies, such as a reasonably anticipated claim against the firm, a subpoena, or a client's own dispute where the firm holds relevant records. Build a simple hold process into the policy: who can issue a hold, how it is communicated to staff and vendors, how automatic deletion is suspended for the affected records, and how the hold is released. Record each hold and release with dates.

Test the hold process once. Pick a closed matter, issue a mock hold and check whether automatic deletion actually stops in each system, including email, the phone system's recordings and any vendor that holds copies. Many firms discover that one system has no hold feature at all, which is better learned in a test than in a dispute.

Destroying records properly

Deleting a file or throwing a hard drive in a closet is not destruction. NIST's media sanitization guidelines, revised in September 2025, describe three methods[5]:

  • Clear: logical techniques that protect against simple, non-invasive recovery, such as overwriting through the device's normal interface. Not appropriate for paper[5].
  • Purge: physical or logical techniques that make recovery infeasible using state-of-the-art laboratory techniques while leaving the media potentially reusable[5].
  • Destroy: techniques that make recovery infeasible and leave the media unable to store data again. This is the only method appropriate for hard copy[5].

The NIST guide includes a sample certificate of sanitization[5]. Ask your shredding company and IT disposal vendor for certificates, and keep them with the destruction log. For cloud services, deletion depends on the provider's own processes, so confirm in the contract how and when deleted data and backups are purged.

Putting the policy in place

  1. Inventory record types

    List every category of record and where it lives, including vendors and phones.

  2. Set periods with sources

    For each category, note the governing rule or reason for the period, so later reviewers understand it.

  3. Tell clients

    Add a short file-retention clause to engagement letters and closing letters, explaining how long the firm keeps the file and how the client can request it.

  4. Configure systems

    Set retention in the practice management system, phone system, form tool, chat and backup services.

  5. Destroy on a calendar

    Run destruction once or twice a year, after checking for holds, and log what was destroyed, when and how.

Example: a first purge

Example (fictional): a five-lawyer general practice discovers it holds closed files going back 25 years in a storage unit, plus every web inquiry since 2014 in a shared inbox. It adopts a schedule, sends notice letters to clients whose files are past the retention period with a deadline to collect them, and keeps those with original wills or minors' matters under the special categories. A shredding vendor destroys the rest and issues a certificate. The inbox is cleared of inquiry narratives older than a year after their conflict data is confirmed in the conflicts system. The firm's records, and its exposure, shrink sharply.

Related guides: what to keep from messaging apps in secure messaging apps for lawyers, recordings in protecting privileged information on phone calls, medical records in HIPAA and medical records in injury firms, and teaching staff the policy in security awareness training.

Frequently asked questions

How long must a law firm keep client files?

It depends on your state. ABA Model Rule 1.15 brackets five years for trust account records, and many states set their own periods for files. Check your state's rules and opinions, your malpractice carrier's guidance and any special categories such as minors' matters.

Can a law firm destroy closed client files?

Generally yes, under a written policy that respects the client's right to the file. ABA Opinion 483 notes Rule 1.16(d) has been interpreted to permit data destruction policies and encourages agreeing file handling with clients.

Should we keep records of people who never became clients?

Keep what you need for conflict checking, such as names and dates, and delete the rest of the inquiry on a schedule.

Is deleting files enough to destroy them?

Usually not. NIST guidance describes clear, purge and destroy methods. Use the method that matches the media and the sensitivity, get certificates from vendors, and confirm how cloud providers purge deleted data.

References

  1. American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2018). Formal Opinion 483: Lawyers' Obligations After an Electronic Data Breach or Cyberattack (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023: U.S. detail file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023: U.S. detail file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. American Bar Association (2026). Rule 1.15: Safekeeping Property, ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. National Institute of Standards and Technology (2025). NIST SP 800-88 Rev. 2: Guidelines for Media Sanitization (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo