Ethics and Compliance

Responding to Negative Reviews: ABA Opinion 496

What ABA Formal Opinion 496 allows when a client posts a negative review: what you may say in public, what you may not, and safe reply templates.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. What Opinion 496 decided
  2. Your four options
  3. What you may and may not say
  4. When the poster is not your client
  5. Templates you can adapt
  6. Why the stakes are real
  7. A decision routine
  8. Who handles reviews at the firm
  9. Directories, social media and comment threads
  10. When it becomes a real dispute
  11. Example: a one-star review after a custody case
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References
Ethics and Compliance: Responding to Negative Reviews: ABA Opinion 496Article coverETHICS AND COMPLIANCEResponding to NegativeReviews: ABA Opinion496Ava for LawyersInsightsEthics and Compliance: Responding to Negative Reviews: ABA Opinion 496Article coverETHICS AND COMPLIANCEResponding toNegative Reviews: ABAOpinion 496Ava for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Opinion 496 (January 2021) says a negative online review is not a controversy between lawyer and client, so the self-defense exception to confidentiality does not apply[1].
  • The committee advises lawyers to give serious consideration to not responding at all; if you respond, reveal nothing about the representation[1].
  • Lawyers may ask the website host or search engine to remove a post, and may say it is inaccurate, without disclosing confidential information[1].
  • Reviews matter: 82% of US adults at least sometimes read them before a first purchase[2], so a calm, compliant reply protects the firm better than a rebuttal.

What Opinion 496 decided

In January 2021 the ABA's Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility issued Formal Opinion 496 on responding to online criticism[1]. Its starting point is Model Rule 1.6: a lawyer may not reveal information relating to the representation of a client without informed consent, implied authorization or an exception. The exception lawyers tend to reach for, Rule 1.6(b)(5), allows disclosure to establish a claim or defense in a controversy between the lawyer and the client.

The committee concluded that a negative online review, because of its informal nature, is not a controversy between the lawyer and the client within that exception[1]. So the review does not unlock the file. Whatever the client says publicly, the lawyer's duty of confidentiality is unchanged.

Your four options

Responses to a negative online review that are consistent with ABA Formal Opinion 496.
OptionWhen it fitsLimits
Do not respondMost situations, especially emotional or detailed postsNone; the committee urges serious consideration of this in all cases
Ask the host to remove itFake reviews, posts by non-clients, policy violationsYou may say it is inaccurate, but not disclose confidential information
Short public replyWhen silence would look like indifferenceNo facts about the representation; invite private contact
Private outreachCurrent or former client with a real grievanceTreat it as client communication; do not discuss the review publicly

The committee's advice on the first option is unusually direct: lawyers should give serious consideration to not responding to negative online reviews in all situations[1]. A reply draws attention to the post, keeps it near the top of the page and invites a second round.

What you may and may not say

If you reply to a client or former client, the reply must reveal nothing about the matter. ABA Journal coverage of the opinion offers wording along these lines: “Professional obligations do not allow me to respond as I would wish.”[1] Inviting the person to contact the firm privately is generally acceptable.

  • Do not confirm or deny that the person was a client if that fact is itself confidential.
  • Do not describe what happened in the matter, the result, the fee or the client's conduct.
  • Do not attach or quote documents, emails or messages from the file.
  • Do not threaten legal action to get a review removed; the FTC's rule on reviews bars suppressing reviews through unfounded or groundless legal threats or intimidation[3].
  • Do not post fake positive reviews to bury the negative one.

When the poster is not your client

Some negative reviews come from opposing parties, people the firm declined or people who never contacted the firm at all. The opinion still calls for care: if the poster is not a client or former client, the lawyer must use care not to disclose any information relating to a representation without informed consent[1]. Even saying “we never represented this person” can reveal that the person consulted the firm, which is itself confidential information about a prospective client.

A safer reply is generic: “We take feedback seriously. We cannot find a record that matches this description, and we would welcome a call to understand the concern.” If the post is plainly fake or from a competitor, report it to the platform instead of arguing in public.

Templates you can adapt

Client or former client: “We take all feedback seriously. Our professional obligations do not allow us to respond publicly as we would wish. We would welcome the chance to speak privately; please call our office manager at the number on our website.”

Unknown or non-client poster: “We're sorry to read this. We can't discuss any person's dealings with the firm in public. If you'd like to talk, please contact our office directly.”

Sign replies with the firm's name or a role, not an individual lawyer's name, so a single lawyer is not drawn into an exchange. Keep the reply short; length invites detail.

Why the stakes are real

Prospective clients read reviews. In Pew's research, 82% of US adults at least sometimes read online ratings or reviews before buying something for the first time, including 40% who always or almost always do[2], and the habit is strongest among younger adults: 53% of 18-to-29-year-olds always or almost always read them[4]. They are also skeptical: 48% of review readers say it is often hard to tell whether reviews are truthful[5].

Lawyers start from a low baseline of public trust. Only 20% of Americans rate lawyers' honesty and ethical standards as high or very high, with 46% saying average and 34% low or very low[6]. A defensive reply that reveals client details confirms the worst assumptions; a calm one, or none, lets the firm's other reviews speak.

How Americans rate lawyers' honesty and ethical standards, December 2025
How Americans rate lawyers' honesty and ethical standards, December 2025Stacked bar chart. High or very high: 20%; Average: 46%; Low or very low: 34%.High or very high: 20% (20%)Average: 46% (46%)Low or very low: 34% (34%)How Americans rate lawyers' honesty and ethical standards, December 2025Stacked bar chart. High or very high: 20%; Average: 46%; Low or very low: 34%.High or very high: 20% (20%)Average: 46% (46%)Low or very low: 34% (34%)
  • High or very high 20%
  • Average 46%
  • Low or very low 34%

Source: Gallup, 2025[6]

Show the data
ItemValue
High or very high20%
Average46%
Low or very low34%

A decision routine

  1. Pause

    No reply on the day the review appears. Screenshot it with the date.

  2. Identify

    Check privately whether the poster is a current, former or prospective client, or unknown.

  3. Look for a real problem

    If a client has a genuine grievance, the right response is a private call from a supervising lawyer, not a public post.

  4. Check the platform's rules

    If the post appears fake, is from a non-client or breaks the platform's policy, request removal.

  5. Decide on a public reply

    Default to none. If you reply, use an approved template with no facts.

  6. Log it

    Record the review, the decision, who approved it and any follow-up in a reputation file.

Who handles reviews at the firm

Negative reviews go wrong when the lawyer named in them replies alone, late at night, from a phone. Give the job to one person, often the managing partner or office manager, and require that any public reply be approved by a lawyer who did not work on the matter. Marketing agencies that manage the firm's profiles should be told in writing that they may not reply to negative reviews at all without that approval, and should never draft replies that mention a client's matter.

Set a response window rather than a reflex. Checking new reviews twice a week and deciding within a few days is fast enough for any platform and slow enough to keep emotion out of the reply.

Directories, social media and comment threads

The same confidentiality rule applies wherever the criticism appears: lawyer directories, social media posts, local forums and comments under the firm's own videos. Some of these places invite a fast, conversational reply, which makes them riskier. Use the same templates, move the conversation to a private channel and resist answering follow-up comments. If a post names an opposing party or discusses a pending case, say nothing about the matter at all; anything said in public can end up in front of the court.

When it becomes a real dispute

The analysis changes if the review is part of something larger: a fee dispute, a grievance filed with the bar or a malpractice claim. Those can be controversies in which limited disclosure is permitted, but only in the proceeding and only as reasonably necessary, never in a public reply. If a review is defamatory and causing serious harm, get advice from ethics or defamation counsel before acting, and remember that state versions of Rule 1.6 and state defamation law differ.

Example: a one-star review after a custody case

Example: a fictional family-law firm receives a one-star review from a former client who says the lawyer ignored her calls and lost her case. The associate wants to post call logs showing twelve returned calls. The managing partner says no: the call logs, the result and even the nature of the case are confidential. Instead, she calls the former client privately, listens, and offers to review the bill. The firm posts the short template reply. Two weeks later the former client edits the review to three stars; the firm never discussed the case in public.

The best long-term answer to a negative review is a steady flow of genuine positive ones, obtained within the rules; see asking clients for Google reviews and testimonials and case results in ads.

Frequently asked questions

What does ABA Formal Opinion 496 say?

That lawyers may not reveal client information when responding to online criticism, because a negative review is not a controversy between lawyer and client under Rule 1.6(b)(5). It advises seriously considering not responding at all.

Can a lawyer respond to a bad review at all?

Yes, if the reply reveals no information about the representation. A short statement that professional obligations prevent a full response, with an invitation to talk privately, is the usual approach.

Can I ask Google to remove a negative review?

You may ask the host or search engine to remove a post and say it is inaccurate, without disclosing confidential information. Platforms decide based on their own policies.

What if the reviewer was never our client?

Be careful anyway. Saying the person was never a client can reveal that they consulted the firm. Use a generic reply or report the post to the platform.

References

  1. ABA Journal (2021). Lawyers must use caution when responding to negative online reviews, new ethics opinion says (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews and ratings (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews and ratings (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews and ratings (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Gallup (2025). Nurses Continue to Lead in Honesty and Ethics Ratings (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo