Ethics and Compliance

Testimonials and Case Results in Attorney Ads

How states treat client testimonials and past results in lawyer advertising, from New York disclaimers to Florida conditions, with a checklist.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. The baseline: not false, not misleading
  2. Three ways states regulate
  3. New York: the disclaimer is mandatory
  4. Florida: conditions on results and testimonials
  5. Case results: making them verifiable and fair
  6. Actors, dramatizations and fake testimonials
  7. Websites, social media and video count too
  8. A consent form for testimonials and results
  9. Example: fixing a results billboard
  10. A pre-publication checklist
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Ethics and Compliance: Testimonials and Case Results in Attorney AdsArticle coverETHICS AND COMPLIANCETestimonials and CaseResults in Attorney AdsAva for LawyersInsightsEthics and Compliance: Testimonials and Case Results in Attorney AdsArticle coverETHICS AND COMPLIANCETestimonials and CaseResults in AttorneyAdsAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Every state bars false or misleading lawyer communications; results and testimonials are judged by whether they create unjustified expectations.
  • New York requires ads with client testimonials to carry the disclaimer “Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome”[1].
  • Florida allows past results only if objectively verifiable and sets six conditions on testimonials, including a no-similar-results disclaimer and nothing of value given[2].
  • The FTC's 2024 rule bans fake reviews and testimonials and allows civil penalties against knowing violators[3].

The baseline: not false, not misleading

ABA Model Rule 7.1 prohibits false or misleading communications about a lawyer's services, and its comment explains that even a truthful report of a lawyer's achievements can be misleading if it leads a reasonable person to form an unjustified expectation that the same results could be obtained for them, without reference to the specific facts of their matter. Most states start from that test. What differs is how much they add on top: some rely on the general test, some require set disclaimers and some list detailed conditions.

The commercial stakes explain the attention. Only 20% of Americans rate lawyers' honesty and ethical standards as high or very high[4], below the 29% average across the professions Gallup tracks[5], and 48% of people who read online reviews say it is often hard to tell whether they are truthful[6]. Advertising that overpromises deepens that skepticism; regulators treat it accordingly.

Americans rating honesty and ethical standards high or very high, December 2025
Americans rating honesty and ethical standards high or very high, December 2025Comparison. Average across professions tracked by Gallup: 29%; Lawyers: 20%.29%Average across professions tracked by GallupAverage across professions tracked by Gallup: 29%20%LawyersLawyers: 20%Americans rating honesty and ethical standards high or very high, December 2025Comparison. Average across professions tracked by Gallup: 29%; Lawyers: 20%.29%Average across professions trackedby GallupAverage across professions tracked by Gallup: 29%20%LawyersLawyers: 20%

Source: Gallup, 2025[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Average across professions tracked by Gallup29%
Lawyers20%

Three ways states regulate

How state lawyer advertising rules approach testimonials and past results.
ApproachExampleWhat it means for an ad
General misleading testStates following the Model Rule closelyResults and testimonials allowed if accurate and not likely to create unjustified expectations
Required disclaimerNew YorkTestimonials must carry the exact words “Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome”
Detailed conditionsFloridaPast results must be objectively verifiable; testimonials must meet six listed conditions

Many states also require lawyers to file certain ads with the bar or keep copies for a period, and some review ads before or after they run. Check filing rules in every state where the ad will be seen, not only where the firm is based.

New York: the disclaimer is mandatory

In Ethics Opinion 834, issued December 15, 2009, the New York State Bar Association's ethics committee concluded that an advertisement containing a client testimonial or endorsement must contain the disclaimer in Rule 7.1(e)(3): “Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.” The committee noted that the older standard let the nature of a testimonial decide whether a disclaimer was needed, while the rule now always requires it, and that testimonials must not be false, deceptive or misleading[1].

Use the exact wording, and put it where a reader will see it with the testimonial, not in a footer several screens away. Additional explanation is fine as long as it does not undercut the required words. Confirm the current subsection numbering in New York's rules before printing, since the rules have been amended since 2009.

Florida: conditions on results and testimonials

Florida's Rule 4-7.13 treats references to past results as deceptive and inherently misleading unless the information is objectively verifiable, subject to the rule on potentially misleading advertisements[2]. It also lists testimonials that are prohibited, which together work as a checklist.

  1. The person giving it must be qualified to evaluate what they are praising.
  2. It must be the person's actual experience.
  3. It must represent what the firm's clients generally experience.
  4. The lawyer must not have written or drafted it.
  5. The person must not have been given anything of value for it.
  6. It must include the disclaimer that the prospective client may not obtain the same or similar results[2].

The fourth and fifth conditions connect directly to review programs: a client review the firm wrote for the client, or paid for with a gift, cannot be used as a testimonial in Florida advertising. See asking clients for Google reviews for a program that keeps reviews usable.

Case results: making them verifiable and fair

  • Keep the substantiation: the verdict form, judgment, settlement statement or closing statement for every figure you publish.
  • Say whether a figure is a verdict or a settlement, and whether it was collected; a verdict reduced on appeal is not the number to advertise.
  • Do not present the gross figure as what the client received if fees, costs and liens came out of it.
  • Avoid aggregate claims such as total amounts recovered unless you can document every component.
  • Get the client's informed consent before publishing anything about their matter; results are confidential information, and many settlement agreements forbid disclosure.
  • Add the disclaimer your state requires next to every result, not only on a results page.

Context is what separates an accurate result from a misleading one. A line such as “Settlement for a client injured in a rear-end collision with clear liability and surgery” tells the reader why the number happened. A bare dollar figure invites them to assume it applies to them.

Actors, dramatizations and fake testimonials

Many states require disclosure when an ad uses actors, re-enactments or a spokesperson who is not a lawyer at the firm, and some restrict them entirely. The FTC's 2024 rule on reviews and testimonials adds a federal layer: it bans the sale or purchase of fake reviews and testimonials, and the agency can seek civil penalties against knowing violators[3]. A scripted endorsement presented as a real client's experience fails both sets of rules.

Websites, social media and video count too

Testimonial and results rules are not limited to billboards and television. A results page on the firm's website, a client video on social media, a case win posted on a lawyer's personal account and a sponsored listing on a directory are all communications about the firm's services. Firms often apply careful review to paid ads and none to social posts, which is where most informal results claims appear.

  • Route every post that mentions a result or quotes a client through the same approval as paid ads.
  • Add required disclaimers to video descriptions and on screen, not only on the website.
  • Remind lawyers that posts on personal accounts about firm matters are still subject to the rules.
  • Review old website pages once a year; results and testimonials posted years ago may not meet current rules.

Example consent wording (fictional firm): “I agree that Ridgeway Injury Law may publish the statement below, with my first name and city, on its website and in advertising. I wrote this statement myself and received nothing in return for it. I understand that publishing it shows I was a client of the firm. I may withdraw this consent in writing at any time, and the firm will remove the statement from materials it controls within a reasonable time.”

Keep the signed form with the ad file, together with the substantiation for any result. When the client withdraws consent, record the date and remove the content everywhere the firm controls it, including social media posts and videos.

Example: fixing a results billboard

Example: a fictional personal injury firm plans a billboard reading “$2.4 million for our client” with a client quote, “They got me everything I deserved.” Review finds three problems. The figure is a jury verdict later reduced by the court, the client was paid less after fees and liens, and the quote was drafted by the firm's marketing agency. The firm replaces the figure with a documented settlement described as a settlement, obtains the client's own words with signed consent, and adds the required disclaimer in the states where the billboard will be seen. It files the ad where filing is required and keeps the substantiation file for the retention period.

A pre-publication checklist

  1. Identify the states

    List every state where the ad will run or be seen online, and pull each state's rules on results, testimonials and disclaimers.

  2. Substantiate every claim

    Attach the document that proves each result and the signed consent for each testimonial.

  3. Test for expectations

    Ask whether a reasonable reader would think the result predicts their own outcome; add context if so.

  4. Add required wording

    Insert the exact disclaimers each state requires, placed next to the content they qualify.

  5. File and keep

    File the ad where required, and keep a dated copy with the substantiation for the retention period.

For related rules, see using specialist and expert in lawyer marketing and responding to negative reviews under Opinion 496.

Frequently asked questions

Can lawyers use client testimonials in ads?

In most states, yes, if they are truthful, not misleading and meet any state conditions. New York requires the disclaimer “Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome”, and Florida sets six conditions, including that nothing of value was given.

Can a law firm advertise past case results?

Generally yes, if the results are accurate, verifiable, presented with context and accompanied by any disclaimer your state requires. Florida allows them only when objectively verifiable.

Do we need client consent to publish a result?

Yes. A client's matter is confidential information, so get informed written consent, and check that the settlement agreement does not forbid disclosure.

Can actors appear in law firm ads?

Many states allow it only with a clear disclosure, and some restrict it. A scripted endorsement presented as a real client's experience is misleading and can also breach the FTC's rule on fake testimonials.

References

  1. New York State Bar Association, Committee on Professional Ethics (2009). Ethics Opinion 834: Advertising; testimonials; disclaimers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. The Florida Bar (2026). Rules Regulating The Florida Bar, Chapter 4: Rules of Professional Conduct (Rule 4-7.13, Deceptive and Inherently Misleading Advertisements) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Gallup (2025). Nurses Continue to Lead in Honesty and Ethics Ratings (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Gallup (2025). Nurses Continue to Lead in Honesty and Ethics Ratings (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews and ratings (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo