Key takeaways
- New Jersey's Supreme Court issued preliminary AI guidelines on January 24, 2024, saying the core duties under the Rules of Professional Conduct are unchanged by AI[1].
- New Jersey's rules do not require lawyers to disclose AI use, but AI is no excuse for false, fake or misleading content[1].
- Pennsylvania's joint bar opinion goes further on clients: lawyers must communicate with clients about AI use and its benefits, risks and limits[2].
- A 2026 New Jersey notice encourages written AI policies and supplies a starter template, while warning that a policy is not a safe harbor[3].
Two neighbors, two kinds of guidance
Many firms in the Philadelphia region practice on both sides of the Delaware River, so the differences between New Jersey and Pennsylvania matter day to day. The sources are also different in kind. New Jersey's guidance comes from its Supreme Court, which regulates the bar directly. Pennsylvania's comes from a joint formal opinion of the Pennsylvania Bar Association's Committee on Legal Ethics and Professional Responsibility and the Philadelphia Bar Association's Professional Guidance Committee, which describes itself as advisory only and not binding on the Disciplinary Board or any court[2].
Neither creates new rules. Both apply existing rules on competence, confidentiality, candor and supervision to AI, and both stress that lawyers remain responsible for everything they submit.
New Jersey: the 2024 preliminary guidelines
The New Jersey Supreme Court's Preliminary Guidelines on the Use of Artificial Intelligence by New Jersey Lawyers, dated January 24, 2024, state that the core ethical responsibilities in the Rules of Professional Conduct are unchanged by AI[1]. They then walk through the duties most affected.
- Accuracy and candor: a lawyer who uses AI to prepare pleadings, arguments or evidence remains responsible for their validity. The rules do not require disclosing AI use, but AI is no excuse for false, fake or misleading content[1].
- Misconduct: lawyers may not use AI to manipulate or create evidence, or allow a client to do so[1].
- Confidentiality: lawyers must make reasonable efforts to prevent the inadvertent or unauthorized disclosure of, or access to, information relating to a representation, and are responsible for the security of the AI tools they choose[1].
- Supervision: lawyers who supervise others must ensure their use of AI meets the same obligations.
New Jersey: the 2026 notice on AI policies
On March 30, 2026, the New Jersey courts issued a notice to the bar encouraging attorneys and firms to develop, adopt and periodically update internal policies on AI use as part of maintaining competence and ethical compliance. It notes that many platforms now include embedded or background AI features that may not be obvious to users, and that attorneys remain fully responsible under Rules 1.1, 1.6, 5.1, 5.3 and 3.3[3].
The notice attaches a starter policy template covering purpose, scope, core rules and a review schedule, with options such as every six months or annually. It is explicit that adopting a policy is encouraged but is not a safe harbor: a document alone does not prevent mistakes or confidentiality lapses, and only careful implementation, training, supervision and verification reduce those risks[3].
Pennsylvania: Joint Formal Opinion 2024-200
Pennsylvania's joint opinion, titled Ethical Issues Regarding the Use of Artificial Intelligence, sets out a list of duties in direct language[2].
- Lawyers must ensure AI-generated content is truthful, accurate and based on sound legal reasoning.
- Lawyers must be competent in the AI technology they use and verify the accuracy of every citation.
- Lawyers must not input confidential client information into AI that lacks adequate confidentiality and security protections.
- Lawyers must watch for conflicts of interest that AI use could create.
- Lawyers must communicate with clients about their use of AI, with clear explanations of how tools are used and their possible effect on outcomes.
- Lawyers must ensure AI-related expenses are reasonable and appropriately disclosed to clients.
- Lawyers must keep up with training and continuing education on AI ethics.
The opinion reads Rule 1.4 as requiring the lawyer to inform the client of the benefits, risks and limits of generative AI, and to decide with the client whether its use would serve the client's objectives[2]. Its conclusion is that, with appropriate safeguards, lawyers can use AI consistently with the Pennsylvania rules.
Side by side
| Topic | New Jersey | Pennsylvania |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Supreme Court guidelines (2024) and notice (2026) | Joint opinion of two bar associations (2024), advisory |
| Client communication | Rules do not require disclosing AI use | Must communicate with clients about AI use, benefits, risks and limits |
| Verification | Lawyer responsible for validity of every submission | Must verify accuracy and citations |
| Confidentiality | Reasonable efforts to prevent unauthorized disclosure; responsible for tool security | No confidential input into tools without adequate protections |
| Costs and fees | Not a focus of the guidelines | AI expenses must be reasonable and disclosed |
| Policies | Firms encouraged to adopt and update written AI policies; template provided | Training and continuing education emphasized |
The biggest practical difference is client communication. A firm that follows only New Jersey's minimum could use AI without telling clients. A firm practicing in Pennsylvania should expect to explain its AI use. Firms working in both states can simply adopt Pennsylvania's standard everywhere.
Courts may ask for more
Bar guidance sets the ethical floor, but individual courts and judges can impose their own requirements on filings, such as certifications that citations were checked or that AI use is disclosed. These orders vary by court and by judge, change often and apply regardless of what the state's ethics guidance says. Before filing in any court on either side of the river, check the local rules and the assigned judge's standing orders.
Build the check into the filing checklist rather than relying on memory: a line for โAI disclosure or certification required?โ next to the existing lines for page limits and formatting. When the answer is yes, keep a copy of the certification with the filing and a note of who verified the citations.
Adoption is uneven by firm size
Small firms are writing these policies from a lower base. As of May 3, 2026, the national AI use rate among US businesses was 19.8%, and less than 20% of firms with four or fewer employees reported using AI, compared with 37% of firms with at least 250 employees[4][5]. A Federal Reserve analysis puts adoption in professional, scientific and technical services, the sector that includes law firms, at about 33%[6].
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2026[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| All US businesses (May 3, 2026) | 19.8% |
| Firms with at least 250 employees | 37% |
That gap cuts both ways. Smaller firms have fewer tools to inventory, but often no one assigned to the job. New Jersey's starter template is a practical place to begin because it is short and already organized around the rules the court cited.
Client-facing AI in both states
Neither state's guidance addresses intake tools at length, but the principles transfer directly. An AI that answers calls or chats with prospective clients handles confidential information before any lawyer is involved, so the confidentiality duties apply from the first sentence. Pennsylvania's communication duty points toward telling callers they are speaking with AI. Pennsylvania requires the consent of all parties to record a call, while New Jersey generally allows a participant to record, so a firm answering calls in both states should announce recording at the start of every call.
- Open every AI conversation with a statement that the assistant is AI and not a lawyer.
- Announce recording before any intake question.
- Collect only what the firm needs for a conflict check and callback.
- Route every legal question to a lawyer.
Example: a firm with offices in both states
Example: a fictional six-lawyer firm with offices in Philadelphia and Cherry Hill drafts one AI policy using New Jersey's starter template. It adds Pennsylvania's client communication duty for every matter, so the engagement letter explains which AI tools the firm uses, how output is checked and that only actual time is billed. The firm lists embedded AI features in its email and document software, switches off a meeting summarizer pending review and schedules a policy review every six months. Training is logged for every lawyer and staff member.
A combined policy checklist
Start from the template
Use New Jersey's starter policy structure: purpose, scope, core rules, review schedule.
Add the Pennsylvania duties
Client communication about AI, reasonable and disclosed AI expenses, and ongoing training.
Inventory embedded features
Include AI built into existing software, which the 2026 notice warns may not be obvious.
Set verification rules
Name who checks output and citations before anything is filed or sent.
Review on a schedule
Pick a review interval and keep a record of each review and change.
For nearby guidance, see New York's ethics opinions on AI and Texas Opinion 705; for wording to use with clients, see disclosing AI use.
Frequently asked questions
Does New Jersey require lawyers to disclose AI use?
New Jersey's 2024 preliminary guidelines say the Rules of Professional Conduct do not require lawyers to disclose AI use, but AI use is no excuse for submitting false, fake or misleading content.
What is Pennsylvania Joint Formal Opinion 2024-200?
An advisory opinion by the Pennsylvania Bar Association and Philadelphia Bar Association ethics committees on lawyers' use of AI. It covers accuracy, competence, confidentiality, conflicts, client communication, expenses and training.
Do Pennsylvania lawyers have to tell clients they use AI?
The joint opinion says lawyers must communicate with clients about their use of AI and reads Rule 1.4 as requiring them to explain its benefits, risks and limits.
Is there a template AI policy for law firms in New Jersey?
Yes. A March 30, 2026 notice to the bar attaches a starter AI use policy and encourages firms to adopt and periodically update one, while noting it is not a safe harbor.
References
New Jersey Courts (Supreme Court of New Jersey) (2024). Notice to the Bar: Legal Practice: Preliminary Guidelines on the Use of Artificial Intelligence by New Jersey Lawyers (opens in a new tab) โ
Pennsylvania Bar Association and Philadelphia Bar Association (copy hosted by LawNext) (2024). Joint Formal Opinion 2024-200: Ethical Issues Regarding the Use of Artificial Intelligence (opens in a new tab) โ
New Jersey Courts (2026). Notice to the Bar: Responsible Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Related Technologies: Benefits of AI Policies (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2026). Large Firms With at Least 20 Employees Biggest AI Users (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2026). Large Firms With at Least 20 Employees Biggest AI Users (opens in a new tab) โ
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2026). Monitoring AI Adoption in the U.S. Economy (FEDS Notes) (opens in a new tab) โ