Key takeaways
- Asking former clients for a Google review is permitted; New York's bar said in 2025 that a nominal gift is acceptable if the lawyer does not draft the review or tie the gift to its content[1].
- Google's policy is stricter: it bans incentives for posting any review and bans selectively soliciting positive reviews[2].
- The FTC's 2024 rule bars fake reviews and incentives conditioned on a review expressing a particular sentiment[3][4].
- Reviews shape choices: 53% of adults aged 18 to 29 always or almost always read reviews before a first purchase[5].
The short answer
Lawyers may ask clients to review the firm online. The ethics questions are about how: whether anything of value is offered, who writes the review, which clients are asked, and whether the request exposes a client's confidential information. Three sets of rules apply at once, and they do not say the same thing. Professional conduct rules set one limit, the review platform's own policy sets another, and the Federal Trade Commission's rule on reviews sets a third. A compliant program meets the strictest of the three.
What a 2025 New York opinion allows
In NYSBA Ethics Opinion 1286, dated September 29, 2025, the New York State Bar Association's ethics committee considered a lawyer who wanted to ask former clients for Google reviews. It concluded that a lawyer may ask a former client to post a review and may offer a nominal gift for doing so, as long as the lawyer does not draft the review and does not condition the gift on its content[1]. The committee treated the request as a communication to a former client rather than an advertisement, and reminded lawyers not to use a former client's confidential information to that client's disadvantage.
The committee also flagged a risk to the client: review platforms typically require user accounts that may be subpoenaed in investigations or proceedings, so a former client's interests may be placed at risk in some circumstances by leaving a review[1]. It left compliance with FTC endorsement guidance aside as a question of law beyond its jurisdiction.
Google's policy is stricter than the ethics opinion
Google's prohibited and restricted content policy for user contributions bans reviews or ratings that have been paid for, directly or in kind, and bans offering incentives, such as payment, discounts, free goods or services, in exchange for posting any review. It also prohibits businesses from discouraging or prohibiting negative reviews or selectively soliciting positive reviews from customers, and treats current or former employment as a conflict of interest[2].
So the gift that New York's ethics committee would permit is still a breach of the platform's policy, and reviews obtained that way can be removed. For Google reviews, the practical rule is simple: no incentives of any kind, and ask every eligible client in the same way rather than only the happy ones.
The FTC rule on reviews
The FTC's final rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, announced August 14, 2024, bans the sale or purchase of fake reviews and lets the agency seek civil penalties against knowing violators[3]. It prohibits businesses from providing compensation or other incentives conditioned on the writing of consumer reviews expressing a particular sentiment, positive or negative, and bars suppressing reviews through groundless legal threats or intimidation[4]. It also covers reviews by company insiders that do not disclose their connection to the business.
- Staff, their relatives and the lawyers themselves should not review the firm.
- Never offer anything in return for a five-star review, or ask for a particular rating.
- Never threaten a client with legal action over an honest negative review.
Practices compared across the three sets of rules
| Practice | Ethics rules | Google policy | FTC rule | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Asking every former client for an honest review | Permitted | Permitted | Permitted | Do it |
| Asking only clients who seemed happy | Not addressed directly | Prohibited (selective solicitation) | Risky if it misleads | Do not |
| Small gift for any review | Permitted in New York if not tied to content | Prohibited | Prohibited if tied to sentiment | Do not |
| Drafting the review for the client | Prohibited in New York | Not genuine | Fake review risk | Do not |
| Staff reviewing the firm | Misleading | Conflict of interest | Insider review without disclosure | Do not |
| Reposting reviews in ads | Testimonial rules apply | Not addressed | Must not misrepresent | Check state rules first |
Reviews that become advertising
A review on Google is the client's statement. Once the firm copies it into its website, social media or ads, it becomes the firm's testimonial and the state's advertising rules apply. Florida, for example, prohibits testimonials in lawyer advertising that the person is unqualified to evaluate, that are not their actual experience, that are not representative of what clients generally experience, that were written by the lawyer, that were given in exchange for something of value, or that lack a disclaimer that the prospective client may not obtain the same or similar results[6]. Our guide to testimonials and case results covers other states.
Current clients and the rule on paying for recommendations
New York's opinion addressed former clients. Asking a current client is more delicate. The client depends on the firm's work, may feel unable to say no and may not yet know how the matter will end, so a request mid-matter can feel like pressure. Wait until the matter closes unless the client raises it first.
Incentives raise a second issue under the advertising rules. ABA Model Rule 7.2(b) generally bars giving anything of value to a person for recommending the lawyer's services, with narrow exceptions, and states apply their own versions. Whether a gift for a review counts as paying for a recommendation is exactly the kind of question opinions answer differently, which is another reason to keep incentives out of the program entirely.
Replying to positive reviews
Thanking a reviewer seems harmless, but the same confidentiality duty applies to praise as to criticism. A reply that says “we were glad to win your custody hearing” confirms the person was a client and reveals the matter. Keep thanks generic: “Thank you for taking the time to share your experience.” Do not add details the client left out, and do not reply at all if the review itself discloses sensitive facts; instead, consider contacting the client privately to suggest editing it.
Why reviews deserve the care
For many prospective clients, reviews are the first evidence they look at. 82% of US adults at least sometimes read online ratings or reviews before buying something for the first time, and 40% always or almost always do[7]. The share who always or almost always read them is 53% among 18-to-29-year-olds and 47% among 30-to-49-year-olds[5].
Those readers are also alert to manipulation, which is one more reason to keep the program clean: a page of genuine reviews with a few honest complaints, answered politely, is more persuasive than a wall of identical praise.
When and how to ask
Choose the moment
Ask after the matter is closed and the disengagement letter has gone out, not while the client is still waiting on a result.
Ask everyone the same way
Send the request to every eligible former client, whatever the outcome, so you are not selectively soliciting positive reviews.
Warn about privacy
Tell clients that a public review shows they used a lawyer, and that they should not include details of their matter.
Make it easy, not scripted
Send a direct link to the review form. Do not suggest wording, ratings or topics.
Offer nothing in return
No gifts, discounts or entries into prize draws, whatever an ethics opinion allows.
Skip sensitive matters
Consider not asking at all in matters where being identified as a client could harm the person, such as criminal, immigration or domestic violence cases.
Email template: “Thank you for trusting Maple Street Law with your matter. If you are willing, we would appreciate an honest review of your experience on Google: [link]. Please don't include details about your case, since reviews are public. There is no obligation, and our relationship is not affected either way.” Maple Street Law is fictional.
Example: fixing a review program
Example: a fictional bankruptcy firm's marketing agency had been texting clients a review link with a five-star graphic and offering a coffee gift card to anyone who posted. Staff had also been asked to leave reviews. The firm stops the gift cards, removes the star graphic, asks staff to delete their reviews and switches to the email template above, sent to every client after discharge. It decides not to ask clients in matters involving creditor harassment, where being identified publicly could cause them trouble. Review volume dips for two months, then recovers with reviews that are more detailed and more credible.
When the occasional negative review arrives, follow the confidentiality limits in Opinion 496.
Frequently asked questions
Can lawyers ask clients for Google reviews?
Yes. Asking former clients for honest reviews is generally permitted. Do not draft reviews, ask for a rating, offer incentives or ask only clients you expect to be positive.
Can a law firm offer a gift for a review?
New York's ethics committee said in 2025 that a nominal gift is permitted if it is not tied to the review's content. Google's policy bans incentives for any review, so for Google reviews the safe answer is no.
Can staff or family members review the firm?
No. Google treats current or former employment as a conflict of interest, and the FTC rule covers undisclosed insider reviews.
Can we use client reviews in our advertising?
Once reposted, they become testimonials and state advertising rules apply, including any required disclaimers. Check your state before using them.
References
New York State Bar Association, Committee on Professional Ethics (2025). Ethics Opinion 1286: Requesting former clients to write Google reviews (opens in a new tab) ↑
Google (2026). Prohibited and restricted content (Maps user contributed content policy) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews and ratings (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Florida Bar (2026). Rules Regulating The Florida Bar, Chapter 4: Rules of Professional Conduct (Rule 4-7.13, Deceptive and Inherently Misleading Advertisements) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews and ratings (opens in a new tab) ↑