Key takeaways
- At intake, "value" means fit, urgency, complexity and economics for the firm, not a prediction of what the caller will win.
- Ask for facts that signal value (dates, injuries, assets, documents) and never evaluate them aloud[1].
- Use the same questions every time so the attorney can compare inquiries; for estate planning, age is a strong signal, since 75%+ of Americans 65 and older have a will versus 20% of under-30s[2][3].
- Sort each inquiry into a priority tier for attorney review, and record why.
What "case value" means at first contact
Firms need to know early which inquiries deserve an attorney's time today, which can wait for a standard consultation and which belong elsewhere. That is what intake staff mean by case value. It is not a forecast of a settlement, a verdict or a result, and it should never be presented to the caller as one.
Four things drive it, and each can be revealed by factual questions:
- Fit: is the matter in a practice area and jurisdiction the firm handles?
- Urgency: is there a deadline, a hearing or a risk that grows with delay?
- Complexity: how many parties, documents and issues are involved?
- Economics: for contingency matters, the facts that affect whether the case is viable; for hourly and flat-fee matters, whether the scope fits a fee arrangement the caller can accept.
The rule for staff is simple. Florida Ethics Opinion 88-6, which the Florida Bar cites for intake, says nonlawyers conducting an initial interview should limit questions to factual information, give no legal advice and refer legal questions to the lawyer[1]. Ask, record and route. The attorney evaluates.
Signals by matter type
| Matter type | Value signals | Red flags for the attorney |
|---|---|---|
| Vehicle injury | Date, medical treatment, other driver identified, police report, insurance details | Incident long ago, no treatment, caller at fault by their own account |
| Workplace injury | Employer, date, reported to employer, medical care, time off work | Not reported, independent-contractor status unclear |
| Family law | Children, property, income, existing orders, hearing dates | Other party already a firm client or prospect |
| Estate planning | Age, family structure, property, business interests, existing documents | Capacity concerns, pressure from a relative |
| Bankruptcy | Type of debts, income, assets, pending lawsuits or garnishments | Recent large transfers, prior filings |
| Employment | Dates of employment and termination, documents, complaints made | Release already signed |
Injury and workplace matters
Volume is large and the signals are well known. NHTSA estimates 39,345 people died in US motor vehicle traffic crashes in 2024[4], and private employers reported 2.5 million nonfatal workplace injuries and illnesses that year[5]. Most inquiries are about non-fatal injuries, and intake needs to separate the strong from the thin quickly.
- "When did this happen?" Dates drive deadlines and urgency. Record the exact date.
- "Did you get medical care, and are you still being treated?" Treatment shows injury and often indicates complexity.
- "Do you know who the other driver was, and was a police report made?" Identification and documentation matter.
- "Has an insurance company contacted you or asked for a statement?" Insurer contact is an urgency signal.
- For work injuries: "Did you report it to your employer, and when?" and "Have you missed work because of it?"
Do not ask "Whose fault was it?" Ask what happened, in order, and let the attorney draw conclusions.
Family law matters
Volume is steady: 672,502 divorces were recorded in 2023 across 45 reporting states and DC[6]. Complexity varies enormously, and intake can reveal it with neutral questions.
- "Are there children under 18, and how many?"
- "Is there property you own together, such as a home, a business or retirement accounts?"
- "Are there any existing court orders, or any court dates coming up?"
- "Is anyone's safety a concern right now?" (Always ask; route by the safety rule if yes.)
- "What is the other person's full name?" This goes to conflicts before anything else.
Estate planning and probate
For planning work, the caller's age and family structure are strong signals of scope and urgency. Gallup found that 46% of US adults have a will, ranging from 20% of adults under 30 to just over three-quarters of those 65 and older[7][3][2].
Source: Gallup, 2021[7]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Under 30 | 20% |
| All adults | 46% |
| 65 and older | 75% |
- "Are you planning ahead, or has someone passed away or become unable to manage their affairs?" Planning and probate are different matters with different urgency.
- "Do you already have a will or trust, and roughly when was it made?"
- "Do you own a home, a business or property in more than one state?" Each adds scope.
- "Is anyone helping you make this call or these decisions?" Listen for signs that a relative is directing the conversation; the attorney may need to speak with the client alone.
Bankruptcy and debt
Filings are rising: Chapter 7 filings reached 382,161 and Chapter 13 filings 215,490 in the year ending June 30, 2026[8]. Callers are often under immediate pressure, and the value signals are mostly about urgency and type of debt.
- "Is anything happening right now, such as a garnishment, a foreclosure date, a lawsuit or a repossession?"
- "What kinds of debt are involved: credit cards, medical bills, taxes, a mortgage, a business loan?"
- "Have you filed for bankruptcy before? If so, roughly when?"
- "Is the debt personal, from a business, or both?"
Employment matters
Employment inquiries turn on dates and documents more than most. The signals are when the job ended, what the caller was told, and what is already in writing.
- "When did you start, and when did the job end or the problem begin?"
- "Did you complain to anyone at work about this before it happened? When, and how: in writing or verbally?"
- "Have you been offered or signed anything since, such as a separation agreement or a release?" A signed release is a red flag the attorney must see first.
- "Do you have any documents: offer letter, emails, performance reviews, the termination notice?"
Mistakes that distort value at intake
- Leading questions. "So they were speeding, right?" puts words in the caller's mouth and produces notes the attorney cannot trust.
- Judging by tone. A calm caller can have an urgent matter; a distressed one may not. Use the urgency questions, not instinct.
- Stopping at the first strong signal. A serious injury with a signed release is a different inquiry from a serious injury without one. Finish the question set.
- Free-text notes. "Good case, call back" tells the attorney nothing. Record the facts that made it look good.
- Different questions from different staff. If one person always asks about insurance and another never does, the firm cannot compare inquiries or learn from them.
Turning answers into a priority tier
Tier 1: same day
Fits the practice and jurisdiction, and has an urgency signal (deadline, hearing, insurer pressure, foreclosure date, safety). Route to an attorney today.
Tier 2: standard consultation
Fits, no urgency signal, enough facts to evaluate. Book the next available consultation.
Tier 3: attorney review before booking
Fit or viability unclear, or a red flag from the table. Summarize and send to an attorney to decide within one business day.
Tier 4: refer or decline
Outside practice or jurisdiction. Decline politely with a specific referral, using attorney-approved wording.
Record the tier and the reason in a structured field, not in free text. Over time this lets the firm see which signals actually predicted signed matters, and adjust the questions.
When the caller asks "What's my case worth?"
"That's the question everyone has, and it's a good one. I'm not a lawyer, so I can't give you a number, and honestly nobody can until an attorney has looked at the details. What I can do is get the right facts to the attorney now so that your consultation can focus on exactly that. Can I ask you a few more questions?"
This answer is honest, keeps the caller engaged and avoids two traps: a number that becomes an expectation, and a brush-off that sounds like the firm is not interested.
Example: A fictional caller says she was rear-ended three weeks ago, has been in physical therapy since, knows the other driver's name and has a police report number, and the other driver's insurer has asked her for a recorded statement. The coordinator records each fact, runs the other driver's name for conflicts, marks the inquiry Tier 1 because of the statement request, and the injury attorney calls back within the hour. Nobody told her what the case was worth.
For the fee side of this conversation, see explaining fees during intake. For the step after triage, see converting intake calls into booked consultations.
Frequently asked questions
Can intake staff tell a caller what their case is worth?
No. They collect facts that signal value, such as dates, treatment, parties and documents, and pass them to an attorney. Any view on value comes from the attorney.
What questions reveal case value in an injury inquiry?
When it happened, what medical care the caller received, whether the other party is identified, whether a police or incident report exists, and whether an insurer has made contact.
How should a firm prioritize inquiries?
Use tiers: same-day for fitting matters with urgency signals, standard consultations for fitting matters without urgency, attorney review for unclear ones, and referral or decline for matters outside the practice.
Why record the reason for a tier?
So the firm can later see which signals predicted signed matters and refine the questions, and so any attorney picking up the inquiry understands the decision.
References
The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ
Gallup (2021). How Many Americans Have a Will? (opens in a new tab) โ
Gallup (2021). How Many Americans Have a Will? (opens in a new tab) โ
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (2024). Early Estimate of Motor Vehicle Traffic Fatalities in 2024 (DOT HS 813 710) (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2024). Employer-Reported Workplace Injuries and Illnesses, 2024 (opens in a new tab) โ
CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2023). FastStats: Marriage and Divorce (opens in a new tab) โ
Gallup (2021). How Many Americans Have a Will? (opens in a new tab) โ
United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts) (2026). Bankruptcies Rise 12.2 Percent (opens in a new tab) โ