Key takeaways
- Let the caller tell the story of the attack, then move to the property: who controls it, what had happened there before and which protections were missing.
- Fewer than half of violent victimizations were reported to police in 2024[1]; record why a caller has no report instead of ending the call.
- Ask about lighting, locks, gates, cameras and guards on the night, and treat camera locations as urgent because footage is overwritten.
- Where a statute lists security measures, as Florida's does for apartment owners[2], mirror that list in the intake form.
A crime victim calling about a property
The person on the line was robbed in a parking garage, assaulted in an apartment stairwell or attacked outside a bar, and the first thing they want to talk about is the attacker. That is natural, and it is rarely where the civil case lives. A negligent security claim looks at whether the owner or manager of the place failed to take reasonable steps against a crime it should have seen coming. Intake has to listen to the story of the attack and then move the conversation, gently, to the property: who controls it, what had happened there before, and what protections were or weren't in place.
These calls never really stop. The National Crime Victimization Survey counted 6.7 million violent victimizations of people age 12 or older in 2024, about 3.1 million of them committed by strangers[1]. Only 47.9% of violent victimizations were reported to police that year, and the share varied widely by type of crime[1]. A caller with no police report is ordinary, so intake records why there isn't one rather than treating it as a reason to stop.
Rape and sexual assault had the lowest reporting rate in 2024, at 23.6%[1]. A caller in that situation may be telling someone for the first time. The trauma-informed client service approach, with as few retellings as possible and no push for detail on a first call, belongs in this script more than almost any other.
Where it happened and who controls the place
Pin the location down precisely: the street address, the building or level, the exact spot (stairwell, laundry room, parking row, elevator, pool gate, the hallway outside a unit) and the time. Then ask why the caller was there. A tenant, a hotel guest, a shopper, a delivery driver and someone cutting through the lot stand in very different positions, and a caller who was working at the time may also raise a workers' compensation question the attorney needs to see.
| Property type | Who may control security | Questions to add |
|---|---|---|
| Apartment complex | Owner, management company, security contractor, association for common areas | Gate and door access, lock and key history, crime notices to residents, maintenance requests |
| Hotel or motel | Owner, franchisee, management company, security contractor | Key card access, night desk staffing, whether staff were warned about a threat |
| Store, mall or gas station | Tenant business, landlord for common areas and the lot, security contractor | Inside or in the lot, guards on duty, what the clerk did |
| Bar, club or venue | Operator, landlord, event promoter, door staff contractor | Door staff, ID checks, an earlier fight broken up that night, calls to police |
| Parking garage or lot | Owner, parking operator, neighboring business that uses it | Lighting, cameras, attendants, call boxes, broken gates or barriers |
Ask for anything that names the business: a lease, a hotel folio, a parking receipt, a card statement line, a photo of the sign at the entrance. Owners, managers and contractors are often separate companies with similar names. Every one of those names also goes into the firm's conflict check before the caller tells the full story.
What the property knew: prior incidents
Whether the crime was foreseeable often sits at the center of these cases, and the facts behind it are things the caller may already know. Ask what they had seen or heard before the attack: earlier robberies, break-ins or fights at the same property, police cars in the lot, notices taped to the lobby door, complaints in a residents' group chat, a broken gate reported to management weeks before. Ask whether the caller or neighbors told anyone, when, and whether there is an email, text, portal request or letter.
- Earlier crimes at the property or next door, roughly when, and how the caller knows about them.
- Complaints the caller or others made about locks, lights, gates, cameras or guards, and who received them.
- Written warnings from the property: a crime alert, a notice to residents, a sign about recent incidents.
- Online reviews or posts mentioning safety, with links or screenshots if the caller has them.
- Whether staff knew this attacker beforehand: an earlier threat, a banned patron, a former tenant, an evicted guest.
Write down what the caller knows and how they know it. Secondhand information is fine at intake. The attorney separates rumor from evidence later, and much of what callers mention, such as earlier police visits, can be checked against public call records.
Lighting, locks, cameras and guards
Next come the conditions on the night. Lighting deserves its own question because callers remember it and researchers have tested it: in a randomized experiment in New York City public housing, adding temporary street lights led to at least a 36% reduction in nighttime outdoor index crimes[3]. A caller who says 'that corner has been dark since the summer' has given the attorney something worth checking.
- Lighting: which lights were out, for how long, and whether anyone had reported them.
- Doors, gates and locks: propped open, broken, missing a closer, a gate code unchanged for years, keys handed out freely.
- Cameras: where they are, whether they looked like they worked, and which business might hold the footage.
- Guards or attendants: on duty or not, where they were, whether anyone responded, the company name on the uniform.
- Access: whether the attacker was a resident, a guest or a stranger, and how they got in.
Some states now write security expectations into statute. Florida gives a multifamily property owner a presumption against liability for third-party crimes if it substantially implements listed measures, among them cameras at entry and exit points with footage retrievable for at least 30 days, parking lot lighting averaging at least 1.8 foot-candles or lit from dusk to dawn, a deadbolt of at least one inch on each unit door, and a crime prevention assessment no more than three years old; the owner carries the burden of proving it did so[2]. Where a statute like that applies, mirror its list in the intake questions so the attorney can see at once which items are in dispute.
That 30-day figure is also why camera questions are urgent. Systems overwrite footage on a cycle, and under the federal rules a party that fails to take reasonable steps to preserve electronically stored information once litigation is anticipated can face court measures, including an adverse presumption where there was intent to deprive[4]. Intake doesn't send preservation letters. It gets the attorney the camera locations and the business names quickly enough to send them.
The police report and the criminal case
- Police: which agency responded, the report or incident number, the officer's or detective's name, and whether the caller has a copy.
- Arrest: whether anyone was arrested or identified, and the criminal case number if charges were filed.
- No report: if police were not called, or the caller chose not to report, the reason in the caller's own words.
- Medical care: ambulance or not, which emergency room, admitted or released, and injuries described in the caller's words.
- Witnesses: names and numbers of anyone who saw it or came to help, including staff, guards and other residents.
Some callers worry that a civil claim will interfere with the prosecution, or they have been asked to testify. Note it for the attorney and stay out of the criminal process. If the caller describes continuing danger, such as an attacker who lives in the same building, switch to the firm's safety wording and urgent routing before finishing the intake.
Dates and state rules
Record the date of the attack, the state, and the dates of any earlier complaints to management. Limitation periods for negligence differ by state and change over time; Florida's is now two years for an action founded on negligence[5]. Intake never tells a caller how long they have. It captures the dates and flags anything close, using the firm's rules for screening limitation deadlines. If the person attacked has died, the call moves to the firm's wrongful death intake script.
Running the call when the office is closed
- Caller
- SI Employee
- System
- Your team
01Caller
Caller phones at 11 pm
Robbed on level 3 of a hotel garage two nights ago; calling from home.
02SI Employee
Lawyer and conflict check
Already represented? Names of the hotel, garage operator and attacker if known.
03SI Employee
Place and conditions
Exact spot, lights out, gate broken, cameras seen, guard on duty or not.
04SI Employee
Police and injuries
Report number, any arrest, ER visit, injuries in the caller's words.
05System
Urgent flag
Footage may be overwritten soon, so the call is marked urgent.
06Your team
Attorney decides next step
Reads the summary and recording first thing; decides on preservation letters.
Example sequence. The attorney decides which answers count as urgent and who is alerted.
Victims often phone the night they get home from the hospital, or the following evening once the shock wears off. Firms are not always there to answer: in Clio's 2024 secret-shopper study of 500 law firms, 48% neither answered the phone nor returned the call[6]. With footage on a short loop, a voicemail heard on Monday can cost the one recording that showed the broken gate.
Scripts for the hard moments
When the caller keeps returning to the attacker: 'I'm so sorry that happened to you. The police deal with the person who did it. I'd like to ask about the building and the lot now, because that's the part the attorney will be looking at for you.'
When the caller is embarrassed they didn't report it: 'A lot of people don't, for all sorts of reasons. Can you tell me why, in your own words? I'll write it down exactly as you say it.'
When the caller asks whether the owner will have to pay: 'That's a question for the attorney once they've seen the details. The most useful thing right now is getting them the cameras, the lighting and the police report number quickly.'
Example: one call, start to finish
Example (fictional): a 29-year-old resident of a 200-unit complex calls on a Sunday evening. She was pulled from her car and robbed in the complex's lot on Friday night. Intake records the parking row, that three lot lights near her building had been out for about six weeks, that she reported them through the resident portal in early October, that the vehicle gate had been stuck open since the summer, and that residents received a notice about car break-ins in September. She has a police report number and was treated in the emergency room for a fractured wrist. The summary flags the leasing office camera facing the lot as urgent, and on Monday morning the attorney decides on preservation letters before the footage cycles.
An SI Employee can take that Sunday call when the firm forwards its line, ask the firm's approved negligent security questions in order, collect the conflict-check names first, send an urgent footage flag down the firm's escalation tree and leave the recording, transcript and summary for the attorney (see what it does). The solo injury lawyer example models how much of a small firm's volume lands outside office hours. Premises cases with no crime involved use the slip and fall screening script instead, and the viability questions every injury call shares are in personal injury intake questions and red flags.
Frequently asked questions
Can there be a negligent security case without a police report?
Intake shouldn't rule it out. Only 47.9% of violent victimizations were reported to police in 2024[1]. Record why there is no report, along with any medical records and witnesses, and let the attorney decide.
Why does intake ask about earlier crimes at the property?
Because what the owner knew, or should have known, is often central to these claims. Callers frequently know about earlier incidents, complaints or warning notices, and writing them down on the first call saves the attorney weeks.
How quickly can camera footage disappear?
It depends on the system, which is why intake treats it as urgent. For comparison, Florida's statute for apartment owners seeking its presumption requires entry and exit footage to stay retrievable for at least 30 days[2]. Get the camera locations and business names to the attorney the same day or the next morning.
What if the attacker was another tenant or an employee?
Record the relationship, anything the caller reported about that person beforehand, and whether management knew. The attorney decides what that means for the claim and which parties are involved.
Should intake ask whether the caller had been drinking?
Ask neutral questions the same way on every call and record the answers exactly. How fault is shared depends on state law, and that analysis belongs to the attorney, not the intake team.
References
Bureau of Justice Statistics (2025). Criminal Victimization, 2024 (NCJ 310547) (opens in a new tab) โ
The Florida Senate (2024). Florida Statutes 768.0706: Multifamily residential property safety and security; presumption against liability (opens in a new tab) โ
National Bureau of Economic Research (2019). Reducing Crime Through Environmental Design: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment of Street Lighting in New York City (Working Paper 25798) (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). Rule 37. Failure to Make Disclosures or to Cooperate in Discovery; Sanctions (opens in a new tab) โ
The Florida Senate (2024). Florida Statutes 95.11: Limitations other than for the recovery of real property (opens in a new tab) โ
Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism (2Civility) (2024). Phone Calls Ignored, Emails Unanswered: Fixing the First Impression Problem for Law Firms (opens in a new tab) โ