Key takeaways
- The center's agents speak for your firm. Under rules like New York's Rule 5.3, a lawyer answers for nonlawyers the firm retains[2].
- Pay for work performed, not for signed clients. New York's Rule 7.2(a) bars paying anyone to obtain employment by a client[3].
- Ask for proof before the first live call: a sample consent record, three recorded calls, a completed authorization and a duplicate-check report.
- Campaign volume can collapse within a year[1], so the contract needs ramp-down, data return and audit terms from day one.
Why vetting matters more than the rate card
Most firms choose a mass tort intake center the week a campaign launches, from a rate card and a sales deck. That order is backwards. The center's agents will speak to thousands of people in your firm's name, collect health information and signatures for you, and decide in the first few minutes who gets a file and who gets turned away. Every one of those calls lands on your license, not theirs.
The volume also moves faster than most contracts allow for. In the 12 months to March 31, 2024, 57,600 earplug MDL cases were filed in the Northern District of Florida; in the following 12 months, 93 were[1]. The same court terminated 248,823 cases in that second year, most of them from the same litigation, and federal civil filings nationally fell 22%[1]. A center staffed for the peak of one litigation will look for the next one, and your callers' data goes with it unless the contract says otherwise.
Source: United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts), 2025[1]
Show the data
| Period | Cases filed |
|---|---|
| Year to March 2024 | 57,600 |
| Year to March 2025 | 93 |
There is rarely only one campaign running. The panel that assigns federal multidistrict litigation listed 65 products liability litigations among 164 pending MDL dockets in its November 2026 summary[4]. Intake centers that serve this market usually run several of those at once, often for several firms. That is the context for every question below.
Who answers for what the agents say
Start with responsibility, because it shapes everything else. New York's Rule 5.3 makes a lawyer responsible for the conduct of a nonlawyer employed or retained by or associated with the lawyer when the lawyer orders or ratifies it, or when a lawyer with managerial or supervisory authority knows or should have known about it and fails to take reasonable remedial action[2]. Most states have a version of that rule. A vendor agreement does not move the obligation; it only tells you how much visibility you have. The general framework is in supervising nonlawyer staff and vendors under Rule 5.3.
Then look hard at how the center is paid. New York's Rule 7.2(a) says a lawyer shall not compensate or give anything of value to a person or organization to recommend or obtain employment by a client[3]. A fee that is only earned when a caller signs a retainer is the structure to question first. Hourly rates, per-minute rates and fees per completed screen tie payment to work performed whether or not anyone signs. Bonuses for agents based on sign-ups raise the same issue one level down. The wider analysis of vendor payment models is in paying for leads: Model Rule 7.2 and lead generation.
Put this question in writing to every center you shortlist: does any part of your fee, or any agent's pay, depend on whether a caller signs with our firm? If the answer is yes, have your ethics counsel review the structure before anything else.
The qualification script: who writes it, who changes it
Your firm writes the criteria; the center follows them. That sounds obvious until you see a center's standard tier 1 script, built for the litigation in general and shared across clients. Ask for a script built from your dated criteria sheet, approved by the responsible attorney, with a change log that shows who changed what and when. If you have not written one yet, start with case acceptance criteria your staff can apply.
- Script ownership. Who drafts it, who approves changes, and how fast a change reaches every agent on every shift.
- Words agents never say. No telling callers they qualify for compensation, no estimates of what a case is worth, no promises about timelines.
- Represented callers. The script asks early whether the caller already has a lawyer or has signed with another firm for this claim, and stops the fact interview if so.
- Disclosures. Agents say who they are calling for and that they are not lawyers, in wording your firm approves.
- Escalation. A written list of situations that go straight to an attorney, such as a deceased claimant, a caller in distress or a filing deadline the caller mentions.
- Declines. A short, consistent decline for callers who do not fit, so nobody hears that they have no case.
Records retrieval and authorizations
Records drive mass tort files, and authorizations collected badly at scale come back rejected at scale. Under HIPAA, a valid authorization has to describe the information, name who may disclose it and who may receive it, state the purpose, give an expiration date or event, and carry the signature and date; it is not valid if any required element is left blank or the expiration has passed[5]. Ask the center for three completed sample authorizations from a live campaign, with personal details removed, and check them against that list yourself.
Then ask about the chase. Providers must act on a patient's request for access within 30 days, with one extension of no more than 30 days[6]. A center that offers records retrieval should be able to show you its follow-up schedule, how it logs each request and response, and what it does when a provider stalls past the deadline. For the intake side of this work, see medical records authorizations at injury intake.
| Area | What to ask for | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
| Script control | Your dated criteria sheet turned into their script, plus a change log | One generic script shared across all firms |
| Fees | Hourly, per-minute or per-completed-screen pricing in writing | Fee or agent bonus earned only when a caller signs |
| Consent records | One real consent record with timestamp, page and exact wording | "We have consent for all our leads" with nothing to show |
| Authorizations | Three completed samples with personal details removed | Blank purpose or expiration fields |
| Duplicates and fraud | A weekly duplicate report across your files and theirs | No answer on whether they work for competing firms |
| Recordings | Every call recorded, searchable, available to you on request | Recordings kept a short time or only on dispute |
| Exit | Data returned in a usable format, then deleted with written confirmation | Callers' data reused for other clients |
Consent records and outbound calls
Many campaigns run on web forms the center calls back, and a vendor's consent problem becomes the firm's problem the moment someone dials. The TCPA lets a person recover $500 per violation, and a court may triple that for willful or knowing violations[7]. The FCC's one-to-one consent rule was vacated by the Eleventh Circuit in January 2025[8], which removes one requirement but not the need for valid consent. People can revoke consent by any reasonable method, and the caller must honor it within ten business days[9], so ask how an opt-out given to the center's agent reaches your own systems, and the reverse.
Recordkeeping is a good test of seriousness. If the center places telemarketing calls, the FTC's Telemarketing Sales Rule requires records including call detail records and records of consent to be kept for five years[10]. Ask to see that the center keeps them, and write your right to receive them into the contract. The firm-side rules are covered in TCPA rules for law firms that call and text leads.
Fraud and duplicate checks
Volume attracts bad claims: people recruited and paid to sign, claimants who signed with two firms, and stories copied from an ad. A center that cannot describe its checks is passing that risk straight to you.
- Duplicate matching on name, date of birth and phone before a file opens, against your existing files and the center's own records for your firm.
- Pattern checks: the same callback number or email on several claimants, near-identical narratives, many form submissions from one device.
- Proof of use or exposure requested before sign-up where the criteria require it: pharmacy records, product packaging, implant cards.
- A firm rule that nobody, at the center or the firm, gives callers money, gifts or gift cards for signing.
- A written firewall if the center works for other firms on the same litigation: separate agents, separate data, and a duty to tell you when a caller has already signed elsewhere.
Callers who reach several firms in one week are common in any campaign. The firm's own process for spotting them is in handling duplicate inquiries and repeat callers; the center's process should feed into it, not replace it.
Audit rights and the exit clause
Run a capped pilot
One week, a fixed number of calls and one attorney reviewing every file the center opens before you widen the flow.
Sample recordings every week
Pull a random set of recordings plus every escalation and score them against the criteria sheet. Send findings in writing and expect the script fix to be dated.
Place your own test calls
Unannounced calls with scripted scenarios: a represented caller, an out-of-criteria caller, a family member of a deceased claimant. The method is in testing your answering service with test calls.
Read the monthly report against your own numbers
Calls received, screens completed, declines, escalations and authorizations returned, reconciled to what actually arrived in your files.
Agree the exit before you start
Data returned in a format your systems can import, deletion confirmed in writing, a ban on reusing your callers' details, and a notice period that fits a campaign that can end in weeks.
- Caller
- Your team
- System
01Caller
Caller responds to ad
Calls the campaign number or submits a form showing your approved consent wording.
02Your team
Tier 1 screen
Center agent asks your dated criteria. No value talk, no promises.
03System
Duplicate and conflict check
Name, date of birth and phone matched against your files before a file opens.
04Your team
Authorization collected
Every required field complete; expiration and purpose filled in.
05Your team
Attorney decides
A lawyer accepts the file or sends a written decline.
06Your team
Weekly audit
Sampled recordings scored against criteria; script fixes dated.
Example sequence. The center's steps and the firm's checks should be visible in the same file.
Price your in-house option honestly
A center's quote only means something next to what the same work costs your own team. Count the tier 1 screens your staff would handle, the minutes each takes including notes, and a realistic hourly cost. Customer service representatives in the industry group that includes call centers earned a mean $18.83 an hour in May 2025[11], but wages are not the whole cost: total employer compensation for office and administrative support workers averaged $36.73 per hour worked in June 2026[12]. Use the higher figure if you would hire for the campaign.
| Input | Example |
|---|---|
| Campaign calls per day | 80 |
| Minutes per tier 1 screen, notes included | 12 |
| Share your own team would screen | 70% |
| Hourly wage of a screener | $18.83 |
| Calls a month | 1,736 |
| Staff hours on these calls | 347 |
| Hours handed off | 243 |
| Monthly value of that staff time | $4,576 |
How it is worked out: Calls a day × 21.7 working days × minutes per call ÷ 60 × share handled = hours; hours × hourly cost.
Assumptions
- Hourly wage is the May 2025 mean for customer service representatives in business support services.[11]
- Total compensation including benefits runs much higher; office and administrative support averaged $36.73 per hour worked in June 2026.[12]
- Call volume, screen length and in-house share are invented for this example. Use your own campaign forecast.
Example only. Change the inputs to your forecast before comparing any vendor quote.
Add the hours an attorney spends reviewing files, the supervision time for whoever audits the center, and the cost of reworking rejected authorizations. A cheaper center that sends back files your attorney has to redo is not cheaper. The quality controls that keep in-house screening honest are in mass tort intake: screening volume without losing quality.
Where your own phone line fits
Plenty of firms use a center for the campaign number and still lose callers on their own line: the person who saw the ad, wrote down the firm's main number and calls at 8 pm on a Sunday. An SI Employee can answer that line when you forward it after hours or on overflow, ask the same approved tier 1 questions, take the names you need for the conflict check, and route urgent calls down your escalation tree. Each call arrives with a summary, a recording and a transcript, which gives you the same audit trail you would demand from a center (see what it does).
The same principle runs through the example of a solo injury lawyer's after-hours intake: the questions are the firm's, the record is complete, and the decision stays with the attorney. Whoever answers the phone, vet them on those three points before you look at the price.
Frequently asked questions
Can we pay a mass tort intake center a fee for each signed client?
Check your state's rules and get ethics advice first. New York's Rule 7.2(a) bars giving anything of value to a person to obtain employment by a client[3], which is why many firms pay by the hour, the minute or the completed screen instead.
Who owns the recordings and caller data?
Whatever the contract says, so write it down: the firm owns caller data and recordings, can request them at any time, and receives them in a usable format at the end, followed by written confirmation of deletion.
Should the center's agents tell callers whether they qualify?
No. Agents apply the firm's criteria and pass files to an attorney. Telling a caller they qualify, or what a claim is worth, is a decision for a lawyer and a promise the firm may not be able to keep.
How many recordings should we review each week?
Enough to see every agent and every script branch. A common approach is a fixed random sample plus every escalation and every complaint, scored against the criteria sheet, with findings sent to the center in writing.
Is it a problem if the center also works for competing firms?
Not by itself, but it needs a written firewall: separate agents and data for each firm, and a duty to tell you when a caller has already signed elsewhere so the file is not opened twice.
References
United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts) (2025). Federal Judicial Caseload Statistics 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 22 NYCRR 1200.5.3: Lawyer's responsibility for conduct of nonlawyers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 22 NYCRR 1200.7.2: Payment for referrals (opens in a new tab) ↑
United States Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation (2026). MDL Statistics Report - Docket Type Summary (November 2, 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 45 CFR § 164.508 - Uses and disclosures for which an authorization is required (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 45 CFR § 164.524 - Access of individuals to protected health information (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 47 U.S. Code § 227 - Restrictions on use of telephone equipment (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit (2025). Insurance Marketing Coalition Ltd. v. FCC (11th Cir. January 24, 2025) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (Office of the Federal Register) (2026). 47 CFR 64.1200: Delivery restrictions (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 16 CFR § 310.5 - Recordkeeping requirements (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics: customer service representatives in business support services, May 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, June 2026 (Table 4) (opens in a new tab) ↑