Key takeaways
- Lawyers may not pay anyone for recommending them, but may pay the reasonable costs of permitted advertising[1].
- The ABA comment allows paying lead generators if they do not recommend the lawyer, the payment fits the fee-division and independence rules, and their communications are not misleading[2].
- Payment tied to a share of legal fees runs into the bar on sharing fees with nonlawyers[3]; check your state before agreeing to any per-case or percentage model.
- Audit what the vendor actually says to consumers, including reviews and any AI claims[4][5].
Why lead generation exists
Many people do not know how to find a lawyer. In the Legal Services Corporation's research, 73% of higher-income Americans were confident they could find and afford a lawyer if they needed one, compared with 45% of low-income Americans[6]. Lead generators fill that gap with comparison sites, case-evaluation forms and call lines that route inquiries to firms. For a firm, buying leads can be a sensible marketing channel. It is also one of the areas where bar discipline and malpractice risk concentrate, because the vendor's words become the firm's words.
Source: Legal Services Corporation, 2022[6]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Low-income | 45% |
| Higher-income | 73% |
What Rule 7.2 says
ABA Model Rule 7.2(b) starts with a prohibition: a lawyer shall not compensate, give or promise anything of value to a person for recommending the lawyer's services[1]. It then lists exceptions. A lawyer may pay the reasonable costs of advertisements or communications permitted by the rule; pay the usual charges of a legal service plan or a not-for-profit or qualified lawyer referral service; pay for a law practice under Rule 1.17; enter a non-exclusive reciprocal referral agreement with another lawyer or nonlawyer professional if the client is told about it; and give nominal gifts of appreciation that are neither intended nor reasonably expected to be compensation for recommendations[1].
Paragraph (d) adds a practical requirement: any communication made under the rule must include the name and contact information of at least one lawyer or law firm responsible for its content[1]. A vendor page that promotes your firm without saying who is responsible for it is a problem in its own right.
The lead generator comment, line by line
The ABA's commentary addresses lead generation directly. A lawyer may pay others for generating client leads, including internet-based leads, as long as three conditions hold[2]:
- The lead generator does not recommend the lawyer. A recommendation, in the commentary's terms, is a communication that endorses or vouches for a lawyer's credentials, abilities, competence, character or other professional qualities[2].
- Any payment to the lead generator is consistent with Rule 1.5(e) on division of fees and Rule 5.4 on the lawyer's professional independence[2].
- The lead generator's communications are consistent with Rule 7.1, the rule against false or misleading communications[2].
The comment then gets specific. A lawyer must not pay a lead generator that states, implies or creates a reasonable impression that it is recommending the lawyer, is making the referral without payment from the lawyer, or has analyzed a person's legal problems when deciding which lawyer gets the referral[2]. Those three phrases are the core of any vendor review.
Directories, group ads and referral services
Not every paid placement is a lead generator. The ABA commentary says directory listings and group advertisements that list lawyers by practice area, without more, are not impermissible recommendations[2]. A paid listing in a legal directory, or a shared advertisement for several family law firms in a county, is usually just advertising. The analysis changes when the directory adds badges, rankings or language that vouches for particular lawyers, so read what the listing actually says about you.
Lawyer referral services are treated differently again. The Model Rule permits paying the usual charges of a not-for-profit or qualified lawyer referral service[1], and states define which services qualify. A for-profit company that calls itself a referral service is not automatically a qualified one. Ask which approval or registration it holds in your state before you assume the referral-service exception applies.
- Directory listing by practice area: generally advertising.
- Directory badge such as recommended or top lawyer: may be a recommendation.
- Qualified lawyer referral service: usual charges permitted, if it meets your state's definition.
- For-profit matching service: analyze it as a lead generator.
Payment models compared
| Payment model | How it works | Main ethics question |
|---|---|---|
| Flat fee per lead | A set amount for each inquiry delivered | Usually treated as an advertising cost; check the vendor's wording |
| Pay per click or per call | A set amount per click or connected call | Similar to advertising; confirm the vendor does not vouch for you |
| Monthly subscription | Fixed fee for placement or a lead volume | Generally an advertising cost if no recommendation is made |
| Per signed case | Payment only when a lead hires the firm | May look like payment for a recommendation; state views differ |
| Percentage of the fee | Vendor receives a share of fees from the matter | Runs into the bar on sharing legal fees with nonlawyers |
The fee-sharing rule is direct: a lawyer or law firm shall not share legal fees with a nonlawyer, subject to narrow exceptions that do not cover marketing vendors[3]. A contract that pays a vendor a percentage of fees from each case it sends is fee sharing under another name. Per-case payments sit in a gray zone, and some states treat them as payment for recommendations; read your state's opinions before signing one.
Vendor due diligence checklist
Read every consumer-facing page and script
Look for words like best, top-rated, recommended, matched to the right lawyer or free referral. Any of these may imply a recommendation or that the vendor is not being paid.
Ask how leads are routed
If the vendor claims to evaluate the person's case before choosing a lawyer, that is the analyzed-legal-problems issue the ABA comment flags[2].
Check the reviews and testimonials
The FTC's 2024 final rule bans the sale or purchase of fake reviews and lets the agency seek civil penalties against knowing violators[4]. Ask where any reviews shown alongside your firm come from.
Check any AI claims
The FTC finalized an order in 2025 requiring DoNotPay, which marketed itself as a robot lawyer, to pay $193,000 and barring it from claiming its service performs like a real lawyer without evidence[5]. Vendors that promise AI case evaluation deserve the same scrutiny.
Confirm consent for calls and texts
If the vendor or your firm will call or text leads, ask how consent was captured and get a copy of the wording.
Confirm the responsible-lawyer statement
Communications promoting your firm should name at least one lawyer or firm responsible for the content[1].
Rewriting a problem landing page
| Vendor wording | Problem | Safer alternative |
|---|---|---|
| We'll match you with the best injury lawyer for your case | Implies a recommendation and case analysis | Submit your details and a participating law firm may contact you |
| Free, no-obligation referral | Implies the vendor is not paid by the lawyer | This is an advertising service paid for by participating law firms |
| Our experts review your case | Implies analysis of the legal problem | Participating firms decide whether they can help |
| Top-rated attorneys near you | Unsubstantiated quality claim | Law firms that advertise in your area |
Put the wording you need into the contract. Require the vendor to submit any change to consumer-facing content for your approval, to keep records of consent and to stop using your name immediately on request.
Supervising the relationship
- Assign one lawyer to own each vendor relationship and review its content quarterly.
- Test the funnel yourself: submit an inquiry and record exactly what the vendor says and sends.
- Track complaints from leads about how they were contacted.
- Keep invoices that show payment is for advertising or leads, not tied to fees earned.
- End the relationship promptly if the vendor will not fix problem wording.
The ABA comment also points back to the rules on responsibility for nonlawyers and on violating the rules through the acts of another[2]. A vendor's sales language does not shield the firm; it is attributed to the firm.
Example: a per-case offer
Example (fictional): a vendor offers a two-lawyer personal injury firm a deal in which the firm pays nothing upfront and the vendor receives a fixed amount whenever a lead signs a retainer. The vendor's site says it connects injured people with the right lawyer after a free case review. The firm's managing partner reads the ABA comment and her state's opinions.
She concludes that right lawyer and free case review imply both a recommendation and an analysis of the person's legal problem, and that payment only on signed cases looks like paying for a recommendation under her state's guidance. She declines the per-case model and instead buys a flat-fee-per-lead package from a different vendor whose pages describe themselves as advertising paid for by participating firms.
Related guides
Following up with purchased leads raises solicitation questions covered in Rule 7.3 solicitation limits on intake follow-up. Payments between lawyers are a separate topic: see referral fees and fee splitting between lawyers. For the broader framework, read attorney advertising rules: Model Rules 7.1 to 7.3. This article is general information, not legal advice.
Frequently asked questions
Can a lawyer pay for leads?
Under the ABA Model Rule comment, yes, if the lead generator does not recommend the lawyer, the payment is consistent with the fee-division and professional-independence rules, and the generator's communications are not false or misleading.
Can a law firm pay a marketing company a percentage of fees?
Generally no. Rule 5.4 bars sharing legal fees with nonlawyers, and a percentage-of-fee arrangement with a vendor is likely to be treated as fee sharing.
Is pay-per-signed-case lead generation allowed?
State views differ. Some treat payment only on signed cases as payment for a recommendation. Check your state's rules and ethics opinions before agreeing to it.
What wording should a lead vendor avoid?
Language that implies a recommendation, that the referral is free or unpaid, or that the vendor analyzed the person's case, such as best lawyer for your case, free referral or our experts review your claim.
References
American Bar Association (2026). Rule 7.2: Communications Concerning a Lawyer's Services: Specific Rules, ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ
American Bar Association (2025). Comment on Rule 7.2, ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ
American Bar Association (2026). Rule 5.4: Professional Independence of a Lawyer, ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Trade Commission (2025). FTC Finalizes Order with DoNotPay That Prohibits Deceptive 'AI Lawyer' Claims (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) โ