Key takeaways
- Write criteria as accept, refer and decline rules, plus one escalate rule for anything staff cannot decide.
- Build the rules from your own past decisions: review recent inquiries and write down why each was taken or turned away.
- Revisit criteria when demand shifts; bankruptcy filings rose 12.2% in the year to June 2026[1].
- A good referral is part of the policy: low-income Americans get no or not enough help for 92% of serious civil legal problems[2].
Why criteria live in partners' heads
In most firms, the decision to take a case is made by feel. A partner hears a summary and says yes, no or "let me think about it". That works when the partner hears every inquiry. It stops working when staff screen first, when the partner is in court, or when the firm grows past the point where one person's instinct can cover every call.
Unwritten criteria cause three problems. Staff book consultations for matters the attorney will never take, wasting both sides' time. They turn away matters the attorney would have wanted. And prospective clients get different answers depending on who picks up the phone. Written criteria fix all three, and they make the firm's decisions easier to explain.
The four outcomes every criterion leads to
Each rule in the policy should end in one of four outcomes. Keep the list short so staff never have to invent a fifth.
- Accept for consultation: the matter meets the criteria; book it.
- Refer: the matter needs a lawyer but not this firm; give a named referral.
- Decline: the matter does not meet the criteria and there is no useful referral; decline politely with a general pointer, such as the state bar referral service.
- Escalate: staff cannot tell, or the matter is in a listed gray zone; an attorney decides, usually the same day.
The escalate outcome is what keeps the policy safe. Staff are never asked to make a judgment call the policy has not already made for them.
What the criteria should cover
| Criterion | Accept when | Refer when | Decline or escalate when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Practice area and sub-type | Matter is on the firm's list of handled sub-types | It is a legal matter the firm does not handle | Unclear category: escalate |
| Jurisdiction | State and county where firm attorneys are admitted and practice | Outside the firm's states | Federal or multi-state matter: escalate |
| Conflicts | Search is clear | Conflict found: refer elsewhere | Possible conflict or common name: escalate |
| Timing | Enough time before any deadline to prepare | Deadline too close for the firm's capacity | Any deadline within the urgent window: escalate now |
| Client goal | Goal is one the firm's services can address | Goal needs a different kind of service | Goal unclear after questioning: book or escalate |
| Capacity | Assigned attorney has consultation slots this week | Firm is not taking this sub-type this quarter | Capacity limit near: escalate |
Criteria should be things staff can check from facts given at intake. "Strong liability" is not something a screener can assess. "Accident happened within the last two years in one of our six counties, and the caller or a family member received medical treatment" is. Keep the merits for the attorney; give staff observable facts.
Extracting rules from partner judgment
Partners usually know their criteria better than they think. The quickest way to get them on paper is to look at recent decisions, not to start from a blank page.
Pull recent inquiries
Export the last 50 to 100 inquiries from your intake log, with the outcome and a one-line reason if you have one.
Sort by outcome
Group them into accepted, referred, declined and lost (no decision recorded).
Ask why, matter by matter
Sit with the deciding attorney for an hour and ask, for each declined or referred matter, what fact drove the decision. Write the fact down in plain words.
Find the patterns
Most reasons repeat: wrong county, too small for the firm's model, already represented, wrong sub-type, deadline too close. Each repeating reason becomes a rule.
Draft the grid
Put the rules in the four-outcome format and list the gray zones that always go to an attorney.
Test on fresh calls
For two weeks, have staff apply the grid to every new inquiry and note when it did not fit. Adjust the rules, then publish version 1.
The lost group is worth special attention. Inquiries with no recorded decision usually mean the criteria were unclear, so nobody felt able to decide.
Criteria are not fixed: review when demand moves
Acceptance criteria should change when the firm's capacity or the market changes. Federal court data show how quickly demand can move by practice area. Bankruptcy filings rose 12.2% to 608,511 in the 12 months ending June 30, 2026[1]. In the year ending March 31, 2025, civil filings in US district courts fell 22% while filings for criminal defendants rose 12%[3].
Source: United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts), 2026[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2025 | 542,529 |
| 2026 | 608,511 |
A consumer bankruptcy practice facing that kind of rise has a choice: tighten criteria (for example, only accept Chapter 13 cases, or only certain counties) or add capacity. Either is reasonable. What is not reasonable is letting staff keep booking every inquiry and then cancelling consultations because the attorneys are overloaded.
Revenue in legal services is seasonal too. Census data show unadjusted revenue peaked at $132.1 billion in the fourth quarter of 2025 and fell 18.9% to $107.2 billion in the first quarter of 2026[4]. Many firms find their own busy and slow periods follow a pattern. Review your criteria at least each quarter, and add a capacity line to the grid that a partner can switch on or off.
Wording staff use for each outcome
Criteria only work if the conversation that follows them is consistent. Give staff one approved line for each outcome, so a declined caller hears the same respectful message whoever answers.
- Accept for consultation: "This is the kind of matter our attorneys handle. The next step is a consultation with [attorney]. I have [day and time] or [day and time]."
- Refer: "This isn't something our firm handles, but [firm or program] does, and their number is [number]. Please contact them soon, as legal matters can have time limits. I'll make a note that we referred you."
- Decline: "Thank you for explaining. We're not able to take this on. The [state] bar's lawyer referral service can help you find an attorney, and their number is [number]. Please don't wait, because time limits can apply."
- Escalate: "I want an attorney to look at this before we decide. I'll have an answer for you by [time today or tomorrow], by phone or email, whichever you prefer."
Never give a reason that sounds like a judgment of the merits, such as "you don't have a case" or "that's not worth pursuing". The reason a firm declines is usually about the firm: its practice areas, its location, its capacity. Say so. It is accurate, it is kinder, and it avoids the caller relying on an opinion the firm never formed.
Every outcome should also be recorded with the rule that drove it. Over a quarter, that log shows which rules fire most often, which ones staff struggle with, and where the firm might be turning away work it would want.
Make referral part of the policy
A declined caller still has a legal problem. The Legal Services Corporation found that low-income Americans get no or not enough legal help for 92% of their substantial civil legal problems[2]. A firm that declines without a referral may be adding to that gap. Your criteria should say, for each refer rule, where to refer: named firms, the state or local bar referral service, legal aid organizations, or law school clinics. Keep the list current and record each referral.
Example: a personal injury firm's version 1
Example (fictional): a two-partner personal injury firm wrote its first criteria after reviewing 80 recent inquiries. It found that most declines came down to four facts: the injury happened outside its six counties, the accident was more than the firm's time window ago, the caller was already represented, or there was no medical treatment at all.
Its version 1 grid says: accept motor vehicle, premises and dog-bite matters in the six counties where the injured person received medical treatment and the incident date is within the firm's window; refer workers' compensation and medical malpractice to two named firms; decline property-damage-only claims with a bar referral pointer; escalate anything involving a minor, a death, a government vehicle or a deadline the caller mentions.
The partners still make the final decision at the consultation. But staff now book the right consultations, and the partners stopped spending afternoons calling back matters they would never take.
Keep the policy usable
- One page. If staff need to scroll, they will stop reading.
- Plain words, not legal terms of art, wherever possible.
- A version number and date at the top, and the name of the approving attorney.
- A short list of gray zones that always escalate.
- A quarterly review on the calendar, with the outcome log as the input.
Frequently asked questions
What are case acceptance criteria?
Written rules that tell intake staff which inquiries to book for a consultation, which to refer, which to decline and which to escalate to an attorney, based on facts gathered at intake.
Who should decide whether a law firm accepts a case?
An attorney makes the final decision, usually at the consultation. Criteria let staff route inquiries consistently before that point and escalate anything unclear.
How often should acceptance criteria be updated?
At least quarterly, and whenever capacity or demand changes. Filings can move sharply by practice area year to year[1][3].
Should we refer cases we decline?
Yes, wherever you can. Give a named firm, a bar referral service or legal aid, and record the referral.
References
United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts) (2026). Bankruptcies Rise 12.2 Percent (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) โ
United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts) (2025). Federal Judicial Caseload Statistics 2025 (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2026). Quarterly Selected Services Estimates, Second Quarter 2026 (CB26-146) (opens in a new tab) โ