Key takeaways
- Write the screening rules down by caller type; Rule 5.3 expects firms to have measures governing how nonlawyers act[2].
- Screening means routing plus acknowledgment: client calls should be promptly returned or acknowledged[3].
- Courts and listed client emergencies interrupt; vendors, sales calls and routine status questions do not.
- Each attorney's status (available, focus block, in court, out) decides how the list applies at that moment.
- Staff never confirm to an unknown caller who the firm represents[4].
Screening lives in someone's head until it is written down
In most small firms the screening rules exist only in the receptionist's memory. She knows the judge's clerk always goes through, the copier rep never does, and the client with a hearing on Thursday gets put through this week. When she is out sick, the temp puts everyone through or no one, and the attorney spends the day buried in interruptions or misses the one call that mattered.
A written screening list fixes that, and it is also what the ethics rules expect of a firm that hands its phones to nonlawyers. Rule 5.3 requires lawyers with managerial authority to make reasonable efforts to ensure the firm has measures giving reasonable assurance that nonlawyers' conduct is compatible with the lawyers' professional obligations[2]. A screening policy is one of those measures. It decides who reaches a lawyer, who gets a message, and what every caller is told about when they will hear back.
Get it wrong in the blocking direction and the cost shows up in bar complaints. In Massachusetts, approximately 18% of all new matters at the bar's attorney and consumer assistance program in FY2019 concerned neglect of clients or legal matters, or failure to return client calls[1]. The program answered 3,162 new inquiries that year, about 78% of them by telephone[1]. Screening that blocks without a promised callback produces exactly that kind of complaint, which is part of why communication drives so many bar complaints.
Screen for routing, not for gatekeeping
The comment to Rule 1.4 sets the standard staff should work to. When a prompt response is not feasible, the lawyer or a member of the lawyer's staff should acknowledge the request and tell the client when to expect a response, and client telephone calls should be promptly returned or acknowledged[3]. Screening, then, is not about keeping people away from the attorney. It is about sending each caller to the right person and telling them, accurately, what happens next.
That changes the words staff use. “She's not available” ends a conversation. “She's in a hearing until about 2:30. I'll make sure she has this before then, and she or her paralegal will call you back today” is screening done properly. The Rule 1.4 guide covers the rule itself; the rest of this article covers the list.
The screening list by caller type
| Caller | Default | Interrupt the attorney when | What staff say |
|---|---|---|---|
| Judge, chambers or court clerk | Put through | Always; if the attorney is in court, the named backup attorney | “One moment, I'll get her now.” |
| Existing client | Message with a callback time | Arrest, hearing within 48 hours, new deadline, safety threat, client at the courthouse | “I'll give her your message by noon. If it's urgent, tell me what's happened.” |
| Opposing counsel | Put through if available, otherwise a message | A negotiation the attorney has flagged, or a deadline today | “May I tell her which matter this is about?” |
| Referring attorney | Put through or priority callback | The attorney's choice; most want these calls | “She'll want to speak with you. Let me check.” |
| New prospective client | Intake, not the attorney | Only under the firm's urgent intake rules | “I can help you get started and set up a time with an attorney.” |
| Witness or unrepresented party | Message only | Never on the first call; the attorney decides | “I'll pass your name and number to the attorney handling the matter.” |
| Experts, court reporters, vendors | Message or email | A scheduling conflict for today | “What's the best email for her to reply to?” |
| Sales calls and robocalls | No message unless relevant | Never | “We're not interested, thank you.” |
Two rows cause most of the friction. Existing clients are the first: they are the people the attorney most needs to hear from, and also the source of most avoidable interruptions. Keep their default as a message with a promised time, and write the interrupt triggers down so staff are not guessing. Existing client calls goes deeper on status calls and callback blocks.
New prospective clients are the second. ABA Formal Opinion 506 allows trained nonlawyers to handle much of intake, but when a prospective client asks what legal services they need, the lawyer must respond[5]. So the screen sends new callers to intake, and intake knows which questions to escalate. Professional callers have their own identification and logging rules, set out in calls from opposing counsel and courts, and witnesses get a short, careful script covered in when a witness calls your firm.
Why attorney minutes are worth protecting
In law firms in May 2023, lawyers earned a mean of $87.51 an hour, against $30.90 for paralegals and legal assistants, $27.21 for legal secretaries and $18.86 for receptionists[6]. Every call an attorney takes that a paralegal could have handled moves work from the cheapest hour in the building to the most expensive one, before counting the billable work it pushed aside.
Example: four attorneys each take six calls a day that the list would have routed elsewhere, at about five minutes a call. That is half an hour per attorney per day, two hours across the firm, and about 42 hours a month over 21 working days. At the mean lawyer wage above, those hours cost about $3,675 a month in wages alone, and they arrive in fragments that break up drafting and hearing preparation.
Attorney status decides how the list applies
A list by caller type is half the system. The other half is a status every attorney keeps current, so whoever answers knows what “interrupt” means at that moment.
Available
Every put-through row applies. Staff still announce the caller and the matter before connecting.
Focus block
Only courts and the client triggers on the list interrupt. Everything else becomes a message with a callback time after the block ends.
In court or in a meeting
No interruptions. Court and urgent client calls go to the named backup attorney or paralegal; answering calls while you're in court covers the hand-off.
Out of office
Messages go to the covering attorney and callers hear the return date. Nobody is told the attorney is “in a meeting” while they are on vacation.
Keep status where staff can see it at a glance: the shared calendar, the presence light in the phone system, or a whiteboard if that is what works in your office. Stale status is worse than none, because it makes staff confidently wrong.
Words that screen without stonewalling
Callers hear screening as rudeness when staff ask for a name before offering anything useful. Lead with help, then ask. “She's with a client right now. May I tell her who's calling and what it's about, so she has what she needs when she calls back?” gets better information than “Who's calling?”, and it does not suggest the answer depends on the name.
Never confirm to an unknown caller who the firm represents. Rule 1.6 bars a lawyer from revealing information relating to a client's representation without consent or other authorization, and the comment says it covers all information relating to the representation, whatever its source[4]. The fact that someone is a client is part of that. When a caller asks whether a named person is a client, staff say: “I'm not able to say who the firm represents, but I'm glad to take a message for any of our attorneys.” Confidentiality for front-desk teams has more scripts.
Spam needs its own line on the list, because there is a lot of it. In a 2025 Pew survey, 68% of US adults said they get scam phone calls at least weekly[7]. Staff who end the obvious ones quickly are doing their job; the sales call and robocall guide covers the harder cases, such as callers who claim to be from a court or a bank.
The message that ends every screened call
A screen only works if the message that comes out of it lets the attorney decide in seconds. Every screened call should produce the same fields: who called and about which matter, the callback number and when they are free, what they want in one sentence, any date or deadline they mentioned, what the caller was promised about timing, and whether staff judged it urgent and why. The last two are the fields most often missing, and they are the ones that stop a promised callback from turning into a complaint.
Example: “Dana Ruiz, client, Ruiz v. Hartwell. Hearing moved to Thursday 9 a.m.; she just got the notice. Call 555-0142 before 4 today. Told her you would call this afternoon. Not an interrupt under the list, but the new date is three days out.” Message-taking standards has a full template, and the same fields work whether a person or a system took the call.
Screening when nobody is at the front desk
The list matters most when the regular receptionist is at lunch, out sick or gone for the night, because that is when calls drift to voicemail or to a service that does not know the firm. The same written list can drive an SI Employee that answers the calls your firm forwards to it. It asks your approved questions, follows your escalation tree of up to three people plus a fallback, and never promises that an attorney is free. When it transfers a call to an attorney, the attorney hears a short briefing first; when nobody picks up, the caller is told plainly and an urgent message is saved. Every call leaves a summary, recording and transcript (see what it does).
- Caller
- SI Employee
- System
01Caller
Client calls main line
Says a hearing was moved to tomorrow morning.
02SI Employee
Checked against the list
A hearing within 48 hours is an interrupt trigger for existing clients.
03System
Transfer to attorney
The attorney hears a short briefing, then the call connects.
04System
No answer: next person
The next destination on the escalation tree is tried.
05System
Urgent message saved
If nobody picks up, the caller is told and the summary is marked urgent.
Example flow for a forwarded call answered with the firm's written screening list.
The solo personal injury example models a firm with no receptionist at all, where a list like this is the only screen between the attorney and every call.
Keep the list alive
- Review it every quarter with the attorneys and everyone who answers the phones.
- Add a row whenever a call went wrong because the list said nothing about that caller.
- Read a sample of messages each month: were callers told when to expect a reply, and did the reply happen?
- Update it when an attorney joins or leaves, because each attorney's interrupt preferences belong on it.
- Keep it to one page. A list nobody can find mid-call is not a list.
Screening done this way is quieter for the attorneys and fairer to callers. Each caller hears an honest answer about what happens next, and the attorney hears about the calls that genuinely need them, in time to act.
Frequently asked questions
Should lawyers answer their own phones?
Some solos do, and it can work at low volume. Once interruptions start displacing billable work, a written screening list and someone to apply it usually cost less than the attorney's time; lawyers in law firms averaged $87.51 an hour in May 2023[6].
Is it a problem for staff to screen client calls?
No. The comment to Rule 1.4 expects that a staff member may acknowledge a request and tell the client when to expect a response[3]. What matters is that the call is acknowledged and then actually returned.
Can the receptionist tell a caller whether someone is our client?
No. Rule 1.6 covers all information relating to a representation[4]. Staff offer to take a message instead.
What should always interrupt an attorney?
Courts and chambers, and the client emergencies your firm lists, such as an arrest, a hearing within 48 hours or a safety threat. Write the list down, since Rule 5.3 expects firms to have measures governing how nonlawyers act[2].
Who handles a new caller who asks the attorney what to do?
Intake staff take the details, but questions about what legal services the caller needs go to a lawyer under ABA Formal Opinion 506[5].
References
Massachusetts Board of Bar Overseers, Office of the Bar Counsel (2019). Office of the Bar Counsel Annual Report to the Supreme Judicial Court, Fiscal Year 2019 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Indiana Supreme Court (2026). Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 5.3: Responsibilities regarding nonlawyer assistants (opens in a new tab) ↑
Indiana Supreme Court (2026). Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.4: Communication (opens in a new tab) ↑
Indiana Supreme Court (2026). Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.6: Confidentiality of information (opens in a new tab) ↑
American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2023). ABA Formal Opinion 506: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistants (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2023). May 2023 National Industry-Specific Occupational Employment and Wage Estimates: NAICS 541100 - Legal Services (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2025). Online Scams and Attacks in America Today (opens in a new tab) ↑