Phones and Call Handling

Answering Calls While You're in Court

How solo and small-firm attorneys keep calls covered on hearing and trial days: coverage models, a court-day playbook, scripts and recess triage.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why court days break the phones
  2. Court time is rising in some practices
  3. Pick a coverage model for court days
  4. The court-day playbook
  5. What the person answering can say
  6. Recess triage: what to act on first
  7. Choosing your urgent backup
  8. Multi-day trials
  9. Set client expectations before court days
  10. Example: a solo defense attorney's motion day
  11. Mistakes to avoid
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References
Phones and Call Handling: Answering Calls While You're in CourtArticle coverPHONES AND CALL HANDLINGAnswering Calls WhileYou're in CourtAva for LawyersInsightsPhones and Call Handling: Answering Calls While You're in CourtArticle coverPHONES AND CALL HANDLINGAnswering Calls WhileYou're in CourtAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Court days are predictable, so coverage for them can be planned: pick a model, brief whoever answers, and change the greeting the night before.
  • Solo practice is common: the Census Bureau counts about 274,000 legal services businesses with no paid employees[1].
  • Some dockets are busier: federal criminal defendant filings grew 12% and bankruptcy petitions 13% in the year to March 2025[2].
  • Use recesses for triage, not for returning every call; urgent items and new-client bookings come first.

Why court days break the phones

For a solo attorney or a two-lawyer office, a hearing day can mean six or seven hours when nobody who knows the practice can answer. Calls that come in during that window are the same calls that come in any day: new clients shopping for a lawyer, existing clients with questions, opposing counsel, the court clerk. The difference is that the attorney is the only person who could take them, and the attorney is on the record.

This is a structural problem, not a discipline problem. About 274,000 US legal services businesses had no paid employees in 2023[1], which means many practitioners are their own receptionist. And because 67% of adults let unknown numbers ring through to voicemail and check messages later[3], callers who do reach you are often ready to talk, and they will try the next firm on their list if nobody answers.

Court time is rising in some practices

Growth in federal court filings, year ending March 31, 2025Civil filings fell 22% over the same period.
Growth in federal court filings, year ending March 31, 2025Column chart. Criminal defendant filings: 12%; Bankruptcy petitions: 13%.0%5%10%15%Criminal defendant filings: 12%12%Criminal defendant filingsBankruptcy petitions: 13%13%Bankruptcy petitionsGrowth in federal court filings, year ending March 31, 2025Column chart. Criminal defendant filings: 12%; Bankruptcy petitions: 13%.0%5%10%15%Criminal defendant filings: 12%12%Criminaldefendant filingsBankruptcy petitions: 13%13%Bankruptcypetitions

Source: United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts), 2025[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Criminal defendant filings12%
Bankruptcy petitions13%

Federal caseload data shows how uneven court demand is across practice areas. In the year ending March 31, 2025, filings for criminal defendants in US district courts grew 12% and bankruptcy courts received 13% more petitions, while civil filings fell 22%, largely because one large multidistrict litigation wound down[2]. If your practice sits in a growing docket, plan for more court days, not fewer.

Pick a coverage model for court days

Coverage models for days the attorney is in court
ModelHow it worksBest forMain risk
Staff answer, attorney gets summariesIn-office staff take calls and send a short summary the attorney reads at recessFirms with at least one trained staff memberStaff absent the same day
Outside answering serviceCalls forward to live agents who take messages or basic intakeSolo attorneys who want a person on every callGeneric scripts; message quality
AI intakeSoftware answers in the firm's name, asks approved questions and books or requests consultationsFirms that want the same intake every timeNeeds careful setup and testing
Colleague coverA trusted attorney or their staff covers urgent calls by agreementSolos with a reciprocal arrangementConflicts and confidentiality
Voicemail plus recess callbacksCourt-day greeting; attorney triages at breaksVery low call volumeNew clients call the next firm

Most small firms combine two models: one that answers every call and one that handles urgent matters. An SI Employee such as Ava, for example, answers in the firm's name, follows the intake questions the firm approves and routes urgent calls to a backup contact without promising that the attorney is available.

The court-day playbook

  1. The afternoon before

    Check the next day's schedule. Tell whoever answers which hours you are unreachable, who the urgent backup is and which callers you are expecting, such as a client waiting on a settlement figure.

  2. The evening before

    Record or schedule the court-day greeting on your direct line and set forwarding for the main line. Clear your voicemail box so it cannot fill up.

  3. Before you go in

    Make one test call to the main line from your cell to confirm forwarding works. Set your phone to silent, not off, so summaries arrive.

  4. At each recess

    Read summaries, not voicemails. Act only on urgent items and anything that needs your decision to move forward.

  5. After court

    Work a short callback block before you leave the courthouse or as soon as you are back. Hand everything else to the next morning's queue.

  6. The next morning

    Switch greetings and forwarding back, and check nothing from the court day is still open.

What the person answering can say

Whoever answers is not the attorney and must say so. Florida Bar guidance on nonlawyer intake says staff should identify their nonlawyer status, ask only factual questions, give no legal advice and refer legal questions to the lawyer[4]. The scripts below follow that rule.

New caller: โ€œ[Attorney name] is in court today, and I'm not an attorney, but I can take your details and set up a time for you to speak with [him or her]. Can I start with your name and the best number for you?โ€

Existing client: โ€œ[Attorney name] is in court until this afternoon. I'll make sure [he or she] sees your message at the next break. Is there a deadline today or tomorrow I should flag?โ€

Caller pressing for an answer: โ€œI understand this matters a lot. I can't give legal advice, but I can make sure the attorney has the details today. What time works best to reach you after 4 pm?โ€

Recess triage: what to act on first

A ten-minute recess is enough to read summaries and act on two or three items, not enough to return every call. Sort quickly:

  1. Anything involving liberty or safety: an arrest, detention or protective order.
  2. Deadlines today or tomorrow, including court calls about scheduling.
  3. New clients who are ready to book; a 30-second text or email from staff confirming a consultation slot is often enough.
  4. Existing clients with questions that can wait until after court.
  5. Everything else goes into the next morning's queue.

The attorney's time is the scarcest resource in the building. The median lawyer earned $76.76 an hour in 2025[5], so recess time spent on vendor calls or routine status questions is expensive in a very literal way.

Choosing your urgent backup

Every court-day plan needs one person who can make a decision when the attorney cannot. For a solo practice that is often a trusted colleague in a related practice; for a small firm it is the other partner or a senior associate. Write down three things about the backup: which matters they may act on, which they may only take messages for, and how they reach you if something truly cannot wait until the next recess.

Give the backup a short list of your open matters with upcoming deadlines, the names of clients who are expecting calls and any matters where they have a conflict. Agree a signal for genuine emergencies, such as a text that starts with URGENT and a one-line reason, so you know which messages to read first when you check your phone in the hallway. Then test the arrangement once on a quiet day, so the first real use is not also the first time anyone has tried it.

Multi-day trials

A trial changes the calculation, because the attorney may be unavailable for days and exhausted in the evenings. Put the direct line in trial mode with a greeting that sends every new caller to the main number. Agree a single evening callback window, for example 6 to 7 pm, and stick to it. Ask a colleague or a contract attorney to cover genuine emergencies on other matters, and make sure they run a conflict check before taking details.

Tell existing clients before the trial starts. A short email saying that you are in trial from Monday to Thursday, who to contact and when you will respond prevents most of the calls in the first place.

Set client expectations before court days

Many court-day calls are existing clients asking for updates. Tell clients at engagement how court days work: that you are often unreachable for whole mornings, who answers when you are, and when they can expect a reply. Repeat it in the confirmation email for any hearing on their matter. Clients who know the rhythm call less and worry less, and they are more patient when a callback comes at 4:30 rather than at noon.

Example: a solo defense attorney's motion day

Example (fictional): a solo criminal defense attorney had a motions calendar from 9 am to 2 pm. The evening before, she scheduled her court-day greeting and set the main line to forward to her intake option. During the morning, nine calls came in: four new inquiries, two existing clients, a bail bond agent, a clerk and a robocall. At the 11 am recess she read summaries, called the clerk back about a rescheduling and approved two consultation slots by text. After court she returned the two client calls from the courthouse steps. The new inquiries were booked before she reached her car.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Forwarding the main line to your own cell on court days, where calls land in personal voicemail.
  • Leaving the normal greeting on, which promises a callback today that you cannot make.
  • Returning calls in the courthouse hallway where others can hear client details.
  • Letting staff promise that the attorney will call during a break.
  • Forgetting to switch forwarding back, so the next day's calls go to the court-day setup.

Court days are one of the most predictable causes of missed calls. Combine this playbook with a same-day callback system and clean call routing, and most of the calls that come in while you are on the record can be handled before you are back at your desk.

Frequently asked questions

How do solo attorneys answer calls while in court?

Most combine a coverage option that answers every call, such as staff, an answering service or AI intake, with a court-day greeting and recess triage. The attorney reads short summaries at breaks and acts only on urgent items.

Should I forward my office line to my cell during court?

Usually not. Calls end up in your personal voicemail, and you cannot answer anyway. Forward to whoever or whatever is covering, and keep your cell for summaries and urgent escalations.

What should my voicemail say on a court day?

That you are in court until a given time, that new callers will get a faster response on the main line, and when you will return messages. Change it the evening before and switch it back the next morning.

Can a colleague cover my urgent calls?

Yes, by agreement, but they should run a conflict check before taking details and know which matters they may and may not discuss. Put the arrangement in writing.

References

  1. U.S. Census Bureau (2023). Nonemployer Statistics 2023: U.S. file (nonemp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts) (2025). Federal Judicial Caseload Statistics 2025 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Lawyers: Occupational Outlook Handbook (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo