Key takeaways
- Ten questions qualify most callers: contact, language, matter type, jurisdiction, parties, representation, dates, goal, source and next step.
- Ask facts, not opinions; nonlawyer staff should not answer "do I have a case?"[1].
- Cost worry is common: 46% of low-income Americans who did not seek legal help cited cost[2], so explain the consultation process plainly.
- Ask for the preferred language early; 22% of US residents aged five and older speak another language at home[3].
The goal of the first call
The first call has one job: decide whether this person should speak with one of your attorneys, and if so, get them booked. It is not the consultation. Staff who try to learn everything on the first call end up hearing confidential details before conflicts are checked, and drift into answering legal questions.
The test for every question below is simple: does the answer change what happens next? If it does not change whether you book, refer, decline or escalate, it can wait for the consultation or the questionnaire.
The ten-question minimum
| Question | Why you ask it | Where to stop |
|---|---|---|
| What is your full name, and the best number and email? | Callback, confirmation and conflict search | Do not ask for date of birth or ID unless your conflict system needs it |
| Is it safe to leave a voicemail or send a text at that number? | Confidentiality in shared households | Note the answer; do not ask why |
| Which language are you most comfortable using? | Book an interpreter or bilingual attorney | Do not test the caller's English |
| In a sentence, what is the matter about? | Practice area routing | Stop them politely once you know the category |
| Which state and county is it in? | Jurisdiction and licensing | Do not guess which court it belongs in |
| Who else is involved? Please give full names. | Conflict check | Names and roles only, not what they did |
| Do you already have a lawyer on this matter? | Represented-person screening | If yes, stop intake on the matter |
| Is there a court date, deadline or something you must respond to? | Triage and urgency | Record the date; do not say whether it can be extended |
| What would a good outcome look like for you? | Fit with the firm's services | Do not say whether it is achievable |
| How did you hear about us? | Source tracking and referral thanks | One answer is enough |
Ten questions sounds like a lot. In practice, a caller answers most of them in under five minutes, because each one is factual and short.
Ask them in this order
The order matters as much as the questions. Contact details come first so a dropped call is not a lost lead. Voicemail and text permission come next because people often answer that more honestly before they are emotional about the matter. Pew found that 67% of Americans say they do not answer unknown numbers but do check voicemail[4], so knowing whether a message is safe decides how you will follow up.
Language comes third. If the caller would be more comfortable in another language, everything after this point goes better with an interpreter or a bilingual colleague.
Matter type and jurisdiction come before parties because they decide whether you need conflict names at all. If the firm does not handle immigration matters, there is no need to collect the names of everyone involved in one.
Parties come before the story. That is the core protection: names first, so the conflict search can run before anyone at the firm hears confidential details.
Dates come near the end, but never get skipped. A caller who answers every other question and forgets to mention a hearing on Monday is the caller who most needs the question.
Questions to hold back for the consultation
These come up on almost every call, and staff should not answer them:
- "Do I have a case?"
- "What would you do in my position?"
- "How much is my case worth?"
- "Should I sign this, sign that, or give a statement?"
- "Can they do that to me?"
Florida's Ethics Opinion 88-6, cited by the Florida Bar's 2024 guidance on intake chatbots, says nonlawyers doing initial intake should limit questions to factual information, give no legal advice and refer legal questions to the lawyer[1]. A good answer is: "That's exactly what the attorney will go through with you. Let's get you booked so you can ask them directly."
Why the representation question goes early
Ask "Do you already have a lawyer on this matter?" before the caller gets into the details. The Florida Bar's guidance suggests screening questions that limit intake communications if the person is already represented by another lawyer[1]. A caller who wants a second opinion or to change lawyers is a different conversation, and an attorney should decide how to handle it.
Handling cost questions without quoting
Many callers ask about cost in the first minute. They have reason to. In the Legal Services Corporation's 2022 Justice Gap study, 46% of low-income Americans who did not seek legal help for a problem cited cost concerns as a reason[2]. Confidence varies sharply by income: 73% of higher-income Americans said they could find and afford a lawyer if needed, against 45% of low-income Americans[2].
Source: Legal Services Corporation, 2022[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Higher-income | 73% |
| Low-income | 45% |
Staff should know the firm's policy on consultation fees and payment arrangements and state it plainly, but should not estimate the total cost of a matter. A useful script:
"The consultation is [free / a set fee of X]. At the end, the attorney explains how fees would work for your matter before you decide anything."
If the firm does not take the matter, a referral to legal aid or a bar referral service is part of a good answer for callers worried about cost.
Adjust the set by practice area
Keep the ten core questions and add no more than three practice-specific ones. Examples:
- Family law: "Are there children under 18?" and "Has anything already been filed with a court?"
- Criminal defense: "Is the person in custody now?" and "When is the next court date?"
- Personal injury: "When did the injury happen?" and "Has anyone received medical treatment?"
- Estate planning: "Is this for you, or for someone else?" (if someone else, the attorney will need to speak with that person).
- Immigration: "Is anyone detained?" and "Is there a hearing scheduled?"
Each one changes what happens next: routing, urgency or who the client really is.
When the caller is not the client
A mother calls about her adult son's arrest. A business manager calls about the owner's contract dispute. A daughter calls about her father's will. In each case the caller can give you contact details, the type of matter and the urgency, but the person who would be the client is someone else.
Add two questions when this happens: "Who would the attorney be representing?" and "How can the attorney reach that person directly?" Record the caller's relationship to the prospective client, and tell the caller plainly that the attorney will need to speak with the person themselves before the firm can take the matter on. That keeps the conflict search pointed at the right names and avoids the firm taking instructions from the wrong person.
Example: what good first-call notes look like
Example (fictional) first-call record:
- Caller: Maria Lopez, mobile, email given. Voicemail OK, no texts.
- Language: Spanish preferred; book with a Spanish-speaking attorney or interpreter.
- Matter: employment, says she was let go after reporting a safety issue.
- Jurisdiction: Harris County, Texas.
- Parties: former employer (full business name recorded), her supervisor (full name recorded).
- Representation: none.
- Dates: received a separation agreement; asked to sign by Friday the 14th.
- Goal: "understand my options before I sign."
- Source: referral from a former client (name recorded for a thank-you).
- Next step: urgent flag for the employment attorney; consultation booked for Wednesday at 4 p.m. by phone.
Notice what is missing: her account of the conversations with her supervisor and any opinion on whether she has a claim. Both belong in the consultation.
Read the answers back before you hang up
Spend the last 30 seconds of the call reading back four things: the spelling of the caller's name, the phone number, every date, and the next step. Callers rarely correct a mistake they were not asked about, and a wrong digit or a misheard date is costly later.
Read dates in full ("Friday, the fourteenth of November") rather than "the fourteenth", and say what each date is for. If the caller is unsure of a date, write "caller unsure, believes Friday the 14th; asked to check the letter and call back" rather than recording a guess as fact. Then confirm how they will hear from you and roughly when, so the caller is not left waiting by the phone.
Common errors and fixes
- Asking "what happened?" first. Fix: start with names and jurisdiction, then the one-sentence summary.
- Writing dates loosely ("next week"). Fix: always record the calendar date and what the date is for.
- Skipping the language question because the caller speaks some English. Fix: ask every caller; more than one in five people aged five and older speak a language other than English at home[3].
- Forgetting voicemail and text permission. Fix: make it a required field in the intake form.
- Ending without a next step. Fix: every call ends with a booked time, a referral or a promised callback time.
Frequently asked questions
What questions should a law firm ask a potential client?
Ten facts: contact details, voicemail and text permission, preferred language, matter type, state and county, other parties' names, existing representation, upcoming dates, desired outcome and how they found you.
Can intake staff tell a caller whether they have a case?
No. Staff gather facts and book the consultation. Questions about merits, value or what to do go to the attorney[1].
Should intake staff discuss fees on the first call?
Staff can explain the consultation fee policy and how the attorney will explain fees, but should not estimate what a matter will cost.
Why ask about other attorneys at intake?
If the person is already represented on the matter, the firm should stop intake on that matter and let an attorney decide how to respond[1].
References
The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2025). New Data on Detailed Languages Spoken at Home and the Ability to Speak English (opens in a new tab) โ
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ