Ethics and Compliance

Written Fee Agreements Under Model Rule 1.5

When Model Rule 1.5 and state rules require fees in writing, what a clear fee agreement covers, and clauses for scope, expenses and AI-assisted work.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. What Rule 1.5(b) actually requires
  2. When writing is mandatory
  3. Clauses every fee agreement should cover
  4. Billing for AI-assisted work
  5. Write for the client's budget, not just the rule
  6. Clause wording you can adapt
  7. Delivery, signature and timing
  8. Paid consultations need terms too
  9. Fee disputes start with the agreement
  10. Example: a hybrid fee, written clearly
  11. Common mistakes
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References
Ethics and Compliance: Written Fee Agreements Under Model Rule 1.5Article coverETHICS AND COMPLIANCEWritten Fee AgreementsUnder Model Rule 1.5Ava for LawyersInsightsEthics and Compliance: Written Fee Agreements Under Model Rule 1.5Article coverETHICS AND COMPLIANCEWritten FeeAgreements UnderModel Rule 1.5Ava for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • For new clients, the scope and the basis or rate of the fee and expenses must be communicated, preferably in writing, before or soon after the work starts[1].
  • Writing is mandatory for contingent fees and fee divisions between firms, and some states add their own written-agreement statutes; nonrefundable fees must be confirmed in writing in Florida[1].
  • Hourly billing must reflect time actually spent, including when AI tools make work faster, and AI does not permit double-billing[2][3].
  • Write for affordability: only 63% of US adults could cover a $400 emergency with cash, so payment terms and estimates belong in plain language[4].

What Rule 1.5(b) actually requires

ABA Model Rule 1.5(b) asks lawyers to communicate the scope of the representation and the basis or rate of the fee and expenses the client will be responsible for, preferably in writing, before or within a reasonable time after starting the work. The exception is a regularly represented client charged on the same basis as before. Changes in the basis or rate must also be communicated. Most states adopted that structure. Florida's version, for example, says that when the lawyer has not regularly represented the client, the basis or rate of the fee and costs must be communicated, preferably in writing, before or within a reasonable time after commencing the representation[1].

Preferably in writing is not the same as optional in practice. Fee disputes are decided on evidence, and a lawyer who explained the fee only on a phone call is relying on memory against a client's memory. The cost of writing it down is a page; the cost of not doing so is often the fee itself.

When writing is mandatory

  • Contingent fees: Model Rule 1.5(c) requires a writing signed by the client stating how the fee is calculated and how expenses are handled.
  • Dividing a fee with another firm: Model Rule 1.5(e) requires the client to agree in writing to the arrangement, including each lawyer's share.
  • Nonrefundable fees in Florida: any fee that is nonrefundable in any part must be confirmed in writing and explain the parties' intent about its nature and amount[1].
  • State statutes: several states, including California and New York, have their own written fee agreement or engagement letter requirements that apply above stated thresholds or to particular matter types.
  • Conflicts waivers and limited-scope engagements: separate rules call for informed consent, often confirmed in writing.

Check your state's version before relying on the Model Rule. State rules differ on thresholds, signature requirements and whether a failure to use writing makes the fee unenforceable or only exposes the lawyer to discipline.

Clauses every fee agreement should cover

Core clauses for a written fee agreement and the rule each one supports.
ClauseWhat it should sayWhy it matters
ScopeThe matter, the tasks included and what is excludedMost disputes start with work the client assumed was included
Fee basisHourly rates by role, flat fee, contingency or a mixRule 1.5(b) requires the basis or rate
Billing methodIncrements, what is billed, how often invoices go outClients compare invoices with expectations
ExpensesWhich costs the client pays and how they are billedExpenses are part of what must be communicated
Advance depositAmount, that it is held in trust, how it is applied and replenishedTrust rules apply to unearned funds
Rate changesHow and when rates may change, with noticeChanges must be communicated
Technology and AIHow AI-assisted work is billedTime billed must reflect time actually spent
Ending the engagementHow either side ends it, refund of unearned funds, file handlingTermination duties apply either way

Billing for AI-assisted work

Generative AI has pushed fee clauses into new territory. California's State Bar guidance says hourly billing must reflect the time actually spent on the client's matter, recognizing that generative AI may reduce the time required, and suggests alternative structures such as flat fees for more predictable assignments[2]. Florida Bar Opinion 24-1 adds that AI does not permit improper billing practices such as double-billing[3].

A short clause avoids surprises: “We may use software tools, including AI tools, to assist with research and drafting. We bill only for the time our lawyers and staff actually spend, including time reviewing any output. We do not charge for time saved, and we do not charge for learning a tool.” If you plan to pass on a specific tool's cost as an expense, say so in the agreement before you do.

Write for the client's budget, not just the rule

Fee language is also a conversion and retention issue. Only 63% of US adults would cover a $400 emergency expense completely with cash or its equivalent[4], and 46% of low-income Americans who did not seek legal help for a problem cite cost as a reason[5]. A client who understands what the first month will cost, and how a deposit is replenished, is less likely to stop paying or stop responding halfway through.

US adults who would cover a $400 emergency expense completely with cash or its equivalent, 2025
US adults who would cover a $400 emergency expense completely with cash or its equivalent, 2025Donut chart. Would cover with cash or equivalent: 63%.Would cover with cash or equivalent: 63%63%
  • Would cover with cash or equivalent 63%

Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, 2025[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Would cover with cash or equivalent63%
  • Give a range for the likely total and say what would push it higher.
  • Show a worked example: a sample month with hours, rate and expenses.
  • State the replenishment rule for deposits in one sentence.
  • Offer a payment schedule in writing if you allow one, with what happens if a payment is missed.

Clause wording you can adapt

Example scope clause (fictional): “Brookfield Law will represent you in negotiating a severance agreement with your former employer. This engagement does not include filing an agency charge, a lawsuit or any appeal. If you want help with those, we will discuss a separate agreement.”

Example rate-change clause: “Our hourly rates are reviewed each January. We will give you written notice at least 30 days before any change applies to your matter, and you may end the engagement if you do not agree.”

The second clause contains a number, 30 days, chosen by the fictional firm, not required by any rule. Choose your own notice period and apply it consistently.

Delivery, signature and timing

  1. Send before substantive work

    Send the agreement with the consultation follow-up, and start work after it is signed, unless urgency requires otherwise; then send it within days.

  2. Use electronic signature

    E-signature with an audit trail is easy for clients and gives the firm proof of the version signed.

  3. Explain it on a call

    Walk through scope, fee basis and deposit in five minutes, and note that you did in the file.

  4. Store it with the matter

    The signed agreement lives in the matter file and the billing system, not only in email.

  5. Amend in writing

    When scope grows or the fee basis changes, send a short amendment and get it acknowledged.

A paid consultation is a small engagement in its own right. Before the meeting, tell the person in writing what the consultation fee covers, how long the meeting lasts, whether the fee is credited against later work and what happens if they cancel. Make clear that the consultation does not by itself mean the firm will take the matter.

The booking confirmation is the natural place for this. One short paragraph in the confirmation email, with a link to the full terms, gives the prospective client the information before they pay and gives the firm a record of what was agreed. If the firm then declines the matter, the non-engagement letter should confirm that the consultation fee covered only the meeting.

Fee disputes start with the agreement

When a client challenges a bill, the first document a bar fee arbitration panel or a court reads is the fee agreement. Vague scope, missing expense terms and unrecorded rate changes are the gaps that turn a routine billing question into a dispute. Many state and local bars run fee arbitration programs, and some agreements refer to them; if yours does, describe the program accurately and check whether your state requires notice of it.

Keep a copy of every version of your template with the date it was introduced. When a dispute arises years later, you will need to show which wording the client signed.

Example: a hybrid fee, written clearly

Example: a fictional employment firm agrees to represent an executive negotiating severance for a flat fee, with an hourly fee if negotiations fail and the client wants a demand letter sent. The agreement states the flat fee, the hourly rates for each lawyer, which tasks the flat fee covers, that the flat fee is earned when the negotiation is complete and how any unused portion is treated, and that expenses are billed at cost. Six weeks later the client asks the firm to also review a non-compete in a new job offer. The firm sends a one-paragraph amendment adding that task at the hourly rate, and the client signs it the same day. When a billing question comes up at the end, both sides are reading the same documents.

Common mistakes

  1. Describing scope as “all matters related to” a dispute, which invites the client to expect everything.
  2. Calling an advance deposit a retainer without saying whether it is earned or held in trust.
  3. Leaving out expenses, then billing them later.
  4. Raising rates without written notice to existing clients.
  5. Using one template for every practice area, so contingency or flat-fee terms are missing where needed.

For the contingency-specific elements, see contingency fee agreement rules; for deposits and trust handling, see flat fees, advance fees and trust accounts.

Frequently asked questions

Does Model Rule 1.5 require a written fee agreement?

Rule 1.5(b) says the scope and the basis or rate of the fee and expenses should be communicated, preferably in writing. Writing is required for contingent fees and for dividing a fee between firms, and some states require written agreements more broadly.

When must the fee be communicated?

Before or within a reasonable time after the representation starts, unless the client is regularly represented on the same basis. Any change must also be communicated.

Can we bill for time an AI tool saved?

No. Guidance from California and Florida says hourly billing must reflect time actually spent, and AI does not permit double-billing. Bill for real time, including reviewing output.

Is a flat fee agreement different?

A flat fee covers defined services for a set amount. The agreement should define those services, say when the fee is earned and how unearned portions are handled; some states require written confirmation for nonrefundable fees.

References

  1. The Florida Bar (2026). Rules Regulating The Florida Bar, Chapter 4: Rules of Professional Conduct (Rule 4-1.5, Fees and Costs for Legal Services) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. The State Bar of California, Standing Committee on Professional Responsibility and Conduct (2026). Practical Guidance for the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence in the Practice of Law (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2025). Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households: Unexpected expenses (data table) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo