Key takeaways
- Duties to a prospective client continue after you decline: confidentiality applies even when no client-lawyer relationship forms[1].
- A good letter says plainly that the firm does not represent the person, gives no view on the merits, warns that time limits may apply and urges prompt advice elsewhere.
- Send it the same day the decision is made, by a method you can prove, and log the person as a prospective client for future conflict checks.
- Include a real referral route: low-income Americans seek legal help for only 25% of the civil problems that substantially affect them[2].
Why a declined inquiry still needs a letter
Most malpractice exposure from declined matters comes from a misunderstanding, not a mistake in the law. A caller tells the story, the lawyer asks good questions, the conversation ends warmly, and the caller hangs up believing the firm is looking into it. Months later a limitation period passes. The non-engagement letter, sometimes called a declination letter, exists to remove that misunderstanding in writing.
It also documents a relationship that does exist. Under the prospective client rule, a person who consults a lawyer about possibly forming a client-lawyer relationship is a prospective client, and even when no relationship follows, the lawyer may not use or reveal what was learned except as the rules allow for former clients[1]. The letter is the natural place to confirm that the information stays confidential.
When to send one
- After any consultation, free or paid, that ends without an engagement.
- After an intake call where the person shared facts about their matter and the firm will not proceed.
- When a conflict check blocks the matter, even before any lawyer speaks to the person.
- When the person goes silent after the firm sent an engagement agreement, once a set deadline passes.
- When the firm cannot decide quickly and a deadline may be close; send an interim letter saying the firm has not agreed to represent them.
If in doubt, send it. A letter to someone who never thought they were represented costs a few minutes. A missing letter to someone who did can cost a claim.
What to include
- A plain statement that the firm will not represent the person in the matter and has not taken any action on their behalf.
- A sentence that the decision is not an opinion on the merits of their matter.
- A warning that legal claims are subject to time limits that may be short, and that they should consult another lawyer promptly to protect their rights.
- Referral routes: the state or local bar's lawyer referral service, and legal aid if the person may qualify.
- Return of any original documents, with a list of what is enclosed.
- Confirmation that what they shared will be kept confidential.
- A contact for questions about the letter itself.
What to leave out
The letter is not the place for analysis. Each extra sentence of explanation is something the recipient can later read as advice they relied on.
- Opinions such as “you do not have a case” or “this claim is weak”.
- A specific deadline date, unless a lawyer has actually analyzed the limitation period and is prepared to stand behind it.
- Reasons that criticize the person, another lawyer or the other side.
- Promises to revisit the matter later, which can blur whether the firm declined at all.
- Case-specific facts beyond what is needed to identify the matter.
A template you can adapt
Example template (fictional firm): Dear Ms. Rivera, Thank you for contacting Lakeside Legal on May 4 about your dispute with your former landlord. After reviewing the information you provided, we have decided not to represent you in this matter. Our decision is not an opinion about the merits of your situation. Please be aware that legal claims are subject to time limits, some of them short, and if you do not act within the applicable period you may lose your rights. We encourage you to consult another lawyer promptly. The county bar's lawyer referral service can be reached through its website, and you may qualify for help from your regional legal aid office. We are returning the copy of your lease you left with us. Anything you shared with us will be kept confidential. Sincerely, Lakeside Legal.
Keep the template short enough to send the same day. Most firms keep two versions: one after a consultation and one for intake-only declines where no lawyer spoke to the person.
Delivery and proof
Decide the method by urgency
Email to the address the person gave is usually enough. Where a deadline may be near, add a call and a letter by mail with tracking.
Use a clear subject line
For email: “Lakeside Legal is not representing you: please read”. Avoid subjects that look like marketing.
Keep the proof
Save the sent email, any delivery receipt and a copy of the letter in a declined-matter file.
Log the prospective client
Enter the name, adverse parties and matter type in the conflicts system, flagged as a prospective client, so a future engagement against them is caught.
Close the loop internally
Mark the lead as declined so marketing does not keep following up.
Declining on the phone first
Many declines start on a call. Intake staff should be able to say no clearly without discussing the merits. A workable script: “Thank you for explaining your situation. Our firm isn't able to take this matter. That isn't a judgment about your case. Because legal claims can have deadlines, please speak with another lawyer soon. I can give you the bar's lawyer referral number, and we'll confirm this in writing today.”
If an SI Employee such as Ava answers some of your calls, give it the same approved wording and referral details, so a caller hears a consistent message whichever way they reach the firm. The written letter still follows from the firm.
Limit what you learn, and what you keep
The prospective client rule lets a firm avoid disqualification in some cases if the lawyer took reasonable measures to avoid exposure to more information than was needed to decide whether to take the matter[1]. That argues for short intake calls that collect parties, matter type, dates and urgency before any detailed story.
Recordings cut both ways. The New York City Bar's ethics committee noted in 2026 that recording a prospective-client conversation can document the reasons for declining and show that only minimal information was obtained, but that a recording accessible inside the firm also creates a conflict risk; its suggested default is not to record absent a good reason[3]. Whatever you keep, set a retention period and restrict access.
A referral is part of declining well
Many people you decline will not find another lawyer on their own. Low-income Americans seek legal help for only 25% of the civil legal problems that substantially affect them[2], against 32% for higher-income Americans[4], and they get no help or not enough help for 92% of substantial problems[5]. 53% of low-income Americans do not know whether they could find and afford a lawyer if they needed one[6].
Source: Legal Services Corporation, 2022[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Higher-income Americans | 32% |
| Low-income Americans | 25% |
A referral line in the letter costs nothing and can be the difference between a person acting in time and not acting at all. Keep the referral details current: check phone numbers and websites each quarter. Our guide to building a referral-out list covers what to include.
Example: a declined injury inquiry
Example: a fictional personal injury firm receives a call about a fall at a store eighteen months ago. The caller has no photographs and was not treated until weeks later. The intake lead collects the basics, the reviewing lawyer decides not to proceed, and the intake lead calls the caller the same afternoon with the scripted decline. The letter goes by email within the hour and by tracked mail the next morning, without naming a deadline but warning that time limits apply. The conflicts entry lists the caller and the store. Two years later, when the store's insurer asks the firm to defend a related claim, the conflict check flags the prospective client immediately.
Frequently asked questions
What is a non-engagement letter?
A letter telling a prospective client that the firm will not represent them in a matter. It confirms there is no client-lawyer relationship, warns that time limits may apply and recommends getting advice elsewhere promptly.
Should a non-engagement letter state the statute of limitations?
Usually not as a specific date. A general warning that time limits apply and may be short is safer unless a lawyer has analyzed the deadline and is prepared to stand behind it.
Do we owe anything to a prospective client we decline?
Yes. Information they shared must be kept confidential, and it can restrict the firm from acting against them in the same or a substantially related matter.
How should we send a declination letter?
Email is usually enough, with proof of sending kept in a declined-matter file. Where a deadline may be close, also call and send a tracked letter.
References
The Florida Bar (2026). Rules Regulating The Florida Bar, Chapter 4: Rules of Professional Conduct (Rule 4-1.18, Duties to Prospective Client) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) ↑
New York City Bar Association, Committee on Professional Ethics (2026). Formal Opinion 2026-2: Ethical Issues Affecting Use of AI to Record, Transcribe, and Summarize Conversations with Persons Who Are Not Clients (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) ↑