Ethics and Compliance

Contingency Fee Agreement Rules and Disclosures

The Rule 1.5(c) elements every contingency fee agreement needs, where contingency fees are banned, and how state rules such as Florida's add disclosures.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why contingency agreements carry extra rules
  2. The Rule 1.5(c) elements
  3. Before or after costs: show the client the difference
  4. Where contingency fees are not allowed
  5. State add-ons: the Florida example
  6. Costs the firm advances
  7. Explaining the agreement at intake
  8. Advertising “no fee unless we win”
  9. Discharge and withdrawal clauses
  10. Closing checklist
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Ethics and Compliance: Contingency Fee Agreement Rules and DisclosuresArticle coverETHICS AND COMPLIANCEContingency FeeAgreement Rules andDisclosuresAva for LawyersInsightsEthics and Compliance: Contingency Fee Agreement Rules and DisclosuresArticle coverETHICS AND COMPLIANCEContingency FeeAgreement Rules andDisclosuresAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • A contingent fee agreement must be in writing, state the percentage for settlement, trial or appeal, list deductible costs and say whether costs come off before or after the fee[1].
  • Contingency fees are barred in criminal matters and in domestic relations matters tied to securing a divorce, alimony, support or a property settlement[1].
  • Some states go further: Florida requires a statement of client's rights, a three-business-day cancellation right and a presumptive fee schedule in personal injury matters[1].
  • Contingency is often the only way clients can afford counsel: 45% of low-income Americans are confident they could find and afford a lawyer, against 73% of higher-income Americans[2].

Why contingency agreements carry extra rules

A contingent fee shifts risk from the client to the lawyer, which is why it opens the courthouse door for people who could never pay by the hour. In the Legal Services Corporation's research, 73% of higher-income Americans were confident they could find and afford a lawyer if they needed one, compared with 45% of low-income Americans[2]. Only 63% of US adults would cover a $400 emergency expense with cash or its equivalent[3].

The same feature that makes contingency valuable makes it easy to misunderstand. Clients hear a percentage and miss the questions that decide what they actually receive: which costs are deducted, in what order, and what happens if the case ends early. The rules force those answers into writing.

The Rule 1.5(c) elements

ABA Model Rule 1.5(c) permits contingent fees except where another rule or law prohibits them, and requires the agreement to be in a writing signed by the client. Florida's rule, which tracks it closely, says the agreement must state the method by which the fee is determined, including the percentage or percentages that accrue to the lawyer in the event of settlement, trial or appeal, the costs to be deducted from the recovery and whether those costs are deducted before or after the contingent fee is calculated[1]. The Model Rule also requires the agreement to tell the client clearly about any expenses the client must pay whether or not they win.

  1. Written agreement signed by the client, with a copy given to them.
  2. The percentage at each stage: settlement before suit, after suit is filed, at trial and on appeal.
  3. Which costs and expenses will be deducted from the recovery.
  4. Whether costs come off before or after the fee is calculated.
  5. Any expenses the client owes even if there is no recovery.
  6. At the end, a written statement of the outcome, the remittance to the client and how it was calculated.

Before or after costs: show the client the difference

The order of deductions is where most surprises happen. Put a worked example in the agreement or in the consultation follow-up, using round numbers that are clearly illustrative.

Example only: fictional figures in US dollars showing how the order of deductions changes the client's share at a one-third fee.
StepFee on gross recoveryFee on net recovery
Settlement300,000300,000
Case costs20,00020,000
Amount the fee is calculated on300,000280,000
Fee at one third100,00093,333
Client receives after fee and costs180,000186,667

Example: on a fictional settlement of $300,000 with $20,000 in costs, calculating a one-third fee on the gross recovery leaves the client $180,000; calculating it after costs leaves $186,667. Neither method is improper if the agreement says which applies. Leaving it unsaid is what causes disputes.

Where contingency fees are not allowed

The rules bar contingency in two areas. A lawyer may not charge a fee in a domestic relations matter whose payment or amount is contingent on securing a divorce or on the amount of alimony, support or a property settlement, and may not charge a contingent fee for representing a defendant in a criminal case[1]. Collecting arrears of child support or enforcing a property division judgment can be treated differently in some states, so check your state's comment and opinions before quoting a family-law client a percentage.

Some matter types also have statutory fee caps, such as certain federal benefits claims and workers' compensation in many states. A contingency agreement that exceeds a statutory cap is unenforceable regardless of what the client signed.

State add-ons: the Florida example

States often add requirements, especially for personal injury, wrongful death and property damage claims. Florida is a useful model because its rule is detailed. Its agreements must state that the client received and read a statement of client's rights before signing, and that the client may cancel by written notice within three business days of signing without owing fees for work in that period[1].

Florida also sets a presumptive fee schedule. Without court approval, fees above the standard are presumed clearly excessive: for example, 33⅓% of any recovery up to $1 million before an answer is filed, rising to 40% after an answer through judgment, with lower percentages on the portions above $1 million and $2 million, and an additional 5% after an appeal begins[1].

Florida presumptive contingency fee standards in personal injury mattersFees above these standards are presumed clearly excessive without court approval; 33.3 stands for one third
Florida presumptive contingency fee standards in personal injury mattersColumn chart. Before an answer is filed: Recovery up to $1 million 33.3%, $1 million to $2 million 30%, Above $2 million 20%; After an answer, through judgment: Recovery up to $1 million 40%, $1 million to $2 million 30%, Above $2 million 20%; Liability admitted, trial on damages: Recovery up to $1 million 33.3%, $1 million to $2 million 20%, Above $2 million 15%.0%10%20%30%40%Before an answer is filed · Recovery up to $1 million: 33.3%33.3%Before an answer is filed · $1 million to $2 million: 30%30%Before an answer is filed · Above $2 million: 20%20%Before an answer is filedAfter an answer, through judgment · Recovery up to $1 million: 40%40%After an answer, through judgment · $1 million to $2 million: 30%30%After an answer, through judgment · Above $2 million: 20%20%After an answer, throughjudgmentLiability admitted, trial on damages · Recovery up to $1 million: 33.3%33.3%Liability admitted, trial on damages · $1 million to $2 million: 20%20%Liability admitted, trial on damages · Above $2 million: 15%15%Liability admitted, trial ondamagesFlorida presumptive contingency fee standards in personal injury mattersColumn chart. Before an answer is filed: Recovery up to $1 million 33.3%, $1 million to $2 million 30%, Above $2 million 20%; After an answer, through judgment: Recovery up to $1 million 40%, $1 million to $2 million 30%, Above $2 million 20%; Liability admitted, trial on damages: Recovery up to $1 million 33.3%, $1 million to $2 million 20%, Above $2 million 15%.Before an answer is filedBefore an answer is filed · Recovery up to $1 million: 33.3%33.3%Before an answer is filed · $1 million to $2 million: 30%30%Before an answer is filed · Above $2 million: 20%20%After an answer, through judgmentAfter an answer, through judgment · Recovery up to $1 million: 40%40%After an answer, through judgment · $1 million to $2 million: 30%30%After an answer, through judgment · Above $2 million: 20%20%Liability admitted, trial on damagesLiability admitted, trial on damages · Recovery up to $1 million: 33.3%33.3%Liability admitted, trial on damages · $1 million to $2 million: 20%20%Liability admitted, trial on damages · Above $2 million: 15%15%
  • Recovery up to $1 million
  • $1 million to $2 million
  • Above $2 million

Source: The Florida Bar, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemRecovery up to $1 million$1 million to $2 millionAbove $2 million
Before an answer is filed33.3%30%20%
After an answer, through judgment40%30%20%
Liability admitted, trial on damages33.3%20%15%

At the end of a Florida contingency matter with a recovery, the lawyer prepares a closing statement itemizing costs and the fee received by each participating firm, signed by the lawyers and the client, and each participating lawyer keeps the contract and closing statement for six years[1]. Other states have their own schedules, statements of client rights or closing statement rules; New York and New Jersey, for example, regulate contingency agreements in personal injury matters through court rules.

Costs the firm advances

Contingency firms usually advance case costs: filing fees, records, experts and depositions. The Model Rules allow a lawyer to advance court costs and litigation expenses with repayment contingent on the outcome, and to pay those costs for an indigent client. The agreement should say which costs the firm will advance, whether interest or administrative charges apply, how much the firm may spend before asking the client, and what happens to advanced costs if there is no recovery.

Explaining the agreement at intake

Clients sign contingency agreements at a stressful moment, often right after an injury or loss. Give them time and a plain explanation.

Consultation script: “Our fee is a percentage of what we recover for you, and nothing if there is no recovery. The percentage is one third if the case settles before we file suit and higher after that, as listed on page one. We pay case costs up front and are repaid from the recovery; here is an example of how the numbers work. You'll receive a written statement at the end showing every cost and the fee.”

  • Send the agreement before the meeting where possible, so the client can read it at home.
  • Offer a call to answer questions after signing, especially in states with a cancellation window.
  • Record in the file that the fee, costs and order of deductions were explained.

Advertising “no fee unless we win”

Cost is a real barrier: 46% of low-income Americans who did not seek legal help for a problem cited concerns about cost as a reason[4]. That is why contingency messages work in advertising, and why regulators watch them. A slogan that promises no fee can mislead if the client still owes case costs when there is no recovery, or if costs are deducted from the client's share.

Make advertising match the agreement. If clients may owe costs regardless of outcome, say so wherever the ad mentions contingency, and several states expect exactly that disclosure. If the firm absorbs costs when there is no recovery, the agreement should say it in the same words the ad uses, so intake staff can repeat it without improvising.

Discharge and withdrawal clauses

Clients can end the relationship at any time. A contingency agreement should say what the firm is owed if the client discharges it before a recovery, which in many states is a claim limited to the reasonable value of the work, payable only if there is a later recovery. Write that clause to match your state's case law rather than copying a form from another state, and never phrase it in a way that penalizes the client for choosing new counsel.

Closing checklist

  1. Reconcile costs

    List every advanced cost with receipts before preparing the statement.

  2. Calculate in the agreed order

    Apply the agreement's before-or-after rule and the correct stage percentage.

  3. Prepare the written statement

    Show the recovery, each cost, the fee, any liens or third-party payments, and the client's net amount.

  4. Get signatures where required

    Some states require the client and every participating lawyer to sign the closing statement.

  5. Disburse from trust

    Pay the client and third parties from the trust account and move the fee to operating only once it is earned and the statement is settled.

  6. Keep the records

    Store the agreement and closing statement for at least the period your state requires.

For the general rule on communicating fees, see written fee agreements under Rule 1.5, and for handling the recovery in trust, see IOLTA basics.

Frequently asked questions

What must a contingency fee agreement include?

It must be written and signed by the client and state how the fee is determined, the percentage at settlement, trial and appeal, which costs are deducted, whether costs come off before or after the fee, and any expenses the client owes regardless of outcome.

Can a lawyer take a divorce case on contingency?

Not where the fee depends on securing a divorce or on the amount of alimony, support or a property settlement. Some states treat collection of support arrears differently, so check your state.

Are contingency fees allowed in criminal cases?

No. The rules prohibit a contingent fee for representing a defendant in a criminal case.

What is a closing statement?

A written statement at the end of a contingency matter showing the outcome, the recovery, costs, the fee and the amount paid to the client. Some states require the client's signature and set retention periods.

References

  1. The Florida Bar (2026). Rules Regulating The Florida Bar, Chapter 4: Rules of Professional Conduct (Rule 4-1.5, Fees and Costs for Legal Services) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2025). Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households: Unexpected expenses (data table) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo