Practice Area Playbooks

Will Contest Consultation Intake: Standing and Deadlines

Screen will contest callers fairly and fast: relationship to the deceased, probate status, notices received and the deadlines that set how soon to act.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing8 min read

On this page
  1. Grief, anger and a calendar
  2. Four screening questions
  3. Deadlines differ sharply by state
  4. No-contest clauses: record them, don't read them
  5. Conflicts and who the client is
  6. From the first call to a consultation
  7. Example: the new will signed in the hospital
  8. The executor's call is intake too
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
Practice Area Playbooks: Will Contest Consultation Intake: Standing and Deadlines46%: of US adults say they have a will (Gallup, 2021), so many estate disputes involve no will at allPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSWill Contest ConsultationIntake: Standing andDeadlines46%of US adults say they have a will (Gallup, 2021), so manyestate disputes involve no will at allAva for LawyersInsightsPractice Area Playbooks: Will Contest Consultation Intake: Standing and Deadlines46%: of US adults say they have a will (Gallup, 2021), so many estate disputes involve no will at allPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSWill ContestConsultation Intake:Standing andDeadlines46%of US adults say they have a will(Gallup, 2021), so many estatedisputes involve no will at allAva for Lawyers
Figure source: Gallup, 2021[1]

Key takeaways

  • Ask who the caller is to the person who died and what they would receive with and without the will; the right to object usually turns on that interest[2].
  • Find out whether probate has started and when any notice was served. Florida bars most objections 3 months after service of a notice of administration[3]; Texas allows 2 years from admission to probate[4].
  • Collect the names of every relative, beneficiary, executor and the drafting lawyer for the conflict check before details reach the attorney.
  • No-contest clauses are treated differently by state: unenforceable in Florida[5], enforceable in New York with listed exceptions[6]. Intake records the clause; the attorney weighs it.

Grief, anger and a calendar

Will contest calls rarely start calmly. A sister who moved in to care for their mother is now the only beneficiary. A new will was signed in the hospital three weeks before the end. A stepparent inherits the house the caller grew up in. The caller wants someone to say it was wrong. Intake cannot do that and should not try. Its job is narrower and more useful: find out who the caller is in the estate, where probate stands, and which date decides how fast the firm has to move.

These calls come from a large pool. The United States recorded 3,072,666 deaths in 2024[7]. Not every estate has a will to fight over: in Gallup's 2021 polling, 46% of adults said they had a will, rising to 76% of those 65 and older[1].

US adults who have a will, by ageGallup polling, May 2021. All adults: 46%.
US adults who have a will, by ageColumn chart. 18 to 29: 20%; 30 to 49: 36%; 50 to 64: 53%; 65 and older: 76%.0%20%40%60%80%18 to 29: 20%20%18 to 2930 to 49: 36%36%30 to 4950 to 64: 53%53%50 to 6465 and older: 76%76%65 and olderUS adults who have a will, by ageColumn chart. 18 to 29: 20%; 30 to 49: 36%; 50 to 64: 53%; 65 and older: 76%.0%20%40%60%80%18 to 29: 20%20%18 to 2930 to 49: 36%36%30 to 4950 to 64: 53%53%50 to 6465 and older: 76%76%65 andolder

Source: Gallup, 2021[1]

Show the data
Age groupHave a will
18 to 2920%
30 to 4936%
50 to 6453%
65 and older76%

Two practical consequences follow. Most will contest calls concern older people's estates, where a will usually exists and may have been changed late in life. And a real share of callers who say they want to “contest the will” are describing an estate with no will at all, which is an heirship or administration dispute rather than a will contest. Ask early. Those callers belong in probate intake.

Four screening questions

  1. Who are you to the person who died, and what would you receive under this will, under any earlier will, and if there were no will?
  2. Is there a will, which one is being used, and do you have a copy? Is there an earlier will, or a trust?
  3. Has anyone started probate? Which court and county, when, and who is acting as executor?
  4. Have you received any notice, citation or court papers about the estate? When, and how did they arrive?

Example script: “I'm sorry about your father. I'll ask some questions so the attorney has the full picture before you speak. I can't tell you whether the will can be challenged; that's what the consultation is for. First, how were you related to him, and do you know whether anyone has started probate?”

The script does two jobs at once. It tells the caller plainly that intake will not judge the will, which keeps the call from turning into an argument about the stepmother, and it reaches probate status within the first minute. It also gives the caller a clear next step, which matters to someone who has spent a week replaying the reading of the will.

Then, and only then, ask what the caller believes went wrong, in their own words: the person was confused, someone controlled them, the signature looks wrong, the will was not signed properly, a later will disappeared. Write it down without labels. Undue influence and lack of capacity are conclusions the attorney may or may not reach.

Standing rests mostly on the first question. In New York, objections to probate may be filed by any person whose interest in property or in the estate would be adversely affected by admitting the will[2]; Texas speaks of an interested person[4]. A neighbor promised the piano, a grandchild whose parent is still alive, or a caregiver named in an earlier draft may or may not qualify. The attorney decides, so intake records what each will gives the caller and what they would take with no will.

Deadlines differ sharply by state

There is no national deadline for contesting a will, and the event that starts the clock varies. Some periods run from the will's admission to probate, some from a notice served on the caller, some from the discovery of fraud. That is why intake asks about notices and service as carefully as it asks about the will itself.

Examples from three states, not a complete list. The attorney confirms the rule for the county where probate is open.
StateRuleWhat intake must capture
FloridaAn interested person served with a notice of administration must object to the will's validity within 3 months after service, or the objection is barred[3]Whether a notice of administration arrived, the date it was served and how
TexasA suit to contest must be brought within 2 years after the will is admitted to probate, or 2 years after forgery or fraud is discovered[4]Date the will was admitted, and when the caller learned of any forgery or fraud
TexasA will generally cannot be admitted to probate more than 4 years after the death unless the applicant was not in default[4]Date of death, and whether a different will has surfaced
New YorkObjections are due by the return date of process or a later date the court sets, or 10 days after any pre-objection examinations finish[2]The citation, its return date and any court dates

Florida's rule shows why the notice matters so much. The 3-month period can be extended only where the personal representative misstated the deadline, and not for any other reason, including misconduct[3]. A caller who signed for a notice in August and phones in late October has days, not weeks. Staff record the date and how it arrived; the attorney counts. The general method is in screening for limitation deadlines without giving advice.

No-contest clauses: record them, don't read them

Many callers have been told, sometimes by the beneficiary they are fighting, that the will says anyone who challenges it gets nothing. Whether that holds depends on the state. Florida makes such a penalty clause unenforceable[5]. New York enforces it whether or not the contest had probable cause, with exceptions, including a contest based on probable cause that the will is forged or was revoked by a later will, and certain preliminary steps such as examining the witnesses and the drafter before objecting[6].

Intake asks one question: “Does the will say anything about what happens if someone challenges it? If you have a copy, please send it.” It does not tell the caller whether the clause applies, whether it is risky to go ahead, or whether a preliminary examination would be safe. Those are the first things the attorney will want to explain, and the explanation needs the full will and the state's law on the desk.

Conflicts and who the client is

Family disputes are where conflicts hide. Several relatives may call the same firm in one week, on opposite sides. The firm may have drafted the will, represented the person who died, or act for the executor on another matter. Run the conflict check before the caller's story reaches an attorney, and before anyone at the firm calls a relative back.

  • The person who died, including any earlier names.
  • The executor or personal representative under each will, and any trustee.
  • Every beneficiary under the will being probated and under any earlier will.
  • Heirs who would inherit with no will: a spouse, children, and the children of any child who has died.
  • The lawyer who drafted the will, and the witnesses if known.
  • Anyone the caller accuses of pressure or wrongdoing.

A supervised non-lawyer may run the conflict check and gather facts at intake[8]. What staff must not do is pass details from one relative's call to another, even to a friendly sibling on the same side. The conflict check guide covers the mechanics, and calls from adult children covers the related problem of one relative calling on behalf of another.

From the first call to a consultation

Example: screening a will contest call
  • Caller
  • SI Employee
  • Your team
  1. 01Caller

    Calls about a will

    Believes a will is unfair, forged or the product of pressure.

  2. 02SI Employee

    Relationship and interest

    Who they are to the person who died, and what each will leaves them.

  3. 03SI Employee

    Probate status

    Court and county, date opened, any notice received and when.

  4. 04SI Employee

    Names for conflicts

    Executor, beneficiaries, heirs and the drafting lawyer.

  5. 05Your team

    Conflict check

    Run before details go to the attorney or anyone else at the firm.

  6. 06Your team

    Attorney consultation

    Standing, grounds, deadline and cost of litigation explained by the lawyer.

Example sequence. Questions, order and urgency rules come from the firm's approved intake.

Family disputes surface in the evening, after a reading of the will or a tense call between siblings. When the firm forwards its line after hours, an SI Employee can ask these questions in the firm's approved order, take every name the firm needs for its conflict check, and book a consultation in the firm's connected calendar or take a request the team confirms. It does not comment on whether a will is valid. AssistCall's family law intake example models a set-up that takes conflict names first, and the two-attorney estate firm example gives probate calls their own opening and a short urgent list.

Example: the new will signed in the hospital

Example. A caller in Florida says her father signed a new will in the hospital three weeks before he died, leaving everything to his second wife. The earlier will, which she has a copy of, split the estate among his three children. A notice of administration arrived by certified mail six weeks ago; she signed for it and put it in a drawer.

Intake records her relationship, both wills' dates and what each leaves her, the court and file number from the notice, and the day she signed for it. It takes names for the conflict check: her father, the stepmother serving as personal representative, both siblings, the lawyer named in the notice and the two witnesses on the earlier will. With six weeks of the three months already gone under the Florida rule[3], the firm's urgent rule applies and the consultation is booked within two days. She asks whether she has a case. Intake says the attorney will go through it with her, and asks her to bring both wills and the notice.

The executor's call is intake too

Not every call comes from the challenger. Executors and beneficiaries call when they learn someone has objected, or expect that someone will. Intake for that side asks the same questions in a different order: who has objected, what papers have been served and when, any hearing date, and who else is involved. The conflict check is identical and just as urgent, because the firm may already have heard from the other side. A firm that drafted the will may be a witness rather than counsel, so flag that for the attorney before booking anything.

Frequently asked questions

Can anyone contest a will?

Generally only someone whose interest the will harms. New York's wording is any person whose interest in property or in the estate would be adversely affected by admitting the will to probate[2]. Intake records what the caller would receive under each will and with no will; the attorney decides.

The caller says there is no will. Is this still a will contest?

No. Without a will, disputes are usually about who inherits by law or who should administer the estate. Treat it as probate intake and keep the conflict check.

How long does a caller have to contest a will?

It depends on the state and on what starts the clock. In Florida, those served with a notice of administration have 3 months after service[3]; in Texas the period is 2 years after the will is admitted to probate[4]. Intake captures the dates; the attorney applies the rule.

Should intake explain what a no-contest clause means for the caller?

No. Record whether the will has one and get a copy. The effect varies by state: Florida does not enforce such clauses[5], while New York generally does, with exceptions[6].

Is a trust contest handled the same way?

The screening questions are similar, but the documents, the court process and the deadlines can differ. Note any trust the caller mentions and let the attorney decide how to treat it.

References

  1. Gallup (2021). How Many Americans Have a Will? (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. New York State Senate (2026). New York Surrogate's Court Procedure Act § 1410: Objections to probate (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Florida Legislature (2026). The 2026 Florida Statutes, s. 733.212: Notice of administration; filing of objections (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Texas Legislature (2026). Texas Estates Code, Chapter 256: Probate of Wills Generally (Sec. 256.003 and 256.204) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Florida Legislature (2026). The 2026 Florida Statutes, s. 732.517: Penalty clause for contest (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. New York State Senate (2026). New York Estates, Powers and Trusts Law § 3-3.5: Conditions qualifying dispositions; conditions against contest (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2024). FastStats: Deaths and Mortality (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2023). ABA Formal Opinion 506: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistants (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo