Key takeaways
- Ask the open question first, then confirm with a short pick list; never lead the caller toward an answer.
- Self-reports blur channels: someone referred by a friend may also have read reviews, as 82% of US adults at least sometimes do before a first purchase[1].
- Pair the answer with system evidence such as tracking numbers and form source tags, and keep both.
- Report signed matters by source, not just inquiries, and never offer incentives for reviews[2].
Why the question matters, and why it misleads
"How did you hear about us?" is the cheapest marketing research a law firm can do. Asked well, it shows which referral relationships, directories, campaigns and content bring in the matters the firm wants. Asked badly, it produces a column of "Google" and "a friend" that tells the partners nothing and quietly misdirects the marketing budget.
The core problem is that people rarely find a lawyer through one channel. A typical path might be a friend's recommendation, a search for the firm's name, a scan of reviews, then a call from the website. Ask that person how they heard about you and they may say any of the four. Reviews in particular sit in the middle of many journeys: 82% of US adults at least sometimes read online ratings or reviews before buying something for the first time, and 40% always or almost always do[1].
Younger callers lean on reviews most. That means a caller who says "I found you on Google" may really mean "my sister recommended you and I checked your reviews before calling". The answer is not wrong. It is incomplete.
The fix is not a longer questionnaire. It is one well-timed open question, one follow-up, a disciplined pick list and a second, system-generated source recorded alongside it. The sections below cover each.
How to ask
Pick the moment
Ask after the screening questions and before booking, when rapport is established but the call is not yet ending. At the very start it feels like a survey; at the very end it gets rushed.
Ask an open question first
"By the way, how did you come across our firm?" Let them answer in their own words, and write down exactly what they say.
Follow up once
If the answer is broad, such as "online" or "Google", ask one gentle follow-up: "Was that a search, a review site or something else? Did anyone recommend us?"
Confirm with the pick list
Choose the closest option yourself, in the system, from what they said. Do not read the list aloud like a menu.
Capture the referrer
If a person recommended the firm, ask their name, and whether it is all right to thank them.
Wording that works: "Out of interest, how did you come across us?" Then, if needed: "And before you called, did you look us up anywhere, or did someone point you our way?" Avoid: "Did you find us on Google?" It suggests the answer.
A pick list that produces useful data
Keep the list short enough that staff use it consistently, and specific enough to act on. Ten or twelve options usually cover a firm's channels.
- Referral: current or former client (with name).
- Referral: another lawyer (with name and firm).
- Referral: friend, family or colleague.
- Referral: professional (accountant, doctor, financial adviser, union, employer).
- Search: searched for the firm by name.
- Search: searched for a type of lawyer or a legal problem.
- Reviews or directory listing (with which one).
- Article, guide or video on the firm's website.
- Social media (with which platform).
- Advertising (with which campaign, if known).
- Event, seminar or community organization.
- Other (with a short note).
Split search into "firm name" and "type of lawyer". A name search usually means something else came first, such as a referral or an article, and the follow-up question should find it.
Asking on web forms and by email
On a form, the question competes with everything else the person is trying to do. Make it optional and place it last, so it never stands between someone and the submit button. Use a short dropdown with the same categories as the phone pick list, plus a free-text "anything else?" box for names of referrers.
Do not rely on the form answer alone. The page the form was submitted from, and any campaign tag on the link that brought them there, are usually more reliable than the dropdown. When the coordinator first speaks to the prospect, confirm the source with the open question, especially if the form field was skipped.
Keeping answers consistent across staff
- Write the pick list and its definitions into the intake manual, with an example of what belongs in each option.
- Practice the open question and follow-up in team training until they sound natural, not scripted.
- Spot-check ten records a month against call notes or recordings where your policy allows.
- Track the share of records where the source is "Other" or blank. If it rises, the list or the habit needs attention.
- Update the list when the firm adds a channel, such as a new directory or campaign, and note the date.
The most common mistake is not a bad list but a skipped question. Make the field required before a consultation can be booked, so it is asked on every qualified call.
Combine self-reports with system evidence
| Source category | What callers usually say | System evidence to pair with it |
|---|---|---|
| Search by firm name | "I Googled you" | Website form source tag; call from website tracking number |
| Search by problem | "I searched for a divorce lawyer" | Landing page on the form; tracking number for search campaigns |
| Reviews or directory | "I saw your reviews" | Directory-specific tracking number or link tag |
| Content | "I read your article on custody" | Form submitted from the article page |
| Advertising | "I saw your ad" | Campaign tag; campaign-specific number |
| Referral | "My friend recommended you" | Referrer name; usually no system trace |
Use separate tracking numbers for the main channels you can identify, such as directory listings, advertising and the website, and tag web forms with the page they were submitted from. Then store two fields: the system source and the self-reported source. When they disagree, both are informative.
When the answers disagree
- Keep both answers. Do not overwrite one with the other.
- Count the first touch for credit. If a caller says a friend recommended the firm and the system shows they called from the website, the friend gets the referral credit and the website gets an assist.
- Treat name searches as a signal, not a source. They nearly always follow something else.
- Review a sample monthly. Pull ten records where the two sources disagree and look for patterns, such as a directory listing that shows up as "Google".
Reviews: measure them, never buy them
Reviews show up in so many paths that it is tempting to treat them as a channel to push. Measure their influence by asking the follow-up question and tracking directory numbers. Do not incentivize them. The FTC's rule on reviews and testimonials prohibits providing compensation or other incentives conditioned on writing consumer reviews, and bans buying or selling fake reviews[2][4].
Remember too that readers are skeptical: 48% of Americans who read online reviews say it is often hard to tell whether they are truthful and unbiased[5]. Genuine, specific reviews from real clients, asked for through a normal process, do the work.
Report on matters, not just inquiries
The point of source data is to see which channels produce the matters the firm wants. Report monthly: inquiries, booked consultations and signed matters by source, and where possible the type of matter. A directory that produces many calls but few signed matters may be worth less than a referral relationship that produces a handful of strong matters. Word of mouth is fragile: in Clio's 2024 secret-shopper research, summarized by the Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism, only 12% of prospective clients said they were likely to recommend the firms they contacted[6].
Example: A fictional estate-planning firm found that "Google" was the top self-reported source, at nearly half of inquiries. After adding the follow-up question and splitting search into name and problem searches, it learned that most name searches followed a seminar or a financial adviser's recommendation. The firm stopped cutting its seminar budget and started thanking the advisers.
For where this field sits among the others, see intake data fields every firm should track. For reporting it to partners, see building an intake dashboard for partners.
Frequently asked questions
When should intake ask how someone heard about the firm?
After the screening questions and before booking, when rapport is established but the call is not ending.
What is wrong with "Google" as a lead source?
It often hides the real first touch. Split search into firm-name and problem searches, and ask whether anyone recommended the firm.
Should we use tracking phone numbers?
Yes, for channels you can identify, such as directories, advertising and the website. Store the system source and the self-reported source side by side.
Can we reward clients for leaving reviews?
No. The FTC's rule prohibits compensation or other incentives conditioned on writing consumer reviews. Ask for honest reviews through your normal process.
References
Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews and ratings (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) โ
Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews and ratings (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) โ
Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews and ratings (opens in a new tab) โ
Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism (2Civility) (2024). Phone Calls Ignored, Emails Unanswered: Fixing the First Impression Problem for Law Firms (opens in a new tab) โ