Key takeaways
- The client chooses who represents them: stay with the firm, go with the departing lawyer or pick someone else.
- Aim for a joint notice; Florida's Rule 4-5.8 requires a good-faith attempt at one before unilateral contact[1].
- The notice must address fees, costs and deposits, and the file must move promptly when the client asks[1][2].
- Keep contact unbroken: 80% of US adults don't generally answer calls from unknown numbers[3], so a departing lawyer's new number may go unanswered.
Start from the client's right to choose
When an attorney leaves, partners and the departing lawyer often talk about which clients belong to whom. Clients do not belong to anyone. A client hired a lawyer and a firm to solve a problem, and they are entitled to decide who continues the work. Ethics opinions and rules across the country rest on that principle, and practical guidance follows from it: tell the client promptly, tell them the truth, give them a real choice and make sure their matter does not suffer while they decide.
Handled well, a departure barely registers with the client. Handled badly, with competing letters, unreturned calls and a file stuck between offices, it becomes the moment the client remembers about both the firm and the lawyer. The cost falls on the client first and on everyone's reputation second.
What a codified procedure looks like
Florida is one of the states that has written the procedure into a rule. Rule 4-5.8 of the Rules Regulating The Florida Bar says that, absent a specific agreement, a departing lawyer may not unilaterally contact the firm's clients without first approaching the firm and attempting to negotiate a joint communication[1]. If negotiations fail, unilateral contact must tell clients the lawyer is leaving and give them the options to remain with the firm, choose the departing lawyer or choose other counsel[1].
- The notice must cover potential liability for fees already incurred, costs expended and how any fee or cost deposits will be handled[1].
- Where appropriate, it must say that reasonable charges may apply to copying the file for a successor lawyer[1].
- A client who does not respond remains a client of the firm until they say otherwise[1].
Other states reach similar results through ethics opinions and general rules on communication and withdrawal, with local differences in timing and who may contact clients first. Check your own state's rule and opinions before anyone sends a letter.
A timeline for a planned departure
Departing lawyer tells the firm
The lawyer gives notice to firm management before contacting clients, and both sides agree who is affected.
List affected matters
Identify every open matter the lawyer handles, with upcoming deadlines and hearings in the next 60 days.
Negotiate a joint notice
Agree wording, timing and who will send it. A short, neutral letter signed by both is the goal.
Send the notice and call key clients
Send the letter and follow up by phone for clients with imminent deadlines or complex matters.
Record each client's choice
Keep the client's written instruction in the file, with the date.
Transfer files and funds
Move files, trust balances and calendar entries according to each client's choice, and confirm to the client when it is done.
Follow up with nonresponsive clients
Send a reminder after a set period and record that the client remains with the firm until they decide otherwise.
What the joint notice should say
| Element | Example wording |
|---|---|
| The change | Attorney Dana Reyes will leave Example Law Group on June 30 to join Example Partners. |
| Your choice | You may choose to stay with Example Law Group, to continue with Ms. Reyes at her new firm, or to hire another lawyer. The decision is entirely yours. |
| Continuity | Until you tell us otherwise, your matter remains with Example Law Group, and attorney Sam Okafor is your contact. |
| Deadlines | Your next hearing is August 14. Whoever represents you will be ready for it. |
| Fees and deposits | Fees for work already done and costs advanced will be billed as usual. Any unused deposit will follow your file to whichever lawyer you choose. |
| File | If you move, we will transfer your file promptly. Copying charges, if any, are explained in the enclosed sheet. |
| How to decide | Please sign and return the enclosed form, or call either office. |
Keep the tone neutral. No disparaging remarks about the firm or the lawyer, no pressure to decide quickly and no suggestion that one option is the default unless your state's rule makes it so.
Phone scripts for both sides
Firm calling the client: βYou'll receive a letter today explaining that Ms. Reyes is leaving the firm at the end of June. I wanted to call so you hear it from us. Your case is in good hands either way. You can stay with us, go with Ms. Reyes or choose someone else, and there's no rush beyond making sure your August hearing is covered.β
Departing lawyer, after the joint notice: βAs the letter explains, I'm moving to Example Partners. I'd be glad to keep working on your case, and the firm will also take good care of you. Whatever you decide, I'll make sure the handover is smooth.β
When a client asks what they should do: βThat's your decision, and either choice is fine from a legal standpoint. It may help to think about who you've worked with most and who you're comfortable with for the hearing.β
Keep contact unbroken
The quiet failure in many departures is that clients cannot reach anyone. The departing lawyer's email bounces, their direct line goes to an unmonitored voicemail, and the new firm's number is unfamiliar. Pew Research Center found that 80% of US adults don't generally answer calls from unknown numbers[3], so a call from the lawyer's new office may simply go unanswered.
- Don't generally answer 80%
Source: Pew Research Center, 2020[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Don't generally answer | 80% |
- Forward the departing lawyer's direct line to a named person, not a general voicemail, for at least several months.
- Set an email auto-reply that names the new contact at the firm and, where agreed, how to reach the departing lawyer.
- Leave a voicemail whenever calling from a new number, saying who is calling and why.
- Update the portal, court records and opposing counsel promptly for every matter that moves.
- Make sure court notices do not go to an inbox nobody reads.
Prospective and current clients alike respond strongly to reaching a real person: in a 2024 secret-shopper study, prospects who spoke with someone by phone were more than three times as likely to recommend the firm as average[4]. A departure is exactly the moment to make sure that happens.
Moving the file and the money
When a client chooses to move, the file should follow quickly. California's Rule 1.16, like other states' versions, requires a lawyer to promptly release client materials and property at the client's request when a representation ends, including correspondence, pleadings, transcripts, expert reports and electronic records[2]. Agree in advance how electronic files will be exported, who checks them and how calendared deadlines are handed over. Transfer trust balances with a reconciled statement, and send the client a short note confirming what moved and when.
Sudden departures: illness, death or a quick exit
Not every departure comes with weeks of notice. A lawyer may fall ill, die, be suspended or leave with little warning. The client's needs are the same, but the order of work changes: protect deadlines first, then communicate, then sort out longer-term choices.
- Pull a deadline report for every matter the lawyer handled and assign each one to a named attorney the same day.
- Call clients with hearings or filing deadlines in the next few weeks before sending any letter.
- Send a short written notice to all affected clients explaining who is handling their matter for now and that they may choose other counsel.
- Notify courts and opposing counsel where a substitution or new appearance is required.
- Keep a log of every client contact and decision, because questions will come later.
Firms that already keep a current list of each lawyer's open matters, deadlines and client contacts can do all of this in a day. Firms that do not will spend a week reconstructing it. A simple succession list, reviewed quarterly, is one of the cheapest forms of client protection a small firm can have.
What not to do
- Do not contact clients before the firm knows about the departure, unless your state's rules allow it.
- Do not take files, client lists or trust records without agreement or a client's instruction.
- Do not tell clients they must stay or must move.
- Do not let deadlines slip while the choice is pending; someone must own every matter every day.
- Do not disparage the other side in writing or on calls; it reflects on both.
Example: a smooth departure from a small firm
Example (fictional): a senior associate at a six-lawyer family law firm accepted a position elsewhere. She told the managing partner first, and they agreed a joint letter within a week. The firm assigned a partner to each of her matters as interim contact, and both lawyers called the clients with hearings in the next month. Most clients chose to follow the associate, and a few stayed with the firm. Files moved within days of each instruction, trust balances transferred with statements, and her old direct line forwarded to the firm's receptionist with a script. No hearing was missed, and two clients who stayed later referred new matters to the firm.
Departures are one moment in a longer client journey. See client journey mapping for law firms and managing client expectations about outcomes.
Frequently asked questions
Who decides whether a client stays with the firm or follows a departing lawyer?
The client. The notice should give them a genuine choice to remain with the firm, go with the departing lawyer or hire someone else.
Can a departing lawyer contact clients before telling the firm?
It depends on your state. Florida's Rule 4-5.8, for example, requires a good-faith attempt at a joint communication before unilateral contact. Check your state's rules and ethics opinions.
What should a departure notice say about fees?
It should explain liability for fees already incurred and costs advanced, how any deposits will be handled and whether copying charges may apply if the file moves.
What happens if a client never responds?
Under Florida's rule, the client remains a client of the firm until they say otherwise. Keep following up and make sure the matter is fully covered meanwhile.
References
The Florida Bar Ethics Department (2022). Notifying Clients of Change in Firm Composition (Ethics informational packet, updated 5-2-22) (opens in a new tab) β
The State Bar of California (2026). California Rules of Professional Conduct (2026) (opens in a new tab) β
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) β
Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism (2Civility) (2024). Phone Calls Ignored, Emails Unanswered: Fixing the First Impression Problem for Law Firms (opens in a new tab) β