Client Experience

What Clients Value Most When Choosing a Lawyer

What research says people look for when choosing a lawyer: responsiveness, credible reviews, cost clarity and trust, and what your firm can do about each.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. What the research can and can't tell you
  2. Being reachable
  3. Credible reputation
  4. Clarity about cost
  5. Honesty and trust
  6. Being understood, and understanding
  7. A human when it matters
  8. How priorities shift by practice area
  9. From research to action
  10. What to do this quarter
  11. Find out what your own clients value
  12. Example: what one firm learned by asking
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References
Client Experience: What Clients Value Most When Choosing a LawyerArticle coverCLIENT EXPERIENCEWhat Clients Value MostWhen Choosing a LawyerAva for LawyersInsightsClient Experience: What Clients Value Most When Choosing a LawyerArticle coverCLIENT EXPERIENCEWhat Clients ValueMost When Choosing aLawyerAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Reachability comes first: prospects who spoke with someone by phone were more than three times as likely to recommend a firm as average[1].
  • Reviews shape shortlists, but 48% of review readers say it is often hard to tell whether reviews are truthful, so specific, credible detail matters[2].
  • Cost uncertainty keeps people away: 53% of low-income Americans don't know whether they could find and afford a lawyer[3].
  • Trust must be earned in each interaction; only 20% of Americans rate lawyers' honesty and ethics as high or very high[4].

What the research can and can't tell you

Ask lawyers what clients value and most will say expertise and results. Ask people who have recently looked for a lawyer and the answers sound different: someone picked up the phone, explained things clearly, was upfront about cost and seemed honest. Clients assume competence from a license; they judge everything else from experience.

No single study captures every practice area or community, and much of the published research comes from vendors or bar groups with particular interests. Still, independent sources point in a consistent direction. This summary pulls together several of them and turns each finding into something a firm can act on. Use it as a starting point, then test it against what your own clients tell you.

Being reachable

The most consistent finding is also the most basic. In a 2024 secret-shopper study of 500 US law firms, reported by the Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism, only 40% of firms answered the phone, and just 12% of the shoppers said they were likely to recommend the firm they contacted[1]. Those who reached a person by phone were more than three times as likely to recommend the firm as the all-channel average, and nearly eight times as likely as those who only got a voicemail follow-up[1].

For a prospective client, being answered is the first evidence that the firm will be there when the case gets hard. For a current client, the same holds every time they call. Reachability is not a front-desk issue; it is part of what people are buying.

Credible reputation

Most people check a firm's reputation before calling. Pew Research Center found that 82% of US adults at least sometimes read online ratings or reviews before buying something for the first time, including 40% who always or almost always do[2]. But they read with suspicion: 48% of review readers say it is often hard to tell whether reviews are truthful and unbiased[2].

That skepticism rewards specifics. Reviews that describe how the firm communicated, how quickly it called back or how clearly it explained fees are more believable than five-star praise with no detail. The firm's own website faces the same test: concrete descriptions of process, timelines and who the client will work with persuade more than adjectives.

Clarity about cost

Cost worry stops many people from calling at all. The Legal Services Corporation found that 46% of low-income Americans who did not seek legal help for a problem cited concerns about cost, and 53% do not know whether they could find and afford a lawyer if they needed one[3]. Confidence differs sharply by income.

Americans confident they could find and afford a lawyer if needed
Americans confident they could find and afford a lawyer if neededComparison. Higher-income: 73%; Low-income: 45%.73%Higher-incomeHigher-income: 73%45%Low-incomeLow-income: 45%Americans confident they could find and afford a lawyer if neededComparison. Higher-income: 73%; Low-income: 45%.73%Higher-incomeHigher-income: 73%45%Low-incomeLow-income: 45%

Source: Legal Services Corporation, 2022[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Higher-income73%
Low-income45%

Even clients who can afford a lawyer value knowing what to expect. Explaining how fees work early, in plain language, removes a barrier that keeps prospects from booking and reduces disputes later. That does not mean quoting a number on the first call. It means saying how the firm charges, what a consultation involves and when the client will get an estimate.

Honesty and trust

The profession starts from a low baseline. Gallup's December 2025 poll found that only 20% of Americans rate lawyers' honesty and ethical standards as high or very high, while 34% rate them low or very low[4]. Prospects arrive braced for spin. Firms that are candid about weaknesses in a case, realistic about timelines and clear about what they will not do stand out quickly.

Being understood, and understanding

Clients rarely say they chose a lawyer for being clear, but they often say they left one for being confusing. The first consultation is where this is decided. People want to hear their problem described back in plain words, to understand the options and to leave knowing what happens next. That expectation lines up with the professional duty: California's Rule 1.4, like the Model Rule, requires a lawyer to explain a matter to the extent reasonably necessary for the client to make informed decisions[5].

  • Repeat the client's problem back in one or two sentences before giving any view.
  • Explain the options as a short list, with the main trade-off for each.
  • Avoid procedural terms, or define them in a few words the first time.
  • Close with three things: what the firm will do, what the client should do and when they will hear from you.
  • Send the same points in writing the same day.

A human when it matters

People are open to technology, with limits. The same 2024 study found that 51% of prospective clients agree that chatbots can be a helpful starting point for exploring legal options, but three in five would only use one if they could switch to a human when needed[1]. Clients value quick answers to simple questions and a real person for anything that matters. Designing your channels around that preference, including a clear route to a person, respects both.

How priorities shift by practice area

The core values are stable, but their order changes with the situation the client is in. Knowing which one leads in your practice helps you decide where to invest first.

  • Criminal defense: speed and availability, often outside office hours, followed by clarity about the next court date.
  • Family law: emotional steadiness, privacy and predictability about cost over a long matter.
  • Personal injury: confidence that the firm will handle the insurer, and clear explanations of how contingency fees and costs work.
  • Estate planning: trust, patience and plain explanations for family members as well as the client.
  • Business clients: responsiveness to deadlines, budgets that hold and lawyers who understand the business.

From research to action

What clients value and how to respond
What clients valueEvidenceWhat to do
Being answeredPhone contact strongly linked to recommendingCover every hour you advertise; same-day callbacks with voicemail
Credible reputationMost check reviews; many distrust themEncourage specific, honest reviews; publish real process detail
Cost clarityCost worry keeps people from seeking helpExplain how fees work early and in writing
HonestyLow baseline trust in lawyersBe candid about risks, timelines and limits
A human optionMost want to reach a person when neededMake the route to a person obvious on every channel

What to do this quarter

  1. Test your own reachability

    Have someone call your main number at different times and send a web form in the evening. Record what happens.

  2. Fix coverage gaps

    Name a backup for every shift and decide how calls are answered when everyone is busy. An SI Employee such as Ava can answer overflow and after-hours calls with your approved intake and route urgent ones.

  3. Rewrite your fee explanation

    Write a plain paragraph on how the firm charges for each practice area, and use it on the website, the phone and in follow-up emails.

  4. Read your reviews as a client would

    Sort them by what they praise or criticize. The pattern tells you what clients notice.

  5. Ask recent clients

    Call five recent clients and ask why they chose you and what nearly made them choose someone else.

Find out what your own clients value

  • Add one question to intake: what made you contact us? Record the answer in a consistent field.
  • Ask clients who did not hire you why, in a short and optional message.
  • Read survey comments for the words clients use, and use those words in your own materials.
  • Compare what referral clients and advertising clients say; they often value different things.
  • Review the questions callers ask most often before booking, since they reveal hidden worries.

Example: what one firm learned by asking

Example (fictional): a criminal defense firm assumed clients chose it for its trial record, and its website led with verdicts. When intake staff began recording why callers had chosen the firm, the most common answers were that someone answered at night, that the attorney explained the next court date clearly and that the fee was explained before the meeting. The firm rewrote its homepage around reachability and clarity, kept the trial experience as supporting detail, and saw more callers mention those points when they booked.

For how these values play out across a whole matter, see client journey mapping for law firms and managing client expectations about outcomes.

Frequently asked questions

What do clients look for most in a lawyer?

Research consistently points to reachability, clear explanations, cost clarity and honesty. Clients assume competence from a license and judge the rest from how the firm treats them.

Do online reviews matter for law firms?

Yes. Most people read reviews before choosing a new provider, but many doubt them, so specific, detailed reviews about communication and process carry the most weight.

Should we quote prices on the first call?

Not necessarily, but explain how the firm charges, what the consultation involves and when the client will receive an estimate. Cost uncertainty keeps many people from seeking help.

Do clients accept chatbots and automated tools?

Many do for simple questions, but most want to be able to reach a human when it matters. Make that route obvious.

References

  1. Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism (2Civility) (2024). Phone Calls Ignored, Emails Unanswered: Fixing the First Impression Problem for Law Firms (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews and ratings (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Gallup (2025). Nurses Continue to Lead in Honesty and Ethics Ratings (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. The State Bar of California (2026). California Rules of Professional Conduct (2026) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo