Key takeaways
- Ask for the date on the latest insurer letter in the first two minutes: ERISA disability plans must allow at least 180 days to appeal a denial, counted from receipt[2].
- Find out whether the coverage is an employer plan, a government or church plan, or an individual policy, because ERISA does not cover them all[3].
- The appeal is often the last chance to add evidence, so collect the claim file, plan documents and treating providers early[2][4].
- Only 37% of private-industry workers had access to long-term disability plans in March 2026[1], so callers often mix up LTD, short-term disability and Social Security.
Start with the date on the letter
Long-term disability callers are usually out of work, often in pain, sometimes foggy from illness or medication, and holding a letter from an insurance company. They want to tell you about the illness, the job they were good at and the claims manager who stopped returning calls. All of that matters later. In the first two minutes, intake needs one thing: where the claim stands, and the date on the most recent letter.
That date runs the file. Under the federal claims regulation, a plan that provides disability benefits must give a claimant at least 180 days after receiving a denial to file an appeal[2]. Six months sounds generous. It is not, if the caller spent four of them phoning the insurer alone, and the appeal record takes weeks of medical requests and opinion letters to assemble.
- Claim pending: the insurer has not decided yet, or keeps asking for more forms.
- Approved, then cut off: benefits were paid and have stopped, often after a review or a change in how the policy defines disability.
- Denied, appeal window open: a denial or termination letter, and no appeal filed yet.
- Appeal filed or decided: the caller already appealed, alone or with help, and may hold a final denial.
Each stage routes differently. A pending claim is a consultation this week. A final denial is a litigation question for the attorney. A denial letter dated more than four months ago is a same-day review under most firms' rules, however calm the caller sounds.
Employer plan, government plan or individual policy
Ask how the caller got the coverage before asking about the illness. ERISA governs most disability plans provided through private employers, but its coverage rules exclude governmental plans and church plans that have not opted in[3]. A policy bought privately from an agent follows state insurance law instead. The deadlines and the court process differ, and the attorney needs to know which set of rules the claim lives under.
- Short-term disability
- Long-term disability
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Sector | Short-term disability | Long-term disability |
|---|---|---|
| Private industry | 44% | 37% |
| State and local government | 26% | 41% |
The split shows up in real calls. In March 2026, 37% of private-industry workers had access to long-term disability plans, while 41% of state and local government workers did[1]. A teacher, a county nurse or a city clerk with LTD coverage may well be outside ERISA. So may an employee of a church-affiliated hospital. Intake does not decide; it records the employer's name and type so the attorney can.
Employer size matters too. Only 22% of private-industry workers at establishments with fewer than 50 employees had access to long-term disability insurance, against 66% at establishments with 500 or more[5]. Plenty of callers from small employers have no LTD at all and are really asking about Social Security disability, which runs on different rules entirely. The Social Security disability screening guide covers that intake.
The ERISA clock, step by step
45 days
for the plan to decide an initial disability claim, with up to two 30-day extensions[2]
180 days
minimum time a claimant must get to appeal a denial, counted from receipt[2]
45 days
for the plan to decide the appeal, with one extension of up to 45 more[2]
Plan terms
the deadline to sue after a final denial is often written into the plan itself[6]
Federal minimums for ERISA disability plans (29 CFR 2560.503-1). Plans can give more time, not less; the attorney confirms what applies.
Intake captures two dates at each step: the date printed on the letter and the date the caller received it, because the appeal window counts from receipt[2]. Ask how it arrived: post, email or an online claim portal. If the caller cannot find the letter, take the date they believe it came and mark the uncertainty in the note.
The last step is easy to miss. Many plans set their own deadline for suing after the final denial, and the Supreme Court has held that a plan and a participant may agree by contract to a limitations period as long as it is reasonable[6]. The plan in that case required suit within three years after proof of loss was due[6], a clock that starts before the appeal process ends. Intake records any date it sees in the plan booklet or the final letter. The attorney does the counting, using the approach in screening for limitation deadlines.
Why the claim file comes first
In ERISA disability cases the appeal is often the last chance to put evidence in front of the insurer, and the record built there shapes what a court later sees. How closely a court looks depends on the plan: a denial is reviewed fresh unless the plan gives the administrator discretion to decide eligibility or interpret its terms[7]. Either way, the attorney wants the whole file early.
The rules help. On appeal, the claimant is entitled on request, free of charge, to reasonable access to and copies of all documents, records and other information relevant to the claim, and for disability claims the plan must share any new evidence or new rationale before it decides[2]. Separately, the plan administrator must furnish the summary plan description and the governing plan documents on written request[4], and a failure to provide requested information can bring a court-ordered penalty of up to $110 a day[8]. Those requests go out from the firm after engagement. Intake's job is to collect the details that make them possible.
- Insurer name, claim number and the claims manager named on the letters.
- Employer name, the HR or benefits contact, and the policy or group number from a benefits booklet or pay stub.
- Every letter from the insurer in date order, including requests for forms and any notice of an independent medical exam.
- Treating doctors and therapists, with the date the caller last saw each one.
- Any short-term disability claim, Social Security application or workers' compensation claim, with its status.
The pre-consultation document guide has the request message. For LTD callers, ask first for the latest letter and the policy booklet, and let the rest follow.
Intake questions for an LTD caller
| Ask | Why the attorney needs it |
|---|---|
| How did you get this coverage: your employer, a union, a government employer, or a policy you bought yourself? | Whether ERISA applies, and which rules and court process follow |
| Who is the insurer, and what is the claim number? | Identifies the file and the claims office |
| Where is the claim now: pending, cut off, denied, or appeal decided? | The stage sets the urgency and the work |
| What date is on the latest letter, and when did you receive it? | Starts the attorney's deadline count |
| Have you already sent an appeal? When, and what did you include? | A filed appeal may limit what can still be added |
| What was your job, and what did it require physically and mentally? | Disability is usually measured against job duties |
| When did you last work, and are you still employed or on leave? | Onset, leave status and benefit timing |
| What conditions keep you from working, and who treats you? | Medical records and opinions to request |
| Have you applied for Social Security disability or short-term disability? | Many LTD policies offset other benefits |
| Has the insurer scheduled an exam, interview or anything else you know of? | Near-term events the attorney may want to prepare for |
Callers who tire or lose the thread
Disability callers can run out of energy halfway through. Plan for a two-part call: the date, the stage and the plan type in the first ten minutes, then a scheduled callback for work history and treatment. Let a spouse or adult child help on the line if the caller asks, and note who was on the call. Some callers use relay services; under the ADA, businesses open to the public must accept relay calls and treat them like any other call[9]. Expect longer pauses and do not rush the operator.
Avoid the phrases that land badly: “you look fine on paper”, “the insurer must have had a reason”, “just appeal it yourself”. The last one is legal advice and it can do harm. Staff can say instead: “The attorney will look at the letter and the dates. Here is when you will hear from us.”
From first call to attorney review
- Caller
- SI Employee
- Your team
01Caller
Calls about a denial
Benefits denied or stopped; the caller has a letter from the insurer.
02SI Employee
Claim stage and dates
Pending, denied or appeal decided; the letter date and the date received.
03SI Employee
Plan type
Employer, union, government or individual policy; insurer and claim number.
04SI Employee
Urgency rule
A letter older than the firm's threshold goes to the urgent path the firm set.
05Your team
Documents requested
Latest letter and policy booklet first; the claim file follows.
06Your team
Attorney decides
Deadline, strategy and whether to take the case.
Example sequence. The urgency threshold is the firm's own rule, for instance any letter dated more than 120 days ago, not a legal deadline.
Disability callers often phone in the evening, when a spouse is home to help, or at the weekend after opening the mail. When the firm forwards its line after hours, an SI Employee can ask these questions in the firm's order, mark a caller holding a four-month-old denial as urgent under the escalation tree, and leave the attorney a summary with the recording and transcript. It does not tell anyone how long they have. The AssistCall overview lists what is live today, and the solo injury lawyer example models a similar after-hours set-up for a contingency practice.
Example: the letter dated in March
Example. In mid-August a former warehouse supervisor calls about long-term disability benefits that stopped in the spring. The termination letter is dated March 3, and she remembers it arriving on March 7. She phoned the insurer twice, sent a note from her doctor, and assumed that counted as an appeal. She has not heard back.
Intake records the letter date, the receipt date and what she sent, without telling her whether the doctor's note was an appeal. The coverage came through her employer, a private company, so intake notes the plan as probably under ERISA, as reported. In this example, 180 days from March 7 falls on September 3, so under the firm's rule the call reaches the attorney the same evening. Staff ask her to photograph the letter and the benefits booklet tonight. Had she called in May, the firm would have had four months to build the record. Now it has about three weeks, and only the attorney can say what is still possible.
The hand-off note
Status line
Stage, letter date, receipt date and whether anything has gone to the insurer, in one sentence at the top.
Plan
Employer and its type, insurer, claim and policy numbers, and how the caller got the coverage.
Work and health
Job duties, last day worked, conditions in the caller's words, treating providers and recent visit dates.
Other benefits
Short-term disability, Social Security, workers' compensation or leave, each with status and dates.
Documents and access
What the caller has, what was requested, the best time to call and any help the caller needs on the phone.
Callers who may also have an employment claim against the employer, such as a firing during medical leave, need that flagged separately. Different deadlines apply, and it may be a different attorney's matter.
Frequently asked questions
Does the 180-day appeal window apply to every disability policy?
The federal minimum of 180 days applies to disability plans governed by ERISA[2]. Government plans, church plans that have not opted in and individual policies follow other rules[3], so intake records how the coverage was obtained and the attorney confirms the deadline.
Should intake tell the caller to send an appeal right away?
No. Telling a caller what to file is legal advice, and a rushed appeal can leave out evidence. Intake captures the dates, flags urgency and gets the attorney involved quickly.
The caller can't find the denial letter. What now?
Note the approximate date and how it arrived, and ask whether a copy sits in an online claim portal or email. The firm can request the claim file after engagement; the regulation gives claimants free copies of relevant documents on request[2].
Is long-term disability the same as Social Security disability?
No. LTD is insurance through an employer or a private policy; Social Security disability is a federal program with its own process. Many callers have applied for both, which is why intake asks about each.
Can intake ask about the caller's medical conditions?
Yes, in the caller's own words and only as far as the attorney's question list goes. Keep the notes in the firm's confidential intake system, not in personal email or text threads.
References
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employee Benefits in the United States, March 2026 (news release) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 29 CFR 2560.503-1 - Claims procedure (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 29 U.S. Code § 1003 - Coverage (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 29 U.S. Code § 1024 - Filing with Secretary and furnishing information to participants (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Insurance benefits: Access, participation, and take-up rates for private industry workers by establishment size, March 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2013). Heimeshoff v. Hartford Life & Accident Insurance Co., 571 U.S. 99 (2013) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (1989). Firestone Tire & Rubber Co. v. Bruch, 489 U.S. 101 (1989) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 29 CFR 2575.502c-1 - Adjusted civil penalty under section 502(c)(1) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division (ADA.gov) (2026). ADA Requirements: Effective Communication (opens in a new tab) ↑