Key takeaways
- Start with deadlines and court dates: a switching client's case keeps running while lawyers change.
- On termination, the prior lawyer must surrender papers and property the client is entitled to and refund unearned fees[1].
- Tell the client in writing that the prior lawyer may claim part of the fee, and how fee divisions between firms work[1].
- Draw a clear line in the engagement letter for when your responsibility begins.
Why switching clients need a different intake
A new client who already has a lawyer is not a blank file. There is a court with a schedule, an opposing party with a lawyer, a prior fee agreement, a file in someone else's office and, often, money in another firm's trust account. Ordinary intake questions miss most of that. A short, separate checklist for substitution calls protects the client, the firm and the case.
Rule 4.2 does not stand in the way. The comment to Florida's no-contact rule says it does not preclude communication with a represented person who is seeking advice from a lawyer who is not otherwise representing a client in the matter[1]. The client may consult you and may change lawyers. Your job is to make the change safe.
The first call: what to collect
| Item | Why it matters | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Court, case number and judge | Locate the docket and local substitution rules | Client, docket |
| Next hearing, deadline or trial date | Decide how fast the firm must move | Client, docket, prior lawyer |
| Opposing parties and their counsel | Conflict check | Client, docket |
| Prior lawyer's name and firm | Conflict check and file request | Client |
| Has the client ended the relationship? | Who acts for the client today | Client |
| Fee agreement with the prior lawyer | Lien or fee claim on the outcome | Client, prior lawyer |
| Money held in the prior lawyer's trust account | Refund of unearned amounts | Client, prior lawyer |
| Liens from medical providers or insurers | Settlement distribution in injury cases | Client, prior lawyer |
Ask about dates before anything else. A pending motion with a response due in four days changes the order of every other step. If the date is close, the attorney may need to speak with the client the same day and decide whether the firm can step in in time.
Step by step from call to substitution
Run conflicts on everyone
Include the opposing parties, their counsel, the prior lawyer and firm, and any lienholders. A firm that has worked with or against the prior lawyer recently may need an attorney to look closer.
Confirm the client's decision
The client decides whether to change lawyers. Do not tell them to fire their lawyer before an attorney has reviewed the matter, and do not criticize the prior lawyer's work.
Review enough to accept or decline
Look at the docket and key filings before the client signs. Some cases are taken over late because something has gone wrong, and the attorney should see that before agreeing.
Sign the engagement letter
Define the scope, the fee, and the date and event when your responsibility begins, such as the court's order granting substitution.
File the substitution
Use the court's procedure, which may be a stipulation signed by both lawyers or a motion. Calendar the hearing if one is needed.
Request the file in writing
Send the prior lawyer a request signed by the client, asking for the complete file, including electronic records, and any trust balance.
Notify everyone
Tell opposing counsel, update service lists and e-filing accounts, and add every inherited deadline to the firm's calendar.
The file and the trust account
Prior counsel has duties too. Under Florida's rule, which tracks ABA Model Rule 1.16(d), a lawyer whose representation ends must take reasonable steps to protect the client's interests, including surrendering papers and property to which the client is entitled and refunding any advance payment of fee or expense that has not been earned or incurred[1]. The same rule allows the lawyer to retain papers and property to the extent permitted by law[1], which is where state retaining-lien law and court rules come in.
Make the request easy to answer. Send it as a letter signed by the client, list what you need, give a reasonable date and offer to collect electronic files by secure transfer. If the prior lawyer asserts a retaining lien, have the attorney review state law before the client's deadlines are affected; many courts will order release of files a client urgently needs.
- Pleadings, orders, correspondence and discovery, including electronic versions.
- Expert reports, medical records and other evidence gathered for the case.
- Settlement offers and demand letters sent or received.
- The prior fee agreement and a statement of fees and costs.
- The trust account ledger for the client and any balance due back.
Fee claims from the prior lawyer
In contingency cases, the prior lawyer usually expects to be paid for work done before discharge, often through a charging lien or a claim on the eventual fee. The client needs to understand this before signing with you, because it affects what they will net and how settlement money will be distributed.
When fees are divided between firms, the rules limit how. Florida allows a division between lawyers in different firms only if the total fee is reasonable and the division is either in proportion to the services each performed, or made by written agreement with the client in which each lawyer assumes joint responsibility and the basis of the division is fully disclosed[1]. Many states follow a similar approach.
Script for the intake call: "Your previous lawyer may be entitled to be paid for the work they did. That usually comes out of the overall fee rather than as an extra charge to you, but the attorney will explain exactly how it would work in your case before you sign anything."
Money is usually on the caller's mind. In the Legal Services Corporation's research, 46% of low-income Americans who did not seek help for a legal problem cited concerns about cost[2]. A switching client who fears paying twice may stay with a lawyer they have lost confidence in, so clear fee information on the first call matters.
When the old lawyer is still holding the retainer
In hourly matters, the problem is often cash. The client paid a retainer to the prior lawyer, believes much of it is unearned and cannot pay a new retainer until it comes back. Federal Reserve data show only 63% of US adults would cover a $400 emergency expense completely with cash or its equivalent in 2025[3], so a second retainer is a real barrier for many clients.
Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, 2025[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2021 | 68% |
| 2025 | 63% |
- Ask for the prior lawyer's final invoice and trust ledger in the file request.
- Agree with the client how your retainer will be funded if the refund is delayed.
- If the client disputes the prior bill, tell them about the bar's fee dispute or arbitration program rather than taking on the dispute yourself without a separate engagement.
- Do not start substantive work on an unpaid retainer unless the firm has decided to do so in writing.
Callers who say they cannot reach their lawyer
Many substitution calls start with a complaint that the current lawyer does not return calls. The broader data make that plausible: in Clio's 2024 secret-shopper study, only 40% of US firms answered the phone and 33% answered emails[4]. Note the complaint for the attorney, but do not repeat or endorse it. Sometimes the prior lawyer is in trial, ill or has closed the practice, and a call from your attorney resolves things faster than a substitution.
Mistakes that cause trouble later
- Taking the story before running conflicts on the prior lawyer and every party.
- Promising the client the old lawyer "won't get anything."
- Starting work before the substitution is approved, then missing a deadline that neither firm thought was its own.
- Requesting the file by phone, with no client signature and no date.
- Forgetting liens from medical providers, insurers or government programs until settlement.
- Leaving the old lawyer on the e-filing service list, so notices go to the wrong office.
Each of these is avoidable with the checklist above. Give the checklist its own intake template so staff use it every time a caller mentions another lawyer, rather than relying on memory.
Example: a late substitution
Example: A fictional caller has a car accident case with a lawyer who has not returned calls for six weeks. Intake asks the dates first and learns a deposition is set in eleven days. The attorney reviews the docket that afternoon, signs the client the next day with a letter stating the firm's responsibility begins when substitution is approved, files a stipulated substitution signed by both lawyers, sends the client-signed file request and asks opposing counsel to move the deposition by two weeks, which they agree to. The engagement letter explains that the prior lawyer has asserted a claim to a share of the fee and how it will be resolved.
Frequently asked questions
Can I talk to someone who already has a lawyer about taking their case?
Yes. The no-contact rule protects represented people from lawyers acting for another party in the matter. It does not stop a represented person from consulting a new lawyer about their own case.
Does the previous lawyer have to give the client the file?
On termination, a lawyer must surrender papers and property to which the client is entitled and refund unearned fees, subject to what state law permits the lawyer to retain.
Who pays the prior lawyer in a contingency case?
Usually the prior lawyer's claim is paid from the overall fee, but it depends on the agreements and state law. Explain it to the client in writing before they sign.
When does my responsibility for the case begin?
Say so in the engagement letter, for example on the date the court approves substitution, and calendar every inherited deadline immediately.
References
The Florida Bar (2026). Rules Regulating The Florida Bar, Chapter 4: Rules of Professional Conduct (Rules 4-1.5, 4-1.16 and 4-4.2) (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) โ
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2025). Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households: Unexpected expenses (data table) (opens in a new tab) โ
Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism (2Civility) (2024). Phone Calls Ignored, Emails Unanswered: Fixing the First Impression Problem for Law Firms (opens in a new tab) โ