Phones and Call Handling

When Scammers Impersonate Your Law Firm by Phone

What to do when scammers use your firm's name or number: a first-24-hours plan, scripts for worried callers, client warnings, reporting and prevention.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. What impersonation looks like
  2. The scale of imposter fraud
  3. The first 24 hours
  4. What to tell people who call about it
  5. If someone has already paid
  6. Warn clients and the public
  7. Spoofing and the law
  8. When your number gets labeled as spam
  9. Voice cloning and payment instructions
  10. Keep a clear record
  11. Example: a spoofing week at a small firm
  12. Prevention checklist
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References
Phones and Call Handling: When Scammers Impersonate Your Law Firm by PhoneArticle coverPHONES AND CALL HANDLINGWhen ScammersImpersonate Your LawFirm by PhoneAva for LawyersInsightsPhones and Call Handling: When Scammers Impersonate Your Law Firm by PhoneArticle coverPHONES AND CALL HANDLINGWhen ScammersImpersonate Your LawFirm by PhoneAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Act within a day: log every report, warn callers on your website and voicemail, tell clients how to verify, and report the scam.
  • Imposter scams are big business: US consumers reported losing $2.95 billion to them in 2024, and phone calls were the second most common contact method for fraud[1].
  • Spoofing caller ID with intent to defraud or cause harm is unlawful under federal law[2], but stopping it is slow, so focus on protecting clients.
  • Publish one simple rule: the firm never asks for payment by phone through gift cards, wire transfers or crypto, and anyone unsure should call the number on the firm's website.

What impersonation looks like

Law firm impersonation usually reaches the firm second-hand. Someone calls the office, confused or angry, saying they got a call from your firm about money. The details vary, but a few patterns recur:

  • Settlement or award scams: a caller claims the person has won a settlement and must pay a fee or tax to release it.
  • Fake court fees: a caller using a real attorney's name says a court fee or fine must be paid today to avoid arrest or default.
  • Recovery scams: people who already lost money are told the firm can recover it for an upfront payment.
  • Debt threats: a caller claims to be from a law firm about to file suit unless a debt is paid immediately.
  • Spoofed callbacks: the scammer's call shows your firm's real number on caller ID, so the victim trusts it.

Scammers choose law firms because legal authority makes people act quickly, and because attorney names, bar numbers and office addresses are public.

The scale of imposter fraud

Reported US fraud losses, 2024 (USD)
Reported US fraud losses, 2024 (USD)Comparison. All reported fraud: 12.5 billion; Imposter scams: 2.95 billion.12.5 billionAll reported fraudAll reported fraud: 12.5 billion2.95 billionImposter scamsImposter scams: 2.95 billionReported US fraud losses, 2024 (USD)Comparison. All reported fraud: 12.5 billion; Imposter scams: 2.95 billion.12.5 billionAll reported fraudAll reported fraud: 12.5 billion2.95 billionImposter scamsImposter scams: 2.95 billion

Source: Federal Trade Commission, 2025[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
All reported fraud12.5 billion
Imposter scams2.95 billion

The FTC reported that consumers lost more than $12.5 billion to fraud in 2024. Imposter scams accounted for the second-highest loss amount, $2.95 billion, and phone calls were the second most commonly reported contact method, followed by text messages[1]. A firm whose name is used in one of these schemes is not just dealing with a nuisance; its clients and its community may be losing real money in its name.

The first 24 hours

  1. Start a log

    Record every report: date and time, who reported it, the number that appeared, the name used, what was asked for and whether money was lost.

  2. Brief everyone who answers

    Give staff and any answering service the script below, so every worried caller hears the same clear answer.

  3. Post a notice

    Add a short warning to the website's home and contact pages, and a line to the main voicemail greeting.

  4. Tell clients

    Send a short email to current clients explaining what is happening and how to verify any call from the firm.

  5. Report it

    File reports with the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, the FCC if your number is being spoofed, your state attorney general and, if money was lost, local police. Tell your phone provider.

  6. Notify your insurer and bar

    Inform your malpractice insurer and consider notifying the state bar, especially if an attorney's name is being used.

What to tell people who call about it

Script: β€œThank you for calling to check. That call did not come from our firm. We never ask anyone to pay by gift card, wire transfer or cryptocurrency over the phone. Please don't send any money or personal information. If you've already paid, contact your bank right away and report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. May I note a few details so we can include them in our report?”

If they are a current client: β€œYou did the right thing by calling the number on our website. Your attorney's office will only contact you from this number or by email from our domain. If you're ever unsure, hang up and call us here.”

Stay calm and kind. Many callers feel embarrassed, and some have already paid. They are calling because they trust the real firm; keep that trust by being clear and helpful.

If someone has already paid

Some callers will have sent money before they think to check. Tell them to contact their bank or card issuer immediately, because some payment methods can be stopped or disputed if reported quickly, and to report the loss at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and to local police. If they paid by gift card, they should contact the card's issuer with the card numbers and receipts. Record what happened in the log. If the person is a current client, the matter attorney should call them personally the same day; a short, kind call from the real firm does a great deal to repair trust and to protect the client from follow-up recovery scams.

Warn clients and the public

Website notice: β€œScam alert: we have received reports of calls falsely using our firm's name or phone number to request payments. [Firm name] will never ask you to pay by gift card, wire transfer or cryptocurrency by phone. If you receive a suspicious call, hang up and call us at [main number], listed on this website.”

Keep the notice up for several weeks after reports stop. Add a one-sentence version to the main voicemail greeting and to the hold message, and mention it in any client newsletter. Translate it into the main languages your clients speak; scammers often target communities in their own language, as covered in call handling for Spanish-speaking callers.

Spoofing and the law

Federal law makes it unlawful to cause a caller ID service to knowingly transmit misleading or inaccurate caller identification information with intent to defraud, cause harm or wrongfully obtain anything of value, in connection with voice or text services[2]. That gives regulators tools, but individual spoofing campaigns are hard to trace and rarely stop quickly. The firm's best response is to make verification easy for clients and to keep a clear record of reports.

When your number gets labeled as spam

After a spoofing campaign, carriers may start labeling your real number as spam because people report the scam calls against it. Then genuine callbacks go unanswered, which hurts more than usual because 80% of US adults already say they generally do not answer unknown numbers[3]. Ask your phone provider to check how major carriers label your number, to register your caller name and to file remediation requests. Some firms also add a secondary outbound number for callbacks during the campaign.

Voice cloning and payment instructions

Synthetic voices make impersonation more convincing. The FCC ruled in 2024 that calls using AI-generated voices are artificial under the TCPA[4], which brings them under the robocall rules, but a cloned voice can still sound like a real attorney. Protect the firm's own money flows with rules that a voice alone cannot satisfy.

  • Never change wire or payment instructions based on a phone call or an email alone; confirm through a known number.
  • Tell clients at engagement that the firm will never send new payment instructions by phone.
  • Use a call-back rule for any request involving trust account funds.
  • Train staff that urgency plus a payment request is a reason to slow down.

Keep a clear record

Fields for an impersonation report log
FieldWhy it matters
Date and time of the scam callShows the pattern and timing
Number shown on caller IDSupports spoofing reports and carrier remediation
Name the caller usedShows whether a real attorney's name is being used
What was requested and howGift cards, wire, crypto or personal data
Whether money was lost, and how muchHelps police and regulators prioritize
Who at the firm took the reportAllows follow-up
Actions takenReports filed, notice posted, client informed

The log also protects the firm. If a victim later claims the firm took their money, a record of prompt warnings and reports shows what the firm did and when.

Example: a spoofing week at a small firm

Example (fictional): over three days, a small debt defense firm received calls from people saying the firm had called them demanding payment to stop a lawsuit. The calls showed the firm's real number. The office manager started a log, posted a website notice, added a line to the voicemail greeting and emailed current clients. Staff used the script with every caller, and the firm filed reports with the FTC and FCC and asked its provider to check carrier labels. Reports tapered off within two weeks, and no current client lost money.

Prevention checklist

  • Publish a standing statement on the website about how the firm does and does not ask for payment.
  • Tell every new client how the firm will contact them and how to verify a call.
  • Keep the firm's numbers and caller name registered with your provider.
  • Have a ready-to-post notice and email template, so the first day goes quickly.
  • Train staff on the script and the log once a year.

Clear communication protects trust that is already fragile: only 20% of Americans rate lawyers' honesty and ethics as high or very high[5]. A firm that warns its clients quickly and plainly is far less likely to be blamed for a scam it did not commit. Pair this plan with the screening rules in screening sales calls and robocalls, the professional-caller rules in handling calls from opposing counsel and courts, and an overflow plan for high-volume days, since a scam wave can bring a sudden surge of worried callers.

Frequently asked questions

What should a law firm do if scammers use its name?

Log every report, give staff a consistent script, post a warning on the website and voicemail, email current clients about how to verify calls, and report the scam to the FTC, the FCC if your number is spoofed, your state attorney general and police if money was lost.

Can scammers make calls show our real phone number?

Yes. Caller ID spoofing with intent to defraud or cause harm is unlawful under federal law, but it still happens. Tell clients to hang up and call the number on your website if they are unsure.

Should we tell clients about impersonation calls?

Yes, promptly and plainly. Explain what is happening, state how the firm does and does not ask for payment, and tell them how to verify any call.

Our number is now labeled as spam. What can we do?

Ask your phone provider to check carrier labels, register your caller name and file remediation requests. Consider a secondary outbound number for callbacks while the campaign lasts.

References

  1. Federal Trade Commission (2025). New FTC Data Show a Big Jump in Reported Losses to Fraud to $12.5 Billion in 2024 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2025). 47 U.S. Code Β§ 227 - Restrictions on use of telephone equipment (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Federal Communications Commission (2024). FCC Makes AI-Generated Voices in Robocalls Illegal (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Gallup (2025). Nurses Continue to Lead in Honesty and Ethics Ratings (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo