Key takeaways
- Federal law allows recording with one party's consent, but some states require every party's consent[1]. Firms taking calls from several states usually disclose on every recorded call.
- Avoid voice analysis unless you have written notice and a release: Illinois treats a voiceprint as a biometric identifier[2], with damages up to $5,000 per intentional violation.
- Treat recordings and transcripts as confidential client information, with set retention periods, limited access and logged listening.
- Check where transcripts and summaries are processed; California Bar guidance warns against putting confidential information into AI tools that pose material confidentiality risks without informed consent[3].
Why record intake calls at all
Recording intake calls helps in four ways. Staff do not have to scribble while a distressed caller talks, so the details are more accurate. Supervisors can review real calls for training. The firm has a record if there is ever a dispute about what was said or promised. And quality checks become possible without sitting next to the person answering.
Recording also creates obligations. Every recording is confidential information about a prospective client, often captured before the firm has decided to take the matter. It needs a lawful basis, a disclosure, secure storage, a retention period and access controls. If the firm is not ready to manage those, it is better to record nothing than to record everything and manage none of it.
The consent rules in brief
Under the federal wiretap statute, a private person may record a call they are part of, or one where a party has given prior consent, unless the recording is made for a criminal or tortious purpose[1]. State laws can be stricter, and several states require the consent of everyone on the call. This is not legal advice for your firm; check the statute in your state and in the states your callers are likely to be in.
Because a caller's location is often unknown, many firms simply disclose on every recorded call, at the start, before anything substantive is said. Continuing the call after a clear disclosure is commonly treated as consent, but if a caller objects, stop recording or offer another way to talk. For a closer look at one strict state, see the Massachusetts Wiretap Act and recorded intake calls.
Disclosure wording
Inbound greeting: βThank you for calling [Firm name]. This call may be recorded so we can make sure we have your details right.β
Outbound callback: βHi, this is [name] from [Firm name], returning your call. Before we start, I'll let you know this call is recorded for accuracy. Is that all right?β
If the caller objects: βNo problem at all. I've stopped the recording. Let's continue.β Then stop it, and note in the file that the call was not recorded at the caller's request.
Keep the disclosure plain and early. Do not bury it in a long greeting or play it after a menu. If an answering service or AI intake answers for you, make sure its greeting carries the same disclosure.
Calls with more than two people
Intake calls often include more than the caller and the staff member: an interpreter, a family member on speaker, a referring professional on a three-way call. Each extra person is another party whose consent may matter in an all-party state. Repeat the disclosure when someone joins, and ask the interpreter service whether it records on its side, since its recording may be kept under its own retention rules.
Be careful with family members who join on speaker. Note who was present in the file, because a third party on the line can affect how the conversation is treated later, and the attorney may want to know before relying on what was said.
Voiceprints and biometrics
Source: Illinois General Assembly, 2025[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Negligent violation | $1,000 |
| Intentional or reckless violation | $5,000 |
Some phone and analytics tools offer voice analysis, such as speaker identification or caller verification. Illinois' Biometric Information Privacy Act defines a voiceprint as a biometric identifier and bars private entities from collecting one without first informing the person in writing and obtaining a written release[2]. A prevailing party can recover $1,000 per negligent violation or $5,000 per intentional or reckless violation, or actual damages if greater[2].
For most firms the simple answer is to switch off any voice biometric feature. A recording on its own is not the concern; building a voiceprint from it is. Ask every phone, tracking and transcription vendor whether any such feature is on by default.
Transcripts, summaries and AI tools
Many systems now transcribe recordings and write summaries automatically. That is useful, and it copies confidential information into more places. California's State Bar guidance says a lawyer must not input confidential client information into a generative AI tool that may present material risks to confidentiality or security, absent informed client consent[3]. Before turning transcription on, find out where processing happens, whether content is used to train models, how long the vendor keeps it and whether it is separated from other customers' data.
If you use an SI Employee such as Ava, each call arrives in your account with a summary, recording and transcript, so apply the same retention and access rules to that account as to your phone system.
When not to record
- When the caller asks you not to, after the disclosure.
- Internal calls between staff and attorneys about strategy, which belong in privileged notes, not a phone system.
- Calls with existing clients about the substance of their matter, unless the firm has a clear reason and a policy covering them.
- Calls on lines where the disclosure cannot be played, such as some direct dials or mobile apps without a prompt.
- Calls where the system's storage or access settings have not yet been reviewed.
Recording less, on purpose, is easier to defend and to manage than recording everything by default.
Storage and access
- Store recordings in one system, encrypted at rest, rather than downloading them to laptops or email.
- Limit listening to the roles that need it: intake lead, supervising attorney, office manager.
- Require multi-factor login for any account that can play recordings.
- Use logs that show who listened to or downloaded which recording, and review them periodically.
- Never forward recordings to personal devices or messaging apps.
- Remove access for departing staff on their last day.
Retention
No single retention period suits every firm, and your state's record-keeping rules and your malpractice carrier's guidance should shape yours. What matters is that you choose periods deliberately, write them down and apply them automatically.
| Recording type | A starting point to discuss with counsel | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Caller became a client | Keep with the client file under your file-retention policy | Link the recording to the matter |
| Caller declined or not a fit | Keep for a defined period after the declination letter | Supports proof of what was said and declined |
| Conflict found, no engagement | Keep only what your conflict records require | Minimize detail kept |
| Spam, wrong numbers, vendors | Delete quickly | No reason to keep |
| Test calls and training samples | Delete after scoring or training | Anonymize any kept examples |
Set the deletion rules in the system itself. A retention policy that depends on someone remembering to delete files will not be followed.
Breach exposure
Recordings and transcripts are attractive to anyone who gains access to your systems. For businesses covered by the CCPA, statutory damages for a data breach rose in 2025 to between $107 and $799 per consumer per incident, or actual damages if greater[4]. Even firms outside the CCPA face state breach-notification laws and professional obligations. Fewer recordings kept for shorter periods means less exposure.
Write the policy in six steps
Decide what to record
Usually intake lines only, not every extension.
Set the disclosure
Inbound greeting, outbound callback wording and what to do if a caller objects.
Check the vendors
Recording, transcription and analytics features, data location, training use and biometric settings.
Define access
Roles that may listen, login requirements and logging.
Set retention
Periods by recording type, configured as automatic deletion.
Train and review
Brief staff, then review the disclosure and logs every quarter.
Example: tightening a recording setup
Example (fictional): a mid-sized injury firm discovered that its phone system recorded every extension, kept recordings forever and allowed every user to play any call. A voice-analytics add-on had also been switched on during a trial. The firm limited recording to intake lines, added a disclosure to the greeting and to outbound callbacks, turned off the voice analytics, restricted listening to three roles and set automatic deletion periods. The cleanup removed years of recordings the firm had no reason to keep.
Related settings to check
Recording touches several parts of the phone setup. Check that any call tracking platform follows the same rules, that new numbers from your number strategy carry the disclosure, and that your message-taking standard still captures the key facts in writing, so nobody has to replay a recording to find a phone number.
Frequently asked questions
Can a law firm record intake calls?
Generally yes, with the right consent. Federal law allows one-party consent, but some states require every party's consent, so most firms disclose recording at the start of every recorded call. Check your state's statute.
What should a call recording disclosure say?
Keep it short and early, for example: this call may be recorded so we can make sure we have your details right. Use similar wording on outbound callbacks, and stop recording if a caller objects.
How long should we keep intake call recordings?
Set periods by type: recordings for new clients usually follow your file-retention policy, declined callers for a defined period, and spam or test calls only briefly. Configure automatic deletion and confirm the approach with counsel.
Are call transcripts covered by the same rules?
Treat them the same as recordings: confidential, access-limited and subject to retention. Check where transcription happens and whether the vendor uses content to train models.
References
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2025). 18 U.S. Code Β§ 2511 - Interception and disclosure of wire, oral, or electronic communications prohibited (opens in a new tab) β
Illinois General Assembly (2025). Biometric Information Privacy Act (740 ILCS 14) (opens in a new tab) β
The State Bar of California, Standing Committee on Professional Responsibility and Conduct (2026). Practical Guidance for the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence in the Practice of Law (opens in a new tab) β
California Privacy Protection Agency (2025). Updated Monetary Thresholds in CCPA (opens in a new tab) β