Practice Area Playbooks

Expungement and Record Sealing Intake

Expungement and record sealing intake: eligibility screening questions, getting the actual record, clean slate checks, red flags and cost concerns.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Most people who qualify never apply
  2. What the caller usually wants
  3. A short opening script
  4. Eligibility screening questions
  5. Get the actual record
  6. Terms that confuse callers
  7. Red flags and special cases
  8. Decision criteria for the attorney's first look
  9. Callers who are not eligible yet
  10. Cost, access and referrals
  11. Example: a job offer and a twelve-year-old conviction
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References
Practice Area Playbooks: Expungement and Record Sealing IntakeArticle coverPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSExpungement and RecordSealing IntakeAva for LawyersInsightsPractice Area Playbooks: Expungement and Record Sealing IntakeArticle coverPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSExpungement andRecord Sealing IntakeAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Most eligible people never apply: in a Michigan study, just 6.5% obtained an expungement within five years of becoming eligible[1].
  • Screen from the actual record, not memory; callers often misremember charges, dispositions and dates.
  • Ask about pending cases, supervision, out-of-state and federal records, and immigration status on every call.
  • Explain fees plainly: 46% of low-income Americans who did not seek legal help cited cost concerns[2].

Most people who qualify never apply

Record-clearing work has an unusual problem: the people who could benefit mostly never ask. Researchers studying Michigan's law found that among people legally eligible for expungement, just 6.5% obtained it within five years of becoming eligible[1]. The reasons include not knowing about the law, not knowing they qualify, cost, and a process that looks complicated from outside.

Legally eligible people who obtained an expungement within five years (Michigan study)
Legally eligible people who obtained an expungement within five years (Michigan study)Donut chart. Obtained an expungement: 6.5%.Obtained an expungement: 6.5%6.5%
  • Obtained an expungement 6.5%

Source: Harvard Law Review, 2020[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Obtained an expungement6.5%

The same study found clear benefits for those who did clear their records: within one year, wages went up by over 22% compared with the pre-expungement trajectory[1]. For a firm, that means a caller who makes it to your phone has already overcome real barriers. Intake should make the next step easy, give honest information about eligibility screening, and avoid sending people away with a vague maybe.

What the caller usually wants

Ask early why the caller wants their record cleared. The answer shapes urgency and sometimes the remedy. A caller with a job offer conditional on a background check, a housing application, a professional license application or a custody case has a deadline. A caller who simply wants the record gone has more time but may need more encouragement.

  • A job, a promotion or a professional license.
  • Housing, including public housing or a rental application.
  • School admission or financial aid.
  • Immigration, travel or naturalization, which needs special care.
  • A family court matter, adoption or guardianship.
  • Peace of mind, and no longer having to explain the past.

A short opening script

Script: Thanks for calling about clearing your record. I'm not a lawyer, but I'll ask some questions so an attorney can look at whether you may qualify. There's no judgment here; we talk with people about old cases every day. Do you have any court papers or a background check report you could send us? That helps us get the details right.

Many callers are embarrassed or expect to be judged. Starting with reassurance and a practical request for documents lowers the temperature and gets better information. Avoid asking why the caller committed the offense; it is irrelevant to eligibility at this stage and makes many people hang up.

Eligibility screening questions

Eligibility rules differ widely by state and by the type of record. Intake does not decide eligibility; it gathers the facts the attorney needs to decide it quickly.

Expungement eligibility questions and why the attorney needs each
QuestionWhy it matters
Which state, county and court handled each case?Each jurisdiction has its own rules and process
What was the outcome of each case: dismissed, acquitted, diverted, convicted?Non-conviction records are often easier to clear
What was the offense, and was it a misdemeanor or felony?Some offenses are excluded or have longer waiting periods
When did the case end, and when was any sentence, probation or parole completed?Waiting periods usually run from completion
Have all fines, fees and restitution been paid?Some states require payment first
How many convictions are on the record in total?Many states limit how many can be cleared
Are there any pending charges, or are you on probation or parole now?These usually block or delay relief
Are any cases federal, military or from another state?Different systems and very different rules
Were any records from when you were under 18?Juvenile records follow separate sealing rules

Get the actual record

Callers often misremember their own history, sometimes in both directions. A charge they think was dismissed was a conviction, or a conviction they fear is on their record was reduced. Screen from documents wherever possible.

  1. Ask what the caller already has

    Court papers, plea forms, probation discharge letters, and any background check report they received from an employer or landlord.

  2. Request the state record

    Most states let people request their own criminal history from the state repository. Explain how, or offer to help with the request once engaged.

  3. Check court dockets

    The firm can check public dockets in the relevant counties for dispositions and dates.

  4. Consider a federal check

    For anyone with possible federal or out-of-state history, a national identity history summary may be needed.

  5. Compare and reconcile

    Records from different sources often disagree. Note every discrepancy for the attorney.

Ask callers to photograph and upload what they have through a secure link. Pew finds 91% of US adults own a smartphone[3], so most can send a background check report or court paper during the call.

Keep copies of every record the firm obtains in the matter file, with the date and source. If the petition is granted, those copies help the client check later that background check companies and agencies have updated their records, which is a common follow-up problem after relief is granted.

Terms that confuse callers

  • Expungement, sealing and set-aside mean different things in different states. Some destroy records, some hide them from most users, some change the conviction's legal effect. Use the caller's words in intake and let the attorney explain.
  • Clean slate laws in a growing number of states automatically seal some records after a waiting period. A caller may already have had relief without knowing, or may be waiting for it.
  • A pardon is a different remedy, usually from a governor or the President, with its own process.
  • Arrest records with no charges, or charges that were dropped, can still appear on background checks and may be clearable.

Red flags and special cases

  • Immigration: a state expungement may not remove immigration consequences of a conviction. Any noncitizen caller should speak with an attorney who understands both areas before taking steps.
  • Pending charges, warrants or current supervision: these usually need to be resolved first.
  • Registration requirements: sex offense registration usually follows separate rules.
  • Driving offenses: some records, such as impaired-driving convictions, may be excluded or treated differently for license purposes.
  • Firearms rights: restoration may need a separate process.
  • Professional licensing: some licensing boards can still see or ask about cleared records.

Decision criteria for the attorney's first look

  • Likely straightforward: non-conviction records, a single older misdemeanor with sentence completed, fines paid, no pending cases, all in one state.
  • Needs closer review: several convictions, felonies, offenses that may be excluded, unpaid fines or restitution, records in more than one state or court system.
  • Not yet: waiting period not complete, current supervision or pending charges. These callers may qualify later.
  • Different remedy: federal convictions, military records and cases where a pardon or certificate of rehabilitation may be the only route.
  • Urgent regardless: a job, housing or licensing deadline, or an immigration matter where the order of steps matters.

Callers who are not eligible yet

Many callers are a year or two short of a waiting period. Do not let them disappear. With their consent, record the date the attorney believes they may become eligible, and set a reminder to contact them then. A short letter explaining what needs to happen before that date, such as paying remaining fines or completing probation, is genuinely useful and builds the kind of trust that brings referrals.

  • Record the expected eligibility date and the conditions to meet before it.
  • Ask whether they want a reminder, and by which channel.
  • Check whether a clean slate law may clear the record automatically, and say so if the attorney confirms it.

Cost, access and referrals

Cost is a real barrier. Legal Services Corporation research found 46% of low-income Americans who did not seek legal help for a problem cited concerns about cost[2], and low-income Americans seek legal help for only 1 in 4 of the civil legal problems that substantially affect them[2]. Explain the firm's fees for record-clearing work plainly, in writing if possible, and keep a referral list of legal aid programs and expungement clinics for callers the firm cannot help.

Language access matters here too. Census data show 22% of US residents aged 5 and older speak a language other than English at home[4]. Offer intake in the caller's language where possible, and use qualified interpreters for any review of the record with the attorney.

Example: a job offer and a twelve-year-old conviction

Example: a caller has a job offer from a hospital, conditional on a background check. She has a misdemeanor theft conviction from twelve years ago and a later arrest that she says was dismissed. She finished probation on time and paid her fines. She is a US citizen with no pending cases.

Intake records both cases, asks her to upload the background check report the employer sent, and notes the employer's deadline. The report shows the dismissed arrest still listed. The summary flags two possible petitions, a time-sensitive job offer, and a clean history since. The attorney confirms eligibility from the dockets the next day.

Related: DUI defense intake, juvenile defense intake, immigration intake and recording intake calls: disclosure and storage.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know if I'm eligible for expungement?

It depends on your state, the type of case, the outcome, how long ago it ended, and whether you have other cases. A firm will usually review your actual record before giving an answer.

What is the difference between expungement and record sealing?

It varies by state. Some remedies destroy records, others hide them from most background checks, and some change a conviction's legal effect. An attorney can explain what applies to you.

Will expungement fix immigration problems from a conviction?

Not necessarily. A state expungement may not remove immigration consequences. Noncitizens should speak with an attorney who understands both criminal and immigration law first.

What is a clean slate law?

A law that automatically seals certain records after a waiting period without a petition. Not every state has one, and not every record qualifies.

References

  1. Harvard Law Review (2020). Expungement of Criminal Convictions: An Empirical Study (J.J. Prescott and Sonja B. Starr) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Pew Research Center (2026). Americans' Use of Mobile Devices in 2026 (Mobile Fact Sheet) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. U.S. Census Bureau (2025). New Data on Detailed Languages Spoken at Home and the Ability to Speak English (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo