Key takeaways
- Start with the denial or payment letter: its date, the reason given and any deadline it mentions. Then get the full policy, not just the declarations page.
- Capture the date of loss, the date it was reported and every inspection, payment and request from the insurer since.
- Many policies set their own deadline to sue; record the policy and the loss date so the attorney can check it at once.
- Claims are larger than they used to be: the average homeowners claim paid rose from $13,884 in 2019 to $20,062 in 2023[1].
- Displaced or cash-strapped homeowners need faster callbacks; only 63% of adults would cover a $400 emergency with cash[2].
Who calls, and what they usually have
Denied and underpaid property claims come from homeowners after storms, fires, burst pipes and roof failures, and from small business owners whose shop or rental property was damaged. By the time they call a lawyer they have usually spoken with an adjuster several times, received at least one letter, and started or delayed repairs. They are often tired, sometimes living elsewhere, and unsure whether the insurer's decision is final. Legal problems also tend to cluster: 74% of low-income US households experienced at least one civil legal problem in the past year[3]. Ask whether the loss has caused other problems, such as lender notices or a lease dispute.
Claims are a routine part of owning a home, and they have become more expensive. In 2023, 5.3% of insured homes had a claim, and property damage, including theft, accounted for 97.3% of homeowners insurance claims[1]. The average amount paid per claim rose from $13,884 in 2019 to $20,062 in 2023[1].
Source: Insurance Information Institute, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Period | Value |
|---|---|
| 2019 | $13,884 |
| 2020 | $14,864 |
| 2021 | $16,601 |
| 2022 | $19,740 |
| 2023 | $20,062 |
The first five questions
What does the insurer's letter say?
Ask the caller to read the date, the heading and the reason given for the denial or the amount paid. Ask whether it mentions any deadline, appraisal, reconsideration or right to sue.
When did the damage happen, and when was it reported?
Date of loss, date first reported, how it was reported and the claim number.
Who is the insurer and who is insured?
Company name, policy number, named insureds, and any mortgage lender listed on the policy.
What has the insurer paid or offered?
Amounts, dates and what each payment was for. Ask whether any check was cashed and whether it said full and final.
Where do things stand now?
Is the property livable? Are repairs done, in progress or on hold? Is damage continuing, such as a leak or mold?
Script: Please find the most recent letter from your insurance company and read me the date at the top and the paragraph that explains the decision. That tells the attorney what we're responding to and how quickly.
Policy and loss questions
| Topic | What to ask | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Policy type | Homeowners, condo, renters, landlord, commercial, flood or other separate policy | Different forms cover different perils |
| The full policy | Do you have the full policy with endorsements, or just the declarations page? | Exclusions and endorsements decide most denials |
| Cause of loss | What caused the damage, in your words? Wind, water, fire, theft, collapse, something else? | Coverage often turns on cause |
| Prior condition | Any earlier damage, repairs or claims on the same area? | Insurers often cite wear, age or prior damage |
| Inspections | Who inspected, when, and did you get their report? | Adjuster, engineer and contractor reports conflict often |
| Requests from the insurer | Recorded statement, sworn proof of loss, examination under oath, documents | Policy duties and their deadlines |
| Other professionals | Public adjuster, contractor, roofer or another lawyer already involved? | Contracts and fees may affect the matter |
Deadlines to record, not to calculate
Property claims have several overlapping clocks, and staff should never tell a caller that any of them has passed or that there is plenty of time. Record the facts that start each one and flag the file:
- The date of loss, because many policies contain a clause limiting the time to sue, often measured from the loss.
- The date of the denial or last payment letter.
- Any date the insurer has set for a proof of loss, documents or an examination under oath.
- Any appraisal demand made by either side and its date.
- State deadlines the attorney will check, such as notice requirements before a lawsuit in some states.
- For flood losses under a separate federal flood policy, note it clearly; those claims follow their own rules.
Answers to the questions callers ask
Property callers ask the same handful of questions. Give staff short, honest replies that do not stray into advice:
- Is the insurer's decision final? The attorney will review the letter and the policy and explain the options. Please don't assume it is final until you've spoken with them.
- Should I talk to the adjuster again? It's your decision, but please tell the attorney about any calls scheduled. If the insurer asks for a recorded or sworn statement, let us know right away.
- Can I throw away the damaged things? Please photograph everything first and ask the attorney before discarding anything that is part of the claim.
- Do I have to keep paying my mortgage? I can't advise on that. I'll note your question for the attorney, and you may want to contact your lender as well.
- How long will this take? It depends on the policy, the insurer and the facts. The attorney can give you a better sense after reviewing the documents.
Documents to request
- The complete policy with all endorsements for the policy period of the loss.
- Every letter and email from the insurer, including the denial or payment explanation.
- Adjuster and engineer reports, and the insurer's estimate.
- The caller's own contractor estimates, invoices and receipts for emergency repairs.
- Photos and videos of the damage, with dates, and any from before the loss.
- An inventory of damaged contents, if contents are claimed.
- Records of additional living expenses if the caller has had to move out.
- Any contract with a public adjuster or contractor that mentions the claim.
Contents inventories are often missing. In a 2023 survey cited by the Insurance Information Institute, 47% of homeowners said they had prepared an inventory of their possessions[1]. If the caller has none, ask them to start one from memory and photos, room by room, without guessing values they do not know.
Urgent flags
Some property callers need help within days, not weeks. Flag these for same-day attorney review:
- The family is displaced, or a business cannot operate.
- Damage is getting worse, such as an open roof, active leak or spreading mold.
- The insurer has scheduled an examination under oath or demanded a sworn proof of loss by a date.
- The loss happened long ago and the policy may set a short time to sue.
- The mortgage lender is threatening default because repairs have not been made.
- The caller has signed or is about to sign a release or a full and final settlement.
Money pressure is common. Only 63% of US adults would cover a $400 emergency expense entirely with cash or its equivalent[2], and a family paying for a hotel and emergency repairs while a claim is disputed may run out of options quickly. Callbacks need to get through, too: 80% of Americans say they do not generally answer calls from unknown numbers[4], so tell the caller which number the firm will use.
Commercial and rental property callers
Business owners and landlords add questions that homeowners do not. Ask whether the policy includes business interruption or loss of rents coverage, how long operations or rentals have been affected, and what income records exist for the months before the loss. Record the entity that owns the property and the named insured on the policy, which are sometimes different, and any lender or tenant with rights under the lease or loan. Ask whether tenants have their own claims or have stopped paying rent because of the damage. These details shape both the coverage analysis and the conflicts check, and they are much easier to gather on the first call than later.
Example: the roof after the hailstorm
Example (fictional). A homeowner calls three months after a hailstorm. The insurer paid a small amount for gutters but denied the roof, saying the damage was from wear and age. The homeowner's roofer says the shingles show hail impacts. Water is now coming into a bedroom. Intake records the date of loss, the report date, the claim number, the denial letter date and its reason, the roofer's estimate, the adjuster's inspection date and the active leak.
The file is flagged because of the active leak, and the caller is asked to send the full policy, the denial letter, the roofer's estimate and photos. The attorney's first call covers protecting the home from further damage and what the policy requires next. A firm that answers evenings with an SI Employee such as Ava can collect the same five first questions and pass the active-leak flag to the attorney under its escalation tree.
Frequently asked questions
Can intake staff tell a caller whether the denial was wrong?
No. Coverage depends on the full policy, the cause of loss and state law. Staff collect the letter, the policy and the facts so the attorney can evaluate it.
Should the caller keep making repairs?
Staff should not advise on repairs, but they should flag ongoing damage to the attorney the same day. The attorney can explain what the policy and the situation require.
What if a public adjuster is already involved?
Record their name, company and the contract terms the caller knows. The attorney will review the contract and how the roles fit together.
Does it matter if the caller cashed a check from the insurer?
It may. Record the amount, the date and any wording on the check or letter, such as full and final, for the attorney.
References
Insurance Information Institute (2026). Facts + Statistics: Homeowners and renters insurance (opens in a new tab) โ
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2025). Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households: Unexpected expenses (data table) (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) โ
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ