Practice Area Playbooks

Civil Litigation Intake: Evaluating Disputes

Civil litigation intake that helps attorneys evaluate disputes: a five-factor screen, adverse party list, damages questions, documents and decline scripts.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. What litigation intake is for
  2. The five-factor screen
  3. Taking the story in a usable order
  4. Adverse and related parties
  5. Damages questions, without guessing
  6. Documents and red flags
  7. Deciding and declining
  8. Measuring litigation intake
  9. Example: the unfinished kitchen
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Practice Area Playbooks: Civil Litigation Intake: Evaluating DisputesArticle coverPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSCivil LitigationIntake: EvaluatingDisputesAva for LawyersInsightsPractice Area Playbooks: Civil Litigation Intake: Evaluating DisputesArticle coverPRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSCivil LitigationIntake: EvaluatingDisputesAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Screen every dispute on five factors: what happened, what it cost, who is responsible, whether they can pay, and how much time is left.
  • List every adverse and related party for conflicts before the consultation, including insurers, parent companies and individuals.
  • Collect damages as categories with rough figures and the documents behind them; the attorney will test them later.
  • Federal civil filings fell 22% to 271,802 in the year to March 31, 2025[1]; most disputes callers bring will be state court matters.
  • Most people with civil legal problems get little help: low-income Americans get no or not enough help for 92% of substantial problems[2].

What litigation intake is for

A caller with a dispute wants to know whether they have a case. Intake cannot answer that, but it can make sure the attorney can answer it quickly and fairly. That means collecting the story in a usable order, identifying every party, putting rough numbers on what was lost, finding the documents, and spotting the dates that limit what can be done. Good litigation intake also filters: it surfaces the strong matters fast and lets the firm decline the others kindly and early, before the caller has waited weeks for an answer.

Federal numbers show how much the mix can swing. Civil filings in US district courts fell 22% to 271,802 in the year ending March 31, 2025, largely because one large set of mass tort cases wound down[1]. Diversity-of-citizenship filings fell 51% and personal injury and product liability filings 73% over the same period[1]. For most firms, the everyday flow of contract, property, business and consumer disputes runs through state courts.

Decline in US district court civil filings, year ending March 31, 2025Mostly due to the end of 3M Combat Arms earplug MDL cases.
Decline in US district court civil filings, year ending March 31, 2025Bar chart. All civil filings: 22%; Diversity-of-citizenship filings: 51%; Personal injury and product liability filings: 73%.All civil filingsAll civil filings: 22%22%Diversity-of-citizenship filingsDiversity-of-citizenship filings: 51%51%Personal injury and product liability filingsPersonal injury and product liability filings: 73%73%Decline in US district court civil filings, year ending March 31, 2025Bar chart. All civil filings: 22%; Diversity-of-citizenship filings: 51%; Personal injury and product liability filings: 73%.All civil filingsAll civil filings: 22%22%Diversity-of-citizenship filingsDiversity-of-citizenship filings: 51%51%Personal injury and product liabilityfilingsPersonal injury and product liability filings: 73%73%

Source: United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts), 2025[1]

Show the data
ItemDecline from prior year
All civil filings22%
Diversity-of-citizenship filings51%
Personal injury and product liability filings73%

The five-factor screen

A five-factor screen for civil dispute intake
FactorQuestions intake asksWhat the attorney looks for
What happenedTell me what happened in order. When did it start? What was agreed, and what went wrong?A coherent sequence, a recognizable legal theory, and what is disputed
HarmWhat did this cost you? Money paid, money not received, property damage, lost business, other harm?Damages categories and whether they can be proved
ResponsibilityWho do you think is responsible? Anyone else involved?Proper defendants and possible third parties
Ability to payIs the other side a business, an individual, a government body? Any insurance involved?Whether a judgment or settlement could be collected
TimeWhen did you first learn of the problem? Have you received or filed any court papers?Limitation periods, contract notice clauses, pending deadlines

Train staff to complete all five before the call ends, even briefly. A dispute with clear liability and no collectible defendant, or strong damages and an expired limitation period, looks very different once the missing factor is known.

Taking the story in a usable order

Callers tell disputes the way they experienced them: angriest part first, background last. Staff should listen for a minute, then rebuild the story in time order. A simple technique works well: ask the caller to start at the beginning of the relationship with the other side, then walk forward event by event, with the staff member reading back each step.

  • Start: How did you first deal with them? Was there a written agreement, a quote, an order or a handshake?
  • Performance: What was supposed to happen, and what actually happened? When?
  • Problem: When did you first realize something was wrong? What did you do then?
  • Contact: What have you and the other side said to each other since, and in what form?
  • Now: Where do things stand today? Has anyone threatened legal action or filed anything?

Record the caller's own words for anything disputed, such as what was promised in a phone call. The attorney will want to know exactly how the caller describes it, and whether any written record backs it up. Keep opinions about the other side out of the note.

Conflicts checks fail when intake records only the name the caller uses. Ask for each party's full legal name and role, and keep going until the list includes everyone who may appear in the case:

  • The main opposing party, with legal name, and for businesses the entity type and state if known.
  • Owners, officers or employees the caller dealt with personally.
  • Parent, subsidiary or affiliated companies, franchisors and brands.
  • Insurers, sureties and guarantors.
  • Contractors, subcontractors, lenders, landlords or other parties connected to the facts.
  • Lawyers who have written to the caller on the other side's behalf.
  • Co-plaintiffs or others with the same complaint, if the caller mentions them.

Script: I need the full names of everyone involved, including companies and their insurers if you know them. That lets us check that the firm can help you before you share confidential details with the attorney.

Damages questions, without guessing

Callers tend to give one large number or none at all. Neither helps the attorney. Ask for damages by category, with rough figures and what documents support each:

  1. Direct losses

    Money paid for something not delivered, unpaid invoices, repair or replacement costs, refunds refused.

  2. Consequential losses

    Lost business, lost customers, extra costs incurred because of the problem, such as hiring a replacement contractor.

  3. Property and personal harm

    Damage to property, and any personal injury or medical treatment, which may need a separate intake path.

  4. Costs so far

    Money already spent on experts, inspections or previous lawyers.

  5. What the caller wants

    Money, completion of the work, return of property, an order stopping something, or a public correction. Goals matter as much as amounts.

Documents and red flags

Ask the caller to gather the contract or agreement, invoices and payment records, emails and texts with the other side, photos, any demand letters, and any court papers. Ask them not to delete anything, including on phones and social media.

  • Court papers already served on the caller, or a case they filed themselves.
  • A prior lawyer on the same matter, and why the representation ended.
  • A contract clause requiring arbitration, a particular court, or notice before suit.
  • An offer to settle with a deadline.
  • Events more than a year or two ago, which may raise limitation questions.
  • A caller who wants to sue a former client of the firm, a government body, or a party in another state or country.

Flag each of these for the attorney. Staff should not tell a caller that time has run out or that an arbitration clause bars a claim.

Deciding and declining

Many callers will not have a case the firm can take. Low-income Americans do not get any or enough legal help for 92% of their substantial civil legal problems[2]. A clear, prompt decline with a referral is a service in itself, and it protects the firm by documenting that it did not take the matter.

Decline script: Thank you for explaining this. The attorney has reviewed your information and our firm is not able to take your case. This is not an opinion on whether you have a claim, and deadlines may apply, so please contact another lawyer or the referral service soon. I will send you this in writing today with some places to call.

Trust also shapes how callers hear a decline. Only 20% of Americans rate lawyers' honesty and ethical standards as high or very high[3]. A written decline that is courteous, specific about deadlines in general terms and quick builds goodwill even when the answer is no. Some callers decline the firm instead because of cost: only 63% of US adults would cover a $400 emergency entirely with cash[4]. Explain fee options, including any contingency or limited-scope arrangements the firm offers, if the attorney approves.

Measuring litigation intake

Track a few numbers each month to see whether intake is helping the attorneys decide: the time from first call to a take or decline decision, the share of consultations that turn into engagements, the number of conflicts found after a consultation was already booked, and the number of declined matters that came back later with a deadline problem. Any conflict found late, or any decline that took weeks, points to a step in the intake that needs fixing.

Example: the unfinished kitchen

Example (fictional). A homeowner calls about a contractor who took a large deposit for a kitchen remodel, did about a third of the work and stopped answering calls four months ago. Intake runs the five-factor screen: the sequence and the written contract; losses for the deposit, a second contractor's higher quote and water damage from an unfinished sink; the contractor's company and owner; the company's license and possible bond; and the dates of the contract, last work and last contact. The contract has an arbitration clause.

Conflicts are run on the contractor, its owner, the bonding company and the second contractor. The attorney reviews the note, sees a possible claim against the bond and the arbitration issue, and books a consultation. If the call had come after hours, an SI Employee such as Ava following the firm's approved intake could have captured the same five factors and sent a summary to the litigation team.

Frequently asked questions

Can intake staff tell a caller whether their claim is worth pursuing?

No. Staff collect facts in a structured way. The attorney evaluates liability, damages, collectability and timing and decides.

Why ask about the other side's insurance?

Insurance can determine whether a judgment or settlement can be collected, and insurers may be parties for conflicts. Record what the caller knows without pressing.

What if the caller has already been sued?

Get the court, case number, date served and any response deadline on the papers, and flag it for same-day attorney review.

Should we send a written decline?

Yes. A short letter or email confirming the firm is not taking the matter, that deadlines may apply and where to seek help protects both the caller and the firm.

References

  1. United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts) (2025). Federal Judicial Caseload Statistics 2025 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Gallup (2025). Nurses Continue to Lead in Honesty and Ethics Ratings (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2025). Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households: Unexpected expenses (data table) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo