Practice Area Playbooks

Debt Collection Lawsuit Defense: Intake Questions

Intake for consumers sued by a debt collector: service date and method, answer deadlines, who is suing, and the papers to get before the consultation.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing8 min read

On this page
  1. Why these calls are urgent even when the caller is calm
  2. The first three questions
  3. Who is suing, and does the caller know the name
  4. Why the consultation matters to the caller
  5. The debt defense intake form
  6. When the caller asks what it costs
  7. Routing a served caller
  8. Example: the papers left with a roommate
  9. Mistakes that cost callers their defense
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Practice Area Playbooks: Debt Collection Lawsuit Defense: Intake Questions70%+: of debt collection lawsuits ended in default judgment where court data were availablePRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSDebt Collection LawsuitDefense: Intake Questions70%+of debt collection lawsuits ended in default judgmentwhere court data were availableAva for LawyersInsightsPractice Area Playbooks: Debt Collection Lawsuit Defense: Intake Questions70%+: of debt collection lawsuits ended in default judgment where court data were availablePRACTICE AREA PLAYBOOKSDebt CollectionLawsuit Defense:Intake Questions70%+of debt collection lawsuits ended indefault judgment where court data wereavailableAva for Lawyers
Figure source: The Pew Charitable Trusts, 2020[1]

Key takeaways

  • The answer deadline runs from service and varies by court: 21 days in federal court, 20 or 30 days in New York depending on how the papers were served[2][3].
  • Default is the common outcome: in jurisdictions with data, more than 70% of debt suits ended in default judgment, and fewer than 10% of defendants had a lawyer[1].
  • Ask who is suing, not only who the caller owes. Debt buyers are often names the caller has never heard of[1].
  • Collect the summons and complaint, the service date and method, and every letter; the attorney decides the defense and the fee.

Why these calls are urgent even when the caller is calm

The caller has a summons and complaint, and it may have been on the kitchen counter for a week. Some think it is another collection letter. Some think it is a scam. Plenty plan to ring the collector and work something out, and only call a lawyer because a friend told them to. Their tone tells you nothing about the deadline, which has been running since the day the papers arrived.

Debt suits are now routine business for state courts. Pew found that the number of debt collection suits rose from fewer than 1.7 million in 1993 to about 4 million in 2013, growing from about 1 in 9 civil cases to 1 in 4[1]. Studies from 2010 to 2019 found that fewer than 10% of defendants had a lawyer, against nearly all plaintiffs, and in the jurisdictions with data more than 70% of these suits ended in default judgments[1]. A default means the court rules for the collector because the consumer never responded. The CFPB's plain warning is that a court could then let the creditor garnish wages or move to freeze a bank account[4].

Debt collection suits in state courts
  • ~4M

    debt collection suits filed in 2013, up from under 1.7 million in 1993[1]

  • 1 in 4

    state civil cases that were debt claims in 2013, up from 1 in 9[1]

  • <10%

    of debt-claim defendants had a lawyer in studies from 2010 to 2019[1]

  • 70%+

    of debt suits ended in default judgment in jurisdictions with data[1]

Figures from Pew's 2020 review of state court data and published studies.

Collections are also a large slice of household finance. In the third quarter of 2026, 4.9% of consumers had a third-party collection account on their credit report[5]. Most of those accounts never reach court, but the ones that do arrive at a law firm's front desk as a single urgent question: what do I do with these papers?

The first three questions

  1. Have you received court papers, or only letters and calls? Court papers say summons, complaint or petition, and name a court.
  2. When did you get them, and how: handed to you, left with someone at your home, mailed, or attached to your door?
  3. What court is it in, and is there a date anywhere on the papers, such as a hearing date or a date to respond?

The method of service matters because deadlines can depend on it. In federal court, a defendant must serve an answer within 21 days after being served[2]. New York's rule is 20 days after service of the summons, but 30 days after service is complete for several other methods, including leaving the papers with someone at the home[3]. Other states and lower courts set their own periods. Staff record the facts exactly as the caller describes them; they do not say “you have 30 days”, because the wrong number is worse than none.

Callers who have only received letters are a different intake: a possible claim against the collector rather than a lawsuit to defend. Route them to the consumer protection intake, and ask whether a lawsuit has been mentioned in any letter.

Who is suing, and does the caller know the name

Ask for the plaintiff's name exactly as printed. Consumers often report ignoring a suit because they do not recognize the debt buyer suing them[1], and the same confusion shows up on the phone: “I never had an account with these people.” Then ask what the caller thinks the debt is: the original lender or store, the type of account, the last four digits if they have them, the amount claimed and the amount they believe is right.

The last payment date matters more than callers expect. Every state has a statute of limitations for debt suits, from three years in Mississippi to 10 in Rhode Island, and the defendant usually has to raise it[1]. Federal rules bar a debt collector from suing or threatening to sue on a time-barred debt[6]. Whether a particular debt is time-barred is a legal question with several moving parts, so intake records the dates and leaves the analysis to the attorney.

Ask where the caller lived when the suit was filed and where they signed for the account. Under the federal debt collection law, a collector suing a consumer on an ordinary debt must sue in the judicial district where the consumer signed the contract or where they live when the action begins[7]. A court three counties away, or in a state the caller left years ago, is a fact the attorney will want on the first page of the note.

Why the consultation matters to the caller

Many callers wonder whether a lawyer is worth it for a few thousand dollars. Intake should not sell, but it can explain why the firm wants to see the papers quickly. Pew's review cites a study of more than 165,000 Utah debt cases from 2015 to 2017: 53% of represented defendants won their cases, compared with 19% of those without a lawyer[1].

Debt cases won by the defendant, Utah, 2015 to 2017Study of more than 165,000 disposed debt cases, as reported by Pew.
Debt cases won by the defendant, Utah, 2015 to 2017Comparison. Represented by a lawyer: 53%; Without a lawyer: 19%.53%Represented by a lawyerRepresented by a lawyer: 53%19%Without a lawyerWithout a lawyer: 19%Debt cases won by the defendant, Utah, 2015 to 2017Comparison. Represented by a lawyer: 53%; Without a lawyer: 19%.53%Represented by a lawyerRepresented by a lawyer: 53%19%Without a lawyerWithout a lawyer: 19%

Source: The Pew Charitable Trusts, 2020[1]

Show the data
DefendantWon the case
Represented by a lawyer53%
Without a lawyer19%

Those numbers do not promise any result, and staff should never quote them as odds. Represented defendants may have had stronger cases to begin with, and Pew notes that represented consumers still lose when the facts favor the plaintiff[1]. What the figures do support is an operational point: a served caller who reaches an attorney before the deadline has options that a defaulted one may not.

The debt defense intake form

Debt collection defense intake. Staff record facts; the attorney applies the deadlines and defenses.
AskWhy it matters
Date and method of serviceThe attorney's deadline count starts here
Court name, county, case number, any hearing or response dateWhere to file, and how fast
Plaintiff's name exactly as printedDebt buyer or original creditor; conflict check
Original creditor, account type and amount claimedWhat the suit is really about
Date and amount of the last paymentFacts the attorney needs for limitation questions
Letters received before the suit, with datesNotice history, and possible claims against the collector
Where the caller lived when sued, and where they signed for the accountWhether the suit was filed in the right place
Any existing judgment, wage garnishment or frozen bank accountA different and more urgent posture
Other debts, suits or collection pressureWhether a broader plan, such as bankruptcy, belongs in the conversation
Whether the caller is on active military dutyFederal law adds steps before a default against a servicemember

Callers facing several suits at once, or a garnishment on top of a new summons, may need a wider conversation than one defense. The bankruptcy intake questions are worth having ready, but whether bankruptcy fits is the attorney's call, not something to float on the first call.

When the caller asks what it costs

Price is usually the second question. It comes from a real place: in 2025 only 63% of adults said they would cover a $400 emergency expense entirely with cash or its equivalent[8]. Someone sued for $2,800 is often the person who could not cover the $400. Staff can repeat the firm's published consultation policy, whether that is a free first call, a flat fee or a payment plan, in the words the attorney approved. Negotiating fees, or saying what the case will cost, belongs to the lawyer[9].

Some firms run simple answer-and-negotiate matters through a fixed-fee lane. The flat-fee fast lane shows how to screen for it without telling a caller the case is simple before an attorney has read the complaint.

Routing a served caller

Example: intake for a consumer sued over a debt
  • Caller
  • SI Employee
  • Your team
  1. 01Caller

    Says they were sued

    A summons, complaint or court notice about a debt.

  2. 02SI Employee

    Service date and method

    Handed over, left with someone, mailed or posted, and on which day.

  3. 03SI Employee

    Court and plaintiff

    Court, case number, plaintiff, original creditor and amount claimed.

  4. 04SI Employee

    Urgency rule

    Served past the firm's threshold, or a hearing this week, goes to the urgent path.

  5. 05Your team

    Papers collected

    Photos of every page of the summons and complaint, plus prior letters.

  6. 06Your team

    Attorney sets the plan

    Deadline, defenses and fee are discussed by the lawyer.

Example sequence. The urgency threshold, such as served ten or more days ago, is the firm's own rule.

Served consumers tend to call in the evening, after finding the envelope or getting home from a shift. When the firm forwards its line after hours, an SI Employee can ask these questions in the firm's order, mark the urgent ones under the firm's escalation tree, and send the attorney a summary with the recording and transcript. It does not give the deadline or advise on the debt. A fictional call on the AssistCall demo line shows how the questions sound to a caller. The same sort-by-urgency logic drives the defense firm night-call example, where a court date decides who gets a call back first.

Example: the papers left with a roommate

Example. A caller rings on a Thursday evening. Twelve days ago a process server left papers with her roommate. The plaintiff is a company she has never heard of; reading the complaint aloud, she finds a store card she stopped paying in 2019. The amount claimed is $3,412. She opened the card while living in another county and moved two years ago.

Intake records the service date and method, the plaintiff, the original creditor, the year of the last payment and both addresses. Twelve days since service passes the firm's ten-day rule, so the call is marked urgent and the attorney sees the summary that night. The caller photographs all nine pages of the papers, including the exhibits stapled at the back, and sends them before hanging up. Whether the debt is too old to sue on, and whether the court is the right one, are exactly the questions intake leaves for the attorney's call the next morning.

Mistakes that cost callers their defense

  • Quoting a deadline. “You have 30 days” is wrong in many courts and for many service methods. Record the facts; let the attorney count.
  • Booking a routine consultation a week out without asking when the caller was served.
  • Treating the call as a collection dispute and pointing the caller to a debt settlement company.
  • Missing an existing judgment. Ask about garnishment notices and frozen accounts on every call.
  • Getting half the paperwork. Exhibits, affidavits and the last page of the complaint often carry the dates and the account details.
  • Forgetting the conflict check. Debt buyers and collection law firms sue in volume, and the firm may already represent or oppose one.

Hearing dates deserve the same discipline as any other court date: exact date, time, courtroom and how the caller learned of it. The court date capture guide sets out the format, and intake triage shows where a served debt defendant sits among the firm's other urgent calls.

Frequently asked questions

The caller only has letters from a collector, no court papers. Is this the same intake?

No. Without a lawsuit there is no answer deadline, and the question is usually whether the collector broke the rules. Route the call to consumer protection intake, and ask whether any letter mentions a lawsuit.

What if the caller already has a default judgment?

Treat it as urgent. Collect the judgment papers and any garnishment or bank levy notice, with dates. Whether anything can be done about the judgment is for the attorney, and the CFPB notes that a judgment can lead to wage garnishment or frozen funds[4].

Can intake tell a caller that the debt is too old to sue on?

No. Federal rules bar collectors from suing on time-barred debt[6], but whether a given debt is time-barred depends on the state, the account and the payment history. Intake records the dates; the attorney decides.

Should the call go straight to an attorney or into the consultation calendar?

That depends on the firm's written rule. A common version: anyone served more than a set number of days ago, or with a hearing in the next week, goes to the urgent path; everyone else gets the next consultation with a document request.

Do we need the whole complaint or just the first page?

Every page, including exhibits and affidavits. Account details, dates and the plaintiff's claimed chain of ownership are often at the back.

References

  1. The Pew Charitable Trusts (2020). How Debt Collectors Are Transforming the Business of State Courts (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). Rule 12. Defenses and Objections (Federal Rules of Civil Procedure) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. New York State Senate (2026). New York Civil Practice Law and Rules § 320: Defendant's appearance (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (2026). What should I do if I'm sued by a debt collector or creditor? (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Federal Reserve Bank of New York (2026). Quarterly Report on Household Debt and Credit, 2026:Q3 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 12 CFR 1006.26 - Collection of time-barred debts (Regulation F) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 15 U.S. Code § 1692i - Legal actions by debt collectors (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2025). Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households: Unexpected expenses (data table) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  9. American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2023). ABA Formal Opinion 506: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistants (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo