Key takeaways
- Court-appointed counsel represented 82% of felony defendants in the largest counties at case end[1], so many of these callers need a route, not a pitch.
- Staff say the firm is private and that the court appoints counsel; they never judge whether a caller qualifies.
- Give one clear public route and one private offer, then log the outcome.
- Keep a local resource card at every phone: public defender, clerk, application rules, legal aid and referral numbers.
- Second-opinion calls from people who already have appointed counsel go to an attorney[2].
Why public defender calls land on your line
Search for “public defender” with a county name and the results fill up with private defense firms' ads, map listings and directory profiles. So the call comes to you: a mother whose son was arrested last night, a man holding a court notice for next Tuesday, someone who has heard the words “public defender” and believes they mean a free lawyer for anything. The first thirty seconds decide whether that caller leaves with a route to counsel, a booked consultation, or the feeling that your firm brushed them off.
The right to a lawyer is not a favor the caller is asking for. In Gideon v. Wainwright in 1963, the Supreme Court unanimously guaranteed the right to counsel for criminal defendants in federal and state courts[3]. Most people charged with serious crimes end up with appointed lawyers. At the end of felony cases, court-appointed counsel represented 82% of state defendants in the 75 largest counties and 66% of federal defendants, in the Bureau of Justice Statistics comparison of defense counsel[1]. Your caller will quite possibly be represented by a public defender or assigned counsel, and staff who know how that works can help in under two minutes.
- Public defender 68.3%
- Private attorney 17.6%
- Assigned counsel 13.7%
- Self or other 0.4%
Source: U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics, 2000[1]
Show the data
| Counsel | Share of defendants |
|---|---|
| Public defender | 68.3% |
| Private attorney | 17.6% |
| Assigned counsel | 13.7% |
| Self or other | 0.4% |
The calls are not getting rarer. Filings for criminal defendants in federal district courts grew 12% in the year ending March 2025[4], and state dockets produce far more arrests than federal ones. A defense firm that advertises will hear this request every week.
What staff can say, and what they cannot
Intake staff can explain facts about the firm and point to public resources. They cannot decide whether someone qualifies, predict an outcome or tell the caller what to do in their case. ABA Formal Opinion 506 lets trained nonlawyers handle much of intake, but when a prospective client asks what legal services they need, the lawyer must respond[5]. That line matters here, because “Should I wait for the public defender or hire you?” is exactly that question.
| Caller says | Staff can say | Who decides the rest |
|---|---|---|
| “Are you the public defender?” | “No, we're a private defense firm. The public defender is a separate office. I can tell you how people usually reach it.” | Nobody, unless they want a private consultation |
| “How do I get a court-appointed lawyer?” | “The court decides that. People usually ask at their first court appearance, or call the clerk or the public defender's office about applying.” | The court |
| “Do I qualify?” | “Each state sets its own test, and the court applies it. The clerk or the public defender's office can tell you what they need from you.” | The court |
| “Is a public defender any good?” | “We don't comment on other lawyers. If you'd like to talk about hiring private counsel, an attorney here can speak with you.” | An attorney, if the caller wants advice |
| “I have a public defender but he won't call me back.” | “I'm sorry, that's stressful. An attorney here can talk with you about a second opinion if you'd like.” | An attorney |
| “It's about my eviction” or “my custody case.” | “Public defenders handle criminal cases. For a housing or family case, legal aid or the bar referral service may help. I can give you those numbers.” | The referral list |
Notice the neutral answer on quality. The same BJS report found conviction rates were the same for defendants with publicly financed and private attorneys; in the large-county sample, 71.0% of defendants with public counsel and 72.8% with private counsel were convicted by plea[1]. A receptionist who hints that appointed lawyers are second-rate is wrong on the evidence and gives the caller a reason to distrust the lawyer the court may assign.
The script, step by step
Acknowledge and clarify
“I can help point you in the right direction. So you know, we're a private law firm, not the public defender's office.”
Check for urgency
“Is someone in custody right now, or is there a court date coming up?” Note the court, the date and the charge if the caller offers it. Custody and close court dates follow your urgent path, as in criminal defense intake.
Give the public route
“Appointed lawyers are assigned by the court. People usually ask at the first court appearance, or call the clerk or the public defender's office to apply. Would you like that number?”
Offer the private option once
“If you'd also like to talk with one of our attorneys about hiring private counsel, I can set up a consultation. Would that help?”
Close and log
Read back the callback number and any court date, repeat the resource number, and log the outcome: referred out, consultation booked or attorney callback.
One offer, not three. Callers who want a free lawyer and hear a sales pitch hang up and tell their family about it. Callers who hear a clear route and a single offer often come back, sometimes when the court finds they do not qualify, sometimes when a relative decides to pay. The wider technique for redirecting requests for free help is in handling callers who want free legal advice.
Put the local details on one card
The process is local, so the script needs local facts. Florida shows how specific it gets. An applicant there pays a $50 application fee for court-appointed counsel within 7 days, yet a person found indigent may not be refused counsel for failing to pay it[6]. Florida treats an applicant as indigent if household income is at or below 200 percent of the federal poverty guidelines[6]. Your state will differ in the fee, the test and who takes the application, so the answers go on a single page by every phone.
- Public defender office for each county you serve: phone, address and hours.
- Clerk of court numbers for the criminal division.
- Jail information lines and the rules for reaching detained clients (jail call setup).
- The state's application form and fee, if any, and where it is filed.
- Legal aid organizations for civil problems, and the bar's lawyer referral service.
- Your own consultation fee and payment-plan policy, in the exact words staff are allowed to use.
Civil callers need a different door. Legal Services Corporation funds cannot be used for legal assistance in criminal proceedings except where its rules allow[7], so legal aid is usually the right referral for the eviction, benefits or custody caller who says “public defender”, not for someone facing a criminal charge. Intake for pro bono and legal aid referrals covers how to hand those callers off well.
When a private consultation still fits
Plenty of these callers become clients. Staff should recognize four patterns.
- The caller does not qualify for appointed counsel, or expects not to, and wants to know what private representation involves.
- A family member is willing to pay and wants a lawyer involved before the first appearance.
- The caller already has appointed counsel and wants a second opinion. Comment [4] to Rule 4.2 says the rule does not preclude communication with a represented person who is seeking advice from a lawyer not otherwise representing a client in the matter[2]. The attorney handles that conversation, not the front desk; see Rule 4.2 at intake.
- The person is under investigation and no case has been filed, so no court has appointed anyone yet.
Cost is the objection you will hear most. Among low-income Americans who did not seek legal help for a problem, 46% cited concerns about cost as a reason[8]. Staff should be able to say plainly whether the firm charges for consultations and whether payment plans exist, in approved wording, and then stop talking. Explaining fees during intake has scripts for that part of the call.
When a relative is the caller
Many of these calls come from a parent, partner or sibling rather than the person charged. The relative is not the prospective client, and the person in custody may not want family involved in the details. Staff can still take the practical facts: full legal name, date of birth, where the person is held, any booking number, the next court date and the caller's own contact details. They should not ask the relative what happened, because those facts belong in a conversation between the attorney and the person charged.
Example: a caller says her brother was arrested on Saturday and asks whether the public defender will see him before Monday. Staff do not know the county's schedule for first appearances and should not guess. They give the clerk and public defender numbers, take the brother's name, facility and booking number, offer a consultation if the family wants private counsel, and flag the call for the on-call attorney because someone is in custody. Calls from family members and third parties covers who the client is in these conversations.
Nights and weekends
Arrest calls arrive when the office is closed, and a parent calling at 11 p.m. is not comparing websites. Whoever answers after hours needs the same script and the same urgent path. An SI Employee can carry it: it asks the questions your firm approved, explains that the firm is private, reads the public defender and clerk numbers you supplied, offers a consultation request, and sends custody calls through your escalation tree without promising that an attorney is available. The three-attorney defense firm example models how that night routing would work, and you can hear a sample call.
- Caller
- SI Employee
- Your team
01Caller
Caller asks for a PD
A mother says her son was arrested and asks for the public defender.
02SI Employee
Firm role made clear
Explains this is a private firm and that the court appoints public defenders.
03SI Employee
Urgency checked
Custody status and next court date captured; custody follows the urgent path.
04SI Employee
Public route given
Reads the county public defender and clerk numbers from the approved card.
05Caller
One private offer
Offers a consultation request; the caller accepts or declines.
06Your team
Attorney reviews
Summary, recording and transcript reach the on-call attorney.
Example flow. Wording, resource numbers and the urgent path are set and approved by the firm.
Mistakes that cost goodwill
- Saying “we don't do free” and ending the call. The caller still needs a route, and the relative who might have paid is gone.
- Guessing whether someone qualifies. Only the court decides.
- Running down appointed counsel. The outcome data do not support it[1], and it undermines a lawyer the caller may depend on.
- Taking the whole story from someone who only needs a phone number. Collect what routing needs and leave the facts for the attorney.
- Not logging referred-out calls. If one county keeps producing public defender requests, your ads may be bidding on the wrong searches.
For matters you never take, keep the referral-out list current and follow the guidance on turning away bad-fit callers, so every call ends with the caller better placed than when it started.
Frequently asked questions
Can a private law firm act as someone's public defender?
Not on its own say-so. Public defenders and assigned counsel are appointed by the court. Some private lawyers take court appointments, which is what assigned counsel and federal panel attorneys are[1], but the court makes the assignment, not the caller or the firm.
How do people usually get a court-appointed lawyer?
They ask the court, usually at the first appearance, or apply through the clerk or the public defender's office, and the court decides eligibility. The right to counsel for criminal defendants rests on Gideon v. Wainwright[3].
Should intake staff tell callers whether they qualify?
No. Each state sets its own test; Florida's, for example, uses 200 percent of the federal poverty guidelines[6]. Staff point to the court or clerk and leave the decision there.
Can our attorneys talk to someone who already has a public defender?
A lawyer may speak with a represented person who is seeking advice from a lawyer not otherwise representing a client in the matter[2]. Route those calls to an attorney, who decides how to handle them.
Do public defenders handle evictions or custody cases?
Generally not; their work is criminal defense. Refer civil callers to legal aid or the bar referral service. Programs funded by the Legal Services Corporation cannot use that money for criminal cases except where allowed[7], which is why the two systems are separate.
References
U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics (2000). Defense Counsel in Criminal Cases (NCJ 179023) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Indiana Supreme Court (2026). Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 4.2: Communication with person represented by counsel (opens in a new tab) ↑
United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts) (1963). Gideon v. Wainwright (Supreme Court Landmarks) (opens in a new tab) ↑
United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts) (2025). Federal Judicial Caseload Statistics 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2023). ABA Formal Opinion 506: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistants (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Florida Senate (2025). Florida Statutes 27.52: Determination of indigent status (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 45 CFR 1613.3: Prohibition (restrictions on legal assistance with respect to criminal proceedings) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) ↑